DomYngBlk -> RE: African complicity in the slave trade.... (5/2/2010 4:40:36 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: WyldHrt quote:
No, I got your point. And there is honor in a struggle. But what I am saying wouldn't it be nice if no one had to struggle to "prove" their abilities? Would it be nice? Of course. That said, please point me to any place in human history where every child got started in life with exactly the same opportunities, any time when life was totally fair within a human society. It has never happened. The only way such a thing could happen is some form of communism, where the gov't takes everything and divides it equally, or where the children are taken away and raised by the gov't. Even if it were possible to implement this system without corruption (unlikely), what would be the motivation for people to do their best and excel? Many people, especially immigrants and lower middle class folks, do so not only for themselves, but so that their children have a better start in life than they did. Would you really go to medical school if the kid flipping burgers was making the same amount of money that you would as a physician? Would your motivation to work hard be as strong if you knew that your children were not permitted to benefit from your success? Say that you invent and patent a widget that revolutionizes manufacturing in some way. You are now a self made millionaire. Would you like to be told that you can't send your kids to private school, or pay for extra tutoring if they need it because it isn't fair to other people's children? That you can't read to your children at night because doing so will give them an edge over children who don't get read to? That said, it seems that you think I'm against changing the current system. That is not the case. I'm a big believer in education, and the state of school systems all over this country is a disgrace. Change is needed, but throwing money at the problem is not the solution. Nothing will change without a fundamental shift in people's attitudes toward education. Look at Japan. The country was nearly destroyed in WWII, and now they are a global power. Why? There are several reasons, but one of the most important is the emphasis put on education by the parents and the communities. In this country, kids are more worried about how to get the latest iPhone or $100 sneakers that their friends have than about learning how to get ahead in life.... and we wonder why they aren't succeeding? Of course there isn't a perfect example of this.....hence the reason to strive to create one...... I don't agree with the premise we wouldn't have the motivation to create.....And for this I make a difference in creating things from marketing things. Bill Gates didn't invent the modern pc or program...he simply marketed it to his advantage, Henry Ford didn't invent the automobile, he marketed it the best. Real creators , inventors simply don't do it for the money they do it for the love of it. Are you telling me you wouldn't do anything unless you are paid to do it? I don't believe that. And, while we are at it, does it make sense that people that are simply involved in financial dealings which do not create one simple things should be able to make 100's of millions of dollars per year? The guy that drove Lehmans in the ground was doing nothing but bundling things that were worth x and convincing people to buy them for y. It created not one thing in this world. Yet, the behavior is rewarded. And for Doctors.....there are plenty of doctors that practice for the money but do you suppose that the care you get is good? I mean that leads one into talking about how and why people are allowed into Medical School. Does it make sense to base those things simply on test scores? I think not. Its nice to see that you think change would be good. I had thought that maybe you thought status quo was really good enough. Lastly, the old canard about not throwing money at education is a bunch of shit. You spend the same amount of money on facilities, boos, classrooms, computers, teacher/student ratios that you do in some of the more affluent suburbs of this country and bring that the inner city. I would bet my ass that test scores in the inner cities would fly to the top. Step into an inner city elementary school someday. Compare/contrast. It isn't even an arguement.
|
|
|
|