|
BamaD -> RE: George Zimmerman Update... (7/21/2012 10:43:57 AM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: igor2003
So suddenly Dee Dee's memory of what happened which was previously sacred truth is dubious when it hurts your conclusion. If this is to be trown out so is everything else she said.
Neither "I can't run" or "I'm not going to run" harms my conclusion in any way. Neither one, said while in hiding from a possible assailant, indicates an intent to attack that assailant, especially when considering that Martin had already run away and hid to AVOID that assailant. Your supposition that he, for some unknown reason after running and hiding to avoid confrontation, then decides to attack that person is ludicrous.
Except of course by saying that on that one phrase Dee Dee must have misunderstood you must then throw out everything she said. Of course both of those fit your position but for you to use what was in the coversation at all you have to take it all, even the part thatblows your position out of the water. You can't logically say this is gospel except for the part where I need for him to say something different which is what you are doing.
So, uh, what happened to that college level reading ability you were bragging about in a different thread? The word I used was "paraphrased", which you changed in order to try to make an arguement to "misunderstood". If you'd like, I can give you a link to a good online dictionary so you can look up the difference for yourself.
The fact of the matter is that "my position" is backed up by statements from both DeeDee AND Zimmerman. But for some reason you aren't willing to disqualify EVERYTHING Zimmerman says when he is a know liar...only DeeDee because you claim she (YOUR word) "misunderstood".
Ok she parphrased you still have to discount every thing she said because who knows what else she paraphased into something that won't fit someones dream scenerio you still just have what she said to work with not what you want her to have said. Now that you mention it hiding is a good way to catch someone to teach them a lesson when you have decided not to run.
College level reading, I have a problem with your kindergarden logic. She didn't say what I wanted her so say so she must have paraphrased sort of garbage. Translation I believe she said whatever she would have had to say to make me right.
|
|
|
|
