RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


stagerle -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 10:51:55 AM)

Sorry first time I've used the quote box thing and I cocked it up.
Yeah Meatcleaver it does seem strange me as an outsider thta the richest and most powerful nation ever isnt prepared to provide some basics like health care.
Health care, free higher education and a social saftey net are some of the defining features of post war Britain. I think they worth the battle.




Politesub53 -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 11:12:02 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Marc2b

I live near the border with Canada and it is not uncommon to see Ontario license plates in the parking lots of our doctor’s offices.  That pretty much tells me all I need to know about socialized medicine.


Incredible, you have worked out all about social health care, by looking at car number plates. Did it ever occur to you some of those Canadians may be working south of the border ?




RealSub58 -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 11:50:42 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: MzMia

quote:

ORIGINAL: Lucylastic

Seems to  me that the health care system in Canada and UK has most problems because there are too many bureaucrats and not enough front line staff. Saving their own asses and not knowing what the hell they are doing and not listening to the people who do make a difference. The systems need streamlined, the money directed to the nurses, doctors, technicians, support staff, not the bloody managers and their never ending assistants.
I worked in the NHS for 8 years and the Canadian system for three. Neither of them is perfect, people suffer and die, needlessly, however the US is damn scary regarding basic care and ongoing treatment unless you can pay for it.
Lucy

Hello Lucy, thank you for posting.
I love to hear stories from citizens that actually live in countries
with Nationalized Health Care.
I have such mixed emotions on the subject.
Are you happy with the standards and level of health care that is available to you?
Do you think your system is fair?
How are the senior citizens treated and those with chronic long term health conditions?
I have heard of people in Canada coming to the USA to get certain operations.

Please give us some more information, thank you!



Ask me on the other side some specifics and I can tell you things that happened to my patients, how the system works in 3rd world countries, not that you will ever live there, what I learned in England, and how the system affects both those who wish to pay private in a nationalized system and those unable to private pay. The bunk about long lines like at the DMV is just that...bunk, depending on which country you live in. 




RealSub58 -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 11:55:39 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kittinSol

quote:

ORIGINAL: RealSub58

quote:

ORIGINAL: kittinSol

Have you ever lived in a country that has national healthcare? It's pretty fucking fantastic - so much less expensive for everybody in the long run - but perhaps you enjoy paying out of the skin of your ass and relish the idea of being taxed on your healthcare plan [&:].

Yes I have and was even a healthcare professional within the system in 2 countries ~ one a third world and the other England.


Thanks - I was interested in the baby's reply, because of her anti-health for all cruisade on the forum boards. I'm curious as to whether she knows what she's talking about, specifically from a personal experience standpoint (something tells me she doesn't have a clue).


kittinOur present system or should I say the position she is in in our present system doesnt work for her. Wouldnt you cry and whine and bitch if the mess you find yourself in is due to fate and/or your own responsiblity? Maybe not, but some do.  It is part of who they are.




kittinSol -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 11:56:30 AM)

Huh? Please make some sense.




RealSub58 -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 11:59:44 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kittinSol

Huh? Please make some sense.


kittinYour reply was in regards to the "pink lady?"So I responded to that.Clear as coffee n milk?




slaveboyforyou -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 12:02:29 PM)

quote:

Clear as coffee n milk?


Coffee and milk is clear?




kittinSol -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 12:04:08 PM)

I was wondering just the same thing. Isn't it "clear as spring water"? All these murky metaphores [8D] ...




RealSub58 -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 12:07:06 PM)

Well hell's bells, how do I know if you DO understand my rheutoric?And since I have coffee n milk in hand... I preferred that metaphor !         [8D]




stagerle -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 12:20:20 PM)

Ok I dont have  a scobby what Realsub is talking about ....is this an Americian thing?




kittinSol -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 12:51:59 PM)

I'm not sure [8D] .




kiwisub12 -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 1:15:36 PM)

Just for interests sake - you don't have to be poor to not have health insurance. I have a friend who runs his own business - and can't afford health insurance. He needs prostate surgery , knee surgerys and probably , follow-up for heart surgery, that he is still getting bills for. There is no way in Gods green earth that someone can pay out of pocket for surgery - even non-emergent surgeries. So he gets up several times a night to pee, on his painful knees and hopes he isn't going to die of a heart attack.

Nation -wide health insurence - i vote for it, and continue private insurance too.
People who can't afford medical care for themselves and their kids need a break - and not all qualify for medicare or medicad.
My daughter has a minimum wage job, and needs an inhaler for her asthma that costs over $100 a month. At the moment, i buy them from India for $40 for three months supply. How just is that?

And there are more and more people in my friends  and my daughters shoes.




ThatDaveGuy69 -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 1:21:33 PM)

MP: I didn't realize it was so bad in Canada.  Is the lack of medical personel due to low pay?  I have heard that many Canadian doctors & nurses move to the US for higher pay.  So woulldn't it be a fairly straightforward process for them to demand better pay?  Or have tuition incentives that require some number of years of service in Canada? 

Wait, am I now trying to fix health care in Canada?  I really need to get some sleep...

~Dave




MontrealPhoenix -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 1:28:58 PM)

Hi Dave,
 
No the lack of personnel on all levels is due to cutbacks and burnout. There will be a further shortage in radiology staff at my hospital as 50 - yes 50 - such people are going to be retiring in 2010. Of course nothing is being done to find replacements, God forbid they be proactive.  There is also a growing number of nurses retiring asap because of the high level of stress. Me, I'm trying to win the lottery [:D]
 
phoenix




came4U -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 1:43:43 PM)

What really gets me, is people with no health insurance that complain (online) and ask medical questions about themselves or their ums yet say they cannot even afford a basic health exam. 

Cut your net bill (if at 30 bucks per month you save yourself 360 bucks per year).  Internet cafes charge 2 dollars an hour. Would you rather Dom/sub search than be without health insurance? 

Besides here, employers ask for proof of health insurance within/after a three month period and if you cannot provide such information you MUST purchase it from their (big hoohah insurance company salesmanship meeting) recommended insurance broker or choose another on your own time.  If you do not prove health/accident insurance I suppose they fire ya. lol.

Health care coverage (govt. sponsored) is 100% here-Canada (not including private room), takes little waiting time *depending on city population/and comparative to other countries, if you are below a certain yearly income.  Obviously, if above income, you have purchased insurance. I've never had to use my provincial health care card for more than ID, yet they take you in to a hospital, even if unconcious, for emergency care (car accident etc).  Clinics take you also but charge you $50.00 (refundable only if you return to show that ID.

I cannot imagine being without health insurance.  If I were, I would avoid other frivolous activities (eating out, internet service, shoe shopping, even telephone if I had to).

If more people put aside money for a rainy day instead of complaining while they sit at Burger King that the napkins aren't softer......

would be paradise.

*before you complain and say some people work on a home computer for a living as an excuse, then obviously you should change professions if it isn't making enough money to even cover a scraped knee. Living beyond means is a common problem when people cannot distinguish between the necessities of life and nonsense purchases.  PRIORITIES.

This isn't the third world that most of us live in.  Think, act and react.  Get some friends together (REAL LIFE) and take some action in your own political system and start writing your Congressman/woman and get something done.  Sitting here complaining isn't going to get anything done.  The politicians in your area are not going to be sitting and watching CM for the 'man on the street's' viewpoints. lol.




NorthernGent -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 2:31:07 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kittinSol

so much less expensive for everybody in the long run



That is not necessarily true. The English NHS is over-burdened by alcohol and smoking related events/illnesses, of which we all bear the cost despite a portion creating the problem.

It ain't all rosy in the NHS garden. The intangible costs and benefits need to be taken into account when comparing systems.

As ever, the issue is one of principle rather than cost.




NorthernGent -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 2:33:13 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slaveboyforyou

I'm generally libertarian minded on most things, but I think we should have some sort of National Healthcare plan too.  I know a lot of people that don't have any coverage, and they don't qualify for Medicaid.  If something happens, they're essentially fucked.  No one should have their credit and finances destroyed because they get sick. 



I'm curious Slaveboy, why would you make an exception in this instance? All welfare is underpinned by the same principle: providing people with the means to contribute to society.




thishereboi -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 2:34:16 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: came4U

What really gets me, is people with no health insurance that complain (online) and ask medical questions about themselves or their ums yet say they cannot even afford a basic health exam. 

Cut your net bill (if at 30 bucks per month you save yourself 360 bucks per year).  Internet cafes charge 2 dollars an hour. Would you rather Dom/sub search than be without health insurance? 

Besides here, employers ask for proof of health insurance within/after a three month period and if you cannot provide such information you MUST purchase it from their (big hoohah insurance company salesmanship meeting) recommended insurance broker or choose another on your own time.  If you do not prove health/accident insurance I suppose they fire ya. lol.

Health care coverage (govt. sponsored) is 100% here-Canada (not including private room), takes little waiting time *depending on city population/and comparative to other countries, if you are below a certain yearly income.  Obviously, if above income, you have purchased insurance. I've never had to use my provincial health care card for more than ID, yet they take you in to a hospital, even if unconcious, for emergency care (car accident etc).  Clinics take you also but charge you $50.00 (refundable only if you return to show that ID.

I cannot imagine being without health insurance.  If I were, I would avoid other frivolous activities (eating out, internet service, shoe shopping, even telephone if I had to).

If more people put aside money for a rainy day instead of complaining while they sit at Burger King that the napkins aren't softer......

would be paradise.

*before you complain and say some people work on a home computer for a living as an excuse, then obviously you should change professions if it isn't making enough money to even cover a scraped knee. Living beyond means is a common problem when people cannot distinguish between the necessities of life and nonsense purchases.  PRIORITIES.

This isn't the third world that most of us live in.  Think, act and react.  Get some friends together (REAL LIFE) and take some action in your own political system and start writing your Congressman/woman and get something done.  Sitting here complaining isn't going to get anything done.  The politicians in your area are not going to be sitting and watching CM for the 'man on the street's' viewpoints. lol.


I am confused, You said employers ask for proof of health insurance, but then you go on say that health care coverage is 100%. If it is 100%, then why would employers ask for proof. Doesn't that mean that everyone has insurance?




came4U -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 2:38:31 PM)

"Health care coverage (govt. sponsored) is 100% here-Canada (not including private room), takes little waiting time *depending on city population/and comparative to other countries, if you are below a certain yearly income.  Obviously, if above income, you have purchased insurance."

if such job pays well and exceeds the income allotted. 

How else is the system able to support itself without taxpayers and other's with private insurance? Low income (min wage) cannot support an entire governemnt system of health care.  The higher the income, the higher the taxes, which in the end helps to pay for the lower economic bracket of citizens. High income persons cannot use provincial ID for more than that, ID and proof of citizenship to that province and as a means of tracking their own medical care history.

Poor or not, we all have basic health care (and beyond-even cancer treatment is covered), the only plus is the added coverages (private room, waiting time etc) for those who pay through an insurance company.

Make sense now?




NorthernGent -> RE: 5 Myths of Socialized Medicine (11/2/2008 2:40:31 PM)

General reply:

Anyone taking a look at the worth of a national health system should steer clear from the English version. It is chronically underfunded due to general public hostility toward public schemes. You'd be well served by looking at the German and French systems. 




Page: <<   < prev  4 5 [6] 7 8   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875