ShaktiSama
Posts: 1674
Joined: 8/13/2007 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: slaveboyforyou I see your point to a degree. Yes, I see your points as well, which is why I thought it was worthwhile to clarify my position. I am not a sex-negative person at all, and ultimately my difficulties with porn as an industry are not about the depiction of sex per se, or the marketing of sex as a product. They are about power, money, and what I suppose I should call "vocality"--the fact that women in these industries are robbed of a voice. Men and women around the world should be able to say today that they are fans of Bunnie Yeager and Paula Kramer--these artists should be revered in the same way that the male painters who created pin-ups are revered, like Elvgren and Vargas. The fact that these women are obscure and unknown is unjust and unfair to both women and men. Similarly, I do not particularly care if people make "huge-titted lesbians rape the pizza boy" porn. What I care about is that they make nothing else. Women have no power to express their own desires in the industry. They don't write the scripts, they don't get to direct, they aren't behind the camera, they aren't calling the shots. Women aren't deciding whose orgasm is worth shooting and whose is not worth the time and trouble to achieve, whose body is sexier than whose, whose time is worth more money, etc.. This isn't a business that allows women a voice, and this is pretty much the sum total of what's wrong with pornography in my opinion. People can say that the only market for pornography is male, which is why the only voices creating it should be male--but this is a worthless line of reasoning, a tautology. Who knows how much porn women would watch if there was more porn for women? I can't wait to see Akasha's boy-on-boy movie; even if gay porn isn't particularly my thing, I would go out of my way to see a film I knew she had directed, because I am dying to see the artistic result of a woman controlling that many male bodies at once. Whether men would enjoy watching erotic scenes that represented a woman's erotic wants and needs remains to be seen, if you ask me. I will say, however, that I think the capacities of men to be aroused by female-created erotica are VASTLY underestimated. I have shot a great many erotic photos at this point, of a great many subjects--women's bodies, men's bodies, t-girls, couples, the works. The one photograph I've ever taken which has gotten the most powerful reaction from all the straight men I've showed it to, regardless of orientation, was actually of a man's body in mid-orgasm. For whatever reason, a lot of men seem respond to the emotions and the pleasure that the model was experiencing at that moment in a positive way. *shrug* Maybe all the "dumb horny guys" wouldn't be so "dumb" if they had more options? quote:
However, as disgusting as it would be; there would be the very white supremacist type of porn you spoke of if there was a large market for it. Perhaps so. But the existence of a market for a product is not necessarily an argument in favor of the product's moral right to exist. There is a large market for child pornography: child pornography is nonetheless morally reprehensible. There is a large market for non-consensual slaves, in certain industries. Nonetheless, non-consensual slavery is morally reprehensible, whether people will pay for it or not. Similarly, stupidity, crassness or thoughtless desire to objectify women does not necessarily justify the existence of a product which satisfies those urges, from a moral standpoint. That fact that you can make money doing something is not a moral justification for doing it--it's not a good thing to commit murder just to cash in a life insurance policy. Anyhoo. Many thanks for the stimulating discussion. I have probably put a few too many strokes into this dead horse. I am glad to hear from some other posters that there are some women who visit OWK and enjoy the Femme Supreme Disneyland. I guess it can't be any worse working there than spending all day dressed as Mickey. It's for the kids, right?
_____________________________
"Women and cats will do as they please, and men and dogs should relax and get used to the idea." -- Robert A. Heinlein
|