FirmhandKY
Posts: 8948
Joined: 9/21/2004 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: DomKen quote:
ORIGINAL: FirmhandKY quote:
ORIGINAL: DomKen Cain declared Muslims have no right to freedom of religion because their holy writings include rules about how they should live. If this standard was followed would any religion be covered by the First Amendment? Certainly Christianity and Judaism would not. FYI, I saw nothing of this in my research. Perhaps it is there, but I'm more dispose to believe that this claim is the worst possible interpretation by liberals and leftists looking for the scent of "damaged goods" that they always try to fling onto any conservative. This sounds amazing like the first leg of such an attack: that he is "racist". I expect canards to be thrown at any serious conservative. Actually, if I don't see the expected liberal attacks that he is racist, stupid and corrupt, then I'd start to worry about his qualifications. Firm Will the words directly out of his mouth satisfy your skepticism? http://nation.foxnews.com/herman-cain/2011/07/17/herman-cain-islam-combines-church-and-state Cain declared Muslims have no right to freedom of religion because their holy writings include rules about how they should live. Of course, this isn't what he said. He is saying that we need to be aware that - for many Muslims - sharia law is an integral part of the practice of their faith, and that sharia law conflicts with the US Constitution, and we should be aware of this, and take it into account. Witness the increasing acceptance of sharia law in other nations and venues. We should be very careful about uncritically accepting such laws - which conflict with American law - on the basis of religious beliefs. This is a valid issue. Think LDS and polygamy. Think Christian Science and medical care for their children. He doesn't say it very well, granted, and he needs to "expand and qualify his remarks". Unfortunately, just as you and some others take anything said negatively about Islam as "racist", there is likely little that he can say on the subject that won't generate negative headlines in liberal media fellow travelers. I'd recommend to him to simply not say much about it at all, at this point. Firm
_____________________________
Some people are just idiots.
|