Zonie63
Posts: 2826
Joined: 4/25/2011 From: The Old Pueblo Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Real0ne Sure there is a gay religion, just like atheism is a religion. Atheism is not a religion. There are gays who are atheists, and gays who are religious. Of those who are religious, they're not necessarily all of the same religion. quote:
If you elect to make law supporting the 'moral' beliefs of a gay person (religious standing) and impose it over the 'moral' beliefs of a christian (religious standing) you would be establishing the gay persons 'moral' beliefs (as the law of the land through legal precedent) while dismissing the christians 'moral' beliefs, hence enforcing the gay persons right to exercise their religious beliefs and simultaneously violating the christians right to exercise their religious beliefs. This falls precisely within the religion v religion argument. The only trouble is that the religion vs. religion argument seems to imply that Freedom of Religion is the only right citizens have in this society. All of these rights have to operate in harmony and balance with each other for society to operate efficiently. This issue has also brought up property rights, the right to do commerce, the right of citizens to not be discriminated against. Even if it's a religion vs. religion issue, I don't think it's as cut-and-dried as you're trying to make it. What if a Mormon-owned business decided that they wanted to refuse service to Baptists? Should they be allowed to do that? Even prior to the court's decision, it has been perfectly legal to be gay. It's perfectly legal to have gay relationships. This means that, in the eyes of the law, they are citizens with equal rights and privileges as any other citizen in society. It doesn't even matter what a person's religion is or what their moral beliefs are. The law is the law, and we all have to face up to it sooner or later. Even if there was a gay religion, it would still be just as legal as any other religion, and the same principle would apply. quote:
Religion is a fundamentally the moral set of beliefs that one uses to govern ones self. Perhaps, although I think that cuts to the very heart of the matter here. Exactly what religious beliefs are being violated here? You say that the Christians' right to exercise their religious beliefs is being violated. Setting aside the Constitution and secular law for the moment, looking at it solely as a theological matter and within the framework of Christian beliefs, what do the Scriptures actually say on this matter, and what are a Christian's obligations as a member of a secular society where the law requires that all citizens be treated fairly and equally? In another forum I visit occasionally, the question was raised as to what Jesus would do if He was working at a bakery and a gay couple came in wanting a cake for their wedding. He'd probably bake them the cake, but it would taste as bland as a communion wafer.
|