Noah
Posts: 1660
Joined: 7/5/2005 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: Mercnbeth ... Islam ... Its members are kept in fear of any alternative view, its leaders have total power, and to defy them results in a death sentence. Even the penalties for 'sinning' resemble old school Catholicism; dismemberment, stoning, whipping, etc. What does "total power" even mean? Lots of Islamic leaders defy lots of other Islamic leaders every day, as do lots of Moslems who don't lead anything. Is the entire Islamic world under an Islamic death sentence? Do you really want to characterize many millions of people in accordance with the one who--impotently--demanded Salman Rushdie's head on a plate, and a few others like him? Merc, come on. Did you take a Comparative Religion seminar from Ann Coulter or something? The Moslems selected for the evening news are of course the wack jobs who will contribute to our fears and thereby bump ratings. I can scarcely believe that you of all people would swallow the propaganda which suggests that the extreme, radical and apparently politically motivated fringe accurately represent Islamic believers as a whole. Let me offer some evidence to the contrary. There has been a vibrant dialog between prominent adherents of Islam and representative of other religions for many, many generations. It has been published for members of all faiths, (including humanism and scientism) to consider. You can find plenty of it at a nearby university library and so can any Moslem. More immediately, I know some of "them". Decent guys they are on average but no saints. The ones I've seen eat pork in public have so far not been dismembered or stoned for their sins. None of them is afraid of a lively discussion comparing and criticising particular religions and religion in general. So I'm calling bullshit on your Evil Monolith of Islam bit. What do you say?
|