RE: The Covert Messiah (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


vincentML -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/22/2013 8:43:25 AM)

quote:

All that aside, it is probable that ethical constraints will make it impossible to the gather evidence likely to be acceptable. And even if by some chance the the requisite biological and physical evidence becomes available, there’s no reason to suppose that it would lead to a complete understanding. For example we have comprehensive descriptions of the chemistry and physiology of sexual arousal but that doesn’t give us any real insight into what an orgasm is does it?

Orgasms, like thoughts, are products of our biology so their character is subject to both external and internal influences which differ for each individual. Orgasms are subject to physical measurement, i.e. strength, duration, etc. What we are not privy to is the subjective emotions experienced by the individual at that singular time. I said previously in this thread if I recall that consciousness is the 'hard' question. Research continues on how the brain translates electrochemical signals into subjective experience. Neuroscience may have to eventually accept that our inner life is simply emergent from our electrochemistry. I am content with that. However, the fact that long-ago memories (subjective experiences) can be easily induced to recur, that hallucinations can be induced, that the blind see images that seem real, that synesthesia is fairly common all lead us to conclude that subjective experiences are products of the brain.

We were discussing your OBE or 'soaring' experience. There is no issue between us if you mean that to be part of your subjective experience.

Regards . . .




vincentML -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/22/2013 8:49:19 AM)

quote:

So you're saying that my segue back to the topic of Christianity after the off-topic detour on astral projection is not on topic for this particular discussion thread on the Judaeo-Christian Messiah. Interesting logic.

Not at all what I am saying. I am saying that it was a deviation from what I was addressing in your near previous messages. A nicely written paragraph but it lacked continuity.




Kirata -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/22/2013 9:39:21 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: DomKen

As to the OBE that has been dealt with, it doesn't happen.

You're just reciting doctrine, and hiding behind the robes of Scientism to defend it.

K.





DomKen -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/22/2013 10:00:20 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Kirata


quote:

ORIGINAL: DomKen

As to the OBE that has been dealt with, it doesn't happen.

You're just reciting doctrine, and hiding behind the robes of Scientism to defend it.

K.



No. I'm stating that there is no evidence for such. Why do you expect anyone else to believe something for which there is no evidence?




TigressLily -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/22/2013 1:30:56 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: vincentML

quote:

{TigressLily}

So you're saying that my segue back to the topic of Christianity after the off-topic detour on astral projection is not on topic for this particular discussion thread on the Judaeo-Christian Messiah. Interesting logic.


Not at all what I am saying. I am saying that it was a deviation from what I was addressing in your near previous messages. A nicely written paragraph but it lacked continuity.


Thread drift is fine, posters do this frequently. I do it myself often and go off topic, whether as part of the ebb & flow of the discussion or not. (Haven't gotten a warning from the Mods or a gold letter yet, amazingly enough.) Aside from this, if I didn't give you an answer to your satisfaction, tough. I'm not here to satisfy your curiosity or to be bulldogged. If I feel I have a cogent message to impart, I'm not going to seek your permission to do so, or anyone else's for that matter (unless it is something about his/her personal life).

Last I checked, nobody elected you the conductor of this dissonant orchestra.
[:)]




deathtothepixies -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/22/2013 4:05:17 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Kirata


quote:

ORIGINAL: deathtothepixies
quote:

ORIGINAL: Kirata

Moreover, regardless of whether or not memories are stored in the brain, there is evidence to suggest that they are not stored only in the brain.

is there evidence that they are stored outside of the body?

I'm not aware of any definitive evidence as to where they're stored or how they're stored. We know how to evoke them via brain stimulation, but that doesn't prove they're stored in the brain. And we know that people have reported memories of events that transpired while they were effectively brain-dead. I have no idea how that's possible, but it seems foolish to deny something just because we can't explain it.

K.



is there any evidence of anything regarding memories or consciousness being stored outside the body?




LookieNoNookie -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/22/2013 4:28:00 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: TigressLily

quote:

ORIGINAL: LookieNoNookie
quote:

ORIGINAL: GotSteel
quote:

ORIGINAL: LookieNoNookie
quote:

ORIGINAL: deathtothepixies
quote:

ORIGINAL: Yachtie
quote:

ORIGINAL: deathtothepixies

but he wasn't the son of god

Says who?

Me, prove he was

Prove he wasn't.

There's a unicorn in this jar, prove there isn't.
[image]local://upfiles/566126/97C352D78C8D4F2CAFB9428DC2A0F9D4.jpg[/image]

This is a trick question....the unicorn is invisible!

*Best Maxwell Smart impression* Oh, the old invisible unicorn in a glass jar trick . . . Almost fell for that diabolical scheme. [sm=doh.gif]

(P.S. Lookie, where'd your kitty & puppy avatar go? Abe's okay, but not nearly as cute.)


I've always been a work in progress.




deathtothepixies -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/22/2013 5:39:36 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: deathtothepixies


quote:

ORIGINAL: Kirata


quote:

ORIGINAL: deathtothepixies
quote:

ORIGINAL: Kirata

Moreover, regardless of whether or not memories are stored in the brain, there is evidence to suggest that they are not stored only in the brain.

is there evidence that they are stored outside of the body?

I'm not aware of any definitive evidence as to where they're stored or how they're stored. We know how to evoke them via brain stimulation, but that doesn't prove they're stored in the brain. And we know that people have reported memories of events that transpired while they were effectively brain-dead. I have no idea how that's possible, but it seems foolish to deny something just because we can't explain it.

K.



is there any evidence of anything regarding memories or consciousness being stored outside the body?


the question still stands




vincentML -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 7:51:01 AM)

quote:

Thread drift is fine, posters do this frequently. I do it myself often and go off topic, whether as part of the ebb & flow of the discussion or not. (Haven't gotten a warning from the Mods or a gold letter yet, amazingly enough.) Aside from this, if I didn't give you an answer to your satisfaction, tough. I'm not here to satisfy your curiosity or to be bulldogged. If I feel I have a cogent message to impart, I'm not going to seek your permission to do so, or anyone else's for that matter (unless it is something about his/her personal life).

Last I checked, nobody elected you the conductor of this dissonant orchestra.

That's all very true. In fact you do not even have to answer. However, when a dialogue is engaged it is not unusual to expect the other person to focus on the issue. Simple courtesy is all. No need to elevate this conversation to an accusation that I am being controlling. That is a dodge you have used in response to others. Very transparent. [:D]




vincentML -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 8:39:52 AM)

quote:

I'm not aware of any definitive evidence as to where they're stored or how they're stored. We know how to evoke them via brain stimulation, but that doesn't prove they're stored in the brain. And we know that people have reported memories of events that transpired while they were effectively brain-dead. I have no idea how that's possible, but it seems foolish to deny something just because we can't explain it.

When I see the sun I simultaneously observe that my locale is lighted and I feel the warmth of the rays. The light and warmth go away when the sun is eclipsed by the moon. There follows a pretty firm conclusion that the sun is our source of light and heat. So, what do you mean by 'proved'?

Also, what is 'effectively brain-dead'? This article, a chapter in a book actually, provides two scales for diagnosing coma neither of which include the instrument flat line we are accustomed to seeing on television dramas ~ The Grady Coma Scale and The Glasgow Coma Scale. A person in coma is not necessarily dead. That provokes some ethical questions for reliance on the monitor readout, but that's another issue.

The locus for the stimulation of awakening is assumed to be in a group of neurons called the Ascending Reticular Activating System. Any number of events that disrupt this system will prevent consciousness.

So, I would suggest we are left with pretty well tested clinical evidence on the one hand vs reports by patients who were presumed dead by someone. The burden falls to the latter to provide definition and proof of brain-dead.







GotSteel -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 9:43:20 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: TigressLily
Again, with the materialistic worldview. *sigh*

Are you by any chance a creationist? I ask because that's a term mostly just used by creationists, I can't say I'm aware of many who refer to themselves as materialists.

I'm actually a methodological naturalist.

quote:

ORIGINAL: TigressLily
Gee, I didn't know I was applying for a job as an Astral Projection guide. Have you been hacking into my computer? [8D]

I've explained why I care multiple times now:

quote:

ORIGINAL: GotSteel
On the other hand psychic energy thingamajig is a claim with profound world changing implications. It's a claim which has been debunked ad nauseum. It's a claim about a phenomenon which has an actual explanation.


quote:

ORIGINAL: TigressLily
I also didn't realize you were so naïve about Eastern culture and worldwide shamanic traditions.

I have some familiarity. The issue is that I'm not gullible and ignorant.

quote:

ORIGINAL: TigressLily
Shamans and yogis have been doing astral projection for millennia.

Nope. They haven't actually been going anywhere.


quote:

ORIGINAL: TigressLily
I'm sure you've heard of Native American vision quests.

Been there done that.


quote:

ORIGINAL: TigressLily
These are practices which are engaged in after much tutelage and mentoring, not to be undertaken by any novice who hasn't attained the right mindset. The same with martial arts at the more advanced levels of mastery. Mental discipline is a pre-requisite.

Nope, OBE's are invokable at the push of a button with no "tutelage" whatsoever. It demonstrably is not a prerequisite.

The brain compiles data from multiple senses to generate a sense of your physical location, if that sense data's conflicting or those regions of the brain aren't operating properly you can receive a feeling of being in the wrong place or even a full blown delusion as the brain tries to cope with the bad data. Out of body experiences aren't proof of some astral psychic woo they are just a glitch.




TigressLily -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 9:45:26 AM)

On this P&R forum, where I don't usually post, there seems to be an "old boys' club" type thing going on which is decidedly lacking in common courtesy. I don't play by those rules, nor do I plan to start. If you feel that you must always have the last word, go ahead. Btw, all the men I've known with this personality trait have multiple shattered divorces behind them.

quote:

ORIGINAL: vincentML

That's all very true. In fact you do not even have to answer. However, when a dialogue is engaged it is not unusual to expect the other person to focus on the issue. Simple courtesy is all. No need to elevate this conversation to an accusation that I am being controlling. That is a dodge you have used in response to others. Very transparent. [:D]


With respect to transparency, I have no problem with being transparent in my conduct and motivations. I have no hidden agenda. Your attempt to lecture me, on the other hand, is a 'very transparent' move on your part by your own definition.

Is it dodging when on the other side I choose to not engage with 4sshats (which I'm calling them, not you) who can't take no for an answer, or who choose to disregard my age requirements because every single one of them feels entitled to be the exception, no matter how outlandishly outside of this range they are? Is this a Freudian slip reference of yours to dodging bullets--I don't think you had dodgeball in mind. In any event, I don't play Byzantine games.

If the truth be known, further discussion with you (or GS, whom I believe is fully capable of doing his own championing without your playing wingman) on metaphysical subjects would be an exercise in futility instead of elevating any discourse. No reflection on anyone's intelligence. Some of us can't see the forest for the trees; others can't see the trees for the forest. A combination of both views makes for a healthy balance in perspective.


{Edited for typo}




Kirata -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 9:48:12 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: deathtothepixies
quote:

ORIGINAL: deathtothepixies
quote:

ORIGINAL: Kirata
quote:

ORIGINAL: deathtothepixies

is there evidence that they are stored outside of the body?

I'm not aware of any definitive evidence as to where they're stored or how they're stored.

is there any evidence of anything regarding memories or consciousness being stored outside the body?

the question still stands

I'm not aware of any definitive evidence as to where they're stored or how they're stored.

If you would like me to continue to repeat that answer, please let me know how many times will be required to satisfy you.

K.




Kirata -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 10:02:38 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: vincentML

When I see the sun I simultaneously observe that my locale is lighted and I feel the warmth of the rays.

What you're feeling isn't "the warmth of the rays." Please read "Dick and Jane learn Science."

quote:

ORIGINAL: vincentML

Also, what is 'effectively brain-dead'? This article, a chapter in a book actually, provides two scales for diagnosing coma neither of which include the instrument flat line we are accustomed to seeing on television dramas

The example was the brain during induced cardiac arrest, not in coma states. Nice fish though.

K.




Kirata -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 10:07:27 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: GotSteel
quote:

ORIGINAL: TigressLily

Again, with the materialistic worldview.

I'm actually a methodological naturalist.

Also related to materialism are the ideas of methodological naturalism (i.e., "let's at least do science as though physicalism is true") and metaphysical naturalism (i.e., "the physical world is all that exists"). ~Materialism

K.




TigressLily -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 12:07:55 PM)


(Not trying to get in the last word--just don't want you to feel slighted, although I don't get the impression that you are as hypersensitive. *Meant that in a good way.*)

quote:

ORIGINAL: GotSteel

Are you by any chance a creationist? I ask because that's a term mostly just used by creationists, I can't say I'm aware of many who refer to themselves as materialists.

I'm actually a methodological naturalist.


Yes, I've come full circle. Alpha-Omega-Alpha. Is there such a thing as a naturalistic creationist? I don't regard "evolution" to be a dirty word. ("Devolution" is, however.) It simply wasn't the starting point. It's a transitional/transformative/metamorphical organic process, in the same way that Nature and animal behavior teach us organically, including this vast cosmos. Not so enigmatic for humans to have evolved from hunter-gatherer to agrarian societies, cultivated animal/plant hybrids, refined livestock strains. The proper application of eugenics. (Consider how many pet breeds we have within the past few centuries that never existed before throughout history.)

quote:

ORIGINAL: GotSteel

Nope, OBE's are invokable at the push of a button with no "tutelage" whatsoever. It demonstrably is not a prerequisite.

The brain compiles data from multiple senses to generate a sense of your physical location, if that sense data's conflicting or those regions of the brain aren't operating properly you can receive a feeling of being in the wrong place or even a full blown delusion as the brain tries to cope with the bad data. Out of body experiences aren't proof of some astral psychic woo they are just a glitch.


You and I are talking about apples & oranges, or else grapefruit & oranges. Ordinarily OBEs are a natural spontaneous, coping-mechanism response to the body being in extreme distress or having suffered physical trauma causing an extreme shock to the system. I really don't want to go into the subject of comas & induced comas. (My father came out of 2-month coma but the tracheotomy made it impossible for him to regain speech; my mother had to have comas induced so that her elderly body had any fighting chance whatsoever to recover from her 3 back-to-back heart surgeries.) These are involuntary experiences.

My concern is safety when it comes to those who deliberately set out to trigger an OBE, aka astral projection/travel, whatever their motivation is. You may consider it noble in the interests of science. I'm concerned about unsafe BDSM practices for those who seek to induce OBE states. I'm not an s-type, so I have no first-hand experience about "subspace" or even what others get out of sado-masochism. There is no required tutelage for BDSMers either, most of us started out winging it, working out assorted techniques as we went along. But would you trust yourself to experiment on your sub with a potentially dangerous practice which requires a high Topping skillset without any prior instruction? Only an irresponsible, reckless Master/Mistress would turn away mentorship from a more experienced Master. I had one sub partner who showed me a third of what I know, because my D/s experience had been limited to my marriage; he would have taught me more, but I wasn't interested in exploring those other kinks.

Not the best analogy either, but one could conceivably drop a hit of LSD all by himself in an unstructured environment, without a safe buddy or anyone to guide him or be there to spot him in case he experienced a bad acid trip. The rest of his life he would be subject to flashbacks, worse than unpredictable PTSD-triggered panic attacks. Short-circuiting of his brain's wiring, of his entire nervous system, would result in dual diagnosis mental illness of schizo-effective disorder most often. Medications can address the mental illness aspect, no effectiveness guaranteed, but there is no treatment for LSD overdose. It's not an addictive form of substance abuse, and there is no detoxification process other than riding out the storm. For those afflicted, this could become a life sentence worse than a quick & painless death. It operates much like a dormant virus, which could flare back up at any stressful moment.

I take back what I said about being naïve. I can see you're more hardened than that. Y'all need to lighten up over here at P&R or you'll end up losing any shred of real objectivity. This particular subject is a wrap for me unless it is germane to the original discussion topic.




PeonForHer -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 3:47:57 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: NoBimbosAllowed

Nope. Wrong again. I pointed out the fault in your reasoning. Quite a talent you have for perceiving emotions I don't feel. Projecting, are you?



quote:


actually, if you know your science of Psychology, projection does not mean that.


It does mean what Vincent implied that it meant, NBA. Freud and his followers all used the word in slightly different ways but Vincent's use of the word meshes with that of Carl Jung at least: that is, roughly, 'you're not seeing me, you're seeing the baddie - the 'Shadow' - in your own mind.




deathtothepixies -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 4:42:05 PM)

edit double post.......fucking boxes, I hate them





deathtothepixies -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 4:43:17 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: deathtothepixies


quote:

ORIGINAL: Kirata



is there evidence that they are stored outside of the body?

I'm not aware of any definitive evidence as to where they're stored or how they're stored.





K " there is evidence to suggest that they are not stored only in the brain"

Ok so there is no evidence as to where they are stored yet there is evidence to suggest they are not only stored in the brain.

Ignoring that where are memories stored if not in the brain?




box nightmare, sorry




Kirata -> RE: The Covert Messiah (10/23/2013 5:25:48 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: deathtothepixies

where are memories stored if not in the brain?

I don't even have a theory, let alone an answer. But when people report an out of body experience characterized by lucid consciousness, and can recount verifiable observations of events occurring during the period when they were in a state of induced cardiac arrest -- when even the most basic brain stem reflexes are unresponsive and there is no evidence of any brain activity sufficient to support conscious awareness or memory -- the question arises of how they could remember those experiences if memories were (only) stored in the brain.

K.




Page: <<   < prev  12 13 [14] 15 16   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.078125