RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Ask a Submissive



Message


DesFIP -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 1:27:42 PM)

I rarely have fought because he doesn't try to push me faster than I am comfortable with and he doesn't demand trust he hasn't earned. When there have been things I balk at, he doesn't assume that I'm being deliberately willful or disobedient. He trusts me to know that there's a problem, even if (as often happens) I can't immediately identify it. At such times he simply switches his focus to something else instead of harping on it to a point I feel required to hard limit it in order to protect myself.

Usually I think about it and bring it up, or a piece of it, on my own. If not he may try it again six months or more down the line. And if neither of us can puzzle out what the problem is, or how to work around it, then he'll drop it for good.

I am more important to him than is one specific activity.




lusciouslips19 -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 1:30:08 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Loveisallyouneed


Were that true I'd not have started this thread nor spent two months trying to figure out how two people who love one another can be together.

It is interesting that so many find it so easy to discuss abuse when it is perpetrated by a dom, but to talk about abuse perpetrated by a submissive is another matter altogether.

The blinders have been pulled and it is not hard for me to guess why.



I will redirect you back to the response I quoted that led me to that statement.
"Bob, it has become abundantly clear to me that you and I cannot communicate, because you still, by your responses, are not understanding what I am saying. I cannot continue to clarify because each new clarification brings a new misunderstanding.

So therefore it is either you or me.  I will accept that I am the problem with the communication between us. I wish you well in your search.

Cali "

The point being made is you have your POV but cant entertain that it takes two. If you have a relationship that is not working it is not solely because of her. YOU play a part. If you cant see that you cant change people only your reaction to them, then you have bigger problems then just a difficult relationship.

There is a metaphysical philosophy based on the laws of Attraction...

You don't always get what you want, but you always get Who you are. Your relationships will always affirm your belief systems. If you believe this is a prosperous and happy world, you Will attract that which affirms that. If you believe you don't deserve to be happy, you will attract those that make you unhappy. If you believe that you deserve to be abused, you will attract those to you that will abuse you.

But what did this thread have anything to do with subs abusing Dom's? This was the first I heard that statement made by you. Poor thing.




lusciouslips19 -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 1:36:33 PM)

ooops.




Loveisallyouneed -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 1:53:03 PM)

I will take one more crack at this and if worse comes to worst I'll give it up as a lost cause.

Curiously this thread has become about why I asked the question, and how to gainsay anything I say so it ends up pointing back at me.

In "Fighting Submission" all the onus for difficulties was taken upon the women who described their struggles. I do not recall one of them claiming their dom/master had caused them to struggle.

But here, I have yet to hear anyone say anything but that the dom/master is to blame, period.

Now if, as appears to be true in "Fighting Submission", there are men who do not cause the struggle submissives were reporting, why is that not something that can be discussed and explored here?

Why can we not discuss what the men described in "Fighting Submission" experienced, and how they might have been helped had they had more information to work with?

On the other hand, if they handled things brilliantly, why can't the methods they used be described for the benefit of others?

Or is education a bad thing now?

As for Cali's comment, I've been writing for 38 years now, a good deal of it professional. She attempted to insinuate I was somehow responsible, I addressed the insinuation. That she wishes to imply I'm too stupid to understand her nuances ... <shrug>

Your "poor thing" would imply that a master cannot be abused. Stupid notion, for certainly a master can be abused emotionally. Hell, in a lot of places he can be black-mailed.

That you dismiss it demonstrates immaturity (a trait not well-hidden in this thread, several people have demonstrated it).

It is unfortunate that there is no civil forum wherein we can discuss the submissive who fights her submission and how that impacts the master/dom she is with.

It seems we lack sufficient civility to discuss what such a master/dom can do in that situation, if anything.

It would seem the idea of a submissive abusing a master/dom emotionally is absurd and ludicrous to the immature set.

After all, presumably this group also believes masters/doms have no hearts that can be broken, suffer no heart-ache when their integrity is attacked without cause, and that everyone who calls herself submissive is one and is ready to serve a decent man, regardless of how much abuse she's suffered in her life.

If this is the best this group has to offer in mature discussion, I'll move on.




lusciouslips19 -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 2:00:51 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Loveisallyouneed

I will take one more crack and this and if worse comes to worst I'll give it up as a lost cause.

Curiously this thread has become about why I asked the question, and how to gainsay anything I say so it ends up pointing back at me.

In "Fighting Submission" all the onus for difficulties was taken upon the women who described their struggles. I do not recall one of them claiming their dom/master had caused them to struggle.

But here, I have yet to hear anyone say anything but that the dom/master is to blame, period.

Now if, as appears to be true in "Fighting Submission", there are men who do not cause the struggle submissives were reporting, why is that not something that can be discussed and explored here?

Why can we not discuss what the men described in "Fighting Submission" experienced, and how they might have been helped had they had more information to work with?

On the other hand, if they handled things brilliantly, why can't the methods they used be described for the benefit of others?

Or is education a bad thing now?

As for Cali's comment, I've been writing for 38 years now, a good deal of it professional. She attempted to insinuate I was somehow responsible, I addressed the insinuation. That she wishes to imply I'm too stupid to understand her nuances ... <shrug>

Your "poor thing" would imply that a master cannot be abused. Stupid notion, for certainly a master can be abused emotionally. Hell, in a lot of places he can be black-mailed.

That you dismiss it demonstrates immaturity (a trait not well-hidden in this thread, several people have demonstrated it).

It is unfortunate that there is no civil forum wherein we can discuss the submissive who fights her submission and how that impacts the master/dom she is with.

It seems we lack sufficient civility to discuss what such a master/dom can do in that situation, if anything.

It would seem the idea of a submissive abusing a master/dom emotionally is absurd and ludicrous to the immature set.

After all, presumably this group also believes masters/doms have no hearts that can be broken, suffer no heart-ache when their integrity is attacked without cause, and that everyone who calls herself submissive is one and is ready to serve a decent man, regardless of how much abuse she's suffered in her life.

If this is the best this group has to offer in mature discussion, I'll move on.


I will attempt this one more time myself. perhaps I will give up as Cali did. No one is being impolite nor are we saying you are to Blame. What we are saying is she is not to blame either. You are seeming to want to assign blame here. Your Thread title says you are "humbly asking advice" But when anyone interjects possible reasons and alternative ways to look at things you get defensive. So if you don't want a submissives advice, why did you come here?

Let us know what you want to hear, and will be able to spout the rhetoric that you desire.




Missokyst -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 2:32:54 PM)

Perhaps if the lady has been doing this before as you indicated, it was not her, but the both of you together.
We do not always fail because one of us was not ready.  Sometimes we fail because the fit did not work. 
Blame only leads to guilt and denial.
Kyst
quote:

ORIGINAL: Loveisallyouneed

quote:

ORIGINAL: Missokyst

But if someone is struggling so hard against submitting, or fighting hard to BE the submissive/slave you thought yourself to be, then maybe it is just the fantasy that appeals. 

If it makes you happy, it shouldn't be that hard.


Try telling them you're going to move on because they're obviously not ready for this life.

It breaks their heart to fail.

Eventually it comes to this, but not before you give them every chance you can to succeed.

Why? Because that is what they say they want. And unless your a mind-reader, it can be very difficult to say they are wrong ahead of time.

(on edit: keep in mind this is a loving relationship we're speaking of, not a casual fling. In this relationship, love, trust, committment, faith are all integral parts, they all play a part in deciding when to stay and when to quit).




lusciouslips19 -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 2:45:28 PM)

As far as Masters being abused their submissives. I have seen it. I would give you the same advice I have given to other abuse victims. GET OUT NOW.




laurell3 -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 2:50:33 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Loveisallyouneed

I will take one more crack at this and if worse comes to worst I'll give it up as a lost cause.

If this is the best this group has to offer in mature discussion, I'll move on.


I'm having deja vu here.  Bob why do you come back to once again ask for advice and tell everyone that responds that they are wrong?  Mature discussion means that you actually LISTEN to what people have to say.  It seems this is not a skill you have improved upon in your absence and may very well be the issue in your relationships as well.   Good luck, I'm not banging my head against the bob wall again, communication takes two.




BitaTruble -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 3:42:42 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Loveisallyouneed



What advice do you give a master when he must deal with this woman, her struggle, and the uncertainty of her committment to the relationship?


When she has a wall to break down, hand her a tool to make it easier. When she's broken down that wall, help her pick up the pieces so it's not such a burden.

Realize that by breaking down that wall, she may discover something on the other side which doesn't include you, and be happy for her discovery because you'll have helped release the woman she is rather than the woman you wish she was.

Celeste




Loveisallyouneed -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 4:37:24 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BitaTruble

When she has a wall to break down, hand her a tool to make it easier. When she's broken down that wall, help her pick up the pieces so it's not such a burden.

Realize that by breaking down that wall, she may discover something on the other side which doesn't include you, and be happy for her discovery because you'll have helped release the woman she is rather than the woman you wish she was.

Celeste


Good advice, Celeste, and I agree it is important to stay open to the possibility that she might discover she doesn't want me.

If I expected otherwise I'd be treating this quite differently. It is the uncertainty of the future while she undergoes this struggle that contributes to the anxiety I feel.

The struggle leads to one of two conclusions: committment or abandonment. Heaven or Hell when you are falling in love with someone.

Nonetheless, regardless of which way it goes, if there has been growth, there is a respect and tenderness towards one another that can lead to friendship.

But if there's been no growth, if the struggle was lost, there can be bizarre behaviour, tantrums and the like. I feel I've failed her, she's angry because all her hopes are dashed and it is downhill from there.

What I have found is that the likelihood of success improves the more willing and open she is about communicating her feelings and thoughts.

Those who "don't want to talk about it" are more likely to not trust.




came4U -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 8:44:46 PM)

quote:

I want to know everything there is to know about her, starting with the things she feels most important to share with me, as she grows comfortable enough to share them. I'm quite happy to take it at her own pace, and I always have questions about what she believes, what she thinks, how she feels, her dreams and aspirations, her past ...


obviously your interview processes don't work if you complain at a later date that a woman has been previously abused.

quote:

Are you saying times have changed and everyone should be asking all women if they've been abused?


I frankly don't care how you screen a gal, as you said, YOU are the one complaining on the subject. 

This (again) whole thread is circular and cumbersome.

Methinks you just want to argue after denying and changing what you previously posted.  I won't play your game nor will I argue with someone who needs more  help than what he can ever find on a kink-forum.




AquaticSub -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/24/2008 8:46:58 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Loveisallyouneed

What advice do you give a master when he must deal with this woman, her struggle, and the uncertainty of her committment to the relationship?


Don't attempt to provide more help than you would be willing to accept in coming to terms with dominance.

Plenty of people struggle with coming to terms with their sadism and desire to dominate and own others. Depending on what is needed, dom helps sub, sub helps dom or both.




Loveisallyouneed -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/25/2008 4:50:18 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DesFIP

I am more important to him than is one specific activity.


Indeed. Any woman I love is not only more important than any activity, but is more important than anything else, period.




angelikaJ -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/25/2008 4:52:23 AM)

It isn't usually a good fit if the rocks in [her] head fit the holes in yours... even though it can seem that way.

And no, blame is not a good way to gain knowledge and perspective.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Missokyst

Perhaps if the lady has been doing this before as you indicated, it was not her, but the both of you together.
We do not always fail because one of us was not ready.  Sometimes we fail because the fit did not work. 
Blame only leads to guilt and denial.
Kyst
quote:

ORIGINAL: Loveisallyouneed

quote:

ORIGINAL: Missokyst

But if someone is struggling so hard against submitting, or fighting hard to BE the submissive/slave you thought yourself to be, then maybe it is just the fantasy that appeals. 

If it makes you happy, it shouldn't be that hard.


Try telling them you're going to move on because they're obviously not ready for this life.

It breaks their heart to fail.

Eventually it comes to this, but not before you give them every chance you can to succeed.

Why? Because that is what they say they want. And unless your a mind-reader, it can be very difficult to say they are wrong ahead of time.

(on edit: keep in mind this is a loving relationship we're speaking of, not a casual fling. In this relationship, love, trust, committment, faith are all integral parts, they all play a part in deciding when to stay and when to quit).





Loveisallyouneed -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/25/2008 4:53:04 AM)

Funny how people make a loud noise about what a waste of time a thread is to them, while they continue to waste their time reading the thread.

A lot like those people who make a loud noise about how they are not going to be making any more noises in a thread.

Some people are just so full of themselves [8|]




Loveisallyouneed -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/25/2008 5:00:30 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: angelikaJ

It isn't usually a good fit if the rocks in [her] head fit the holes in yours... even though it can seem that way.

And no, blame is not a good way to gain knowledge and perspective.



I agree.

This thread is not intended to be a complaint or a blame-game.

But that doesn't stop others from trying to turn it into one [;)]

It seems maturity and civility is beyond some folk here.

Fortunately there are others here who more than make up for it. [:)]




angelikaJ -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/25/2008 5:03:52 AM)

quote:



(on edit: keep in mind this is a loving relationship we're speaking of, not a casual fling. In this relationship, love, trust, committment, faith are all integral parts, they all play a part in deciding when to stay and when to quit).



You can't make a decision to stay with someone who wants to end the relationship.

That is an element of control one does not have... if you feel love for someone, when it doesn't work, the most loving thing you can do is to wish them well and then let go.

Here is the thing....it is true that you can make square pegs fit into round holes...provided that you hit them with a big enough hammer...but in the end they aren't square pegs anymore.

To hold onto that which doesn't work does damage to the other person and you....and that is obsession; NOT love or devotion.




Loveisallyouneed -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/25/2008 5:20:52 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: AquaticSub

Don't attempt to provide more help than you would be willing to accept in coming to terms with dominance.


I'm not sure how I'd accomplish that.

I have no desire to be dominated, and there is nothing that would help me come to terms with being dominated (especially in the context we are discussing here).

And I've never been physically abused. Thus I lack the background of those whom I've known. Seems to me this would also change the degree and nature of the help required.

quote:


Plenty of people struggle with coming to terms with their sadism and desire to dominate and own others.


I don't see the relevance of that statement to the topic in hand.

I won't deny some have difficulties with that, but I am speaking of how a master might best address the needs of a submissive who is fighting her desire to submit. Fighting not because the master has done anything abusive or disrespectful, but rather fighting her desire to submit because of the many reasons provided in the "Fighting Submission" thread.





Loveisallyouneed -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/25/2008 5:58:46 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: angelikaJ

quote:



(on edit: keep in mind this is a loving relationship we're speaking of, not a casual fling. In this relationship, love, trust, committment, faith are all integral parts, they all play a part in deciding when to stay and when to quit).



You can't make a decision to stay with someone who wants to end the relationship.

That is an element of control one does not have... if you feel love for someone, when it doesn't work, the most loving thing you can do is to wish them well and then let go.

Here is the thing....it is true that you can make square pegs fit into round holes...provided that you hit them with a big enough hammer...but in the end they aren't square pegs anymore.

To hold onto that which doesn't work does damage to the other person and you....and that is obsession; NOT love or devotion.



I agree, providing the analysis of the situation can result in an assessment which is as black and white as that.

However, sometimes the situation is obscured in a flurry of mixed messages.

After all, while the struggle continues within the heart and mind of the submissive, she hasn't made a decision and is bouncing back and forth in her thoughts and feelings.

If she externalizes this conflict, verbalizes it or acts it out, then the master is being involved in a tug of war between the submissive's opposing sides.

He's bombarded with mixed messages: sometimes he's a saint and other times he's satan.

My feeling is this occurs because in some way the master, being who he is, has tempted the submissive to be a submissive. She wouldn't be going through the angst of the struggle if not for the fact he exists and she wants to be in his life.

Should she externalize the internal struggle, it seems most likely he will come to represent one of the sides in the struggle: the side that wishes to submit.

Thus she projects her desire to submit onto him, and in her eyes he comes to represent all that is driving her desire to submit.

And anything he contributes in the way of encouragement to submit is magnified by her projection.

Now what can he do in this situation?

Once the struggle has been externalized and the master has been dragged into it it becomes a Catch-22 for the master.

He cannot encourage without appearing to be trying to force her to submit.

He cannot discourage as there is likely months of talking and dating and growing affection that has led to the intimacy needed to trigger the crisis the submissive experiences when she struggles against her desire to submit.

And trying to assume a neutral position in the struggle is disingenuous at best.

My own approach has been when she expresses doubts to remind her of things she's said about what she wants and why she thinks she might have difficulty attaining it.

I reassure her that what I want most is her happiness, with me if possible but if not with me then that is how it should be.

There could be no joy in my life with someone who is miserable, an obvious truth many seem to overlook.

But as I said earlier in the thread, my ability to participate in the process very much depends upon her willingness to talk about her thoughts and feelings. Those who won't are already demonstrating the lack of trust that will lead to the end of the relationship if not reversed.

And this is where the mixed messages obscure my ability to assess the situation.

Some submissives need time to think things through before they're willing to talk. In recognizing this and respecting her need, we focus on other things and there can be goodness in those experiences. But when the difficulty with trust arises again and again, a pattern eventually emerges, and the need to address the issues increases for these issues are hampering the growth of the relationship.

Sometimes a submissive fights her desire to submit because she is too damaged to be able to extend the trust needed to submit. Either life as a submissive is not for her, or it can only be for her after she has addressed her trust issues (with professional help if need be).

But this is not evident in her statements or behaviour at least some of the time, as she very much wants the security and love she believes she will find once she submits to the right man.

Thus: mixed messages.

I have yet to find a crystal ball that can tell me this is coming.

Love, by its nature, extends hope and trust and faith in the one loved. As long as one I love is still trying to address her issues, I cannot see me saying it is over.

But should she give up trying, or in the attempts she makes she ends up worse off than before she tried, then it is more obvious that the relationship we'd initially discussed is not going to happen.

But it is difficult to make that judgment as long as the mixed messages continue.




came4U -> RE: Humbly asking for advice ... (2/25/2008 6:14:04 AM)

quote:

I am speaking of how a master might best address the needs of a submissive who is fighting her desire to submit.


here we go again...

why not ask MALES/DOMINANTS on the ask a Master forum, it might be possible some men don't even read the 'ask a submissive' arena.  Wondering, would having to ask male dominants not give you the attention you crave from sumbissives and you are unwilling to get a more accurate answer from Dominants who have experience or expertise in the questions you ponder?  Does whining with your(supposed)peer-group instead scare you? Would you have to resort to explaining your issues with grown men, instead of playing this arguement game with (supposedly weaker) submissives? Do you assume the mind games included in this thread are a means to gain pity or are they influenced to provoke confusion to 'us' lil-brained submissives because of your flip-flop explainations?

It has become tiresome (your tactics) to witness the attempt at undermining of others by merely changing or forgetting your own earlier comments.




Page: <<   < prev  1 2 [3] 4 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
4.492188E-02