RE: Abused into submission (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


Aswad -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 8:16:54 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: marieToo

This I don't understand, really.  I'm not minimizing a horrible experience such as rape for anyone who has actually been through such a personal violation, however, I think it's almost become fashionable for women to claim they've been raped.   All of a sudden,  everybody and their sister has been raped.  Can there be that many rapists among us? 


You'd be amazed. In Denmark, 0.3% of all males born in a particular year (79, I think) had been convicted of raped by the age of 27. Police figures indicate that some of these have haped more than one woman, and that convictions account for less than half (some claim as low as one tenth) of the actual cases.

I seem to recall the lifetime prevalence is that about 6% of all males rape someone at some point in time, with fairly high recidivism rates (about 1 in 3 if untreated, 1 in 6 if treated with the currently preferred method). That should indicate that at least 6% of women are raped at some point in time, probably significantly higher.

Note that I'm not saying that women don't commit rape, or have the wiring to do so, just that most studies focus on males and that I therefore lack figures to quote for women. FWIW, and slightly OT, three women just got off the hook in Norway for gangraping a man; the three of them took turns, and videotaped the whole thing. Problem was, he got an erection when they used fellatio to get him hard, which the judge saw as evidence that he appreciated being raped; kind of insane, as that's a physiological response that isn't under voluntary control for most males.

But, yeah, it's become fashionable in some circles, which is a pity, because it belittles those that have been through the real thing. And it's also become a "fairly" common way to attack a man, especially an ex.





Sinergy -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 8:30:45 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: CuriousLord

BDSM often simulates rape.  Some my tie up, gag, bind, and otherwise strip control from another, forcing themselves upon them sexually.
I've come to understand that one of the most tramuatic aspects of rape is that it can be intensively physically enjoyable.  I doubt it would be half so bad if not.  To physically enjoy being violated.. to have a lose of control.. and to hate it, all at once.



I disagree with this from the standpoint that it while it is true, in a sense, it misses the reality.

Rape is not about sex.  A person can go almost anywhere and get laid or buy sex.

Rape is about control.  It is about violence.  It is about stealing a portion of the victim's inner soul.

From the survivors I have spoken to, and what I have studied as an adjunct to my job, one of the biggest issues a survivor has to deal with is the profound sense of loss of control, as well as the self-hatred for having lost control of the situation.  She/He has something stolen from her soul by the animal that rapes her which she may spend the rest of her life trying to regain.

Sex is a biological imperative.  This woman may physically enjoy the act of sex.  But the mind recoils in horror from a rape because the context of deciding when and where to have sex is ripped from her control.  While you might enjoy the idea of being raped, I imagine you might feel differently when a large gang of other prison inmates breaks a light bulb inside your anus to ensure you have ready lubrication for their use during your incarceration.

It is not about the sex aspects, it is about the choice.  Rape is when the person being raped believes they do not have one.

Sinergy




darkinshadows -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 8:31:27 AM)

I don't think anyone denies there is a link between abuse victims and those that come into BDSM - but there are also people outside wiitwd that don't come into BDSM practises.  There isn't any 'proof' either way one is more than the other and I don't understand the disappointment that the thread brings this up.
 
Some people 're-enact' rape scenarios as some type of cathartic release due to past experiences.  Fact.
Some rape victims don't and find those that participate in such scenes to purge themselves as disturbing. Fact
Some rape victims do not use BDSM at all and choose another route. Fact.
 
quote:

BDSM often simulates rape. 

This I totally disagree with - although I get what you are saying, the inference is dangerous.  Unless you have been raped, you would have no idea what it can involve.  Some rape isn't violent at all and some do not even include Bondage.  For some, there isn't even a pinning down. Rape comes in many forms - some of it isn't even penetrative.  BDSM can consist of a scene that simulates rape, but to state that BDSM often simulates rape is a minor but dangerous supposition. (I am not meaning to be pedantic - but clarity is incredibly important and it isn't about being 'PC' it is about examining boundaries and clearing the way so that abuse in BDSM isn't acceptable in the Stein example)
 
So we get that some people involved in BDSM have been past abused, or even abusers.  But whether they got into BDSM because of that, is a wild and unanswerable guesstimate, because there is no possible way of knowing whether they would have experimented with BDSM without the abuse taking place.  It is simply one of those 'just never know' outcomes.  People can perceive that their rape or abuse led them to a place in their life where they need to use BDSM as a purging instrument, but that is like saying all self harmers are masochistic etc...
It is a simple unknown quantity...




MariaB -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 8:31:40 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: CuriousLord

quote:

ORIGINAL: MasterFireMaam

quote:

ORIGINAL: CuriousLord

rape was an introduction.  Into sex, into submission, into something outside the vanilla world. 


Rape isn't an introduction to anything but negative things. What we do is not negative. Please don't imply that rape is a "hazing" event for us.

Master Fire



Ick!  You cut my sentence part way through!  It read: "For those I've had, rape was an introduction."

Rape has been an introduction for at least some.  I imagine more.  It is not romantic.  It is not beautiful.  It is not the ideal.  It is, however, the truth.

This has been the truth for some of mine.  I have heard it from the vanilla world, in news reports.  I have learned it in Psyc101.


What do you mean by 'Introduction' ? By saying the word introduction, you are implying that rape has something to do with BDSM otherwise how on earth could it be an introduction. I think what you are trying to say is, by someone being raped they then then, therafter, took on a submissive mind set. I say NO WAY!!!




mixielicous -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 8:54:42 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: daddysprop247

i am not submissive because i was abused, i was abused because i was submissive.

my childhood abuser was so attracted to me because he sensed...as predators do...my deep submissive nature. he didn't want a challenge. he didn't want a struggle or a fight. he knew that he could take me easily, use me up, and that i would never tell.

unfortunately that wasn't my only experience with abuse in life, as i got older my submissive nature repeatedly got me into insane, scary, damaging situations. it was my discovery of the D/s lifestyle, and of what it meant to be submissive, that saved me. i finally realized that i was not just some hapless, hopeless freak of nature with the world's worst luck, but that i actually had a place in the world and that there were others like me. finding a Master, and especially the wonderful one i did, turned my submissiveness into a thing of beauty and value, whereas in the past it had been nothing but a burden and source of shame and self-disgust.



wow, this touched me so deeply. granted i am a bit emotional today but this brought me to tears. it was like a realization i could never see before. [also a rape/abuse victim but not as an intro to sex so much as an intro to "love"]

i feel like a massive weight was lifted, and i know a little better the "why of me"




mixielicous -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 9:03:36 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: KnightofMists



On it's surface.. it's a good quote.... but there is an implication that is gained from the quote that I think is not accurate.

"I was abused because I was submissive" equates to "I am submissive therefore I will be abused"

Abused individuals are person's that fail to protect the boundaries that maintain a healthy Well-Being. They are submissive and they can be Dominant personalities as well.

"I wasn't abused because I was submissive... I was abused because I failed to protect my Well-Being"

this to me is a more accurate quote.



i completely disagree. to me, you are reading between the lines and finding new words that do not exist. i cannot expect a man to understand what its like to be a young submissive woman, but i can tell you this much, if she *had the audacity* to speak up [aka - being out of line, asking for it, being rude, yadda yadda] then it would either, yes - get him to go away, OR get her worse - so is she really protecting her well being? so to equate the fact that she was unable to protect her wellbeing as the reason for her abuse, imo, is a very male thing to say. yes, she is submissive, yes that causes the abuse. NO that does not mean that all subs are abused, all it means is that a predator can pick up signals from a mile away. i am not saying dom persons are not victims either, but i can be sure they ARE the minority.




mixielicous -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 9:06:50 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: amiciaN
In my opinion, domination comes from a place of strength, whereas domineering behavior usually masks deep insecurity. One 'bullies' someone into submitting, the other inspires one into it. Bullies are inconsistent, those Dominants with long-term relationships seldom are.


thank you so much for this. so often i try and find the correlation within myself of HOW THE HELL did i make that transition from abuse to D/s, with the same actions, why dont they feel the same? i am definitely inspired into my current submission




mixielicous -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 9:15:00 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: MariaB

quote:

ORIGINAL: kyraofMists

quote:

ORIGINAL: MasterFireMaam

quote:

ORIGINAL: CuriousLord

rape was an introduction. Into sex, into submission, into something outside the vanilla world.


Rape isn't an introduction to anything but negative things. What we do is not negative. Please don't imply that rape is a "hazing" event for us.

Master Fire



I am glad someone else caught this too. That someone would even think that rape is an introduction into BDSM just boggles my mind. I have experienced both and I can say the two could not be farther apart if they tried. Being raped stripped me of my power. Being a slave to him enhances my power.

Knight's kyra


Ditto to that. At first I thought I was reading into something that was not there. I read this over and over wondering if I was missing something!
If rape is an introduction into BDSM then BDSM must = abuse. If someone entered into BDSM because of past abuse then they are in the wrong place because it would be a form of self harm by proxy.

gah, more people assuming the "across the board declaration" i am pretty sure when this man speaks of introductions, it is specific reference to the woman he types about it. it was their personal experience, does not mean that he believes all subs are intro into BDSM like this!!

yes, if the rapist declares that he is a master/dom, no matter how you wish it werent true, it WILL be their intro. YES it is an intro to submission, wether it is right or wrong intro was not even touched upon, but not everything is peachy. we would like to think people become aware of submission thru own learning but some people WILL have violent/wrong intros. it is up to you to show that this was the wrong way, that no matter what you are told, usually d/s is about love and nurturing.

yes its unfortunate, but accurate that he called it their intro to bdsm. it was their first experience with submission & hopefully they were able to learn from it and apply it to modern bdsm relationships

[puts on fire retardant pants]




mistoferin -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 9:29:17 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: mixielicous
she is submissive, yes that causes the abuse.


I could not possibly disagree more. It is possible for anyone of us to become a victim, submissive or Dominant. But submission is not an excuse to allow ourselves to continue to be someone's victim.




MariaB -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 9:30:22 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: WhipTheHip

Abuse can lead to a female becoming a top or a bottom.  Those those are genetically predisposed to directing their anger and aggressiveness outwards are more likely to become tops, doms / Dommes. 


So are you saying that Tops are generally angry? or just the Tops that have had past abuse?
Im a survivor of my past. Im never outwardly angry and never angry at all when I dominante. Never have been and never will be because thats not what being dominant is about.
So did what happened to me make me a Top? well I thought about it but then I remembered when I was very young I used to play games of being the teacher, the mother and the captor, so no, it was always in me.




mixielicous -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 9:35:00 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: mistoferin

quote:

ORIGINAL: mixielicous
she is submissive, yes that causes the abuse.


I could not possibly disagree more. It is possible for anyone of us to become a victim, submissive or Dominant. But submission is not an excuse to allow ourselves to continue to be someone's victim.

excuse? who said anything about excuses? there is no excuse, it is the simple reason why . i never claimed victims were 100% submissive, but hmm, i'd put it at least 60%.

i would not say one ALLOWS ones self to be a victim. why, because they are to young or scared to leave? is this how they allow the abuse to keep happening, or is it their inborn nature not to talk back? or the part where they feel wrong, and like they deserve it for being such a weak push over?

i could not possibly disagree more that anyone allows ones self to be abused. submissive nature completely aside.

submission is not the how, its the why.

and i never claimed it is across the board, just the majority. if you deny that, well then, look harder.




mistoferin -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 9:54:18 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: mixielicous
and i never claimed it is across the board, just the majority. if you deny that, well then, look harder.


Actually mixie, I have looked harder. As a counselor of Domestic Abuse and Sexual Assault for many years I think it would be fair to say that I have looked at the issue pretty thoroughly. And yes, I am here to say that MANY women in abusive situations are ALLOWING themselves to continue to be victims and that the cause for their abuse and their continued  victimization doesn't have one damn thing to do with being submissive. Staying in an abusive situation IS a choice....one that granted, will be justified by a million different excuses....some of them even understandable excuses....but excuses nonetheless. I can tell you that as a counselor I have worked very hard with victims of abuse to help them find their way around the roadblocks that keep them there....some will grasp the opportunities and free themselves....others will find a new roadblock every single time you take one away. But in all of the hundreds, possibly thousands of women I have councelled....not one has ever looked at me and said that she is doomed to a life of being abused because she is submissive and it's something we must simply accept as a cause and reason. That is utter BS.




mixielicous -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 10:01:40 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: mistoferin

....not one has ever looked at me and said that she is doomed to a life of being abused because she is submissive and it's something we must simply accept as a cause and reason. That is utter BS.

hmmm, well i agree that no sub woman is "doomed" to a life of abuse [if i claimed otherwise, please enlighten me again]

but i still must disagree with your last statement, that submissive nature is not the cause and reason.

i can tell you this much, if i was not meek, quiet, reserved, respectful, with in my bounds, always bending to please, then - no i would never have been abused. i would never have put up with it. granted, this was before i found M/s/D/s, but i can say with great confidence, if i, personally, was unruley, untamed, wild, relentless, without desire to please, appease, and not cause conflict, no, i would never have been in that situation, ever.

for me, there WAS a DIRECT correlation between my submissive nature and my abuse. and yes, i did try to say no when it came right down to it, and it felt wrong. and for you to say that i am using my submissive nature [or any woman for that matter] as an EXCUSE to why i became present in that situation, then you are belittling me, my experiences, my position in life and my choice of servitude.

edit coz i forgot some punctuation




daddysprop247 -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 10:10:40 AM)

mistoferin,

from this and past comments of yours regarding girls and women who have been abused, i know that you tend to take a rather hard/cold attitude towards people who are continually abused. to me such an attitude is almost as damaging as the abuser themselves, and far from helpful or empowering.

i do not think that simply because one is submissive, that they are "doomed" to a life of abuse. for me, it was recognizing the underlying cause of all the abuse in my life...my submissive nature...and truly understanding that, that gave me the tools to start taking measures to protect myself and prevent an ongoing cycle of abuse. after all, when you learn you are allergic to peanuts, you will avoid eating peanut butter. if you know you have skin cancer, you will not lounge in the sun. however you must know.

i was more conscious of the way i talked to people, the way i came across to others. more cautious of the places i went and when. i didn't become a fighter, i didn't start kicking butt or even saying "no" to people...those things will never be my nature. however because i was now aware, i was able to avoid most abusive situations. was it a cure all? not hardly. but i ceased feeling like a constant victim, and instead began to feel like a survivor. i think that self-awareness can be empowering, and this can help a submissive person who's endured abuse after abuse slowly start to end the neverending cycle.




mistoferin -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 10:14:24 AM)

mixie, I am not trying to belittle you or anyone else. One does not have to be wild, unruly and lacking a desire to please to avoid abusive situations. One can be meek, mild, respectful and be servitude driven and still be unwavering in what they will accept...and in what they will not tolerate. Submissive qualities are not a license that justifies abuse....or even a catalyst for it. I respect your view of the issue...I just don't happen to agree with it. It has been in my experience that victims stay victims because they continue to volunteer to be one. Without continued access to a victim it makes it very difficult for an abuser to be abusive.




hammernhoney -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 10:15:38 AM)

WHO says raping and abusing into submission is ok.IT isn't and it doesn't have to be part of this lifestyle.IF I caught someone raping against the others will .I would personal stomp a mudhole in his ass.I have done it and I would again...bounty




juliaoceania -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 10:24:21 AM)

quote:

 was more conscious of the way i talked to people, the way i came across to others. more cautious of the places i went and when. i didn't become a fighter, i didn't start kicking butt or even saying "no" to people...those things will never be my nature. however because i was now aware, i was able to avoid most abusive situations. was it a cure all? not hardly. but i ceased feeling like a constant victim, and instead began to feel like a survivor. i think that self-awareness can be empowering, and this can help a submissive person who's endured abuse after abuse slowly start to end the neverending cycle


While personally I do not have an opinion on whether or not being submissive is a common factor of being abused. I have no statistical information about the topic, therefore it seems rather rash to assume this is a causitive factor for most abuse.. I think that it can be, I also think that the above highlighted post shows how the way we perceive ourselves, our lives, and our histories can very well lead to an understanding of self that leads to finding ways to protect ourselves from the same situations occurring over and over again. Whatever works, do it!

Personally I can see how being submissive in personality could lead to being abused. I do not have any information on the prevalence of it though.

I would like to point out one more thing. It has been shown that people who become accustomed to living in a certain environment (whether that is one of abuse or not) will recreate that psychodrama over and over again. The new neuro science has postulated that we draw situations to us that will recreate our abuse, as though we are addicted to anger, fear, or other emotions biochemically.

It is hard to determine whether this is the chicken or the egg... and I think it is both and neither. I think some people are abused that are dominant, some people are abused that are submissive, some people are abused because they are submissive, some people are submissive because they were abused, some people were never abused, some people that have been abused were neither submissive or dominant....

Like my Daddy always says, Venn Diagrams solve all questions... lets make one[;)]




mixielicous -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 10:26:42 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: mistoferin

mixie, I am not trying to belittle you or anyone else. One does not have to be wild, unruly and lacking a desire to please to avoid abusive situations. One can be meek, mild, respectful and be servitude driven and still be unwavering in what they will accept...and in what they will not tolerate. Submissive qualities are not a license that justifies abuse....or even a catalyst for it. I respect your view of the issue...I just don't happen to agree with it. It has been in my experience that victims stay victims because they continue to volunteer to be one. Without continued access to a victim it makes it very difficult for an abuser to be abusive.

erin, i am sorry to come off abrasive. it is the only defense mechanism i have developed. we can agree to disagree, but unlike DProp247, it was not a relative to introduce me to abuse, it was someone i had made a commitment to. i was within a relationship with my abusee. for me this is where my nature greatly comes into play. i had made a commitment to this man and therefor felt my abuse was justified. i am sure in your line of work you hear all the time that "i deserved it", but combining my nature with the commitment i had pledged at the time, yes submission can become a catalyst. it does not matter what i desire to tolerate, all that matters to me, in the moment, is that i am good, still obedient and the strike was swift. yes, obviously i left [after being raped by the man] but i never felt so out of place, confused, jaded, and wrong for breaking my commitment and pledge to him. when you are submissive, [for me personally] it is not about what you are willing to tolerate but keeping true to the few promises i make.

yes, for me i would have, and was eventually, disenchanted enough to leave him.

avoiding the situation, i agree, anyone can do, but often the situtation comes to you. like many other relationships "it hadnt always been that way"




mistoferin -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 10:54:01 AM)

mixie, I too have been a victim of both abuse and sexual assault, long after I had come into this "lifestyle" if you will. There was a time when I believed that it was my submissive nature that opened the gates and made it possible for those realities to come to pass. Many years and much soul searching later I now realize it had absolutely nothing to do with my submission and everything to do with my inability at the time to take control and set healthy boundaries. In my situation of abuse I made every last one of the same excuses I hear from so many others as to why it was I couldn't get myself out of it. I continued to do so until one day the lightbulb finally clicked on and I could see clearly that I had as much personal responsibility for the situation continuing as he did and I had to step up to the plate and assume that responsibility.....and the responsibility from that point forward. As I said, I do understand and respect your perspective.




Aswad -> RE: Abused into submission (4/13/2007 11:16:04 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: WhipTheHip

People genetically predisposed to internalizing anger become depressed and submissive.  Those those are genetically predisposed to directing their anger and aggressiveness outwards are more likely to become tops, doms / Dommes.


While I haven't been sexually abused as a child, I've been through a lot of things that spawned a fair bit of anger. I tend to internalize that kind of anger, yet I'm a Dom. My slave has a tendency to directing it outwards instead, and has been through a lot more than I have, yet she's been submissive as long as she can remember. She even used to tie up her barbie-dolls when she was little...

I realize you are talking about probabilities, rather than absolutes, but in my experience, there is no correlation between internalizing and externalizing anger and whether any kind of emotionally adverse experiences lead to a tendency toward dominance or submission.

There may be a different relation for sadism/masochism, but again, I'm not seeing it. Do you have any numbers, even informal small-sample ones, from a somewhat more representative population than CollarMe that we could have a look at?

quote:

High testosterone makes people more prone to anger, hostility, physical and sexual aggression, a need to control and command.  Less testosterone lead to the opposite.


This overgeneralization has a core of truth to it, but it depends a lot on personality, and I seem to recall there is a bit of a sweet-spot issue here. That is, too low or too high can both cause similar problems.

I've always had very high testosterone (I started getting male pattern hair loss by the age of 18, etc.), which changed radically due to negligent medical treatment. In the lowest valley, the lab requested that the doctor check if I was undergoing unsupervised sex reassignment hormonal therapy, because my values were close to the female norm.

Low testosterone, for me, had the effect of muscle loss (about 30%), more feminine fat distribution, severe loss of energy, more anger, more hostility, more physical agression, stronger sex-drive, erectile dysfunction, and absolutely no effects on the dominance side of things. I realize this is typical, but it illustrates the point that the effects of testosterone are not uniform.

Dominant traits appear more closely related to neurotransmitter balance, not neurohormonal balance. I would presume the same is the case for submission.

quote:

When women are ovulating they are more likely to be attracted to high testosterone men. When they are not ovulating they are more likely to be attracted to men with les testosterone.


This does tend to be correct, although it is a matter of instinctual/animal attraction, and the extent to which this figures in attraction varies a lot between women, just like the correct use of dominant body language and such can seduce many but not all, as a remnant of the alpha/beta dynamic seen in apes.

More relevantly, though, testosterone levels affect how attracted they are to men in general, as well as sex drive; whether they're attracted to high-testosterone males in this period, might just as easily be more related to exposure, however.





Page: <<   < prev  3 4 [5] 6 7   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.0625