NorthernGent -> RE: Bin Laden urges Americans to convert to Islam (9/8/2007 3:46:38 AM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Politesub53 quote:
ORIGINAL: NorthernGent quote:
ORIGINAL: seeksfemslave While believe it or not I agree with some of what NG says,eg criticism of the Wisconsin Senator's antics in the 50's and especially the CIA, he appears to be overlooking the fact that bin Laden sees himself and his religion as being in a fight to the death with Western values.We either appease or oppose. To achieve their aims fundamentalist Muslims will do anything up to exploding dirty nuclear devices. Is that western propaganda ? You're confusing Bin Laden, fundamentalism, terrorism and Islam: they're not one and the same, so there's no use in trying to fit them into a neat package to support your pre-conceived notions. Bin Laden is an Islamic fundamentalist involved in terrorism. How can you say they are not linked in a package ? True enough only a few Muslims are terrorists. Seeks views on Bin laden and what he hopes to achieve, by any means he can, are correct. He ( Bin Laden ) has issued a Fatwah stating as much. The OP is concerned with Bin Laden, but, as per usual, we've progressed from Bin Laden to fundamentalism to Islam as if they're all irretrievably linked i.e. the opinion that there is something about Islam that inevitably leads to terrorism, in a way that other religions don't. My point is/was that Bin Laden is one person, he is not Islam, nor is he fundamentalism, nor does fundamentalism necessarily lead to terrorism. 'Not sure how much you know about the Middle East, but they are far more concerned with fundamentalism than you and I, because they will have to live with the consequences, unlike you and I. quote:
ORIGINAL: Politesub53 Also when Bin Laden speaks of embracing Islam its obvious to me he means convert to Islam, perhaps you choose to see it differently but that doesn`t mean everyone else is wrong. Is it obvious? Not to me. When I hug someone I embrace them, I invite them and accept them: I'm not attempting to control/convert that person to my way of thinking; in my mind, embrace suggests acceptance, rather than control. I'll hazard a guess that if you have a look in the dictionary for a definition of the word embrace, it will suggest inclusion rather than conversion. If you choose to see embrace as control, then I'd be baffled, but it's your call if you want to go down that road.
|
|
|
|