RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


thetammyjo -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/10/2009 2:07:43 PM)

There is still a lot of sexist thinking out there. One of my academic mentors confided in me that this year while she helped on the search committee for a new position in her department, she overheard incredibly sexist comments that were hidden under the guise of "reality". For example, male candidates who were married were described as "stable" while female candidates who were married were described as "too busy" with the search committee was talking in private. It's a sad reality and even more so because to say such a thing to your candidates would be to open yourself up to a law suit but that doesn't stop the thinking from existing.

The result is that women in the field know this and so may not wear a wedding ring and avoid any discussion of a personal life while men purposely may bring up these same issues. I've see it on search committees myself though my colleague never said such things out-loud we noticed the applicants did this. Sadly this can make the female seem less "personal" than the male which can be a big factor in hiring when it comes down to 10 people all wonderfully qualified and now it's a "who fits best" question.

People often think that you change the laws and BAM everything changes. This ignores millennia of thinking and socialization.


quote:

ORIGINAL: NorthernGent

quote:

ORIGINAL: lusciouslips19

Woman are still minimized, demeaned or downright loathed on such an unconscious level.  But belive me, its there.



I have the good fortune to be dating a woman who considers herself to be a feminist - it's a first for me - it's interesting to hear her point of view.

She has a point in one sense: of course women play second fiddle to men when it comes to positions of authority, but there have been prominent women throughout history and to suggest otherwise would devalue the role played by women in important issues such as the beginning of the end of the slave trade (many of the quakers who campaigned for the end of slavery in late 18th century Britain, were women - an act that ultimately led to the British government abolishing slavery before most others and sending ships/soldiers to Africa to enforce the ban).

I think, however, she falls foul of the same stance as yours above. She insists she is at a disadvantage in her workplace because she is a woman, and, as per any self-fulfilling prophecy, it materialises. Ultimately, disadvantaged or not, no one is going to lay it on a plate for you - there's no such thing as something for nothing in this life. To suggest women are loathed is ridiculous considering hetrosexual men spend an inordinate amount of time trying to find a suitable mate.

On the OP, I suppose if power is your goal, then, yes, perhaps women/submissives will be marginalised. On the other hand, if making friends is your goal, then I can't see why women/submissives will be any less respected. Perhpas the trick is to stay away from the power games and their followers.





LaTigresse -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/10/2009 2:11:39 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: lusciouslips19

But the question was is the submissive respected. I say, its obvious that the answer is no.


I believe different people have different views of the word "respect" so to answer that would be a deeper quagmire.

I could count the number of people I respect, if not on one hand, then definitely two with fingers left over.

What you are considering respect, I consider courtesy. I answered the OP in that light.




sirsholly -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/10/2009 2:18:10 PM)

quote:

No but the submissive should be protected from predators.
This statement sounds as if a submissive is a victim unless there is a Dom around to protect her.

My submission has nothing to do with my ability to take control of a volatile situation. Submission does not make me weak and/or helpless. If a predator comes after me he will see a submissive that is 6 feet of concrete.






lusciouslips19 -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/10/2009 2:22:46 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly

quote:

No but the submissive should be protected from predators.
This statement sounds as if a submissive is a victim unless there is a Dom around to protect her.

My submission has nothing to do with my ability to take control of a volatile situation. Submission does not make me weak and/or helpless. If a predator comes after me he will see a submissive that is 6 feet of concrete.





Im not suggesting that a submissive has to be weak. But if I try to take care of a problem by reporting it, I dont think it should be treated in a dismmissive way. Its possible if you came down on someone with 6 feet of concrete you may be the one who gets in trouble.




LaTigresse -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/10/2009 2:37:01 PM)

If I am at a restaurant and another patron is making such a fuss that he is disrupting other diners or endangering them, it is only right to talk to the manager, or leave. If that asshole patron is a wealthy regular, the complaint may be disreguarded. I wouldn't return to that restaurant. I would probably also demand my food to go, at a discount. A huge discount. But that's just me.

It's not a male female thing, and it's not a dominant submissive thing. Courtesy is a human thing.

However, the thread was about respect, not courtesy.




sirsholly -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/10/2009 2:38:49 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: lusciouslips19

quote:

ORIGINAL: sirsholly

quote:

No but the submissive should be protected from predators.
This statement sounds as if a submissive is a victim unless there is a Dom around to protect her.

My submission has nothing to do with my ability to take control of a volatile situation. Submission does not make me weak and/or helpless. If a predator comes after me he will see a submissive that is 6 feet of concrete.





Im not suggesting that a submissive has to be weak. But if I try to take care of a problem by reporting it, I dont think it should be treated in a dismmissive way. Its possible if you came down on someone with 6 feet of concrete you may be the one who gets in trouble.
I doubt i would find myself in trouble, Lushy. I know how to conduct myself.  The "six feet of concrete" simply means i will not back down, will not cower in a corner. Playing the role of the little woman that is need of protection, the helpless victim, has never suited me, and heaven forbid it ever does.

As to someone dismissing a complaint i have made? I am not about to shrug my shoulders and walk away. The second time i address the issue will be louder and more direct, and i will expect to be told why the first complaint was dismissed.




NorthernGent -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/10/2009 3:37:36 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: thetammyjo

For example, male candidates who were married were described as "stable" while female candidates who were married were described as "too busy" with the search committee was talking in private. It's a sad reality and even more so because to say such a thing to your candidates would be to open yourself up to a law suit but that doesn't stop the thinking from existing.



Is this due to the prospect of the female candidates taking maternity leave at some stage?




sblady -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/10/2009 3:59:45 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: NorthernGent

quote:

ORIGINAL: thetammyjo

For example, male candidates who were married were described as "stable" while female candidates who were married were described as "too busy" with the search committee was talking in private. It's a sad reality and even more so because to say such a thing to your candidates would be to open yourself up to a law suit but that doesn't stop the thinking from existing.



Is this due to the prospect of the female candidates taking maternity leave at some stage?


Men are allowed to take a leave of absence to assist their wives after a child is born, adopted, etc.  Some do, others don't.  Every female is not necessarily going need maternity leave.  Leave of absence is taken regardless of the circumstances...illness can befall anyone.   Just sayin'.

Sorry to go off topic. [:)]




catize -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/10/2009 10:43:35 PM)

I have read both threads with interest.  I see it as more than a BDSM community issue because I have watched very similar social problems in all facets of life; work, church, neighborhoods, any type of group gatherings that are out there.
There are the type of ‘hosts’ or ‘leaders’ who are uncomfortable with confrontation.  So they allow the group to disintegrate rather than make a stand for the good of the whole.
There are the type of members who will never stop carping; whether something is dealt with or ignored, ‘they’ aren’t happy and try to undermine any positive steps.
There are the socially inept members who are not malicious, but simply annoy.  They are the ones who never ‘get it’; blunt confrontations are as useless as subtle hints. They believe they are popular because they end up talking to everyone over the span of the gathering—never realizing that the reason they speak to so many is that people slowly drift away to escape.   The group as a whole tolerates them simply hoping they will learn over time—and they never do.
Then you have gender issues; not only the differences between communication styles between men and women; but how those styles are valued.  The belief that men are assertive, but women are bitchy for example. There will always be certain men and women who refuse to accept that anything a member of the opposite gender says is valid.  Unfortunately, there will always be women and men who act in a way that each respective sex see  as proof of how correct they are in their generalizations.
You will almost always see and hear accusations of gender bias when things get heated.
Dominant and submissive members abound in any group.  Unfortunately, most of the time males are viewed as dominant and females as submissive.  Add that to a group of (tongue in cheek) like minded D/s people and the dominant/submissive problems are apt to be exaggerated.  It takes a strong contingent within the group to overcome that. 
 How many listen to the women who talk in girlish voices, burst out in girlish giggles and say to them ‘You are an adult!  I would find you less annoying if you saved that for your own dominant if that’s what they like.’ How many of us watch a man come on to every woman in the room and say to him “You are an adult.  I’d like you much better if you could carry on a conversation that didn’t demand I submit to you’?
I firmly believe that I must respect myself first and foremost. I believe that if I conduct myself in a way that keeps my self respect intact, then the good folks will also respect what I stand for.  And I really don’t want any respect from ‘bad’ folks.  Self respect means that if no one values what I say then it is time to find a venue where they will.
If a situation arises where I am made uncomfortable or feel vulnerable or unsafe, then my self respect demands that I speak up.  If no one listens, then I speak louder—sometimes louder in volume, sometimes ‘louder’ as in more forceful and often repeated until the issue comes  into the light.  I had a neighbor a number of years ago who harassed me; not sexually, he just decided to make my life miserable.  He was sneaky and I couldn’t prove a thing.  But I bided my time and waited for him to make a mistake.  The neighbors were all outside for something, I can’t even remember what.  But this guy walked behind me and muttered a derogatory comment as he pretended to stroll by.  I loudly asked him, “Would you like to repeat that so everyone can hear what you just said to me?’  Everyone stared at both of us and he slunk away with a bright red face.  He never bothered me again.
 
My sense of self respect compels me to say that the term of ‘save-a-hoe’ from the other thread offends me on several levels.  Unless the writer of that term is talking about a garden implement, I don’t find it an appropriate word in this context; nor do I appreciate the connotation that if I am in a sticky situation I must be a ‘ho and therefore deserve it.   It may not be true for all, but I for one do not care to be perceived as a damsel in distress in need of a white knight,.   But some back up from the troops (male and female) can turn the tide while I am doing battle.
 
Groups are made up of people with all their flaws.  I personally have never been a member of a perfect group.  For some of us the socialization is worth the hassles, for some of us the hassles don’t make it worth our time to stay in that dynamic.
Once again, we can’t change other people; we can only change our response to them.




LaTigresse -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/11/2009 6:19:04 AM)

Beautiful post Catize. I love how you differentiate between white knight and troops.




Guilty1974 -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/11/2009 8:20:10 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: mistoferin
When the shit hits the proverbial fan...does a submissive voice carry the same weight or credibility as a dominant one? To take it out even farther, does a dominant females voice carry the same weight as a dominant male voice?


Yes and yes.




stella41b -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/11/2009 8:45:36 AM)

Respect is something which shines from within and is thus recognized and shared.




MistressDolly -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/11/2009 9:39:44 AM)

Not respecting a person because they identify as a submissive is no lesser a form of lunacy than respecting a person because they identify as a dominant.




StormsSlave -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/11/2009 12:17:18 PM)

People are people.  I have learned a very simple thing.  As a very general rule, when people hang out together on a regular basis, especially large groups of people, there is eventually going to be drama.  I know, because it happens everywhere, to everyone, even us, who make it a point to avoid it like the plague.  Still, the occasion arises where we end up sucked into somebody elses stuff simply by proximity. *shrug.*  It happens.  Somebody's opinion is always going to offend someone elses sensibilities.  I don't know why, really, because everyone is entitled, or so I'm told.  Still, it happens.  We see it on here all the time.  It's a perfect example.





RacerM95 -> RE: Submissive as a respected member of your community. Real or illusion? (4/12/2009 12:59:35 PM)

It is the PERSON, not the(quote) Dom/me  sub (un-quote) that earned the respect. It does not matter what side of the coin you are.. 




Page: <<   < prev  1 2 3 4 [5]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875