LadyConstanze
Posts: 9722
Joined: 2/18/2005 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: slave4bull2 quote:
ORIGINAL: LadyConstanze quote:
ORIGINAL: Charles6682 Hell,I hear FloriDUH is giving tax breaks for people to buy YACHTS!!!Hell,it dosent get any better than that.FloriDUH loves to have the little guy bend over so you Billionaires can come and fuck them in the ass! Have you considered that those yachts are sold in Florida and a lot of them are actually made in Florida. So by giving people tax breaks to purchase them, you are creating jobs for people working on them, then they will need maintenance, staff, all that, it creates jobs... The company I work for is looking to open a US branch, they will go to Florida due to the tax breaks there, which means they will invest in Florida and not in another state, they'll have an office there and all that, which will be staffed by largely local people. So the tax breaks actually do create jobs. It makes so much more sense than keeping companies away with high taxes. Ok........how do you explain the fact that the tax rate in the late 50's and early 60's was 85% for the top income brackets? And that all of this posturing and squalling is about putting the Tax rate back to 38% for that bracket, that's what it was during the Clinton boom years of the 90's. Were there no Yacht sales then? Living in S Florida for most of my life and in the Ft Lauderdale area during that exact time, I can tell you there were no shortage of Yacht sales. Here is what is happening right now: A very, very small handful of Wall Street bankers and investors basically brought the entire financial world down around us all. WE..and that is all of us...bailed them out. With borrowed money. We borrowed money to bail out billionaires, it really is that simple. Now...they have sold this bill of good that...if only they get just a little more of a tax break..if we give them just a bit more at the expense of the other 98%...they will make it ALLLL better for everyone again. Fox news and the extremely wealthy talk show mouthpieces of the far right have done a great job selling this to the masses. So here we are, having a discussion about 3% points for the top 2%, that did not exist before 2000. Remarkable. By the way Lady C, notice how I HAVE NOT name called you here. I am very capable of conducting a civil conversation. I treat everyone the way they treat me, its not anymore complicated than that. What has one to do with the other? And why do you feel the need to point out that you have not name called me? Is that so extraordinary that you need to point it out? I would have thought that is normal. The very same thing with the banks happened all over the word, the US is not alone in that, surprisingly the US is alson not the only country in the world. Now why it might not seem fair that the rich (and btw not all the rich are bankers, just thought I throw that in since you seem to be under the impression that only bankers get the tax breaks) get tax breaks, it keeps them and their money in the country, if you raise taxes for them, they will simply get out of the country and settle somewhere else, you know Switzerland, Monaco and to a large degree Austria generate enormous income by giving the very rich tax breaks - this is money that is then missing in your own country, so the people remaining there will have to pay more tax because the country has expenses. If you give them a tax break moving away and taking their money with them will become less desirable for them, a rich very rich person, even with tax breaks might pay more in taxes than a lot of poor or just moderately wealthy people, I'd say it is in the best interest of a country to keep them there, otherwise they leave and the whole tax load is on the poor. If you care to look at the past of Europe, there were a lot of countries who taxed the rich and super rich to high heaven, with the result that most of them left and didn't pay ANY tax in that country anymore. Also if you punish people for doing well by taxing them much much higher, what reason do people have to actually work hard and achieve more? Would you work hard for a better position if you manage to slip into a higher tax bracket and you are left with more or less the same amount of money or less? I doubt I would then spend as much time working as I do, because where would be the point? As was pointed out by several people, rich people don't just sit on their money, they spend it, they invest it, all things that drive the economy, you drive them away, well they not only will pay their taxes in another country, they will also spend and invest in another country. Why do you think that some of the countries who have the lowest taxes are also the wealthiest countries and even their poor are better off? They have a secure income from the tax of the very rich they attract by giving them tax breaks, so it does benefit the rest of their population. Imagine the general tax a country needs to run efficiently like a household, now if the richest members of the family leave, the others have to pay more to make the rent. If we'd be millionaires, we also wouldn't want to pay sky high taxes and in general people don't get rich because they are stupid (of course there will always be some who just inherited) or lazy, if you'd win the lottery and end up with millions, the place where you live would take more than half of it, another lace would say "Come and live here, nice, safe, clean - you only pay 10%" what would you do? While it doesn't seem fair, it makes more sense to keep them in your country, to attract investors with tax breaks and all that. What help would it be if nobody would by yachts and the factories close and more people are unemployed? If you put the tax up to 85% in the top income bracket, those people will all be gone, I would be, if I'd only get 25 cents of a dollar, what motivation do I have to earn well and generate a fortune? Why should I pay more because I work hard? I'd move myself and my money somewhere else where they aren't trying to rip me off, so the old country would end up with zero income from me and others would have to make up for that. You know, you would also do the same. Why punish people for being successful? To stop them being successful or to drive them away?
_____________________________
There are 10 kinds of people who understand binary Those who do and those who don't! http://exdomme.blogspot.com/2012/07/public-service-announcement.html
|