RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


thompsonx -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 6:26:15 PM)

quote:

That because they don't grow good pot in the North duh.


Without a doubt that is the most ignorant thing I have ever heard in my life.




slvemike4u -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 6:26:55 PM)

ROFLMAO.....that crosswalk thing was pretty good too [:D]




thompsonx -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 6:29:42 PM)

quote:

We should bring the troops home from Iraq/Afghanistan and invade 75 miles into Mexican territory and set up shop.


Besides violating the soverignty of mexico and the u.n. charter wouldn't it also make all of those mexicans in that, approximately 150,000 square mile, zone american citizens?




thompsonx -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 6:37:19 PM)

quote:

Well thank God there's none of them in here! We get all the bleeding heart Lefties in this site who want to raise EVERYONE's taxes for some reason.


Everytime legalizing pot comes up you are out in front seeking to tax it while claiming you have never used it.
So have you moved from center right independent to tax and spend liberal?




thompsonx -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 6:39:48 PM)

quote:

Since then our policy toward the Mexicans has been conflicted. Sometimes we want them; sometimes we don't. During the Great Depression we deported 500,000 Mexican-Americans.


Actually the number was more than a million american citizens of latino heritage. The punch line was that when wwII came along the u.s. govt sent all of the draft age males a draft notice which 100% of responded to by comming back and putting on a uniform to protect a country that threw them out and expropriated their property.




thornhappy -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 6:52:08 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Marini
Using all the modern technology that is available, it would hardly be comparable to the "Berlin Wall".

There have been several efforts to use "high tech" methods to secure the border, and they failed gloriously.  The most recent attempt was by Boeing.




Marini -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 6:59:11 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyPact

quote:

ORIGINAL: slvemike4u

Personally I find it distressing that folks ,who up till this point I held in some regard,actually believe militirizing our border is a viable and workable solution.The funny thing is none who advocate this have even contemplated that this is not the sort of mission our military trains for.Soldiers are not law enforcement personel....but as long as we go with servants shoot first,screw the questions idea that should be an issue.


Actually, it does.  Soldiers of the National Guard have been brought in specifically to police people many times where there has been a state of emergency.  That includes having to handle a situation such as this.  I don't think that you're suggesting that the INS has superior training to our Nation's military.

The thread original asked what would work.  Militarizing the boarder would work.  A wall would work.  The Berlin wall, in it's four different phases, worked for twenty-eight years.  That's a pretty effective wall. 

This is a bit over the top, but people need to start thinking of the United States less as a country of unlimited resources for the world and start thinking of it with the realization that we have limited means.  If you had some type of emergency shelter that had enough food, water, and medical supplies to sustain a dozen people for the six months you needed to stay in there, if there was an emergency, you and eleven people would go in it.  You wouldn't invite the whole neighborhood along.  Even if you stretched a bit and let more people in, at some point, you would have to say it is holding all that it can and there just wasn't enough resources for everybody.



LadyPact, I have said the same exact thing that you have said, so many times around here it is not even funny.

Most people here will not understand the statements you just typed.
We have a never ending source of unlimited resources here, and we can take every disadvantaged person into this country from all over the world, and we can and should provide them with food, clothing, education, shelter, medical and hospital care, and everything else.

America has a bottomless pit of resources, and it is our duty to not only welcome but to encourage all the poor and downtrodden people in South America, to come here and we will take care of them.
It is the American way!

The following facts MEAN nothing to most here:
The fact that unemployment is near 20% in some area's, we have no idea how high it is because so many have just stopped looking.
The fact that many people are seriously underemployed and basically desperate, and willing to do just about anything to make money.
The fact that we have millions of people that are American citizens that continue to have no health or medical insurance.
The fact that it is so bad that many communities are laying off teachers, and many don't realize how large class sizes are becoming in public schools and don't care.
lol
The fact that we have thousands of people considered the working poor that are living in shelters and motels because they don't make enough to pay rent and take care of their families.
I am not even going to mention the money being spent on two wars, and the emotional and financial costs of the never ending wars.
The fact that many, many working people are going to soup kitchens because they are still running out of food and can't feed their families.
I have posted several threads on this topic.
We have many, many people already living here that need more help than it appears we can provide.
So naturally, we need thousands and thousands of people to come here at this time, and partake of the feast of plenty.


In fact, if you dare say anything about "limited resources", or the fact that we may not be able to take care of millions of more poor people that are pouring into this country {and no one really knows how many are here or how many are coming as I type these words}, and that this is not 1922 at Ellis Island, and we don't need millions of more poor people coming into this country to help build this country up, you will soon be called racist.

In fact, I actually believe that there is a segment of people that enjoy seeing millions of people strolling across our borders to add to the current situation.
The fact that people don't comprehend what we are saying, speaks volumes on how bad off our country is as we spiral downward.

America is the Land of Oz, all we have to do is encourage every disadvantaged person in the world to just come here legally or illegally, and then they can stay and we can take care of them.

President Obama will soon pull out the big magic stick, and everything is going to be okay.
*Or else it is surely his fault, lol.

The boat is big enough and we have enough resources for everyone in the world.
Let's now hold hands and sing Kumbayah.

Personally, I believe we are viewing the "end of an era", and we are moving towards a much larger and powerful government state, at this point, I don't see any other way.
And we will deserve the government run country that we allowed to be created, because there are going to be just too many people that NEED the government to provide for there every need.
Peace




jlf1961 -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 7:02:13 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: thornhappy

quote:

ORIGINAL: Marini
Using all the modern technology that is available, it would hardly be comparable to the "Berlin Wall".

There have been several efforts to use "high tech" methods to secure the border, and they failed gloriously.  The most recent attempt was by Boeing.


High tech sensors fail because the time it takes for a team of border patrol agents to arrive at the scene is too long.

Thus making the necessity of a physical fence, most likely a double fence along the border the only viable alternative. Once the fence is put up, you need constant patrols, with no long periods between patrol passes. It would also mean watchtowers manned 24/7 to aid in watching the border.

So, as I have asked the conservative members of this board, where is all the money going to come from to build the fence, patrol the fence and detain anyone caught coming across the border?




jlf1961 -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 7:31:14 PM)

FYI, for anyone that cares, the cost of the fence, or at least part of it, is as follows...

quote:

The fencing erected along the U.S.-Mexico border in the past three years by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security has cost more than expected, a government report shows.
The 140 miles of pedestrian fencing put up under the Secure Border Initiative before Oct. 31 of last year cost an average of $3.9 million per mile, a Government Accountability Office report released this week found. Costs ranged from $400,000 to $15.1 million a mile.
That per-mile average is more than the $3 million estimated by the Congressional Budget Office in August 2006 and much more than the $2.2 million estimate the Senate used during the immigration reform debate that same year. Even the highest estimate at the time, $3.2 million per mile from U.S. Rep. Duncan Hunter, R-Calif., ended up being too low.

full story

Now, the entire area that would have to be fenced, with a actual physical fence is 533 miles.

As noted, 140 miles of pedestrian fence (designed to stop people on foot) cost $3.9 million per mile, so the entire length of fence would cost $2.0787 billion dollars. Not too awful bad, and a lot cheaper than the "virtual" fence that Boeing was contracted for, that never materialized due to cost overruns and missed deadlines.




LadyPact -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 7:42:35 PM)

A nice size chunk of that could come from closing the military bases in Okinawa.  Pretty good source for personnel, too.




AQuietSimpleMan -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 7:57:52 PM)

Screw the fence.

As Carlos Mensia said:

Let all the current illegal immigrants stay, give them a gun and a govenment pay grade. Then let them patrol the border, and here is the deal if they let someone through then they get their job. The guy who let them through has to go back.

GUARANTEED No more Illegal Immigrants.

OR MY IDEA.

My Idea. Take all the money you would spend on this over 5 years and Buy Plastic Land Mines. Then Set up Cameras and charge Pay-per-view to watch it. Anyone who gets across with all their Limbs.... Free Green Card. The Pay-per-view in The South will pay for this in a matter of a few years.

QSM





Marini -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 8:04:23 PM)

nm
my new laptop owns me.
It types by itself.
[;)]




AnimusRex -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 8:27:03 PM)

FR-

Laws are able to be enforced only when the vast majority wants to abide by it; very few people want (or are daring enough to) to rob liquor stores, so the law against armed robbery can be enforced with sufficient policing.

The immigration law is a bit like the 55 MPH speed limit- the number of people (both employers and workers) who want to break it is so vast, that it forms nearly an outright majority of the country. I would bet that everyone on this thread has patronized a business that employed illegals within the past 24 hours.

The reason so many people want to break this particular law is that the law is an unreasonable barrier to a naturally occurring marketplace demand for low wage labor. Sorry, just because we don't like what the marketplace demands doesn't make it go away, or make it possible to enforce.

Workers immigrating here to take low wage jobs is just the mirror image of offshoring manufacturing; instead of shipping factories to Mexico, we just bring Mexico to the businesses here that can't be exported, like farms. In the Midwest, many meat processing plants use almost all illegal labor; if we really cracked down on the border, those meat processing plants would move to Tijuana or Juarez.

Globalization is a two-edged sword- it brings us the benefit of cheap labor from China, but also forces American workers to compete with those same Chinese workers.




popeye1250 -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 8:31:22 PM)

So Rex, what would it take to secure that border with Mexico?




AQuietSimpleMan -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 8:42:22 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: AnimusRex
I would bet that everyone on this thread has patronized a business that employed illegals within the past 24 hours.



A bet you would lose.

I didn't shop at all in the last 24 hours, the only thing I ate was Hungry Howies Pizza which only employes stupid Teenagers as proven by the fact that I ended up with 4 pizzas cause the first 2 were wrong.

I only used my Verizon Cell Phone which was built by Asians, and watched my TV Cable which is all decided by the Magnificent Jewish people who run Hollywood (Is it Racist if you think it's a good thing?)

My Couch and most of my Funniture was built by me which was a genius idea by the Norwegians.

And I haven't had any fruit in about a week.

Pretty sure in the last 24 hours I have yet to support illegal immigration.

QSM




AnimusRex -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 8:54:36 PM)

Nice try:

The ingredients on Howies Pizza were probably wheat (processed across America by illegal labor);
tomato sauce (picked in the San Joaquin Valley by Mexican hands);
the fabric and lumber in your furniture- lumber loaded by illegals, fabric made in nonunion mills in Georgia, all staffed by...

Anyway, you get the idea.

As to how I would secure the border-
1. Drastically increase the number of worker visas granted to Mexico, so that it matched the marketplace demand for labor.
2. Legalize marijuana and cocaine to cut the flow of money to the drug cartels.
3. Deport all Republicans to Mexico.

OK, one of those was a bit much. Maybe we should only legalize marijuana.




AQuietSimpleMan -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 9:01:15 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: AnimusRex

Nice try:

The ingredients on Howies Pizza were probably wheat (processed across America by illegal labor);
tomato sauce (picked in the San Joaquin Valley by Mexican hands);
the fabric and lumber in your furniture- lumber loaded by illegals, fabric made in nonunion mills in Georgia, all staffed by...


Just Called I was assure they all were Legal.

[:D]




tazzygirl -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 9:27:42 PM)

~FR

I have said that America does not stop at its border, that wherever there is an American, there is America.




domiguy -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 10:05:30 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: popeye1250




JLF, that's a bargain!
Two years ago illegal aliens were costing us $93 Billion per year. This year I think that figure is $104 Billion!
And Soldiers and Marines don't do "shifts." They can stay for a month at a time then give them two weeks off or whatever and they're already being paid so they won't cost us anymore than they are now.
Hell, they can raise my taxes for that!



I would like to see the source for this information....The Howie Carr show is not a reliable source.


I tried to find it and could find no "reliable" source that documented the annual cost of illegals.




domiguy -> RE: What would it take to actually secure the border with Mexico? (7/27/2010 10:09:57 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: tazzygirl

~FR

I have said that America does not stop at its border, that wherever there is an American, there is America.



What in God's name is that even supposed to mean?




Page: <<   < prev  10 11 [12] 13 14   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875