Musicmystery
Posts: 30259
Joined: 3/14/2005 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: KenDckey quote:
ORIGINAL: Hillwilliam quote:
ORIGINAL: KenDckey I think that Piscao was on LSD and his art reflected that. Do college profs appreciate my point of view. No. LSD wasn't synthesized until 1938. Most of Picasso's works predate that. I think that ignorant students should have lower grades. So you realize that you are condeming any student that when asked an opinion question and answers it with his personal justification (opinion) that the question should automatically be wrong. Well unless it meets the opinion of others who disagree. Art's value is of personal opinion to determine it's value to that person. Personally I am a realist. I like my art to look like something real. What some of our educators are/were teaching is that if you don't think a certain way that meets our parameters (it doesn't matter what they are) that you are a failure and you should be failed for expressing something counter to our thinking. If asked a real question about content aside, it doesn't matter if you know the subject. BTW I passed the lit class but only because the instructor couldn't justify failing me for having an opinion and probably would have wound up in court if he had. Haven't taken an art class. One of the problems with mankind is our ability to find those with a differing opinion as ignorant, failures, etc and should be subjected to persecution. It goes back into history as far as it was recorded and probably before. Personally, I like others opinions and respect them as such. Doesn't matter to me if they agree or disagree with me. But persecution as I perceive by your statement that I should have failed because my opinion didn't match that of the instructor is just beyond my belief that education should encourage opinion. It is OK to disagree and verbalize against that opinion, but the name calling, foul recommendations, etc should go. At that point we have moved beyond debate over opinion into persecution. I'm not going to dispute that there are abysmal teachers. And it's possible you had some. At the same time, you're displaying disregard and seeming lack of awareness of the differences between matters of opinion and matters of fact, and because of that falling back on "Well, my opinion is" whatever any understanding of what's at work in this art and literature, and hence, no real basis for discussion. NOT the same as like/dislike.
|