RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


SolarAndViolet -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 11:25:19 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: ownedgirlie

There seems to be an assumption that if we don't all think the same, because some of us don't subscribe to limits and safe words in our relationships, that something is wrong with us. Well, maybe there is, lol. Maybe there isn't. But to assume this as fact would be an incorrect assumption.



I personally didn't see where that assumption has came up in this thread... I didn't see it. But may be I missed it. I don't deny that that assumption floats in the world, in the community though... But so does the assumption that goes another way. Assumption that those of us who do subscribe to limits and safewords, lack something or have something wrong with us. :) :) :) Goes both ways, doesn't it?

I recognize that people have different types of relationships, at different levels and different preferences.

'violet'




missturbation -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 11:28:56 AM)

My apologies if i have made you feel i was implying you lack something because you use safewords and limits, that was never my intention. [:)]




WillowRain -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 11:32:12 AM)

I suppose it depends on how you think of limits or how you define them.

The first limit that pops to mind for me, about myself that I can't imagine ever changing or flexing is that I won't intentionally act in a way to acheive personal gain at someone elses loss, damage or detriment. I have real issues with this and it is a foundational part of who I am and my moral set. Now I can't imagine ever serving someone who would say, "You willow, that person over there displeases me, go do something mean to them to hurt them and wound them emotionally, physically, and spiritually just to make me happy. I want to benifit at the price of their emotional damage and harm."

I cannot imagine anyone I would serve ever wanting me to do such a thing, ever, not imaginable. BUT, should someone I was in service to, actually lose their mind temporarily and tell me to do something like that... I would balk... I would say no.. It would hit so hard to my own personal sense of self and moral code that I would be smack dab pressed against a boundary.

I also wouldn't kill a child.

Or kick puppies to death.

These seem like crazy extreem examples. There are edges and places where I am who I am, and doing something that would foundationally damage my ability to respect them and myself would be a nail in the coffin of the relationship anyway.

But as I think on it... maybe I would be learning that they weren't worthy of trust. So maybe I think of limits as lines and places where trust can break, or perhaps should break. Like caution lines, and the spaces beyond that are danger zones. I consider myself a trust fetishist and love trust.... but do I want to be in a situation where if someone told me to kill an infant, I would? No, I don't want that actually. I want my common sense to kick in.




RumpusParable -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 11:37:11 AM)

Shortest way of saying it:  Trusting someone isn't the same as expecting them to be superhuman.




SolarAndViolet -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 11:44:44 AM)

*smiles* I am no offended, but it does sound so. :)

I just think that we all should accept that we are different, with different likes, dislikes and types of relationships... not to mention different partners :) (that's the best part I think ! :) )

We perceive and relate trust to different things perhaps too... just may be :) But that doesn't mean we trust less or more in our own, personal and therefor different situations.

Take things outside of BDSM lifestyle.. there are things in the world that I don't understand (and i won't list them here because I don't want a flood of people trying to explaining them to me... that'd be hijacking the thread :) ) But just because I don't understand them, doesn't mean they are wrong, or worse than things that I do. I just accept them as things that work for those people but may be not me.

'violet'

*edited to add* --- By the way, we here discuss and don't understand each other on different types of relationships and ways of living them... But there are many 'vanilla' folks out there who don't understand any of us, and think that we lack many things if we have to get into D/s relationships. (not that I care what they think.. but it's an example) Then there are those 'nilla' folk who don't understand, but just accept us as we are, still remain our friends. (I'm sure many of us have those friends) ...
Just wanted to add that.




ownedgirlie -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 11:54:47 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: AquaticSub

quote:

ORIGINAL: ownedgirlie

There seems to be an assumption that if we don't all think the same, because some of us don't subscribe to limits and safe words in our relationships, that something is wrong with us.  Well, maybe there is, lol.  Maybe there isn't.  But to assume this as fact would be an incorrect assumption.


I hope that isn't the flavor you've gotten from me. Some people just don't want safewords - and to be honest, you'd never know we had one since it never gets used and we keep forgetting what the damn thing is! - and some people do. We just don't see it as a measure of trust either way in our relationship. [:)]


Hi Aquatic, no it is not a flavor I got from you (other than jello, lol).  You are always very clear that you are speaking about your own relationship and you understand that others will do what they do.  You simply seem to be explaining your relationship to others so they can understand it.  It's all good [;)]




ownedgirlie -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:12:48 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: SolarAndViolet


quote:

ORIGINAL: ownedgirlie

There seems to be an assumption that if we don't all think the same, because some of us don't subscribe to limits and safe words in our relationships, that something is wrong with us. Well, maybe there is, lol. Maybe there isn't. But to assume this as fact would be an incorrect assumption.



I personally didn't see where that assumption has came up in this thread... I didn't see it. But may be I missed it. I don't deny that that assumption floats in the world, in the community though... But so does the assumption that goes another way. Assumption that those of us who do subscribe to limits and safewords, lack something or have something wrong with us. :) :) :) Goes both ways, doesn't it?

I recognize that people have different types of relationships, at different levels and different preferences.

'violet'


I think I've spent too much time on several of the threads here, in which the theme does seem to be an assumption, so I probably carried some of that frustration with me when coming to this thread.  For the most part, this thread has been a civil discussion and I did not mean to misrepresent it.  There are some quotes, however, that fed the overall theme I've been seeing a lot of lately.  And while I understand I may have misread or misunderstood them, because of the bigger picture, they had that negative effect on my thinking.

As for it going both ways, I honestly see the "You must be insane" accusation flying in the direction of those without limits or safewords far more than toward those who have them. 

Examples (I bolded the parts that affected me):

Chellekitty:  ... but thats common sensem after i say it...but...i am gonna say it

My thoughts - what is common sense?  Why would you deem what is common sense for me?  Common sense is highly subjective and I very likely may not feel the same as you.
 
Maya2001:  …to allow that person, whom you do not know well  to do whatever they want to with you without any  limits at all would be insane…

Define "not know well."  I visited my Master for the first time after 2 months of internet and telephone calls.  I went to him to offer myself to him fully, without limits or safewords.  That was three years ago.  I didn't know him well enough to trust him completely.  Hell it took years to trust him completely.  But I had a pretty good blend of trust and leap of faith going on.  Maybe you'd call me insane for that.  But since you do not know me at all, that would be an ignorant assessment.

and then later in the the same post:

So say you have no limits but I am sure you do, it just may not be necessary for you to express  them with your current dom.

 
Such certainty expressed about other people.  I know two people whose lives brought them to the point of having no limits for themselves at all, regardless of relationship.  Lots of people in this world.  To express certainty about strangers is not something I recommend.
 

If your dom decided tomorrow to pimp you out, would you agree? 
if your dom want to have a dog penetrate you, would you agree?
would you allow your dom to brand you , shave your head, defecate, urinate  on you  etc?
If you would say no to any of the above they are in fact limits, there are some doms that enjoy these activities, a sub may say they do not enjoy,   that  becomes a limit.
 


I see these kinds of examples on a lot of posts.  These activities are more commonplace than I think people are aware of.  I personally would answer yes to all of them, and in fact many of them are things he engages me in fairly regularly.  Nothing you posted is shocking to me, personally, and in fact all of them have been talked about between he and I.  Whether I enjoy them or not is not the issue; it's whether I obey his direction to do them.  You might be surprised at the benefit I've received from doing things I don't like to do.  Heck, I hate cleaning my bathroom...but I sure enjoy bathing in a sparkling clean tub [;)]


WillowRain:  If you didn't trust them, why on earth would you do any bdsm type stuff with them? Why would you follow them? Why would you entrust them with leadership? Why would you let them tie you up? Or take you into extreme sensation? None of that makes any rational sense unless you deeply trust the person.
 
 
To this I would ask, Why?  Deeply trust?  "Deeply" is subjective, but some people do take leaps of faith - is that irrational behavior?  Some people do listen to that gut feeling that tells them when going into a situation is safe or dangerous - would that be irrational?  I did not "deeply trust" my Master when I asked him to train me as his slave...a leadership position.  In which he tied me up.  In which he gave me extreme sensations.  I grew to deeply trust him, but we didn't start out that way.  Maybe that was irrational, maybe not.  It worked for me...but the statement above claims I was irrational.

It's the themes that seem to communicate absolute truths for all that brought me to say what I did above.  And I see them so often that it was reflected in my thoughts that were quoted above. 

Hope that explains where I was coming from.
 




SolarAndViolet -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:28:06 PM)

Ownedgirlie,

I understand where you coming from, whether I agree or not, that's another story :)

Just like the OP (and most people), it is totally human to apply other people's examples and experiences onto our own perceptions. I myself am not innocent of doing so, but I often try to take a step back and say to myself "This is not my way and yes I think it's crazy enough that I wouldn't do it but... if it words for that person and they are happy and healthy, it's all fine." :)

Not everyone is into everything, that's what we all should remember. :) We are all different but we are in the same community.

Understand the differences, or at least just accept them.

'violet'




ownedgirlie -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:29:30 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: SolarAndViolet
I understand where you coming from, whether I agree or not, that's another story :)



Thanks, SolarAndViolet, and if we all agreed, what a boring world it would be :) 

I agree about accepting the differences, which was my original issue, if we can call it that.  Thanks for your reply!




missturbation -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:33:03 PM)

I think perhaps i'm just going to have to let this one go. Don't think i'm going to understand or really agree with those whose opinions differ to my own.
However each to their own and as long as everyone is happy, fulfilled etc its all good.
Thank you to everyone who took the time to try and help me understand. [:D]




breatheasone -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:36:42 PM)

I think i too have reached that point..... Its been suggested that people with limits don't have trust...TO ME thats DEAD wrong...but you know what?....thats ok too...because we all have the right to be wrong.




missturbation -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:40:27 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: breatheasone

I think i too have reached that point..... Its been suggested that people with limits don't have trust...TO ME thats DEAD wrong...but you know what?....thats ok too...because we all have the right to be wrong.


Who stated that? Not me. I said i didn't understand how there can be trust when placing limits, not that there wasn't. Please do not put words in my mouth. No i'm probably not going to understand how it works but i resent the way your last post makes me sound.

edited to add :- I don't believe there is any right or wrong in this. What i choose to take away and belive from this discussion is my perogative. Even if i say to you, you i truely believe that trust is lacking in your relationship because of limits / safewords etc it is still just my opinion and not wrong and not right. The lack of safe words and limits  works for me and Sir and the use of safewords and limits works for you. Does that really mean either one of us is wrong?




breatheasone -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:45:00 PM)

quote:

I guess it boils down for me to the question 'If you trust your partner 100% why do you need limits / safewords?'
Does this not show a lack of trust?
And if you havent got 100% trust what have you got?






missturbation -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:51:11 PM)

Yes, FOR ME. Noone else just me.
Also isolating that one statement doesnt allow for the fact i also said i knew i was being judgemental and that i was attempting to understand.
Am i therefore to be condemned for attempting to understand anothers position?




breatheasone -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:52:39 PM)

Condemned?...can you show me ANY quote i made that condemned you?




BeingChewsie -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:53:58 PM)

quote:

if your dom want to have a dog penetrate you, would you agree?
would you allow your dom to brand you , shave your head, defecate, urinate  on you  etc?


I can't help but break out into a chorus of "and these are a few of my favorite things...

What makes them some of my favorites,what makes them sooooo hot is that if I could limit them, if I could impose/enforce boundaries on those things I would. The fact that he just pisses all over my *limits*(no pun intended) and does what he wants...hot.

I don't expect anybody to understand that.




missturbation -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:55:52 PM)

Ok maybe too strong a word to use but you accuse me of being wrong in my values. They are my values and whilst they may not be yours that does not make them wrong.
You then go on to pull a quote from me which points to me being extremely judgemental of others but fail to state that i had already admitted my thoughts were judegemental and i was trying to change that.
Give a girl a break for gods sake.




ownedgirlie -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:56:25 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BeingChewsie

I can't help but break out into a chorus of "and these are a few of my favorite things...


LOL  "when the dog bites, when the bee stings..."

quote:


I don't expect anybody to understand that.


Trust me, I do.




missturbation -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:57:57 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BeingChewsie

quote:

if your dom want to have a dog penetrate you, would you agree?
would you allow your dom to brand you , shave your head, defecate, urinate  on you  etc?


I can't help but break out into a chorus of "and these are a few of my favorite things...

What makes them some of my favorites,what makes them sooooo hot is that if I could limit them, if I could impose/enforce boundaries on those things I would. The fact that he just pisses all over my *limits*(no pun intended) and does what he wants...hot.

I don't expect anybody to understand that.


Im with ya there. I do certain things i dont like doing but obviously have not put limits on doing them. Sir doing them knowing i dont like doing them and enjoying himself whilst doing it is hot [:D]




breatheasone -> RE: I'm being judgemental - apologies !! (9/20/2007 12:58:45 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: missturbation

Ok maybe too strong a word to use but you accuse me of being wrong in my values. They are my values and whilst they may not be yours that does not make them wrong.
You then go on to pull a quote from me which points to me being extremely judgemental of others but fail to state that i had already admitted my thoughts were judegemental and i was trying to change that.
Give a girl a break for gods sake.

Nope ......i said that you were wrong about me not having trust in my Master. Not once did i mention your values were wrong.




Page: <<   < prev  5 6 [7] 8 9   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.0625