RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


Elisabella -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 1:38:25 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: MistresseLotus


(very good point.  I think all those babies that were forced to be born.. should end up on the doorstep of the well-meaning pro-lifers)



Why does that sound an awful lot like "fine, if you won't let me evade responsibility for my actions by having an abortion, I'll just foist that responsibility onto you!"




Darias -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 3:27:00 AM)

*shudder* Hell has definitly hit the snowy season... I agree with Axe We have a Winner

peach thank you for sharing what Im sure was something you didnt want to dredge up for what should be a non starter topic in a fetish lifestyle forum.Im sorry it got to the stage where you Had to educate people through examples of Your personal Experiences but am Glad you did so in such a clear manner ( i doubt in the same situation I could have done half the job you did)

Moral outrage in the parking lot of a clinic or doctors office is great when all you have to do is stand around shaking your placard and roaring insults  in the face of those who enter or leave. but shouldnt that outrage come with moral responsiblity?

if your willing to condem someone for their choice shouldnt you also be willing to help them with it? provide counseling before and After the fact? financial support ? resist the urge to tell some emotionally crippled girl on her way home after the worst choice shes ever had to make that shes going to hell?

its easy to stand atop a pedastal and look down upon those less worthy than you. much less simple to climb down and help the unwashed  up from the mud your fling at them

for Me this topic boils down to one thing. when did We ever have the right to control the lives, choices and emotions of those who have not asked for our input? how can we justify forcing someone into a place in life that justifys or satisfys our beliefs

there have been atrocitys performed in the name of religion morality belief ... each one because  We KNEW we were right. its only 50 a   hundred , 500 years later the world looks back in colective disgust and says *what the f**K * were they thinking

Darias




thishereboi -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 3:39:50 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: WyldHrt

CL- When you can tell me firsthand how it feels to be a 16 year old girl, pregnant (despite precautions), physically and emotionally unprepared, and scared out of your mind, then you get to judge. Until then,  realize that what you keep pressing as fact is simply your opinion, and you know what they say about opinions...


So unless you got pregnent at 16, you have no clue and shouldn't state your opinion on this subject? Interesting.




thishereboi -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 3:42:18 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: MistresseLotus

quote:

ORIGINAL: ncprincess

quote:

ORIGINAL: Elisabella


Men have a vested interest in abortion. Or do you imagine that all aborted fetuses are female?

Besides, as the laws currently stand, a woman can terminate a pregnancy without the father's consent or even knowledge. That child wasn't created by the woman alone. That's pretty messed up.


If the pregnancy were a result of rape or incest you think the man should have a say in what happens to the fetus? IMO, the only say I'd give THAT man was if I used a sharp or dull knife to ensure he'd never rape again.


   If only science could find a way to take the result of his rape and implant the fetus into his abodomen to gestate, birth and raise.....


I was with you up until the raise part. Put him in a chain gain and make him support it, yes. But let him near enough to help raise it.....sorry, I just can't see that.




celticlord2112 -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 4:33:01 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: WyldHrt
CL- When you can tell me firsthand how it feels to be a 16 year old girl, pregnant (despite precautions), physically and emotionally unprepared, and scared out of your mind, then you get to judge.

Feelings are not relevant to the matter.  Nor is age.




kittinSol -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 4:46:05 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Elisabella
But what would you prefer me to say? "It's okay honey, it was just a mess of tissue. You made the right choice! You go girl!" I'm sorry but I can't support her choice, especially when she calls talking about her "miscarriage" to be "sentimentalizing" and then gives the awful line "Life goes on" in regards to the life she terminated.


Life goes on, honey. Fuck guilt, that's not for me; occasional nostalgia over what could have been, that's inevitable. Guilt? I shall leave you to feel that on my behalf. You should also get a clue.




SilverMark -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 4:50:23 AM)

In your view anyone who seems to oppose is obviously incorrect.....I have yet to see a Man get an abortion....and the first you see let me know...will you?
I assume nothing in this argument....I dislike this argument....I find abortion distaeteful as a subject and am ready to cede the argument to those who must face the decision but, perhaps I do not have that right?
p.s. to say that I would have that view because I am male and therefore assuming all fetuses that are aborted are female is perhaps the weakest of all your posts would love to see your argument for relevency but, I cannot really stomach much more of this thread....but, I do appreciate your determination.....




Aswad -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 5:44:33 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Elisabella

Why does that sound an awful lot like "fine, if you won't let me evade responsibility for my actions by having an abortion, I'll just foist that responsibility onto you!"


How is killing the foetus any more of a responsibility than birthing it?

Either way, you are making an important decision on behalf of another being, although one could argue that it is technically a benign neoplasm in your own body until such time as the umbilical is cut. Certainly, no few species in nature demonstrate that humans are not alone in practicing elective killing of their newborn. In my own view, irrelevant as it may be, there are valid reasons for a pregnant woman to kill the foetus, such as self-defense, but I would say that those reasons are rarely present, if statistics and personal experience hold. And, in most cases, it's possible to work around the problem by just requiring the anti-choice camp to put their uterus where their mouth is.

Why the anti-choice camp wants to go back to "DIY abortions," however, is beyond me, since there's this thing about it contradicting their supposedly pro-life position, unless it is only babies they want to live, in which case I am somewhat perplexed at what manner of thought process can arrive at the notion that the seed is more noble than the flower.

Finally, for those who take exception to the word killing: if either position requires rationalization or linguistic distance to work, then it's a flawed one.

Will see if I can find time to cover it better later.

Health,
al-Aswad.




Owner59 -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 6:01:16 AM)

 
Folks,

Though it`s hard to walk around the terms and all,we shouldn`t be mentioning UMs.Be more careful or don`t do it.

I feel a group Mod slap a-comith.




rulemylife -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 6:39:51 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: celticlord2112

quote:

Murder is a legal concept. Murder is established by law as killing under specific proscribed circumstances. Absent abortion being defined in law as murder, there is no "pretense" to the claim that it is not murder. The pretention is your claim that it is.

US Code, Title 18 ยง1111(a) defines murder as the "unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought."

Abortion is the killing of a human being.  It is intentional, therefore it is malicious.  Save for the particular legal sanction granted it, it meets the legal criteria for murder.



Why would you quote something like this when you know it is not the issue?

The issue is when human life begins. 

The Supreme Court has ruled on that, whether you agree or not, making your quoting of the law entirely pointless and invalid as abortion does not fall under the statute.




Lucylastic -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 7:16:19 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: celticlord2112

quote:

Death penalty for abortionists!

Capital punishment is also murder.  It, too, should be stopped.


What about  people who are trained to kill, women, men,children?
killing is killing is killing, state sanctioned, or not.

No Im not putting anyone in the forces down, my hubby and my father were both in of the armed forces and I love them to death for their sacrifices and duty.

But training people to kill others is ok but a woman making a decision about Her life isnt.
Armies are of course (unfortunately) never likely to disapear. Abortion isnt either, at least until 100% effective birth control is found for every woman out there.
Lucy







GreedyTop -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 7:21:14 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Aswad
Why the anti-choice camp wants to go back to "DIY abortions," however, is beyond me, since there's this thing about it contradicting their supposedly pro-life position, unless it is only babies they want to live, in which case I am somewhat perplexed at what manner of thought process can arrive at the notion that the seed is more noble than the flower.


A point I tried to make earlier which has been so obviously avoided by the rabid 'right-to-lifers', Aswad

(nice to see you posting :) )




beargonewild -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 7:27:44 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: hizgeorgiapeach

I had originally promised myself that absolutely, positively, under no circumstances, would I reply to this thread.  I managed until now, but simply can't any longer.  I've been fighting the urge to do so for Hours now - and I'm through fighting with myself.
 
Phil - as to your OP - you make a very good point.  Free Will means having the option for ANY of the choices, and then choosing what the individual feels is best for herself (or himself) - not in being told by folks who don't know you, don't live your life, don't have your personal relationship with Diety, your individual experiences and concerns tell you, "hey, I find this particular choice invalid because I consider it morally objectionable, therefore I'm making the choice FOR YOU, so that *I won't be Offended by Your morality.  But just so you feel like you still have some say in the matter - here is an option that I Will approve of as Morally Viable In My Own Eyes, and you can do that.  Good luck, don't ask for my help now that I've made your decision for you."  If nothing else, such an attitude out of Kinksters - folks who are Routinely Judged About Their Sexuality by the "normals" in society - I consider it hypocritical to start getting pissy about a Moral issue while condeming others for getting pissy about YOUR sexual Morality.  (You being Generic in this sense.)
 
As for the Rest of the various comments on the thread.....
 
How many of you have actually had to face the decision making process?  How many of you have been faced with agonizing over what is actually Best for Everyone Who Is Actually Concerned with the situation?  How many of you have sat in the doctor's office, waiting for an appointment, having to face the second thoughts that run rampant?  How many of you have woken up afterwards in both physical and emotional agony, not even knowing that you've been crying nearly hysterically in your drug induced sleep until the nurse asks you if you're through crying?  How many of you have faced hate filled, judgemental, obscenity screaming asshats waiting outside the doctor's office to call you a murderer - while at the same time having no idea of WHY you were there, or what brought you to the decision, and frankly not giving a shit as to the Why so long as you know that they consider you scum because they're screaming it at  you at the top of their lungs six inches from your face?  How many of you have had to try and pull the shreds of your dignity around you to walk that sort of gauntlet, while inside all you want to do is scream back at the unknowing, unknown haters who have the temerity and Utter Gall to think they have some sort of right to stand in Judgement - or perhaps just to punch a few of them violently and repeatedly in the face to make them back off?
 
It is Not an easy decision to make.  It is even more difficult to carry through with once it's made, even knowing that it IS the best choice available to you.  It is something that you question yourself on for the REST OF YOUR LIFE once it's made.  Yes, I have faced that decision making process.  I faced that hate filled screaming gauntlet.  And not one... NOT ONE... of those screaming "pro-life" folks stopped even for a second to ask me WHY I did what I did, or to find out what my emotional state was in coming to the decision, or to give a flying rat's ass what sort of pain I was in across the emotional and physical spectrum.
 
How many of you who simply say, rather self rightously, "put the kid up for adoption" would stand up and volunteer to take in a child that might not live to see his or her first birthday?  How many of you - HONESTLY - have the fucking Fortitude it takes to raise a severely handicapped child from birth, to deal with the daily emotional traumas, the uncertainty, the constant medical emergencies?  And if you have the fortitude to do it Once, how about 2? 3? 4? that all have severe problems and can't even survive without machines to keep their blood pumping and force oxygen into their lungs, and that will never - for as long as the machines are capable of forcing oxygen - know who you are, who they are, or do anything other than lay in a crib with a feeding tube up their nose while You wait for the machines to finally fail in their task? 
 
It's so easy to sit there, smug and self rightous, saying that it's never a valid option.  That it's never the right choice.  But you're wrong.  Sometimes, it's the Only viable choice.


I thank you for being able to explain this side as straight forward and blunt as possible and in a way which we males and people who have never been in a situation of making a choice such as this. Kudos.




GreedyTop -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 7:29:10 AM)

what Bear said.

*hugs Peach*

Nobody should ever have to go through that.




kittinSol -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 7:35:04 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Aswad

How is killing the foetus any more of a responsibility than birthing it?



To carry on a pregnancy or to terminate it are both responsible choices. In many cases, in fact, I believe the choice to terminate comes from a high feeling of personal responsibility (knowing that one will be incapable of raising an infant is the first reason that comes to mind).




MistresseLotus -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 7:36:32 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Elisabella

Why do you feel so strongly about another's decision if you don't want to take the responsibility for the life you so desire to "save"?
Why does that sound an awful lot like "fine, if you won't let me evade responsibility for my actions by having an abortion, I'll just foist that responsibility onto you!"


(very good point.  I think all those babies that were forced to be born.. should end up on the doorstep of the well-meaning pro-lifers)




camille65 -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 7:38:21 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: GreedyTop

quote:

ORIGINAL: Aswad
Why the anti-choice camp wants to go back to "DIY abortions," however, is beyond me, since there's this thing about it contradicting their supposedly pro-life position, unless it is only babies they want to live, in which case I am somewhat perplexed at what manner of thought process can arrive at the notion that the seed is more noble than the flower.


A point I tried to make earlier which has been so obviously avoided by the rabid 'right-to-lifers', Aswad

(nice to see you posting :) )



I mentioned it too. Funny how E-whatever her nick is, is fine with taking herbs but not so fine with an actual medical procedure. I wonder where 'a swift kick to the stomach area' falls in her appropriate means to an end?




celticlord2112 -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 7:44:25 AM)

quote:

Why the anti-choice camp wants to go back to "DIY abortions," however, is beyond me, since there's this thing about it contradicting their supposedly pro-life position, unless it is only babies they want to live, in which case I am somewhat perplexed at what manner of thought process can arrive at the notion that the seed is more noble than the flower.

Point of clarification:  No matter the mechanism, abortion is a wrong choice.  DIY abortions are just as wrong as the current sanctioned procedures.  The goal should not be a "return" to DIY abortions, but an end to the practice, period.




MistresseLotus -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 7:45:59 AM)

Now back to the original OP about free will...

Perhaps the Christians (Pro-lifers) love God SO much.. they have chosen to PLAY God for the rest of us.




MadRabbit -> RE: Pro-life Anti-Christian (10/28/2008 7:46:09 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Elisabella
2. I've LIVED in multiple "childrens homes" and it is pretty shitty there. But if ANY of those children, myself included, thought that we would have been better off aborted we would have committed suicide. It's pretty shitty to tell anyone, much less a child, that their life is so horrible they would be better off dead.


It's so much better to tell them that they were the byproduct of spreading one's legs behind a dumpster for a stranger for $50 so the mother could get a fix of crack coccaine.

Or they are a constant symbol of resentment and hatred towards the man who raped her and brought on their completely unwanted and unplanned pregnancy and they were just brough into the world because she "had" to.

It's equally as shitty to force people to bring children into this world when the child's life never had any value to them to begin with.






Page: <<   < prev  8 9 [10] 11 12   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
6.201172E-02