Musicmystery
Posts: 30259
Joined: 3/14/2005 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: sunshinemiss quote:
ORIGINAL: Musicmystery quote:
ORIGINAL: JstAnotherSub quote:
ORIGINAL: VideoAdminGamma Fast reply Unless some effort is made to steer this topic towards a Gorean perspective, then it will be moved to the Off Topic section. Thanks, Gamma Personally, I believe that seeing how people who claim the Gorean label respond to threads like this does reflect a Gorean perspective. It is claimed that being Gorean affects all aspects of life, so wouldn't any topic be Gorean if discussed by Goreans? Just as any slave is a Gorean slave, if owned by a Gorean, Everything written by a Gorean on these boards offers another insight into the beliefs and ethos of Gor. I believe topics like this, and the opportunity to see how they are replied to, give everyone one more way to learn about Goreans. Yeah, when I buy wheat bread, or go skiing, or turn left at an intersection, or throw sticks for my dog, you can tell I'm doing it in a very Gorean way, clearly distinct from how others do this. Hello Music Mystery, I would say that's actually correct. Are you following your principles when you do those things? buying wheat bread and going skiing- What is your motivation? What underpins your decisions? To enjoy life? To care for your body and keep it strong? To enjoy fellowship with your friends? Those seem to me to be reasons a Gorean would do them. turn left at an intersection - respecting the laws of the land, disobeying if dealing with an emergency, taking good care of your property... these are Gorean if I've read the books and the boards correctly. throw sticks for my dog - sure ... giving your animal exercise, making it healthy, enjoying your time with it, NOT hitting the dog with those same sticks. you can tell I'm doing it in a very Gorean way, clearly distinct from how others do this. Yes, actually, I would hope so. It is in the small decisions in life that we show our mettle. It is not the big, grandiose gestures that show who we are, it is not in the words we spout off, but in the day to day decisions. Are these things only in the realm of Goreans? Of course not. Morality does not live solely in the sphere of one philosophy or another. Treating animals well, enjoying life, following the law of the land - these are also not simply Gorean as you point out. But it does beg the question... would beating your pet to death, breaking the law for no good reason, destroying your body be considered Gorean traits? If so, then I stand corrected. If not, then yes, you are doing them in a way that the philosophy of your life would lead you... and there are people in these forums who consider themselves Gorean and believe in that philosophy... and believe in LIVING that philosophy. In fact, it was my understanding that the entire point of this forum was about living the philosophy. But if you can do anything in any fashion for any reason, isn't that Anarchy? And is that the Gorean philosophy? If not, then what the heck is "Gorean" if there is no application of the philosophy? Or is all this simply mental masturbation? I don't think it is. I think it would be surprising for many Gorean people (and most people actually) to learn that their ACTIONS are not expected to be informed by their life philosophy. best, sunshine *edited to make sure that the points I'm making are "you" general and not "you" specific. Well we can be sure you don't teach Logic. To identify something as an action belonging to a particular group, the criteria is a mutually exclusive set of identifiers. I also buy bread as a musician. But I'm not sure you could tell the difference. That's because there is no relevant difference. By your criteria, my dog is Gorean. In fact, by your criteria, everything alive is Gorean. Yet there's a subset of living things identified as Gorean. Your criteria, then, have not yet found the identifiers.
|