StrangerinBlack
Posts: 44
Joined: 4/27/2008 Status: offline
|
"I'll try to break it down more simply. " Thank you, this post was must easier to understand, ill try to be as honest with I can in responding. "I wrote a post, wondering where the line is drawn between what is considered "edgy" and what is considered mentally unhealthy. I gave a few examples as to what I meant and asked what people think about that. " Maybe I misunderstood what you were getting at. If so, I apologise ( I think that you might missed a lot of specific language here though "generally sick, may be inicative of an illness, ect). To address that directly, I would say that one becomes unhealthy when they are unable to stop themselves from doing things that will lead to lasting damage or duress. Now, I know these terms are subjective, and most people outside of an institution are able to do so, but there are obviously cases where people do in fact need help. Now, without calling anyone anything, I would suggest that most amature amputations are unhealthy in general (you seemed to think that I thought that having a body part removed and removing it yourself are somehow equal, I have only been talking about non-skilled removal here), because they are inherently dangerous and have a good chance of leading to permanent disability or death (I personally believe that is is also a major indicator of a mental illness, but if you don't, thats ok). I would also say, that the intent to remove your own sexual organs, preventing you from ever having an orgasm, or making love directly again, seems to fall into the category of unhealthy, in the sense that it would most likely later lead to disability and distress. ( I also do not find a sex change operation and cutting your willy off with a butcher knife have anything to do with each other, do you , really?) "You replied, saying no one was talking about mental health issues. " No, I said that no one was judging the sanity of another person. I think that the concept of mental health or unhealthy from a practical, daily life, perspective, has been valuable to explore here. "I replied, showing you where people, yourself included, were indeed talking about mental health issues, and hoping you (or anyone else) might address the examples I wrote earlier. " Just because I used the word psychosis, does not mean that I was calling anyone insane, which I thought was what you were telling me. "What I understand about what you're getting at here, is that this subject is black and white to you, " You really should read what I wrote. I have said again and again that these terms are not black and white, and that individuals can not be judged by us and several other things. You just don't want to believe me. We are talking about health in a context based discussion, my current challenge is for anyone to present a personal definition or context of mental health, which includes either of the two stories mentioned as healthy. So far no one has done so. "although I don't know where you draw the line." That's because I don't. Although if you look at individual examples, you can often see if a decision was constructive or destructive over the long run (I have personally done things I later wish I had not, I'm sure most people have. "I have not projected a thing, nor have I judged. " You just misjudged me as trying to reduce this to a black and white issue......... "I have, in fact, refrained from judgment and simply pondered a question. " No, that's not possible, but I do appreciate your thoughts and insights in the matter.
< Message edited by StrangerinBlack -- 7/1/2008 1:45:20 PM >
|