willbeurdaddy -> RE: Go Get Him, Al! (12/19/2009 4:58:16 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: SpinnerofTales quote:
No, what my posts show is that I actually HAVE thought about my positions, and they are consistent and defensible. Unlike claims that "single payer health care" isnt socialism, or claims that there are no just wars. ORIGINAL: willbeurdaddy Well, what I have seen is that you find it difficult to differentiate between socialism and communism. I have no problem with our disagreements. I feel that single payer is no more socialism than social security, medicare and the minimum wage law. I also have said, in many posts, that pure capitalism isn't working in this country nor would pure socialism. That any "pure" system is giving simple solutions to complex problems. You feel otherwise. That is fine. What I object to is your assumption that because I disagree with you I have spent less time thinking, investigating and learning the issues than you have. I object to your assumption that anyone who doesn't believe as you do is foggy headed and incapable of doing well in a business environment. In short, I object to your constant attitude that anyone who doesn't agree with you is your inferior in a host of ways. As for just wars, I agree they exist. Iraq wasn't one of them. Afghanistan is a simpler matter: It's not a war we can win. I am against fighting wars without good cause, but I am even more against fighting them and coming out losers. That isn't blind ideology either. I have no problem differentiating them. Socialism is economic policy, communism is political policy that tyranically imposes socialism. So what? you are right..single payer is no more socialism than those 3...they are ALL socialism. I dont feel otherwise on your next statment, we agree that no pure "ism" can work, I have never promoted pure capitalism (ie anarcho-capitalism). I have never assumed or stated that you havent thought about the issues etc. What I do believe is that despite thinking about them you have no rational basis to support them. As far as "foggy headed businessmen" goes, I have built 3 businesses and sold two of them. I know what it takes to make a successful business that is both profitable and fair to its employees. Your liberal positions are totally inconsistent with the ability to do that. Therefore if you were a businessman, you would certainly be a foggy headed one. My attitude rarely has anything to do with inferiority of intellect or morality. It has everything to do with intellectual dishonesty as exhibited constantly by RML and the dearly departed DomKen. We disagree on Iraq and agree on Afghanistan (at least that it isnt winnable in the current environment), which is why Obama is wrong on both. There is an alternative to fighting a just war and coming out losers. Fight to win and we will win. We no longer have the moral clarity to do that.
|
|
|
|