Collarspace Discussion Forums


Home  Login  Search 

RE: The Concept of Fate?


View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest
 
All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid >> RE: The Concept of Fate? Page: <<   < prev  1 2 [3] 4   next >   >>
Login
Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 1:18:07 PM   
darkinshadows


Posts: 4145
Joined: 6/2/2004
From: UK
Status: offline
quote:

As I've said, unlike most of the fate-debunkers on this thread, I believe that all things are fated, because I don't see how any other conception of the universe is possible. But I don't believe they are fated by an intelligent power, and I don't believe you can get away with saying that some things are fated and other things aren't.


This is a really interesting concept. I don't think I have had a conversation with someone who believes in fate minus the intelligent/higher power. How is fate controlled in your perception of it?

Thank for taking the time to read my question

Peace and Love


_____________________________


.dark.




...i surrender to gravity and the unknown...

(in reply to Lordandmaster)
Profile   Post #: 41
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 2:08:55 PM   
FangsNfeet


Posts: 3758
Joined: 12/3/2004
Status: offline
quote:

I do not think this analagy holds up. Because sometimes, those poolballs, just end up on the floor.


On floor yes and sometimes on another table but it eventually gets picked up and moved. If the other ball with the same number goes to the table you came from, oh well, you're still going to end up in a hole.

_____________________________

I'm Godzilla and you're Japan

(in reply to darkinshadows)
Profile   Post #: 42
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 2:43:31 PM   
MstrHellsFury


Posts: 388
Joined: 1/5/2005
Status: offline
I'm not going to strain my brain for a rational answer to this one...we all have theories of what is or isn't..from scientific reason to just plain faith based reason...I know what I believe is a reasonable answer but that fits for me..not everyone else...so I'll just smile on your good fortune and wish you well...


Fury

(in reply to mistoferin)
Profile   Post #: 43
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 3:09:47 PM   
Lordandmaster


Posts: 10943
Joined: 6/22/2004
Status: offline
It's controlled by processes we don't understand. Yes, that's kind of a cop-out answer, but it's the only honest one. We understand SOME things about those processes, and will understand a lot more in the future, but I don't think we will ever be able to understand them fully.

Astrophysics has a fairly decent time explaining how we got from the Big Bang to here (although there are, obviously, some major outstanding questions), but not a very good time at all explaining what happened before the Big Bang or how the Big Bang happened in the first place. But whatever the truth (and, again, much of it is probably unknowable to us), I don't think any of the events that preceded the Big Bang could have been random because none of the events that happened AFTER it were random either. (I'm not a physicist myself, but have friends who are, so I'm fairly confident about making statements like this; however, if someone believes I am making some seriously erroneous claims about physics, please correct me.) At any rate, I don't believe the behavior of any particle anywhere in the universe is random. It may APPEAR to us to be random, but I don't think it really is random.

Lam

quote:

ORIGINAL: dark~angel

How is fate controlled in your perception of it?


(in reply to darkinshadows)
Profile   Post #: 44
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 3:11:06 PM   
darkinshadows


Posts: 4145
Joined: 6/2/2004
From: UK
Status: offline
quote:

On floor yes and sometimes on another table but it eventually gets picked up and moved. If the other ball with the same number goes to the table you came from, oh well, you're still going to end up in a hole.


Yes. But thats another game...

Peace and Love


_____________________________


.dark.




...i surrender to gravity and the unknown...

(in reply to FangsNfeet)
Profile   Post #: 45
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 3:13:26 PM   
darkinshadows


Posts: 4145
Joined: 6/2/2004
From: UK
Status: offline
quote:

It's controlled by processes we don't understand. Yes, that's kind of a cop-out answer, but it's the only honest one. We understand SOME things about those processes, and will understand a lot more in the future, but I don't think we will ever be able to understand them fully.

Astrophysics has a fairly decent time explaining how we got from the Big Bang to here (although there are, obviously, some major outstanding questions), but not a very good time at all explaining what happened before the Big Bang or how the Big Bang happened in the first place. But whatever the truth (and, again, much of it is probably unknowable to us), I don't think any of the events that preceded the Big Bang could have been random because none of the events that happened AFTER it were random either. (I'm not a physicist myself, but have friends who are, so I'm fairly confident about making statements like this; however, if someone believes I am making some seriously erroneous claims about physics, please correct me.) At any rate, I don't believe the behavior of any particle anywhere in the universe is random. It may APPEAR to us to be random, but I don't think it really is random.


Thank You for reply - lots to think on there...

Peace and Love


_____________________________


.dark.




...i surrender to gravity and the unknown...

(in reply to Lordandmaster)
Profile   Post #: 46
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 3:21:38 PM   
anthrosub


Posts: 843
Joined: 6/2/2004
Status: offline
I'm going to reply to both you and Lordandmaster here. The example I will use is a forest to represent the complexity of everything going on, simultaneously, all around us, at any given moment.

When you look at a forest, most people see a bunch of trees of various sizes, maybe some bushes and plants around the edges, a few inside the forest, as well as a few dead tree trunks and limbs scattered about. Most people would say this is chaotic. But if you take the time to study what's going on, you will see a natural order that's always in the making, refining itself, adjusting to the flow of changes, and so on...instead of the "order" people try to impose when they plant everything in neat little rows and patches and call that "order."

Every tree and plant in that forest is competing with each other. Not competition like we think of in sports but the process of one plant getting more resources simply because of where and when it started growing in comparison to all the others. Because of this, some trees will grow faster (and bigger) than those around it and continue to benefit from getting more sunshine, more rain, and more nutrients from the ground.

Over time, the forest will "sort itself out" as it matures. Some trees will die off early while others grow quite tall. Trees that are of the same species will appear to dominate an area while others will take up other areas that are more favorable to their requirements. Storms, forest fires, parasites, and animals will all have a part to play in how this process continues as well.

Eventually the forest will become what dendrologists refer to as a "climax forest." The trees are about as big as they'll ever get. At some point a tree will die, weaken, and fall to the ground (usually due to high winds from a storm) and take a few other trees with it or at least damage them. The moment this happens, an opening is created and the whole process starts anew.

It's been said that the forests we see around us today are nothing compared to what existed when the first European settlers arrived 500 years ago. I think the giant Redwoods in California are the only remaining stand of virgin trees in the continental United States. Anyway, there's an order in the world without intelligence. The forest is my example of how this takes place.

One might argue that there's a difference because we can make choices (like taking the back road instead of the familar highway) where trees cannot. But when you think about it, the choices we make remain within the boundary of our own lives which happens to be a larger sphere than that experienced by a tree growing out of the ground. It's really only a difference of scale. So in effect, we are just like the trees in the forest and it's only a matter of circumstance that one day we will "fall" in our "forest" for some varied reason just like the tree in my example.

anthrosub


_____________________________

"It is easier to fool people than it is to convince them they have been fooled." - Mark Twain

"I am not young enough to know everything." - Oscar Wilde

(in reply to darkinshadows)
Profile   Post #: 47
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 4:43:36 PM   
Lordandmaster


Posts: 10943
Joined: 6/22/2004
Status: offline
Basically I agree with anthro, and the fact that we can make choices (or that we believe we can make choices) does not rule out the possibility that all those choices were in fact foreordained. In other words, on the question of free will, I subscribe to compatibilism, which is the view that the doctrines of free will and determinism are not incompatible with each other. Our sense of our free will is something like our sense of our consciousness; neither one necessitates a dualistic universe.

(in reply to anthrosub)
Profile   Post #: 48
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 4:57:33 PM   
knees2you


Posts: 2336
Joined: 3/15/2004
Status: offline
Maybe it was "Preterists"


Sincerely, Ant

(in reply to Lordandmaster)
Profile   Post #: 49
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 5:02:51 PM   
Lordandmaster


Posts: 10943
Joined: 6/22/2004
Status: offline
And ... maybe it wasn't.

(in reply to knees2you)
Profile   Post #: 50
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 6:00:59 PM   
darkinshadows


Posts: 4145
Joined: 6/2/2004
From: UK
Status: offline
Thank You for putting your take on it anthro. I understand the concept, but am having difficulty with something. See, what you describe I dont see as fate - I see that as evolution (unless I am misinterpreting what your saying) - see fate to me is the place that is already organised by an individual source or entity. Now ultimately that is death. I dont have a worry about that being 'fate' - My fate is to die and thats ok with me. But fate a a predetermined occurance like - 'I am fated to marry this person' or 'I was fated to not be involved in this accident' - I cant get my head around that kind of fate belief. I see only another lesson to gain experience from.

What anthro said makes sense that we have a total end result - I can grasp that concept, but not a fate concept that is a kind of 'destiny' I guess.

Peace and Love


_____________________________


.dark.




...i surrender to gravity and the unknown...

(in reply to anthrosub)
Profile   Post #: 51
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 6:01:56 PM   
darkinshadows


Posts: 4145
Joined: 6/2/2004
From: UK
Status: offline

quote:

ORIGINAL: knees2you

Maybe it was "Preterists"


Sincerely, Ant

Howso?

Peace and Love


_____________________________


.dark.




...i surrender to gravity and the unknown...

(in reply to knees2you)
Profile   Post #: 52
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 6:21:19 PM   
knees2you


Posts: 2336
Joined: 3/15/2004
Status: offline
quote:

Howso?

Peace and Love


_____________________________


Blessings


~Angel~


They have of a different way of looking at things~

http://www.planetpreterist.com/

Not my cup of tea, but hey~

Sincerely, Ant

(in reply to darkinshadows)
Profile   Post #: 53
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 6:26:32 PM   
darkinshadows


Posts: 4145
Joined: 6/2/2004
From: UK
Status: offline
Oh, I know what a preterist concept is, I just didnt see how is fitted into the context of fate or what anthro said.
It just confused me...

Peace and Love


_____________________________


.dark.




...i surrender to gravity and the unknown...

(in reply to knees2you)
Profile   Post #: 54
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/9/2005 8:25:32 PM   
anthrosub


Posts: 843
Joined: 6/2/2004
Status: offline
My example has nothing to do with evolution but rather how things proceed as determined by time and place. For example, a seed falls from a tree and lands on a spot where it probably won't take root. It fell there because the wind was blowing through the tree branches that day. So the tree branches played a part in directing the force and path of the wind which in turn affected the path of the falling seed. Perhaps a squirrel picks up the seed to eat it and starts carrying it along only to be spooked by a hawk that flys overhead and scares the squirrel so much that it drops the seed in a better location where it can now grow. Is that fate?

I understand your difficulty and think it might have something to do with putting fate "on" the situation (similar to putting a map grid on an area of land to organize it into squares). In this case, your trying to understand where the organization of events comes from in terms of a.) some outside actor or force and b.) your ability or inability to sense what's happening at such a small level of detail that you can almost but not quite "predict" an outcome. The experience is similar to seeing something out of the corner of your eye but when you try to look directly at it with purpose, it disappears.

What I'm saying is the order of events are part and parcel to the total environment. In short...self organization of events where everything plays a part in the outcome. Now in a situation where it seems like fate, you might say you were either very receptive to what was happening around you without realizing it...or...you were part of some key events that gave you an unconscious sense of what to do next without having to reason it out like you might normally do.

In my experience, fate is similar to deja vu. It comes out of thin air and feels like you are having hindsight on events that are just about to happen. It's like being on the cutting edge of the present where you feel like you're in a balancing act. But if you step back and look at the whole thing later on, you can see how all the events fit together in a huge web of causality.

anthrosub


_____________________________

"It is easier to fool people than it is to convince them they have been fooled." - Mark Twain

"I am not young enough to know everything." - Oscar Wilde

(in reply to darkinshadows)
Profile   Post #: 55
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/10/2005 12:10:56 AM   
brightspot


Posts: 3052
Status: offline
It's my personal belief..Magic Happens....Shit Occurs!

*Brightspot


< Message edited by brightspot -- 8/10/2005 12:14:12 AM >


_____________________________

"Comedy is NOT Pretty!" ~Peter Nelson

But..."May at Least One person have a sense of Humor!" ~KML.

http://360.yahoo.com/my_profile-TD4TwEw8crWS3GHFDcs_DK1rHmW6Dq_E;_ylt=Av2PfG9gH0wkQrMPivuMCivGAOJ3

(in reply to mistoferin)
Profile   Post #: 56
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/10/2005 3:10:50 AM   
darkinshadows


Posts: 4145
Joined: 6/2/2004
From: UK
Status: offline


quote:

For example, a seed falls from a tree and lands on a spot where it probably won't take root. It fell there because the wind was blowing through the tree branches that day. So the tree branches played a part in directing the force and path of the wind which in turn affected the path of the falling seed. Perhaps a squirrel picks up the seed to eat it and starts carrying it along only to be spooked by a hawk that flys overhead and scares the squirrel so much that it drops the seed in a better location where it can now grow. Is that fate?


See, I dont see fate, I just see a process.

I don't have a problem with fate persay, like I said, I kind of believe in the concept of 'we are all fated to eventually die' - but I dont understand or agree personally with the whole 'mystical' qualities designated to fate by some people.

I think one persons fate is anothers destiny. Now destiny I can comprehend, because to me it implies a process. A journey - a destination to be reached.

If I put water in a kettle and place it on a fire, then its destiny is that it will boil. If a caterpillar survives, then its destiny is that it will become a moth or a butterfly, depending on its breed. That seed that fell is destined one day to become a tree - but the way it becomes a tree is nothing to do with how it reaches that destiny. Its a possiblity that the tree wont become a tree, due to an outside event - like landing on concrete - but thats nothing to do with fate IMO - thats to do with the luck of the draw. Wind strength, weather etc... isnt 'fate' in my eyes - fate is by definition an inevitable event, not one of luck.

Peace and Love


_____________________________


.dark.




...i surrender to gravity and the unknown...

(in reply to anthrosub)
Profile   Post #: 57
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/10/2005 3:18:01 AM   
imtempting


Posts: 1280
Joined: 2/11/2005
Status: offline
so Fate is stronger then what God is meant to be?? Or is fate set by god? Fate just seems an excuse to believe there was nothing you could do to change an event or the event was meant to be.

Was it fate I let an ex girlfriend use me or my stupidity?

(in reply to mistoferin)
Profile   Post #: 58
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/10/2005 4:56:53 AM   
anthrosub


Posts: 843
Joined: 6/2/2004
Status: offline
quote:

See, I dont see fate, I just see a process.


That's basically my point. Life is a process for the most part. We humans have this big brain that's always looking at everything around it and trying to put meaning on it. I know a lot of people will disagree but life IS meaningless in and of itself. It's we who bring meaning to life, not the other way around.

I think a lot of folks have a problem with this because of what it implies. It's also a big disappointment because many think there must be a reason behind everything. But that's just a part of being human. One person will look at a series of events and say it was fate, another will say it was inevitable, and yet a third will say it's magical. But in the end it all simply happened. The fact that we are capable of discerning patterns doesn't make it all any more special, it just means we have the ability to see patterns in things (like seeing objects in clouds as they pass overhead).

By the way, none of what I'm saying means you still can't have fun doing these things.

anthrosub


_____________________________

"It is easier to fool people than it is to convince them they have been fooled." - Mark Twain

"I am not young enough to know everything." - Oscar Wilde

(in reply to darkinshadows)
Profile   Post #: 59
RE: The Concept of Fate? - 8/10/2005 5:47:07 AM   
domtimothy46176


Posts: 670
Joined: 12/25/2004
From: Dayton, Ohio area
Status: offline
In reply to the OP, I would describe it as a confluence of disparate things.

It's my belief that we all have a "potential" life that is possible for us if we make the correct decisions and that by making poor decisions we can fall short of that potential.

I also believe that sometimes we get a little "nudge" to choose one course of action over another. I think that "nudge" manifests in different ways: deja vu, unwarranted feelings of dread or optimism, intuition, etc.

It seems to me, based on what you wrote, mistoferin, that you got a little nudge that you chose to heed. As to the drunk's "fate", it seems fair to say that he was there as a result of his own actions, just as you were left uninvolved as a result of your actions.

Timothy

(in reply to mistoferin)
Profile   Post #: 60
Page:   <<   < prev  1 2 [3] 4   next >   >>
All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid >> RE: The Concept of Fate? Page: <<   < prev  1 2 [3] 4   next >   >>
Jump to:





New Messages No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages Locked w/o New Messages
 Post New Thread
 Reply to Message
 Post New Poll
 Submit Vote
 Delete My Own Post
 Delete My Own Thread
 Rate Posts




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy

0.094