ALAstella -> RE: Deeply Troubled (1/3/2009 5:24:14 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: beargonewild I am wondering if the regular bureaucracy isn't willing to help Aszhrae in her city, if she talks to an advocate in the local GLBT community to speak on her behalf? There is also the option of talking to an MP or a local MPP who is gay positive. Sven Robinson is a MP for the province of BC and another recourse is EGALE You know I'm thinking it would be much better if North America (the United States and Canada) fell in line with the United Kingdom in terms of gender reassignment and acknowledged anyone with a clear diagnosis of long term gender dysphoria as being a member of their acquired gender from identification and diagnosis rather than wait until after surgery. This would help the thousands of transgendered folk who are struggling to transition and I feel that they should be recognized as such legally. It would also help to avoid situations such as the one Aszhrae finds herself in, where she perhaps felt that it would have been much easier for her to enter into domestic enslavement rather than continue independently and have the option of living full time in her acquired gender in addition to having the legal recognition for being of her acquired gender, which would enable her to obtain all the documents and status necessary which would make it easier. I cannot understand the standpoint of social assistance in Canada, their position that 'you should stop transitioning if you want to be hired' doesn't make any sense to me. First thing is, you do not receive welfare for being transgendered. This sort of logic if followed further could suggest that someone be advised to be less male or female to become more employable, which to me is ridiculous. One other such aspect of this is the failure to recognize gender dysphoria - the mental condition suffered by the transgendered - for what it is, a mental condition (not an illness) which can only be changed or relieved by going through the gender reassignment process. The line of whoever it was who gave Aszhrae the 'top transitioning' advice is being completely ridiculous, it is to me beyond the pale for someone to even suggest such a thing. It would be like suggesting a paraplegic ditch the wheelchair and learn to walk to become more employable. This strikes me as wholly unacceptable as advice. But sadly this is the truth. I spent over two years trying to find employment in the UK, and bear in mind I have a rather rich 8 page CV with varied work experience, and I was prepared to do anything, literally anything - including shovelling shit from one place to another - to get employment. However even if I got a reply from my application it would be something like 'We understand your predictament, but...' or even 'We simply don't have the training to deal with transgendered employees..' Training? WTF? What has being transgendered got to do with my ability to work or hold down a job? I feel that until gender recognition happens much earlier in North America, there are going to be many more stories like Aszhrae, not to mention those who have o other option than prostitution, pro-domming, and being a sex worker. I'm not saying it's impossible to get employment being transgendered, many transgendered folk do work and live independently, but many more don't and are stuck on welfare or in situations such as Aszhrae. This is the situation I found myself in over a year ago attempting to visit the United States in Atlanta, where I was declared inadmissible to the United States under Section 217(a) (I) of the Immigration and Nationality Act 'lack of a valid unexpired pasport or travel document' .. my brand new biometric UK passport was female and in my name of Stella and obtained legally under the UK's Gender Recognition Act 2004. However the border guard claimed that in the United States my having a penis meant I was male, not female and as such my passport wasn't valid. This is overlooking the fact that I am a citizen of the United Kingdom not the United States, the passport is a sovereign travel document and the official had no legal authority to remove me from the Visa Waiver Program or deny me entry on such grounds to the United States, where in effect he was denying the sovereignty of the United Kingdom in rejecting my passport as legal proof of identity. My struggle continues with Washington a year later and I'm hoping that in 2009 this will be resolved if not through the granting me of an artistic visa then through diplomatic channels. Returning to the OP: quote:
My transition is long overdue. My lifestyle choice and purpose to serve is the world that I have become accustom. Walking away from it to become independent of it, is not an option. I am in a similar situation here. The thing is Aszh, you cannot serve unless you can find someone to serve. Here you are asking for too much.. you might as well be asking for the Moon. I am similar to you, I have a constant need to serve and to be guided... However for me this need to serve goes way beyond the confines of BDSM, and I have taken it upon myself and am committed to serving mankind through my work in theatre, my charity work and my activism. This is something which is never going to change in my life. I haven't had a Mistress to serve in any sort of stable relationship since long before I left Poland. Yes when I did leave Poland earlier in 2004 to enter into service in a BDSM household in the UK it was with the same intention as you probably had, I was looking for support from other people - the one thing you need if you are going through your transition. I found it, or so I thought, in domestic service, I had a room, work, and I was well looked after. However there were two problems, the first was that I wasn't able to start my transition, and the second was a developing conflict between two members of the BDSM household. This BDSM household has since been disbanded and the house has been sold, but fortunately I extricated myself from the situation long before. But there are other ways you can serve others without being with a Mistress and being a domestic slave. The BDSM community doesn't exist to support the transgendered through their transition, this is not what it's there for, and lumping your gender issues together with your need for submission I feel is one of the root causes of your problems. There are alternatives and your priority at this moment in time is finding a secure place to live where you can continue your transition, some form of income whether it be work or welfare, and access to the Internet. This is the bare basic I feel which is necessary for anyone who is transitioning. Nobody is asking you Aszh to become permanently independent, nothing needs to be permanent here and most things are unlikely to be permanent in your life. However if you were to compromise and to accept this as a temporary measure until you could find the basic necessities of life you will be able to return to service, being dependent and the BDSM community at a later date. You are also negating your own position here. You claim to need to complete your transition, and yet you also claim that you cannot be independent - despite not making any attempt - but if you cannot function independently as a person how do you expect to be able to get through your transition? How are you going to manage this if you are unable to function independently as a woman? Yes Aszh, it's hard, I know how hard it is, I'm going through the same process, but what is stronger here? Your desire to be who you really want to be and to get through your transition or maintain your current circumstances? Surely the only way forward in your transition is to try and keep on trying until you gain that acceptance and recognition for who you really are, right? Just what is important to you, and I mean really important? You've spent 18 years with your current couple, you've known all through your life that you are transgendered and that you need to transition, what is stopping you from progressing in that transition? The fact that they are turfing you out in nine months' time? Something has got to give here in order for things to start moving forward. That something has to come from you Aszh, you are going to have to come to some sort of a compromise at some point.
|
|
|
|