Stephann
Posts: 4214
Joined: 12/27/2006 From: Portland, OR Status: offline
|
No offense intended, but I've been using this font well before you joined the forums. My 'bold' isn't an expression of enthusiasm, it's just to make the Georgia font legible. I like when people use distinctive fonts, it's easier to 'see' their voice. Fortunately, we're all free to use whatever font we like I'm just pointing out that YOU don't NEED to WRITE like you're YELLING at ME to GET your POINT ACROSS. ORIGINAL: farglebargle Then why is CONGRESS the body delegated with the authority to declare War? That declaration, and ONLY THAT determines WHO and WHY the military fights. Now there's an interesting legal debate over this particular point. The president is expressly declared Commander in Chief of the Army and Navy. He is the one man with 100% authority and responsibility for the actions of the military. Thus, if the military screws up, it's his head that may roll. As we have seen throughout history, a state of war may exist whether the congress wishes to declare that state to exist, or not. Your suggestion, means that in the event the Papal State attacked, say, Washington DC (that could destroy the capitol, and enough members of Congress in the process to make congressional business impossible) the President would not have the 'legal' authority to mobilize the military for a strike against them. In effect, any country would be free to act with impunity since it would require a congressional act to engage in hostilities. Clearly, this is nonsense. In fact, in Public Law 93-148 (the War Powers Act of 1973) Congress attempted to restrict the powers of the President from waging war, without a declaration of war. Essentially, the President may engage in any sort of military action, so long as congress declares war within 60 days of said actions; to continue to fight would require such a declaration. Ironically, this particular act has been invoked, as well as Public Law 107-243, authorized the President to use force against Iraq. Whether the acts were performed under a 'fraudulent' premise or not, this doesn't negate the legality of the activities, nor is it an effective positive argument that Congress has the power to create such laws in the first place. Fundamentally, the President wages war. Congress declares war. The President could ignore a declaration of war, by simply refusing to send troops. Congress can cut the purse strings on any war, or forcibly remove the President from office if they wish. For any law to have value, it must have teeth; the War Powers acts do not. Votes do. WHERE and WHEN are best left to Staff Officers and below. The Executive *should* set Policy, Joint Chiefs & Generals Strategy, and Units the Tactics. The WHERE and WHEN being the realm of Strategy. Clearly, you've never spoken with many Generals, have you. It won't be Generals who are impeached when a war goes bad. Permitting a system where seven or eight people are given the ultimate responsibility for being 'right' or 'wrong' means nobody will ever be held accountable for mistakes. The real failure isn't in the hands on the President here. The failure is in the will of the American people. Millions of hands in the air, demanding 'justice' or 'answers' or 'retribution' against the evils of the world translate to poor policy decisions. The more we demand our government to 'take care of us' without taking the time to understand who or what we are taking care of, the more trouble we will face. The seeds of ignorance are poverty, disease, and war. Naturally, it must be 'some raghead's' fault though. Naturally, the abuses of these people come at the hands of our 'evil' president. Naturally, the fault is someone other than me. Ed Bundy And get over the whole, "I didn't close your bold-tag" whining. Don't use them in the first place, and you won't have to suffer the indignity of your typography being trashed. p.s. I don't care if you bold the text or not. I care if you use caps to attempt to yell.
_____________________________
Nosce Te Ipsum "The blade itself incites to violence" - Homer Men: Find a Woman here
|