RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


heavyblinker -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/8/2016 9:18:01 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDizzyChick

OK, let's try a different tack. let's say I decide to go out topless (perfectly 100% legal here in Canada, though really fucking dumb at this time of year). Now I might well be doing it because it was just a really hot and muggy day, or I might well be doing it to make a political statement. Either way, this would definitely be considered as controversial and provocative by many people.


Yes.

quote:

Now, would the fact that some people do find it controversial and provocative justify them harassing me?


No.

quote:

Should I "expect" that harassment?


Why are you putting "expect" in quotations?

Yes, if you go out topless, you can probably expect a reaction of some kind. I don't know what you can "expect" because I don't know what you mean by "expect" vs. expect. I also don't know what kind of neighborhood you're going to visit or who you'll run into. I don't know if you can expect harassment, but you should probably realize that it could happen. It's up to you to determine what could happen if you do something provocative, and what you will do if someone confronts you about it.

quote:

Should those who harass me be excused because I "should have known" some people would object?


No.

quote:

is it right for anybody to accuse me of being a slut or immoral just because I have sweaty tits?


No.

AND since you're still incapable of separating the reaction from the provocation, let's try a different example.

If a pornstar parachuted into Mosul wearing nothing but whipped cream and an American flag, could she expect to get out alive?
Is it right for her to be tortured and abused by ISIS?

The answer is no.

But exactly what kind of person parachutes into Mosul like that and expects everything to be fine? How stupid do you have to be to not expect something to happen when you do that?? You know what ISIS is capable of, you know that Mosul is overrun, you know that they have extremely conservative views on sexuality... WHY are you provoking them like that unless you're looking for a reaction, probably a bad one?

That is my point... but since I've already made it using similar examples and you completely ignored me, I don't expect you to acknowledge it this time either. You seem adamantly convinced that I support horrible things happening to people who don't deserve it.

The reason I think things like feminism are important is because I recognize that these problems exist. If I didn't think that women couldn't expect to be harassed if they dress a certain way, I would probably be one of those 'mission accomplished, now stop being feminists' people. But there is a difference between defending and acknowledging problems, and there is nothing wrong with accepting that as a society, we're not quite at the point where everyone is basically Vulcan.

Are you just upset that I'm talking about the provoker and not condemning the provokee enough? Is the appropriate reaction here to aggressively defend the provoker and savagely attack and belittle the provokee, declaring myself to be of a superior temperment and them to be disgusting human beings whose worth as a living creature is questionable?




ThatDizzyChick -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/8/2016 10:37:31 PM)

Darling, the US is NOT Mosul, or are you saying that anti-Trump folks are as radical and fucked up as Daesh types?




heavyblinker -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/8/2016 11:17:10 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDizzyChick
Darling, the US is NOT Mosul, or are you saying that anti-Trump folks are as radical and fucked up as Daesh types?


The point has been completely missed AGAIN, probably because you're just looking for things to nitpick and aren't actually processing my argument as a whole.

No, I don't think you can expect the same reaction from Americans as you could from ISIS... but if you are provoking people you can definitely expect a reaction of some kind... depending on who you happen to be provoking. How many times do I have to say this, exactly? It really isn't even that complicated... I am saying that expecting and deserving ARE NOT THE SAME THING.

I am not in any position to say how other people will respond to provocation. I can say how they are LIKELY to respond, but of course I could be wrong. That LIKELIHOOD informs everyone's expectations... it isn't a moral judgment of any kind and it isn't about my personal opinion on what the appropriate reaction to a certain provocation is.

I seriously have to wonder why I even keep responding, because no matter what I say, you're just going to pick some small detail and be obtuse about it while ignoring everything else. This isn't even a real conversation.




ThatDizzyChick -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 12:07:50 AM)

quote:

and aren't actually processing my argument as a whole.

That, my dear, is because I have rejected your argument as being entirely invalid. You're wrong, and since you are apparently impervious to reason on this matter, I have decided not to bother anymore, and so will just poke fun at your sillier remarks.




heavyblinker -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 2:19:04 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDizzyChick
That, my dear, is because I have rejected your argument as being entirely invalid. You're wrong, and since you are apparently impervious to reason on this matter, I have decided not to bother anymore, and so will just poke fun at your sillier remarks.


You haven't actually rejected my argument because you don't understand what I'm saying and it seems pretty obvious now that you never will.




MasterBrentC -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 2:30:59 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDizzyChick

quote:

and aren't actually processing my argument as a whole.

That, my dear, is because I have rejected your argument as being entirely invalid. You're wrong, and since you are apparently impervious to reason on this matter, I have decided not to bother anymore, and so will just poke fun at your sillier remarks.


If you say that his argument is wrong but don't say where he is wrong, then you don't have a leg to stand on. Perhaps you should go back to sucking your pacifier and let the adults talk.




heavyblinker -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 3:09:35 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: igor2003
Well, let's try yet another tack. Let's say you go out in public wearing a t-shirt with a controversial picture or slogan on the front, or you are a woman going out topless. In doing so you KNOW that there are some people that are adamantly for what you are doing or expressing, and you also know that there is approximately 75% of the people that are adamantly against what you are doing or
expressing.


I like that you put it this way, because this is sort of what I have been trying and failing to explain.

If 75% of people are adamantly against what you are doing and expressing, it seems to me there is a greater likelihood that one of those people could harass you than if only 25% of people are against what you are doing or expressing. If you do it despite being conscious of the risks, you're taking a gamble... and the greater the odds against you, the more you could be considered to be 'asking for (the unspecified) it', in which case you should be prepared.




mnottertail -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 7:35:05 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: MasterBrentC


quote:

ORIGINAL: ThatDizzyChick

quote:

and aren't actually processing my argument as a whole.

That, my dear, is because I have rejected your argument as being entirely invalid. You're wrong, and since you are apparently impervious to reason on this matter, I have decided not to bother anymore, and so will just poke fun at your sillier remarks.


If you say that his argument is wrong but don't say where he is wrong, then you don't have a leg to stand on. Perhaps you should go back to sucking your pacifier and let the adults talk.


Then you dont belong in the conversation, if adults are talking.




tamaka -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 7:45:30 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: heavyblinker

quote:

ORIGINAL: igor2003
Well, let's try yet another tack. Let's say you go out in public wearing a t-shirt with a controversial picture or slogan on the front, or you are a woman going out topless. In doing so you KNOW that there are some people that are adamantly for what you are doing or expressing, and you also know that there is approximately 75% of the people that are adamantly against what you are doing or
expressing.


I like that you put it this way, because this is sort of what I have been trying and failing to explain.

If 75% of people are adamantly against what you are doing and expressing, it seems to me there is a greater likelihood that one of those people could harass you than if only 25% of people are against what you are doing or expressing. If you do it despite being conscious of the risks, you're taking a gamble... and the greater the odds against you, the more you could be considered to be 'asking for (the unspecified) it', in which case you should be prepared.


Yes the more people that might not agree with you the higher the probability that someone does not have self- control. Whose problem is that?




tamaka -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 7:47:01 AM)

*




heavyblinker -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 8:13:40 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: tamaka
Yes the more people that might not agree with you the higher the probability that someone does not have self- control. Whose problem is that?


That person's, and potentially yours too if you go out of your way to make it so.
Remember we're talking about provocation here?




tamaka -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 8:21:57 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: heavyblinker

quote:

ORIGINAL: tamaka
Yes the more people that might not agree with you the higher the probability that someone does not have self- control. Whose problem is that?


That person's, and potentially yours too if you go out of your way to make it so.
Remember we're talking about provocation here?


And that right there, to me anyways, is the essence of the debate. Is someone who wears a t- shirt that supports their particular perspective lacking self- control by wearing it out in public.




Musicmystery -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 8:27:07 AM)

~FR~

The inanity of these conversations never ceases to reach new heights.

Self-control means acting purposefully, not merely reacting. That includes thinking through the consequences.

The point of publicizing a provocative view, T-shirt or no, is to provoke. If it got no reaction, then the mission failed.

If it did get a reaction, the next step is conversation--and here's where so many today become children instead of message bearers. The result is name calling, not discussion. It's a cross between a tantrum and masturbation, with a little reckless adrenaline seeking thrown in.

It's an attitude, not a purposeful agenda.

To quote the new hero: Sad.




heavyblinker -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 9:10:54 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: tamaka
And that right there, to me anyways, is the essence of the debate. Is someone who wears a t- shirt that supports their particular perspective lacking self- control by wearing it out in public.


I'm honestly not sure that you could say he isn't.

Calculated provocation isn't quite as explosive as the reaction it could potentially elicit, but it still involves a certain refusal to carefully consider the consequences of your actions.

Sometimes the intended result is to offend, and then revel in the fact that you've unbalanced your political opposites and undermined their credibility.




heavyblinker -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 9:15:04 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Musicmystery
The inanity of these conversations never ceases to reach new heights.


As opposed to all of the newbie-bashing, links to RWNJ blogs and 'liberals are stupid' threads?




WhoreMods -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 9:22:12 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Musicmystery
If it did get a reaction, the next step is conversation--and here's where so many today become children instead of message bearers. The result is name calling, not discussion. It's a cross between a tantrum and masturbation, with a little reckless adrenaline seeking thrown in.

"Mantrum" is a useful term for that sort of petulant spazz out, as it's almost always a guy doing it.




Musicmystery -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 9:25:22 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: heavyblinker

quote:

ORIGINAL: Musicmystery
The inanity of these conversations never ceases to reach new heights.


As opposed to all of the newbie-bashing, links to RWNJ blogs and 'liberals are stupid' threads?

Why are they in opposition? Seems equally inane.




ThatDizzyChick -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 10:58:14 AM)

quote:

If you say that his argument is wrong but don't say where he is wrong

I did, several times, a few pages back
quote:

Perhaps you should go back to sucking your pacifier and let the adults talk.

Go fuck yourself




stef -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/9/2016 2:07:20 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: MasterBrentC

If you say that his argument is wrong but don't say where he is wrong, then you don't have a leg to stand on. Perhaps you should go back to sucking your pacifier and let the adults talk.

You better get back to the day room before they run out of tapioca. You remember how cranky you were the last time that happened?




WhoreMods -> RE: Leftists Bully Trump Supporter Over ‘Racist’ #BuildtheWall Shirt (12/10/2016 4:45:43 AM)

Tapoica or not, it'd difficult to take posts from somebody whose avatar photo looks like a special needs version of Paul O'Grady, isn't it? I keep hearing his posts in Lilly Savage's voice...




Page: <<   < prev  5 6 7 [8] 9   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.0625