RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


slvemike4u -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 6:18:09 PM)

Geez,way to blame us for every little damm thing.




LadyConstanze -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 6:21:59 PM)



quote:

ORIGINAL: Arpig

I see this as a result of the failure of the capitalist system to effectively provide for the lowest strata of society. The failure to provide all members of society with the means to lead a decent life, is the weakness of the present system, and until it is addressed, these sorts of disturbances will only become more and more common. And more violent.
That would be the historical pattern.

Unfortunately the communist system has also failed, completely and was unsustainable. Capitalism doesn't have the obligation to provide for everybody, most civilized countries see it as an obligation, but to be honest, there doesn't seem anybody starving here, people seem to be provided with the means to lead a life, even if it can be very basic, but it can't be the job of the society to make sure that all members have an equal status of luxury, there have to be rewards for working hard and achieving something and material rewards seem to motivate people the most. In the UK everybody has access to health care, support and food, if you want more, you got to work for it.




Lucylastic -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 6:32:38 PM)

no body remind em that WE have the Yellow Cake, fuck knows what would happen




Aylee -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 6:38:38 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Lucylastic

no body remind em that WE have the Yellow Cake, fuck knows what would happen


Does it have chocolate frosting? Because I am only interested in the yellow cake if it has chocolate frosting.




Lucylastic -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 6:42:13 PM)

ok that made me smile, no, it made me Laugh loudly
Ill remember that.
Thanks I needed to laugh
seriously




Marini -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 7:41:48 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Aneirin

I don't know where you are in the strata of society, but from my level their is an air of anger, hopeless anger, an air which has been becoming tighter and tighter over the years and seems to be falling on the present government and undoubtedly their austerity and money grabbing policies have accelerated that feeling culminating in, perhaps what we are seeing on the tv these last few days.

Thank you for addressing "the air of anger".
I think we can address the "air of anger" involved, without condoning the rioting and looting.

There is a definite feeling of there's them, and then there's us, and this feeling permeates all levels of society, we are definately not an United Kingdom, perhaps in reality, never were.

Now many of those at my level of society are not benefit scounging scumbags, but work for a living, some even have struggling small businesses, people who just get on with life lawfully in the best way they can, but they are struggling, swimming against a tide of decreasing funds and with that increasing government inspired demands, the austerity measures and lack of service that appear to be hitting the lower stratas of society the worst. The small businesses, well as you know the banks are jacking them, and the politicians though they may mouth words, seem toothless in the face of the great god that is the banking system, but when what is described as life's little pleasures after a hard day's work, the pub is hit hard, then one tends to feel the action more, as the pub, is a British institution.


I admire you Aneirin, there are many ways to measure a man, beyond the amount of wealth he has accumulated.
You are one of the few on here, that could probably survive, under almost any circumstance.

Now one of the biggest complaints I hear, and I do agree, is about that necessity to life, the use of the private motor vehicle, as believe it, what passes for public transport in this area, part city and part rural, is an expensive unreliable joke, in fact from my position as unemployed, employers are now asking does one have their own transport to get to work, as no one wants an employee who fails to start on time through public transport issues, and I do understand the employers completely in this respect, and don't blame them. I blame the forces that have taken the necessary use of the private motor vehicle into the realms of a luxury commodity as increasingly, employed persons are finding it very difficult to pay the increased sums demanded for their lawful pleasure of living in the UK, as to remember, everything we need to live by, is governed by the fuel cost to the customer and undoubtedly unchecked greed. But many of those whom I know may rant and grind their teeth, but they perhaps exist at a higher flash point than the young and that due to maturity. As to whether maturity means one with age gets wiser, or one with age becomes eroded at what they see and experience with age is a good question. But do the mature flash like the young, perhaps through hopelessness they have learned not to, for there is a hell of a lot of middle aged depressive issues around at the moment.

But, what is affecting the young, well undoubtedly their parents struggles do not go unnoticed, but they have their own problems to contend with, and one of the biggest with the kids of the aforementioned adults I know, is unemployment. Many have degrees and other qualifications up the yinyang, but can they find a job, well, a few are lucky if their parents are in a position to employ or influence employment. But even with the young employment is not an easier existence, for the employed young fall into the same crap the mature have to deal with and because of their youth and stated inexperience, they do not receive good wages thus making their living perhaps harder than that of the elders, for one has to take into account their transportational issues and housing problems, many young people cannot afford car insurance, and of course you know about the housing problem. Many whom I have known to be in employment, have opted for the social benefit existence, because in many cases one can be better off in receipt of benefits, but the benefits lifestyle is no life at all, it destroys the mind, erodes hope and belief paving the way for anarchistic and revolutionary beliefs to take root and ferment, the benefits lifestyle is a thought realignment exercise.

But of these riots, my understanding is the mob who we see smashing, burning and looting is a willing and ready tool, a tool to be used and perhaps discarded, but behind the tool is a tool user, for this does strike me as in many ways organised and not the result of interweb hue and cry, there is political agenda at work here, but what agenda and who is the question. What was that someone said about the fighting nation that is the British, the only time they can stand together as one is in violence.

One thing is apparent from the reports of the riots though, is what is being attacked by the rioters, the locations and the businesses, was this a central intelligence requirement, or was it the feeling in the minds of those at the forefront, if the latter, then this reveals more about the source of the action, a probable palpable class divide. Then there is the police, you know those who enforce government policy, and that, the latter is becoming more apparent as the years go by, for they no longer appear to be interested in protecting the public, all the public, not just those with influence, for as has been reported with these riots, the police have neglected their duty to protect. But why attack the police, well, could that be because the police as governmental policy enforcers are seen as the face of the government on the street ?

Or is it The UK is run like a British War ship of old, Marines protect the officers from the crew ?

Now the government, any government, for they are all the same no matter what party is in power, many whom I know feel disconnected from government to the point where government is seen as a parasite, bleeding the people dry, as one thing is often forgotten, the money they keep telling us about, is the people's money, not the governments, yet that money has been seen to be given to the wealthy whilst the poorer are told to pull in their belts. They say they listen, but in reality they have no idea, and that because what the government is, many of them, political affiliation irrelevant sat in the same classrooms in the same public schools in their youth, therefore they cannot understand what conditions face many stratas in this society, with them I perceive a Mary Antoinette syndrome, aka haven't got a fucking clue beyond what their inexperienced thinking gives them.

I feel what is increasingly at work in the problems of this time is that age old British chestnut ; class divide.


The class divide, may be an age old British chestnut.
But I don't think the youth and many of the disenfranchised, are going to go quietly into the night, as they might have done in days of yore.


I feel sorry for the victims of the rioting, looting and marauding.
I would prefer to see well-organized, ON-GOING, continuous, non-violent protesting,
**Emphasis on well-organized, ON-GOING, and as non-violent as possible.

I was hoping and waiting for you to post.
Thank you for the superb commentary that came from your heart!
Bravo!!
[sm=applause.gif]




tweakabelle -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 8:53:52 PM)

Well done Anerim! Finally we have someone who is looking seriously at the possible causes of the civil unrest in the UK.

I have been saddened by much of the tone of the discussion here. Many people seem happy to assert that the unrest is a consequence of a single cause (eg they're all mindless thugs)) and leave it at that. It seems to me that the causes of the unrest are far more complex than any single cause simplistic analysis can outline.

Riots don't suddenly materialise out of vacuums. They don't fall off the back of a truck. They don't fall from the heavens. They aren't products of divine wrath. They are not initiated by either mindless thugs or anarchists (even though anarchists might like us to think otherwise). Most people are loath to resort to such extreme actions - with good reason. Invariably riots turn out to be the culmination of years of poor social policy, neglect, marginalisation, and oppression. There is usually a trigger (in this case, the police shooting of Duggan) that ignites a fire that has been smouldering for years.

Behind the unrest, it is easy to identify numerous social factors that may have contributed to the riots - poor housing, unemployment, poor education, lack of social integration or prospects for improvement, racism, poor and/or heavy-handed policing, feelings of exclusion from the political process etc.... Nor does it appear that any single group/sector of society is responsible - gangs, alienated youths, political groups such as anarchists, blacks and whites and all colours in between and so on - all seem to have been involved. At this point, the only commonalities seem to be poverty and social marginalisation. Treat people with contempt and they will invariably react contemptuously.

Unless these factors are identified, analysed and policies developed to address them, all the finger pointing, all the blaming, all the hand-wringing exclamations of horror at the anger and violence (which, let me state unequivocally, was mindless - a senseless reaction to events) will be a waste of time and energy. At worst such reactions can exacerbate the underlying problem(s) by leading to repressive policies designed to put down the unrest without addressing its causes.

Modern societies have a tendency to alienate those sections of the population who feel the benefits and gains have (for whatever reasons) bypassed them. Most Western societies seem to have lost the point that people live in societies rather than economies. Until the benefits of 'progress' are distributed more evenly, until we realise that the role of politics and social policy is to ensure all citizens benefit from the advances, then we will continue to create sections of society that feel they have more to gain from the destruction of the prevailing system than in its continuation.




Icarys -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 9:01:26 PM)

Someone wrote something earlier to the tune of " Happy people don't riot". Short and sweet I say.

These types of social situations are peppered ALL through history. Pick up a book or sit down for a second and try an recall what you were taught. I may be one to forget every little detail but I never forget the lesson. Ya know?




Marini -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 9:27:31 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: tweakabelle

Well done Anerim! Finally we have someone who is looking seriously at the possible causes of the civil unrest in the UK.

I have been saddened by much of the tone of the discussion here. Many people seem happy to assert that the unrest is a consequence of a single cause (eg they're all mindless thugs)) and leave it at that. It seems to me that the causes of the unrest are far more complex than any single cause simplistic analysis can outline.

There are a few of us here, that feel as you do tweaky!
[;)]

Riots don't suddenly materialise out of vacuums. They don't fall off the back of a truck. They don't fall from the heavens. They aren't products of divine wrath. They are not initiated by either mindless thugs or anarchists (even though anarchists might like us to think otherwise). Most people are loath to resort to such extreme actions - with good reason. Invariably riots turn out to be the culmination of years of poor social policy, neglect, marginalisation, and oppression. There is usually a trigger (in this case, the police shooting of Duggan) that ignites a fire that has been smouldering for years.

Behind the unrest, it is easy to identify numerous social factors that may have contributed to the riots - poor housing, unemployment, poor education, lack of social integration or prospects for improvement, racism, poor and/or heavy-handed policing, feelings of exclusion from the political process etc.... Nor does it appear that any single group/sector of society is responsible - gangs, alienated youths, political groups such as anarchists, blacks and whites and all colours in between and so on - all seem to have been involved. At this point, the only commonalities seem to be poverty and social marginalisation. Treat people with contempt and they will invariably react contemptuously.

[sm=applause.gif]

Unless these factors are identified, analysed and policies developed to address them, all the finger pointing, all the blaming, all the hand-wringing exclamations of horror at the anger and violence (which, let me state unequivocally, was mindless - a senseless reaction to events) will be a waste of time and energy. At worst such reactions can exacerbate the underlying problem(s) by leading to repressive policies designed to put down the unrest without addressing its causes.

Modern societies have a tendency to alienate those sections of the population who feel the benefits and gains have (for whatever reasons) bypassed them. Most Western societies seem to have lost the point that people live in societies rather than economies. Until the benefits of 'progress' are distributed more evenly, until we realise that the role of politics and social policy is to ensure all citizens benefit from the advances, then we will continue to create sections of society that feel they have more to gain from the destruction of the prevailing system than in its continuation.


Very well written post as usual, tweaky.
We can disagree with the methods being used by the protesters, and agree that they have every
reason to feel marginalized, hopeless, and disenfranchised.




Real0ne -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 9:39:17 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Marini

We can disagree with the methods being used by the protesters, and agree that they have every
reason to feel marginalized, hopeless, and disenfranchised.



If you can figure out how to be disenfranchised here in america let me know because I will put together a packet and sell it because there scads of people where who are trying to be recognized as disenfranchised and cant.

hell who wants that old ruling king/queen shit any more anyway




Marini -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 9:41:36 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Real0ne

quote:

ORIGINAL: Marini

We can disagree with the methods being used by the protesters, and agree that they have every
reason to feel marginalized, hopeless, and disenfranchised.



If you can figure out how to be disenfranchised here in america let me know because I will put together a packet and sell it because there scads of people where who are trying to be recognized as disenfranchised and cant.

hell who wants that old ruling king/queen shit any more anyway



My father asked me something similar tonight.

I don't think the marginalized and disenfranchised in the United States, are just going to sit back, and say "oh well", and accept the status quo, forever.

I do hope methods that include: non-violent, well organized, on-going continuous protests, with plenty of media coverage is used.
The revolution will be televised.




Real0ne -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 9:44:24 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: tweakabelle
Modern societies have a tendency to alienate those sections of the population who feel the benefits and gains have (for whatever reasons) bypassed them. Most Western societies seem to have lost the point that people live in societies rather than economies. Until the benefits of 'progress' are distributed more evenly, until we realise that the role of politics and social policy is to ensure all citizens benefit from the advances, then we will continue to create sections of society that feel they have more to gain from the destruction of the prevailing system than in its continuation.


well call the crown up and tell em you want a refund due to breach of trust. 

The whole asshole lot of them should have their little racket abrogated.




Real0ne -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 9:48:22 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Marini
My father asked me something similar tonight.
I told him the United States is not that far behind.
I don't think the marginalized and disenfranchised in the States, are just going to sit back and say "oh well" forever.
The revolution will be televised.


Being franchised is being "subject to" a sovereign.   unlike the UK ours are only empty names.  At least they have a head to chop off.

It is clear to many people that the government is not for and of the people, it is for and of the guv and that is the problem.

When people would rather live under al capone's protection instead of the gub you know its bad.




ArizonaBossMan -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 9:50:34 PM)

This is what happens when so many are so dependent on government handouts. Plus the failure of multiculturalism.




tweakabelle -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 10:11:29 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ArizonaBossMan

This is what happens when so many are so dependent on government handouts. Plus the failure of multiculturalism.


Such an incisive analysis! Such profound insights! Now why didn't I think of that?

Obviously these two factors are all that require examination and consideration. The handouts gave them the money to buy the matches to ignite the fires. And all those multicultural foreigners couldn't read the "Rioting Prohibited Here" signs. It's as clear as daylight isn't it? Thank you ABM for opening everyone's eyes.

And the obvious solution is to abolish government handouts and multiculturalism. That'll learn those pesky foreigners/rioters! ABM for President I say!

BTW ABM, did I remember to congratulate you for using a 6-syllable word (mul-ti-cul-tur-al-ism)? Isn't this a first for you? I'm so impressed with your progress - clearly, those remedial classes are working for you. Stick at them!

Now that you have mastered spelling it, all you have to do now is understand the concept - but please don't worry that's the easy bit. It just means lots of different people from different backgrounds living together without riotingpeacefully and harmoniously.




Icarys -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/9/2011 10:21:15 PM)

A good riot can be like a healthy diet of greens. It helps a society get regular on those pesky constipated days.




susie -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/10/2011 1:28:39 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: xssve

quote:

ORIGINAL: Sanity


Wasnt the UK a workers paradise

What socialist policies or programs are they lacking

quote:

ORIGINAL: Arpig

I see this as a result of the failure of the capitalist system to effectively provide for the lowest strata of society. The failure to provide all members of society with the means to lead a decent life, is the weakness of the present system, and until it is addressed, these sorts of disturbances will only become more and more common. And more violent.

Birmingham is a steel/manufacturing town, pure working class - clearly, they listened to the neo-cons and following their "milk the middle class dry and let the devil take the hindmost" formula.

You know those guys are all "reformed" socialists, they want capitalism to collapse, there is no other explanation for their economically suicidal policies, I cannot understand how "real Americans" such as yourself can sit there and lap it up, you're a chump baby.

Like Murdoch is "a man of the people", lol - they're laughing at your ignorant ass, all the way to the bank.



Birmingham has never had anything to do with the steel industry. In its history it has been know for manufacturing small arms, being a fine jewellery producer and being the home of Cadbury chocolate.




Aneirin -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/10/2011 2:40:28 AM)

Grrrrrr



Collarchat.com has encountered an error on the page you were looking at.
We're sorry for any inconvenience or loss of work this may have caused you.

You can click here to return to the website.




PeonForHer -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/10/2011 3:04:24 AM)

FR

A solution to football hooliganism, first proposed decades ago, might pertain in the present. Can the Left and the Right come to an agreement? Watch this debate develop.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=04clpd7h0b0

;-)




Aneirin -> RE: Riots continue to spread in UK/ is this a means of protest? (8/10/2011 3:10:53 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Aylee


quote:

ORIGINAL: Aneirin

I don't know where you are in the strata of society, but from my level their is an air of anger, hopeless anger, an air which has been becoming tighter and tighter over the years and seems to be falling on the present government and undoubtedly their austerity and money grabbing policies have accelerated that feeling culminating in, perhaps what we are seeing on the tv these last few days.



And it is this that causes people to /lootsteal plasma tvs? Would it help in the taxpayers bought every person on the dole a plasma tv?



Looting is not a new phenomenom, it has always existed and exists in other layers of society but might be called something else, free enterprise for example, as when those in power mop up after the armed forces have removed opposition in other countries, what is it other than looting a country's wealth ? Because it is the lower elements of society that do much the same as any powerful government, in stealing from the wealthy they are classed as criminals, but are they the lower echelons of society, for anyone can be devoid of morals class is not a decider in this.

As to the riots, it has already been noticed that the last tranche of riots that swept this nation were in the 1980's a time which was under conservative power via Thatcher when I know feeling was high as to the divisions in society as I also was unemployed at the time, (not through not wanting a job or not trying as I remember I was forever writing spec letters to employers in the search for an apprenticeship and had as a result a thick wad of refusals), but because in my area, the area of the Toxteth riots there was 25% unemployment. But myself as a useful and perhaps hopeful alternative to gainful employment I attended a technical college on a full time basis and through Toxteth I had to pass every day and I saw a lot, a lot which did influence a lot of my later political belief, but coming from a middle class background I at the time didn't understand and indeed could see much of what many here are saying, but I suppose one has to live it to understand it, no use commenting from the peripherals where the problems others experience do not touch one's daily lives.

But of the looting I do kind of find it ironic, and ironic in the fact that what is being looted is the present symbols of success, you know those things we as a consumerist society are expected to have via effective marketing. Luxury items, expensive entertainment equipment and designer body wear.

If it were me that was in that position, I would be going for the grub, as it is food that is my hardest commodity to obtain, no point having a plasma tv if your stomach is constantly rumbling, one cannot eat a tv. Also you will notice of the things stolen, business will prosper, as electronics needs power to run it and of course the stolen items will be paid for by all of us via increased insurance premiums. If that is we can afford insurance to protect our property. But perhaps the unaffordability of insurance is part of the problem, as one adopts a loss/obtain mentality and it has been said, we are a throw away society, perhaps what was stolen was out of date/fashion anyway, so is in effect no real loss beyond the time needed to obtain another.

All things that propel business, for in reality the powerful businesses never lose, but set into motion a whole host of other businesses that parasite of each other and ultimately the beleagured man on the street and ergo, the rioter, looter or observer.

If it taken that what we think we become, then society, what it thinks it becomes and from my persepective, it ain' t pretty nor wholesome, we have taken a wrong turn somewhere.




Page: <<   < prev  4 5 [6] 7 8   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.09375