RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


Aneirin -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 5:51:18 AM)

Fast Reply


For those interested in world costume, see here for excerpt from a nineteenth century book; ''Manners and Customs of the Modern Egyptians by E.W.Lane'', which describes Muslim attire from the time of the authors observation- 1850

And for the complete section in the book concerning costume see here

And for an online version of the complete book, see here

So, nineteenth century at least and maybe even further back in time the face covering was worn by Muslim women, the Victorians if anything, their collector mentality was good at recording information if not for their cultural analysis and judgement.

But just exactly what is wrong with Muslim women being covered up, what is it that get's your goat, is it a sign of difference, a sign of oppression, a reminder even, a reminder of the wars fought in foreign lands against the very people who choose to be so attired, or is it you just don't like it, being denied the lascivious thoughts you think is your right ?

Driving what do we employ in driving, the nose, the mouth, the hair or is it the eyes, yes the eyes from those parts we see, so naturally with traditional Muslim female attire the eyes are uncovered else they would always be walking into things never mind driving. And whilst such garments as over coats and mac's exist in Western attire, don't go on about how Muslim female dress can hide stuff. As for men in Muslim female attire to avoid detection sure the face may be covered, but have you noticed, women tend to have a different gait and that caused by their bodily difference, to the observant involved in security, well naturally one would think they new the differences, how a body moves beyond facial recognition.

France- Vive la liberte, I am surprised at, but at the same time not so surprised as France for a long time has been heading down the racist path with it's seeking those to blame for societies ills, just like some other countries in the West I suppose, so , they are not alone in that. I am just waitin to see which country follows France's lead now, who else is goin to stick their neck out and follow like a little puppy dog.

As to identity cards,driving licenses and such, (which are a form of Identity used in the UK for those that have them), well if there is a requirement for identity, then it makes no sense for the identifying image to show a covered face, for that is not the identity of a person, might be, but cannot be confirmed, so if the rule exists regards facial recognition, then it exists for all, no exceptions as anything else could be deemed discriminatory towards those who do not wear face veils.

Hijab, Burqa, Shayla, Al-Amira, Khimar, Chador, Niqab, they are all different and signify different things




rockspider -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 4:25:06 PM)

Well, tell that to the family of the Red Cross aid workers family who just got slaugthered in Afghanistan or the british nurse who got whipped for having a drink in Saudi Arabia or the countless other who haven´t been as lucky as you.
quote:

ORIGINAL: stellauk


quote:

ORIGINAL: rockspider

Well a survey in my country based on Muslim men aged 18 - 30 showed that 48 % of them believed in the Khalifat. Muslim worlddominated rule with sharia law as the rule. I don´t really see much difference in that and "The Third Reich" as proposed by that little german gefreiter named Hitler. Both are equally sick. The truth is they hate us with a vengeance and everything we stand for. If you are in doubt, just try and stay in a Muslim dominated country for a while and see for your self how much respect you get for our western views.


I spent my teenage years in Bradford. In one year in my school I was one of two white kids in my class, the remaining 30 were all Pakistani, and Muslim. I have worked with Muslims and I have spent time in Baku, Azerbaijan.

As you can see I still have a head on my shoulders, I am still alive, I have not been blown up, taken hostage, or indeed suffered in any way as a result of contact with Muslims.






ArizonaBossMan -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 4:25:56 PM)

France is getting smarter, aren't they?




rockspider -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 4:32:01 PM)

To many if you may ask me. And for 6 month of my life i hardly meet any other than Muslims which is not unusual if you live in a Muslim country. There the rule was to follow their rules or get punished. As simple as that. No pork, no women, no booze and total respect for their religion. If you didn´t like it you could get the fuck out of their country.
quote:

ORIGINAL: Politesub53

quote:

ORIGINAL: rockspider

Well a survey in my country based on Muslim men aged 18 - 30 showed that 48 % of them believed in the Khalifat. Muslim worlddominated rule with sharia law as the rule. I don´t really see much difference in that and "The Third Reich" as proposed by that little german gefreiter named Hitler. Both are equally sick. The truth is they hate us with a vengeance and everything we stand for. If you are in doubt, just try and stay in a Muslim dominated country for a while and see for your self how much respect you get for our western views.


I suspect you meet loads of Muslims on a daily basis and form your views on that ? 





Politesub53 -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 4:37:00 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: rockspider

To many if you may ask me. And for 6 month of my life i hardly meet any other than Muslims which is not unusual if you live in a Muslim country. There the rule was to follow their rules or get punished. As simple as that. No pork, no women, no booze and total respect for their religion. If you didn´t like it you could get the fuck out of their country.



Surely you knew the laws out there before you went ?

It isnt just Muslims who cant eat pork either.




kdsub -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 4:56:39 PM)

I am conflicted …do these women WANT to wear this covering? Are they given a choice within their own families? Imagine how miserable it is to have every inch of your body covered at all times when in public. Even if these women know nothing else should France allow the degradation and physical discomfort of women?

If a religion allowed men to whip their women for showing their eyes or an ankle should they allow it in their country?

Then again as a religious person I believe in traditions and the right to display them. But remember this extreme form of dress is not mandated by Islam and is not the tradition in many Islamic countries.

So I do not call France racists…I do believe they are looking to the welfare of their citizens…I’m just not sure they are right.

Butch




NocturnalStalker -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 4:57:03 PM)

Good for France.  It's about time somebody did something and bravely said, "Look you're in my house, you take off your shoes."  Don't like it?  Don't go there.  Live there already?  Go somewhere else where they tolerate that. 





Phoenixpower -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 4:57:21 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Politesub53

quote:

ORIGINAL: rockspider

To many if you may ask me. And for 6 month of my life i hardly meet any other than Muslims which is not unusual if you live in a Muslim country. There the rule was to follow their rules or get punished. As simple as that. No pork, no women, no booze and total respect for their religion. If you didn´t like it you could get the fuck out of their country.



Surely you knew the laws out there before you went ?

It isnt just Muslims who cant eat pork either.


I am confident he did, but so do others (or at least should) know the rules of the countries they come in to.

I do remember, that where I am from in Germany we always had the cross hanging in our classrooms during my childhood and if I remember it correctly (but can be wrong about it due to living abroad I am not entirely sure) then some years ago was there some sort of debate that we shouldnt have the crosses anymore in the classrooms as it would be disrespectful towards others religious faith...

now...personally I don't mind them wearing their robe or not but I do mind when all of a sudden home countries get accused of not being tolerant just because they want to continue the path they did since centuries.

So for me sometimes it is a bit the problem between at one side other nationalities expecting to respect everything they bring in to be respected but in return then don't want to respect rules their new country has and expects them to change from one day to another towards them...now, I don't know what the outcome is back at home at my school if they took the crosses off or not, but I do remember it somewhere that it was topic some years ago...so quite frankly it does go both ways [8|] and IMO the other side is not always seen as much as the side from the people who move in from abroad.




Politesub53 -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 5:07:57 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub

I am conflicted …do these women WANT to wear this covering? Are they given a choice within their own families? Imagine how miserable it is to have every inch of your body covered at all times when in public. Even if these women know nothing else should France allow the degradation and physical discomfort of women?

If a religion allowed men to whip their women for showing their eyes or an ankle should they allow it in their country?

Then again as a religious person I believe in traditions and the right to display them. But remember this extreme form of dress is not mandated by Islam and is not the tradition in many Islamic countries.

So I do not call France racists…I do believe they are looking to the welfare of their citizens…I’m just not sure they are right.

Butch



There were several women who were arrested in France today who wore veils in protest. Do you assume they dont have free will.

Physical discomfort due to clothing.....ever seen what high heels does to young girls expected to "look sexy" in the west.





tweakabelle -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 6:20:41 PM)

quote:

rockspider
The truth is they hate us with a vengeance and everything we stand for. If you are in doubt, just try and stay in a Muslim dominated country for a while and see for your self how much respect you get for our western views.


Having taken your recommended method of investigation, my experience doesn't conform to your alleged 'truth' at all.

Western people and what they stand for are not hated. As is obvious from the Arab 'Spring', democracy, free speech, a free press and other Western values are admired and desired. The idea that "they hate us for our freedom" is even sillier than it sounds.

The West and it's history of intervention in Muslim/Arab lands is hated. There are good historical reasons for this - installing and propping up corrupt vicious dictators and autocrats, colonialism, inflicting the what is seen as the catastrophe of Israel on the region, the tens of thousands of deaths due to Israel and various Western invasions, taking their resources for decades for next to nothing ...... add up to some pretty powerful reasons for hating the West's policies in the region.

Western armies are in Muslim/Arab lands, not the other way around. Foreign invasions/occupations are pretty powerful popular reasons for disliking the countries that invade and occupy. Ask the Irish, or the Poles or the French .........




kdsub -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 8:16:50 PM)

I don't assume that because two women protested that all are against the law...and remember women wear high heels to attract men...the purpose of the Burqa is to hide from men...and if kinky other women.

If schools and business can require dress codes why cannot a country...if a miniskirt is against the code in one country why cannot the Burqa be against the code in another.

From what I could find the Koran does not require women to wear a Burqa...so this is a cultural dress rather then a religious one.

Butch




kittinSol -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/12/2011 8:44:50 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: kissheels

Country with a backbone or racist?


Shame on the frogs.




Politesub53 -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/13/2011 3:26:10 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub

I don't assume that because two women protested that all are against the law...and remember women wear high heels to attract men...the purpose of the Burqa is to hide from men...and if kinky other women.

If schools and business can require dress codes why cannot a country...if a miniskirt is against the code in one country why cannot the Burqa be against the code in another.

From what I could find the Koran does not require women to wear a Burqa...so this is a cultural dress rather then a religious one.

Butch


High heels damage feet. Women wear them to attract men ( Your words ). The purpose of the Burqa is modesty.

Full covering from head to toe isnt forced on women except in a few hardline Islamic states. Full covering, except the face veil also exists in other religions, such as Christianity.

Once again this whole concept of nasty Muslims forcing women to wear whatever, overlooks the fact that it is only a small percentage that actually does this.






rulemylife -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/13/2011 3:30:51 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kissheels

there is a difference between a turban and a burqa, turban does not cover the face.... besides women wearing this scare the shit out of the kids on the street..




You never know, some of them might scare the kids more if they took it off.








DeviantlyD -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/13/2011 3:50:41 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: kissheels

quote:

ORIGINAL: slvemike4u

quote:

ORIGINAL: kissheels

there is a difference between a turban and a burqa, turban does not cover the face.... besides women wearing this scare the shit out of the kids on the street..

if I wear a ski mask and walk in a bank, what do You think will happen?
I urge you to run a few tests here...try some different banks in your area and please do get back to us with the results [:)]



ahh a smartass lol


And this surprises you? ;)




kissheels -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/13/2011 3:54:04 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: rulemylife

quote:

ORIGINAL: kissheels

there is a difference between a turban and a burqa, turban does not cover the face.... besides women wearing this scare the shit out of the kids on the street..




You never know, some of them might scare the kids more if they took it off.






Very True [:D]




Aneirin -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/13/2011 5:17:41 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub

I don't assume that because two women protested that all are against the law...and remember women wear high heels to attract men...the purpose of the Burqa is to hide from men...and if kinky other women.

If schools and business can require dress codes why cannot a country...if a miniskirt is against the code in one country why cannot the Burqa be against the code in another.

From what I could find the Koran does not require women to wear a Burqa...so this is a cultural dress rather then a religious one.

Butch


Schools and businesses are either institutions or businesses were one is paid to advertise the company via their clothing, countries, some countries, france included are supposed to be free, that is one can wear what one wants to wear, whether that be through personal choice or a cultural requirement, the freedom shoud be upheld.

As to some situations where one supposes the wearing of a head to toe covering is not required of religious law perhaps something else comes into the equation, freedom from the lascivious thoughts of others, a husband does wish his wife to be hassled by others, so cover the goods up, as in that case he has little fear that her head will be turned by others attention. Perhaps those that put upon others to wear such garments, do it out of insecurity more than anything else, but of what goes on between two married persons, I believe the state has no business and should not be making laws to thwart.

The other thing of course that a head to toe covering can hide, is marital abuse, but if that is happening it can be endured or in western countries the law might take an interest, unlie perhaps other countries.

But one thing that is reported about people that come to live in western countries, is that through time they break away from their past beliefs and become more like the rest of us, they start to interate with each generation.

Two films worth watching, if you are interested ;

East is East

and

Yasmin

East is East is hilarious, but it puts the point across succinctly

Asian, Muslim and British in the 21st century, told from the viewpoint of a Westernised woman working in Britain while living in her own traditional culture.

Written by Simon Beaufoy (highly acclaimed writer of The Full Monty), the script was developed out of months of research and workshops with the Muslim community in the North of England, resulting in an emotionally resonant story, which comes directly out of the community's experiences.

Set in a Northern mill town, against a backdrop of poverty, high unemployment and racism, Yasmin's story deals with universal themes such as guilt, transgression and the search for identity.

Having rebelled against her Pakistani culture as a teenager, Yasmin agrees to marry a cousin 'from home' to please her widowed father. The omens are not good when the goatherder from a Pakistani village meets the sparky, Westernised Yasmin.

But her confidence begins to evaporate after 9/11, when Yasmin becomes increasingly ostracised at work. After a total crisis of identity, the internment of Yasmin's husband triggers a new determination and a sense of purpose. Yasmin fights vigorously for his release from a holding centre - and through her campaign is forced to re-evaluate her faith, her culture, and her relationships.

Both well worth watching if you desire an insight beyond the rabid press and if you like an insight into the English of Northern England.




kissheels -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/13/2011 5:59:47 AM)

This is what some of you are defending

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dsLOpFrlHAc

http://en.news.maktoob.com/20090000502988/Terrorists_use_burqas_to_hide_identity/Article.htm




kdsub -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/13/2011 9:18:04 AM)

As I've said politesub the Burqa, or this type of dress, is cultural not exclusive to Muslims and if a country wants to have a dress code so be it. They certainly limit the amount of nudity allowed which is a dress code. Because there is a culture of nudity should they allow all to go naked in their streets...lol... I would much rather see this law.

But I do believe they have the welfare of women at heart even if wrong.

Butch




liks2plzlf -> RE: France bans face covering veil (burqa) (4/13/2011 9:27:22 AM)

Death to France!!!




Page: <<   < prev  2 3 [4] 5 6   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.03125