RE: Flag Etiquette (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


joether -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 2:09:02 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: HunterCA
What BS. Baltamore had over $15,000 per Pupil. School funding everywhere has escalated way beyond inflation. If there's a problem, it's not money, it's regulation coming from the Department of Education.


How does Baltimore enter into this equation exactly?

This is a thread about 'Flag Etiquette' not 'Making cheap shots at the Department of Education'.





HunterCA -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 2:12:05 PM)

Read the quote Joe, what you said. Then see if you can figure it out.




mnottertail -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 2:14:53 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: HunterCA


quote:

ORIGINAL: joether

quote:

ORIGINAL: JVoV
Don't most classrooms still have American flags in them already? How could a t-shirt with one be disruptive? (Not including any text added, only a flag. Ok, maybe an eagle.)


Not all classrooms have American flags in them. The more affluent the neighborhood to which the school is located in; the more likely an American flag will be in a class room. Unfortunately it comes down to budget items. Schools in poor neighborhoods would like many things; unfortunately their resources are quite limited.

Its a curious thing with artwork to a t-shirt. Back when I was in school, a t-shirt showing the demons from Warhammer (i.e. the Chaos Armies) had images of demons and armored 'knights' (called Chaos Lords in the game system). Had a teacher that was offended by it. I knew of one person that wore a t-shirt with snakes on it because one of the students they were bullying had a fear of them. I'm sure if want to know more, take a visit to your local school system and either ask the principals or 'school psychologists' what impacts imagery on shirts can have towards staff and student alike. Even one with an American flag upon it.

How could a flag be disruptive? Consider the Nazi War Flag towards Jewish students in the 1950's whom are recent immigrants from Europe. Would that not be disruptive? Or the Confederate flag to black students in the South? Or the American flag towards Native Americans?



What BS. Baltamore had over $15,000 per Pupil. School funding everywhere has escalated way beyond inflation. If there's a problem, it's not money, it's regulation coming from the Department of Education.


At 15k they probably could spell it
Baltimore though.




PeonForHer -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 2:53:50 PM)

quote:

At some point all you special snowflakes need to stop insisting that other people fall in line with your delicate sensibilities.


No. When it comes to national flags, I think a lot of us, of all political hues, are 'special snowflakes'. I'm not ever going to feel about the Union Jack the way a WW2 vet is going to feel about it. I understand that and wouldn't want to trample on such a man's corns. But at the same time I also understand what the Union Jack has come to mean for, for instance, West Indians in London, who've seen British National Party thugs march through their areas. They find it aggressive, angry and frightening - which, actually, is pretty much the way it's meant.

There *are* contexts and ways in which the Union Jack is used harmlessly and well, in my opinion. The difference between 'used well' and 'used badly' is subtle - and I think anyone who suggests that it's all simple and black and white is bullshitting. Brandishing your national flag is *not* either 'always good, because you love your country' or 'always bad, because it's a symbol of oppression, etc, etc'. Context is all.






joether -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 3:13:02 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: HunterCA
Read the quote Joe, what you said. Then see if you can figure it out.


Let's back up, you tell me where "Baltamore" exists in the United States.

Baltimore spending is a rather misleading and ultimately 'simpleton' understanding of their situation. First lets see where that $15,000 quote originates. That's right, from FOX 'news'. An organization that usually does a crap-tastic job on journalism. Its target audience is someone like you; i.e. 'The Low Information Voter'. The sort of person that can not handle complex and complicated things.

I would think for an 'engineer' with '30 years' of experience could handle the more complex and complicated stuff associated with education. Apparently not....

While 'How much per pupil' is a factor; it is but one factor in the whole equation. Where are the schools? What are their conditions? Where are they located in the city? What are those neighborhoods like? What is the status of public and civil services in those areas (i.e. police, fire, libraries, parks, etc.). What is the quality of the teaching staff? How much are they being compensated for services (pay plus benefits)? Are their 'wages' in line with the industry? How many special needs students are there and what are their needs? What are the after-school programs and clubs at each of these schools? How much do the parents of these children help in the education system? What is the status of technology and knowledge being displayed and used (from computers to access to high school and college level material)?

Those questions are just the tip of the iceberg. Meaning it takes some real fact finding research to develop an 'as complete' analysis of the problem(s). From there, a plan can start taking form to keep what is good and improve upon the bad. That this sort of stuff seems very complicated for someone claiming to be an engineer with an education and thirty years seems very unusual. I dont know a single engineer that would behave like you on this topic. Many of the questions above are 'engineer-like' questions. Engineers can not fix something unless they understand the problem(s) or have the ability to gauge success after changes are made.

Finally, what is the caliber of the student population? You can have all the best systems in place; but if the kids are dumb as boards, your not going to succeed.




HunterCA -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 4:49:05 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: joether

quote:

ORIGINAL: HunterCA
Read the quote Joe, what you said. Then see if you can figure it out.


Let's back up, you tell me where "Baltamore" exists in the United States.

Baltimore spending is a rather misleading and ultimately 'simpleton' understanding of their situation. First lets see where that $15,000 quote originates. That's right, from FOX 'news'. An organization that usually does a crap-tastic job on journalism. Its target audience is someone like you; i.e. 'The Low Information Voter'. The sort of person that can not handle complex and complicated things.

I would think for an 'engineer' with '30 years' of experience could handle the more complex and complicated stuff associated with education. Apparently not....

While 'How much per pupil' is a factor; it is but one factor in the whole equation. Where are the schools? What are their conditions? Where are they located in the city? What are those neighborhoods like? What is the status of public and civil services in those areas (i.e. police, fire, libraries, parks, etc.). What is the quality of the teaching staff? How much are they being compensated for services (pay plus benefits)? Are their 'wages' in line with the industry? How many special needs students are there and what are their needs? What are the after-school programs and clubs at each of these schools? How much do the parents of these children help in the education system? What is the status of technology and knowledge being displayed and used (from computers to access to high school and college level material)?

Those questions are just the tip of the iceberg. Meaning it takes some real fact finding research to develop an 'as complete' analysis of the problem(s). From there, a plan can start taking form to keep what is good and improve upon the bad. That this sort of stuff seems very complicated for someone claiming to be an engineer with an education and thirty years seems very unusual. I dont know a single engineer that would behave like you on this topic. Many of the questions above are 'engineer-like' questions. Engineers can not fix something unless they understand the problem(s) or have the ability to gauge success after changes are made.

Finally, what is the caliber of the student population? You can have all the best systems in place; but if the kids are dumb as boards, your not going to succeed.




Joe, I'm betting that with the life expectancy of a flag, hanging indoors, at $15,000 per year per student, they could afford to keep a flag in class and that just like everything else you've said you pulled that statement of yours out of your ass just to argue.




Aylee -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 5:26:15 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: BamaD

We have required children to pay attention in class; its called Common Core. I seem to recall you were against that concept as well....regulating that children pay attention in class. Again, your against what your for and for what your against.

Come on Joether use that much praised (by you) brain. As far back as the one room school house kids were required to pay attention, they didn't need a federal program.


I would not worry about it Bama, the twit is not making sense again. You can "see" the spittle flying from his fingertips.




MercTech -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 5:41:46 PM)

The only federal law on flag etiquette I know of is that the U.S. Flag will not be dipped in salute to any foreign country. But there are some strict rules in how and when the flag is displayed at official locations. (includes military flag protocol)

I'm enough of an old fart that I remember court rulings about wearing the U.S. flag as apparel. That got hashed out in the 1960s.




BamaD -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 6:00:16 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Aylee


quote:

ORIGINAL: BamaD

We have required children to pay attention in class; its called Common Core. I seem to recall you were against that concept as well....regulating that children pay attention in class. Again, your against what your for and for what your against.

Come on Joether use that much praised (by you) brain. As far back as the one room school house kids were required to pay attention, they didn't need a federal program.


I would not worry about it Bama, the twit is not making sense again. You can "see" the spittle flying from his fingertips.

I know, sop.




kdsub -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 6:26:08 PM)

I would say the first picture represents a deed that is unnecessary at school and not worth the outrage of veterans or anyone else.

The second is a peaceful protest, though distasteful, as a way to emphasize a feeling among many African Americans that they do not have the same rights in the country that flag represents.

I think the second picture is a far better use of the flag than the first.

Butch




Wayward5oul -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 6:36:27 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Aylee


Bull. The courts have upheld the right to wear the flag, walk on the flag, set it on fire.




Actually, schools are allowed to limit freedom of speech (to a degree), including the display and/or wearing of the flag, if they feel it necessary to avoid severe disruption. To what degree they can limit it remains to be seen. If I am not mistaken, there is a case headed to the Supreme Court right now regarding this exact issue-banning students from wearing clothing with the flag on it as a direct response to other students' celebrating their ethnic heritage (Mexican).




HunterCA -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 6:41:18 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Wayward5oul


quote:

ORIGINAL: Aylee


Bull. The courts have upheld the right to wear the flag, walk on the flag, set it on fire.




Actually, schools are allowed to limit freedom of speech (to a degree), including the display and/or wearing of the flag, if they feel it necessary to avoid severe disruption. To what degree they can limit it remains to be seen. If I am not mistaken, there is a case headed to the Supreme Court right now regarding this exact issue-banning students from wearing clothing with the flag on it as a direct response to other students' celebrating their ethnic heritage (Mexican).



I remember that news. So I'll say so here in order that someone doesn't ask you for a link. I didn't know it was going to the SCOTUS. That's interesting.




HunterCA -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 7:03:02 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: HunterCA


quote:

ORIGINAL: Wayward5oul


quote:

ORIGINAL: Aylee


Bull. The courts have upheld the right to wear the flag, walk on the flag, set it on fire.




Actually, schools are allowed to limit freedom of speech (to a degree), including the display and/or wearing of the flag, if they feel it necessary to avoid severe disruption. To what degree they can limit it remains to be seen. If I am not mistaken, there is a case headed to the Supreme Court right now regarding this exact issue-banning students from wearing clothing with the flag on it as a direct response to other students' celebrating their ethnic heritage (Mexican).



I remember that news. So I'll say so here in order that someone doesn't ask you for a link. I didn't know it was going to the SCOTUS. That's interesting.



Here's a link to the shirt flag thing. I've posted it because it mentions the Tea Party and I know joether will have comments about it:



http://dailycaller.com/2014/05/05/students-its-illegal-to-wear-an-american-flag-shirt-on-cinco-de-mayo/

A second link showing the same sort of thing on a different campus, but regarding tacos.


http://dailycaller.com/2013/05/09/latino-student-group-says-eating-tacos-is-offensive-to-mexicans/#ixzz30o2UEuyx




A third link to the group mentioned in the second link

https://atuva.student.virginia.edu/organization/latinostudentalliance/DocumentLibrary/View/19954


A quote from the purpose statement of the group linked showing that they'll work with anyone, except white people...unless you want to give them money.



quote:


The purpose of this organization is to be the coordinating body for all Hispanic/Latino organizations on Grounds and to provide services of political, social and cultural matters to the Hispanic/Latino population. LSA will work as a network of support for the Hispanic/Latino community, in the graduate and undergraduate level. LSA will work with all other organizations on Grounds that are involved with minority groups as well as any organizations who would like to sponsor programs with LSA.





BamaD -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 7:20:13 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub

I would say the first picture represents a deed that is unnecessary at school and not worth the outrage of veterans or anyone else.

The second is a peaceful protest, though distasteful, as a way to emphasize a feeling among many African Americans that they do not have the same rights in the country that flag represents.

I think the second picture is a far better use of the flag than the first.

Butch

I find the second grossly offensive and am not offended by the first at all.




kdsub -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 7:27:34 PM)

I find it offensive as well but it is still a better use of our flag and far more important than some kid throwing a temper tantrum over flag waving.

Butch




Aylee -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 7:33:21 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub

I would say the first picture represents a deed that is unnecessary at school and not worth the outrage of veterans or anyone else.

The second is a peaceful protest, though distasteful, as a way to emphasize a feeling among many African Americans that they do not have the same rights in the country that flag represents.

I think the second picture is a far better use of the flag than the first.

Butch


So. . . the kid should bolt and unbolt the flags from his truck because you think they are unnecessary at school?

Since one of the flags was a POW-MIA flag, maybe this is not about school, but about something he feels he needs?




Aylee -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 7:35:07 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub

I find it offensive as well but it is still a better use of our flag and far more important than some kid throwing a temper tantrum over flag waving.

Butch


Yeah, 'cause if it is his uncle that is the MIA soldier. . . well, he just needs to stop giving a shit. That is all history.




KenDckey -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 7:38:23 PM)

Aylee That is like saying someone loses a kid should immediately get over it because they are history now. I hope you were kidding.




VikingPrince -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 7:49:05 PM)

The greatness of America is that while we may hate what someone says or does as free speech, we will still fight to the death to preserve their right to say it.
Having said that, if you wish to exercise your rights in that manner, I may very well be forced to voice my disagreement in a most forceful manner. Do we have the right of free speech?
Absolutely. Should we have he responsibility of good manners? Absolutely. Of course, this is just my opinion...Exercising my right to free speech...




Wayward5oul -> RE: Flag Etiquette (5/18/2015 8:03:49 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: HunterCA


I remember that news. So I'll say so here in order that someone doesn't ask you for a link. I didn't know it was going to the SCOTUS. That's interesting.


Thank you.

I just saw where last month, SCOTUS refused to hear the appeal.
http://www.newsweek.com/supreme-court-rejects-appeal-american-flag-clothing-case-317989

I think the issue deserves to be heard, but personally I wish that it had been initiated by something other than the recognition of Cinco de Mayo, which, in practice at least, is more of an American holiday than a Mexican holiday.




Page: <<   < prev  1 [2] 3 4 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875