Aswad
Posts: 9374
Joined: 4/4/2007 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: deadbluebird aww, don't ya all feel soo bad for her? As probably the only one here, I do. Granted, what she did was unacceptable, and people are supposed to be equal under the law. But the question was whether we felt bad for her, and I do. Whether or not she's a spoiled brat who doesn't have half a clue what's going on in the world around her really doesn't matter all that much; that's how she was raised. This probably isn't making any sense to her, if she's been living so sheltered from the real world as it might appear, and it always hurts and confuses to be punished for something when you don't understand what's behind it. While it doesn't obviate personal responsibility, we are still very much a product of our environment, and are not always in control of that environment. Also, quite relevantly, I think it's rather a nasty idea to put her in a regular jail. House arrest somewhere like the witness protection programme would make more sense, and probably be as much of a "step down" from what she's used to as jail would be for the rest of us. Bear in mind that there are more than a few people out there, myself included, who have the distinct urge to take her down a few notches; show her the "real world", so to speak. I have the restraint that would prevent me from actually doing so, or considering it the right thing to do (although I really do dislike a lot of things about her), but a lot of the people she will be serving time with might not have that restraint, and I would in no way put it past her to keep her foot as firmly planted in her mouth in there as she does in the media, which could constitute provocation. In the outside world, she has bodyguards to deal with that sort of thing. Not so in prison. The wardens don't count, and quite a few of them might actually be added to the list of candidates that might hurt her in there. I really don't think it'll be improving anything, and I don't think punishment is a valid goal of any justice system (although it is apparently a stated goal of the US justice system). As I said, putting her in house arrest with a fairly basic quality of life would be more in the interests of justice. And as for the added cost, just have her foot the bill. I'm sure she'd be happy to, given the alternative. So, yeah, I feel sorry for her.
_____________________________
"If God saw what any of us did that night, he didn't seem to mind. From then on I knew: God doesn't make the world this way. We do." -- Rorschack, Watchmen.
|