RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just on line? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


colouredin -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just on line? (3/13/2008 12:42:25 PM)

Can I say my issue was that she was tlaking about validty, i wasnt arguing pro or against online i was simply arguing with the whole one has to be better than the other mentality. 




lytehaze -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just on line? (3/13/2008 1:10:20 PM)

Oh sorry colouredin, I wasn't talking about you personally. I was just discussing the thread in general. The issue about online vs r-t was my response to the OP's question about if others felt the same way.




Evility -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/13/2008 4:20:57 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BoiJen
I mean interest doesn't mean participation in any certain community or lifestyle. Just because someone researches or participates on gay forums doesn't mean they're gay.


This may be the most asinine comment I have ever seen. So if you are a guy who is attracted to men and haven't yet sucked someone's cock you're not really gay? I guess if you're attracted to the opposite sex but you're saving yourself for marriage then you just don't count, either. You can't be heterosexual if you're not participating, right?

First you whine about usage of the term boi that doesn't meet your criteria. Now the onliners are persona non grata.
I'll admit I do not know many lesbians personally. Are they all as hostile as you?




colouredin -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/13/2008 4:22:39 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Evility
. I'll admit I do not know many lesbians personally. Are they all as hostile as you?


Hey hey be careful now being a lesbian doesnt make you a specific personality type, and her oriantation has nothing to do with her hostility




BoiJen -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/13/2008 6:51:00 PM)

I do happen to believe that a real relationship and people who participate in the actual acts and activities of BDSM and SMsex are more valid than someone surfing the net.

BTW Alfred Kinsey was the man who did on the most extensive studies on human sexuality and found that most people who consider themselves "straight" have had at least one homosexual fantasy in their lives. It doesn't make them gay. And there's numerous men who consider themselves straight even though they surf gay porn sites. So sue me if you don't like my opinion




junecleaver -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/13/2008 7:12:42 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BoiJen

Am I the only one who think surfing the net isn't a qualifying action to consider oneself "in the lifestyle"?

I mean interest doesn't mean participation in any certain community or lifestyle. Just because someone researches or paricipates on gay forums doesn't mean they're gay. So why would just doing those things make one part of the BDSM community or lifestyle?

And don't go on about how "unsafe" it is to do this in the real world...because of who might find out. It's a load of bullshit. Because you don't want your partner finding out means your fucking around on them looking to be a weekend warrior. Not part of a community. What if my boss finds out? How's your boss going to find out? Somebody gunning for your job was there? Uh-huh let's see how that works out when you mention that little fact.

So call me a snob or whatever...that's my opinion on it.


Okay, you're a snob.

What exactly makes a person gay?  When you say they are?  When they have fucked enough people of the same sex?

The 'community' has its fair share of bullshit.  I find the good outweighs the bad, personally.  But I can understand how others might feel differently.  I used to date a lawyer.  He was not out.  He spent years of his life and a lot of money studying to become a lawyer.  I completely understood why he kept his choices private.  That is a lot to sacrifice for participating in 'the lifestyle.'  For example, I love tattoos and piercings.  I do not have them plastered in visible places on my body, because someday I will be working in an environment where it's frowned upon.  Like it or not, that's how the workforce is.  Like it or not, people have lost their jobs or come dangerously close over lifestyle choices.





LadyHibiscus -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/13/2008 7:31:38 PM)

For me, the online thing just doesn't do it.  It's too easy to get swept away with fantasies, and not fulfilling for me in the long term.  I will honestly say that I have NO CLUE what folks that do enjoy it get out of it.   There is practically nothing a submissive could do for me in the virtual world that would satisfy me as a dominant. 

I am not going to sit here and say they are stupid or not valid for making the choice of staying behind their terminal.  IF someone is not happy with what they are doing, the first piece of advice I give them is LEAVE THE HOUSE and meet people in realtime.  If they give me bullshit then....well, I advise them that they have made their choice and are living with it.  It doesn't affect me one way or the other, and it harms no one, so I am not going to be judgemental.




stella41b -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just on line? (3/13/2008 7:35:11 PM)

I see the point in the OP, I understand the argument, and defining myself as lesbian also I see where she's coming from... but there's a pretty good counterargument - everyone is different.. everyone.

I'm not lifestyle anything because I have my own lifestyle. It's mine, and it's probably unlike that of 99% of people here.

Two things which bug me here, and yes, they do bug me.

First thing is this whole perception that 'online' somehow doesn't count but real time does.

I shared my BDSM interests with other people in Warsaw, Poland. I'm currently living temporarily in London, but working towards relocation to Canada. I'm in an online relationship with a Domme in the States. The friendships in Poland are real, irrespective of whether they're online or not. Same too as regards to my relationship with my Domme. So this means that if another Domme turns up here in London that I should ditch the one in the States and move on to the Domme in London because she's real time?

And what about my family in Toronto? Is this less of a family than someone who meets their family every week?

Had it not been for the Internet, I wouldn't be me, I wouldn't be who I am today, and I wouldn't be leading the life I am leading now. I don't live online, I do have a social life, I work, the Internet for me is a resource of information, a powerful means of communication, a reliable way of integrating into society, and so on.

The second thing is when people start talking about 'the lifestyle' or 'the community' as if it's some sort of secret brotherhood, a branch of Zen Buddhism, or some sort of secret society.

This is where it starts becoming negative and people start losing contact with reality. And the reality for a lot of people, for whatever reason, is that quite a lot of their contact with BDSM is done online and not everyone is able to find a BDSM partner, a munch, a scene or whatever at the snap of their fingers.

I spent a lot of my life working against myself and trying to fit in with others and it almost cost me my life. Those days are long gone, I'm me, I'm myself, take it or leave it.

I mean what lifestyle are we talking about here? What community? Is there any one aspect in our lives which unifies us?

We were talking about this earlier today in this charity theatre I'm working to set up with others with the purpose of removing social stigma. How can you remove the stigma from one section of the community (society) without stigmatizing someone else?

We came up with the umbrella term 'intimate lifestyles' - which takes in kinky and not so kinky, straight, gay, lesbian, transgendered, BDSM, and whatever else.

People being intimate with each other might be that common trait we share, but there are also those who for some reason who are not intimate with anyone.

"Don't let them fool you
Or even try to school you, oh no
We've got a mind of our own
So go to hell if what you're thinking is not right
Love would never leave us alone
Ayin the darkness must come out to light.."

BOB MARLEY 'Could you be loved?'




LuckyAlbatross -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/13/2008 7:41:16 PM)

Jen you spend way too much of your time thinking about people doing things inappropriately IMO.

Gotta love irony :)




ProfessorStakes -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/13/2008 8:22:42 PM)

First - I'm a Hetero Male Dom, (that's for anyone who thinks I'm a lesbian in disguise), and I've had over 25 years (more like 30) Hands On experience in the real life "Lifestyle", I'm a real life Master - I've trained and played with dozens of lovely real straight and bi women in real time play and  have kept and collared only two women in the past, though I could have collared more if they had been seeking that exclusive a relationship. My profile here details my interests for those who want to read it, and I have plenty of real life play person references to back up my statements, my experience shared with others here, and I've also been a member of several long term online communities in the Lifestyle so I can speak from that side as well.

  Now, I happen to agree with the Op who started this discussion. I have seen what online only ppl claim to be, and what happens when they go to "real life" play thinking it's the same as online. It isn't the same.  Online is fantasy. Yes, you may get hot and turned on by it, yes you may be great at your verbal and finger-typed Dominance, Mastery, slavery or submission, but it isn't the same as playing in real life. Online is more closely related to how you want to be seen, but not actually as you are. Online you can claim to be taller or shorter than you are, sexually way over-experienced, claim to have "years" of bdsm experience, and do everything you want to do and be - because it's all just so much "talk".  There's no proof, so you can be "all that you can be" but may not be ... in reality.

  I know that some of you will say that it's your "only" way to play because you are (choose one) happily married to a vanilla guy/girl who wouldn't understand,  in the military, in some job that would be terribly changed if you got caught, living with your parents, living with college roomates, or more likely ..because you don't want to do it in real life, and think that fantasy is the same as reality. Do you also believe that the characters on Stargate Atl  are also real and living on distant planet in another galaxy? Of course not. That's fantasy.  The same goes for you who choose to roleplay (just like those actors and actresses are role playing) ... online.   It's not real.  The actor gets shot,  the actress gets "tortured" , but when the camera's stop rolling (just like when your computer screen goes off) - the actor and actress go back to reality,  just like you do when the computer is off.     
  I know lots of real people - with real vanilla families, real vanilla friends, vanilla jobs and even in the military who play for real. They meet and play every weekend, some even every night. We got to Munches at real vanilla resturants and we talk about all kinds of stuff - just to get to know one another as people - before we meet together either privately or perhaps in parties - to play. We learn about each other, we chat by phone and learn that everyone has weaknesses, everyone wants to have someone special/Special in their lives, but we do it based on reality.
   Yes, there's risk - the risk of real injury, real responsibility, real physical sex and love and real compassion. There's the reality of  having to live with yourself because you played this weekend with someone  real,  and  you  (or they) were  hurt -- willingly  hurt - in the process.  It's  a big responsibility,  a  big  acceptance of  being  the  who or Who  you  really are.  Not online,  online doesn't hold a candle to Reality. 
   So...New to the Lifestyle - or just ...online?   Online isn't real. It may seem real because your fingers feel the tactile sensations of keyboarding, your eyes may see the screen and interreact with someone who claims to be what you are seeking at that moment, but if you never take that to reality, and see the real person - play with the real person - then you aren't real either, you're just and actor or actresses playing a part. It may be a part you like so much you've gotten "good" at it, but it's just a role, just a part with lines you type instead of speak.

   My opinion is backed up by many years of experience - but your mileage may vary.

Professor Stakes 




stella41b -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/13/2008 10:00:18 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ProfessorStakes

First - I'm a Hetero Male Dom, (that's for anyone who thinks I'm a lesbian in disguise), and I've had over 25 years (more like 30) Hands On experience in the real life "Lifestyle", I'm a real life Master - I've trained and played with dozens of lovely real straight and bi women in real time play and  have kept and collared only two women in the past, though I could have collared more if they had been seeking that exclusive a relationship. My profile here details my interests for those who want to read it, and I have plenty of real life play person references to back up my statements, my experience shared with others here, and I've also been a member of several long term online communities in the Lifestyle so I can speak from that side as well.

Now, I happen to agree with the Op who started this discussion. I have seen what online only ppl claim to be, and what happens when they go to "real life" play thinking it's the same as online. It isn't the same.  Online is fantasy. Yes, you may get hot and turned on by it, yes you may be great at your verbal and finger-typed Dominance, Mastery, slavery or submission, but it isn't the same as playing in real life. Online is more closely related to how you want to be seen, but not actually as you are. Online you can claim to be taller or shorter than you are, sexually way over-experienced, claim to have "years" of bdsm experience, and do everything you want to do and be - because it's all just so much "talk".  There's no proof, so you can be "all that you can be" but may not be ... in reality.

I know that some of you will say that it's your "only" way to play because you are (choose one) happily married to a vanilla guy/girl who wouldn't understand,  in the military, in some job that would be terribly changed if you got caught, living with your parents, living with college roomates, or more likely ..because you don't want to do it in real life, and think that fantasy is the same as reality. Do you also believe that the characters on Stargate Atl  are also real and living on distant planet in another galaxy? Of course not. That's fantasy.  The same goes for you who choose to roleplay (just like those actors and actresses are role playing) ... online.   It's not real.  The actor gets shot,  the actress gets "tortured" , but when the camera's stop rolling (just like when your computer screen goes off) - the actor and actress go back to reality,  just like you do when the computer is off.     
I know lots of real people - with real vanilla families, real vanilla friends, vanilla jobs and even in the military who play for real. They meet and play every weekend, some even every night. We got to Munches at real vanilla resturants and we talk about all kinds of stuff - just to get to know one another as people - before we meet together either privately or perhaps in parties - to play. We learn about each other, we chat by phone and learn that everyone has weaknesses, everyone wants to have someone special/Special in their lives, but we do it based on reality.
  Yes, there's risk - the risk of real injury, real responsibility, real physical sex and love and real compassion. There's the reality of  having to live with yourself because you played this weekend with someone  real,  and  you  (or they) were  hurt -- willingly  hurt - in the process.  It's  a big responsibility,  a  big  acceptance of  being  the  who or Who  you  really are.  Not online,  online doesn't hold a candle to Reality. 
  So...New to the Lifestyle - or just ...online?   Online isn't real. It may seem real because your fingers feel the tactile sensations of keyboarding, your eyes may see the screen and interreact with someone who claims to be what you are seeking at that moment, but if you never take that to reality, and see the real person - play with the real person - then you aren't real either, you're just and actor or actresses playing a part. It may be a part you like so much you've gotten "good" at it, but it's just a role, just a part with lines you type instead of speak.

  My opinion is backed up by many years of experience - but your mileage may vary.

Professor Stakes 



Think what you like of my experience but I write here from experience.

Yes, I've played, and I've played with 'lifestylers' who play every weekend and at every available opportunity, and yes they go out and meet people and make contacts and attend parties and munches and so on and so forth.

And do you know? I've seen people among these 'lifestylers' go on about their knowledge of floggers, of crops, of bondage techniques and so on. I've seen some of them boast and brag of their experience and techniques when all in reality all they're doing is doing the very same ropework and very same techniques with the floggers but with different people. Some have been doing it for years.

And do you know? I'm there and I watch them, and I cringe to see them making elementary mistakes.

Also curious you draw the analogy of the actor in performance, but are you aware of the actual process of developing a film or stage play? The hours of introspection, character development, development of roles, the performances are just the tip of the iceberg. Hours of rehearsals, days, weeks, months, even years in some cases. I know, I make my living and my reputation is based in the theatre. This isn't 'just' a role play, it's a profession, a fiercely competitive profession of which only the top 10% ever make it to true success.

And just like the actor needs to spend time in development and rehearsal, as does the musician, the clown, the stand up comedian, and quite a few others who entertain us so too people interested in BDSM may wish to spend time online, learning, interacting with others, researching, finding out about themselves.

Play is only just a small part of BDSM.

Horses for courses so they say, each to their own. I wish you luck with your 'real time' experience and wish you many more scenes.

Personally I much rather favour quality and intensity of experience over mileage, quantity and hours and weekends of playing. Not everyone online is a fantasist.

And trust me, when I do play it is for real.




StormsSlave -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/13/2008 10:14:36 PM)

Ain't sex supposed to be fun?  That's what I keep thinking.  Whether you like it online, 24/7, Gorean...whatever your taste, if you and your partner(s) are happy, more power to you.  I am who I am, and life is a learning process.  I am just trying out what feels good.  This feels soooooo good.  So, I keep doing it. 

As for my boss, he's so cute, I think if he found out, I'd invite him over for a beer.[sm=lol.gif]




faithfulfemme -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just on line? (3/14/2008 12:20:37 AM)

 
jenboi, you seem to think because online BDSM relationships do not seem to have the ability to express physical interactions between the Dom/me and the submissive they are therefore a "waste of time" and not real.  Which, of course, also in your way of thinking, means that the only "true" BDSM relationships are those experienced in real time for the simple reason they then have the ability to contain some form of physical interaction.  

First, i must tell you that not all BDSM relationships have the physical interactions that you seem to think makes BDSM relationships "real". 

Many, many BDSM (Leather, lifestyle, kink--whatever label you wish to put on it) relationships are strictly mental, of the mind, and have no physical interactions within them whatsoever but are just as real as those which do.   


Let's see:  BDSM. 

Nowhere in the words, Bondage, Discipline, Sadism or Masochism is there a direct or an indirect connotation of physicality.

1.  Bondage - i have been put into mental bondage many times without so much as a 6" piece of rope in sight.  No physicality here.

2.  Discipline - nope, no physical connotations here, either.  One can be restricted from a plethora of things as punishment, and the restrictions could certainly have absolutely no physicality about them.  

3.  Sadism - mental sadism is every bit as painful as the physical kind.

4.  masochism - it doesn't have to be physical to hurt.


So, in order for a BDSM relationship to be valid, you feel it must have some type of "physicality" with the structure, and therefore as a result must only be real time. 


Ok, you want physicality with on-line experience?  How about this:

True story.  The Domme and the submissive were having a long distance, on-line, with webcam, relationship. 

The Domme found out that the submissive had eaten cookies that were specifically forbidden.  The submissvie was then directed to buy another box of cookies and have them with her that evening when the Domme and the submissive got on-line, and on webcam, together.

The Domme said to the submissive, "Open the new box of cookies and pee on them now, on the webcam, so I can see you, as punishment for eating that last box of cookies I specifically told you not to eat."

The submissive thought to herself, "And how is that punishment for eating the other box of cookies?"

"And after you pee on the new cookies, you are then to eat them," said the Domme.  "In front of me, now, on the webcam."



It doesn't get much more physical than that.  And.....i'd also say that was pretty much real time, online or not.  However, your poor opinion of online relationships simply misses the point that people can be wickedly creative, regardless of how or where they hook up.  
.
.




MistressCamille -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just on line? (3/14/2008 12:36:17 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: faithfulfemme


jenboi, you seem to think because online BDSM relationships do not seem to have the ability to express physical interactions between the Dom/me and the submissive they are therefore a "waste of time" and not real.  Which, of course, also in your way of thinking, means that the only "true" BDSM relationships are those experienced in real time for the simple reason they then have the ability to contain some form of physical interaction.  



They are not real, not by any means. It's only a game when it's online, that's about it. I don't care the reason, in most cases it doesn't have to stay online. There are fetish parties, Munches, etc everywhere these days. The only time I've messed with online scenes is when I was being paid to do it.  It's like reading a story about a spring day instead of walking out the door to enjoy a real one.




faithfulfemme -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just on line? (3/14/2008 1:36:23 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: MistressCamille

quote:

ORIGINAL: faithfulfemme


jenboi, you seem to think because online BDSM relationships do not seem to have the ability to express physical interactions between the Dom/me and the submissive they are therefore a "waste of time" and not real.  Which, of course, also in your way of thinking, means that the only "true" BDSM relationships are those experienced in real time for the simple reason they then have the ability to contain some form of physical interaction.  



They are not real, not by any means. It's only a game when it's online, that's about it. I don't care the reason, in most cases it doesn't have to stay online. There are fetish parties, Munches, etc everywhere these days. The only time I've messed with online scenes is when I was being paid to do it.  It's like reading a story about a spring day instead of walking out the door to enjoy a real one.




i respectfully disagree.  i came from a large metropolis where there was great kink community, but now i live in a very small town.  An area where the kink community, if there even is one, is buried so deeply you'd need an oil driller and a stick of dynamite to find it.  And a womyn's kink group?  That's just a pipe dream, not my reality.  And as i'm a queer womyn, this is where i would find a play partner, and hopefully, a life's partner.  As there's nothing even remotely like that here, i NEED the Internet and am glad to have it.  With any luck, i'm going to move away, but there's absolutely no guarantee of that, and until then, it's the Internet and moi....

i'm very surprised that CM isn't considered a "community" by many of the posters in this thread.  If it weren't for this place, i'd have little to nothing to identify with.  There are good people here......you know who you are......lol....and i'm thankful for them.

Those of you who have had bad experiences with online relationships.......well, i'm sorry it went that way.  However, i have met, online and in r/t, those persons who have found each other on this nutty "highway" and made a go of it.  Therefore i believe it can work and as such have no ill feelings for it.  Doesn't mean i'm not cautious, i simply pick and choose who i wish to be in contact with.

Just my opinion, nothing more.....
.




RCdc -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just on line? (3/14/2008 1:37:20 AM)

Ah yes - the irony of wasting time talking about a subsection of people who you (generic) think are wasting their time with doing what they are doing...[;)]
 
So, we have a
 
quote:

Hetero Male Dom, (that's for anyone who thinks I'm a lesbian in disguise), and I've had over 25 years (more like 30) Hands On experience in the real life "Lifestyle", I'm a real life Master -


You're not 'real'.   You are words on a scene to me and every person reading.  You are nothing but words.  Experience ?  In what ?  Bondage?  Fire Play?  Rape Scenes?  Knife play?  Scat?  Leather?  That is such a sweeping statement as if having 25 years means something to everything.  It doesn't - it means you have maybe known about BDSM for that length of time but that is about it.

quote:

They are not real, not by any means. It's only a game when it's online, that's about it. I don't care the reason, in most cases it doesn't have to stay online. There are fetish parties, Munches, etc everywhere these days. The only time I've messed with online scenes is when I was being paid to do it.  It's like reading a story about a spring day instead of walking out the door to enjoy a real one.



Nor is CM.  It is words on a screen.  You are nothing but words - you are not 'real' by your very statement.  But then you contradict yourself by posting - because if you didn't think this was real, why on earth would you post?
 
And for some people, fetish parties, munches etc are crap and not everyone has the time nor the inclination to start their own.
 
the.dark.




faithfulfemme -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just on line? (3/14/2008 1:46:25 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Darcyandthedark


quote:

They are not real, not by any means. It's only a game when it's online, that's about it. I don't care the reason, in most cases it doesn't have to stay online. There are fetish parties, Munches, etc everywhere these days. The only time I've messed with online scenes is when I was being paid to do it.  It's like reading a story about a spring day instead of walking out the door to enjoy a real one.



Nor is CM.  It is words on a screen.  You are nothing but words - you are not 'real' by your very statement.  But then you contradict yourself by posting - because if you didn't think this was real, why on earth would you post?
 
And for some people, fetish parties, munches etc are crap and not everyone has the time nor the inclination to start their own.
 
the.dark.

 
 
".....Because if you didn't think this was real, why on earth would you post?"........


GO!, the.dark!..........if there's ever a debate team here on CM, i want you on my side! 

With all due respect, no offense intended to Darcy....

 
Edited for font size. 

.




Justme696 -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/14/2008 1:49:19 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BoiJen

BTW Alfred Kinsey was the man who did on the most extensive studies on human sexuality and found that most people who consider themselves "straight" have had at least one homosexual fantasy in their lives. It doesn't make them gay. And there's numerous men who consider themselves straight even though they surf gay porn sites. So sue me if you don't like my opinion


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kinsey_Reports#Criticism





BoiJen -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/14/2008 6:34:11 AM)

My opinion is not politically correct and I don't have to be diplomatic about it. Yep I bust time on the collarme forums...because my IM is waiting to pop up to make plans for Wicked and to do a quick scene negotiation for that very same party. In which I will confirm my understanding of the negotiations over dinner prior to the scene. AND MsKitty is demanding that I surf for an undiscovered gem in the cheap eats section of the free press. I can multitask because I use BOTH my hands.

The very definitions of sadism and masochism and bondage demand physicality. Punishment and discipline mean nothing without the physical means to back it up. Otherwise it's worse than the make believe boyfriend you had when you were 12. If you don't like taking part of a "community" then don't say you're new to it. Fine whatever. It doesn't matter. Congrats for having the balls to do something fulfilling for yourself rather than bending to societal demands to be "normal."

Like I said...you don't have to like me or what I think. I'm not placing any demands on that.




Justme696 -> RE: New to the Lifestyle ...or just online? (3/14/2008 6:48:47 AM)

quote:

Like I said...you don't have to like me or what I think. I'm not placing any demands on that.


you don't love me ? :(

neah seriously...I like your thoughts...they just come across violently...but lol...I hear the same about me :P




Page: <<   < prev  2 3 [4] 5 6   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875