The Issue With Fidelity (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


BlissfulBunny -> The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 4:07:56 PM)

I need advice.  I can't promise I will follow it, or do the right thing or even the smart thing, but I will listen and value it.  Here is my query...

I am married with one young unmentionable.  I have been in the lifestyle for some time, but my husband had not been in it before me.  When my husband and I met I made my needs as a submissive very clear to him and he seemed happy to oblige.  He swore up and down that he was interested and had just never acted on it.  Within a month after we married all activities relating to BDSM had ground to a halt.  Now, several years later, there is still nothing.  Nada.  Zilch.  The only sexual activity that occurs is a five minute bout of the most vanilla, missionary sex you could imagine, and that only happens once every two weeks.  It may sound full of myself, but I'm a very, very attractive woman and can't figure out what's going on.  I've told him how much this bothers me and he doesn't care.  He led me to believe that BDSM would be an ongoing part of our life when he had no real genuine interest in it.  He snagged me, and as soon as he had me he quit the thing that won me.

Bad though all that is, it's not the real conundrum.  I've never had a problem with fidelity.  No one ever struck my fancy enough to do any real damage.  The infatuation would always pass in a day or two.  But there is one man who fires me up in a way that is irresistable.  He's a friend of a friend, and we'll call him "Z" for the sake of ease.  I've had a deep lust for Z for a while now, and I harbor some other feelings for him that scare me terribly.  I'd thought that he might reciprocate those feelings, but was never sure.  Things came to head last night when I went out with a few friends.  I wasn't expecting Z to be there, as I see him irregularly, but he was there and I ended up talking to him and another friend (his roommate) about the problems I was having with my husband.  After Z left the table my other friend confessed to me that Z was crazy about me and would push the issue if he got a chance.  And it also came up that Z is a dominant and very, very interested in me in that capacity as well.  That threw a wrench in the works.  I could contain my feelings when I thought they weren't returned, but it's so much harder now.  There is so much heat between he and I that it's nearly uncontrollable.  If looks could screw I'd have been thrown down on the table and fucked senseless.  And what scares me is that I'd love every damned minute of it.  On one hand, it seems unfair to me to lead a joyless existence needlessly, and on the other I've never been the cheating type.  I never want to be a homewrecker, and having a little unmentionable makes things sticky.  But it's getting more and more difficult to say no.  I don't think I'm strong enough to hold out too much longer, and I can't avoid Z forever.  I really, really want to say yes, and I have no idea what the right thing to do is in this situation.

I need advice.  I'm so confused.




MyNameisMaam -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 4:23:42 PM)

Been there...had a tough heart to heart at home in which we agreed that 1 person isn't really capable of meeting every single need of another...and unmet needs lead to frustration, anger and resentment. Neither one of us wanted to end what we had, but we had to make some changes. Those led to us each "dating" others with full knowledge and permission. He dates vanilla, I have a regular play partner now. When I find a potential play partner, we talk about it - sometimes they meet, sometimes they don't. Home still comes first, and that has stay that way for this arrangement to work, but so far so good - we are 17 years and counting...

Good luck - I hope your conversation leads to wonderful things for both of you! 




FunLuvinNJf -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 4:47:22 PM)

Well, I have been where you are now.. and all I can say is really think about what you are doing.  If you can go into infidelity accepting that you may lose your husband and unmentionable, --- and I mean you  must really be willing to accept their loss ---- if you can do this, than go for it.  If you can't deal with a breakup... then by all means don't do it.  Try to get husband into counseling, introduce mild bdsm during your intimate moments.  You have to be willing to face the worse or it will be a mistake.  And, if you do it and he finds out and agrees to stay, you have to be willing to hear snide comments (esp during arguments) on and off for the rest of the marriage...
Good Luck and really think about what you want..




patina -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 5:01:30 PM)

I have never and probably will never have this problem, but as a family counselor I do have recommendations.  I think that you should talk with your husband about your feelings, let him know how unsatisfied you are.   Put it more on the bdsm though not on his performance.  Pass it off as you know it is not his thing.   Ask him how he would feel about you having a Dom outside the home.  You could say it would not involve sex starting out, but might go into it later.  Or you say yes you would like to have that aspect of it too, you know best how to bring that issue into the discussion. 

Even if no physical sexual contact is allowed there may be other ways you could seek release with Z.  Having the bdsm activities will help in the frustration department.  I hope i have helped with this suggestion.  Good luck in your delima

patina 




adaddysgirl -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 5:04:39 PM)

The problem isn't Z...it's your marriage.  If you can't find a way to be happy there, you'll come across a million Zs over the next 20 years.  If your marriage isn't working, talk to your husband.  Do the right thing, not the wrong one.  And please don't use your child as an excuse to stay with your husband and cheat.  You won't be doing anyone any favors....including the child.
 
Daddysgirl




Focus50 -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 5:21:04 PM)

First off, sounds like your vanilla hubby did some "guy thing" in telling you what you wanted to hear re him being into BDSM.  Yet you say you're a hottie and hubby only wants very occasional sex?  Either his libido is wayyy down or he's getting it somehwere else.  Frankly, I think he's got some "splainin" to do (on both counts) so you should at least start there....  If he dodges the issues, at least you've tried.
 
'Z' is still an unknown quantity - you'll look and feel a real goose if it turns out he's no different to hubby, who you also must've been hot for at some stage.  I believe water always finds its own true level and if 'Z' is all your instincts are telling you, this will eventually resolve
itself. 
 
But be warned!
You sound like you're relating solely to whatever primal dom vibes 'Z' is giving off - the thing
you're not getting at home.  Most people stray outside their relationship because of unmet needs.  You may not be looking at his "bigger picture" and could end up destroying your marriage for a great dom who's generally an unlikeable arsehole once the lust wears off.  And be wary of friends pushing someone else's cause - they rarely finish with the metaphorical bloody nose and battered ego. 
 
Sorry, there's no quick or easy fix to this dilemma.  I'd suggest you take things veryyyyy slowly and have a closer look at 'Z's other attributes and especially any flaws you're undoubtedly ignoring in weighing the pros and cons of any future actions.
 
Focus.




hereyesruponyou -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 6:05:16 PM)

Been there myself, but thankfully it was a second marriage and no kids involved, so after 2 years of thinking about it and 8 months of "I'm going to tell him tomorrow" i ended the relationship. I did try before that to get him more involved in just sex!  He was even uncomfortable getting a blow job. On our anniversary i planned a trip to DC. We did the museums (which he loves), dinners, walks, a Motley Crue concerts with great seats, fantastic hotel room. After 4 days i finally rolled him over and just tried to take HIM and he pushed me away and said he wanted to sleep. Taht was the start of the final 8 months to me leaving.  By the time i got to the "you need to go now" point, i had been to the cardiologist, urologist, internal med guy, gyno and my own dr repeatedly with all kinds of complaints and physical symptoms. They couldn't pin point any cause. Amazingly a month after he moved out all symtoms went away. It was all stress and anxiety.

Personally i kinda "tried" the cheating thing (only online, but very emotional) and realized i couldn't live with myself and do it. I don't judge others about it, i just do the "could i look at my daughter and explain what i am doing and why" thing and it kept me in check.  Don't stay if it makes you completely miserable. I am all for trying counseling and if you can work out the permission from him to have a Master then go for it, but otherwise you have to decide what is best for you and your child. Seeing a miserable relationship with not help the child grow up healthy and well either. Best of luck.




rrsierramist -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 6:19:37 PM)

I think your husband is probably just as unhappy with the sexual side of your marriage as you are. You laid it out for him in the beginning of your marriage when he 'snagged' you and he tried BDSM  in the beginning because he knew that was what would make you happiest.  He tried it....he apparently wasn't comfortable with it...and now it even effects the vanilla side of your intimacy because he is aware that he's not giving you what you want.  And I can tell you from experience....that Z will probably not hang around long even if you and he do connect on some level.  In one way, even through your husband isn't your Dom....you still can't have two Masters.  You can look past the needs you aren't getting and make your husband your priority so that HIS needs are met (it's all a mind game anyway, this D/s stuff)....or you get out.  AND....the grass isn't greener on the other side or all of us subs and Doms would have hooked up by now and this site would be empty.  If you look around carefuly....we are all the same people constantly looking.  Don't become one of us if you can help it.  :)    On the other hand....two people shouldn't be miserable 'just because'. 




gypsygrl -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 6:23:58 PM)

Heh.  Your story sounds alot like my marriage except for the Motley Crue concert.  I never thought about cheating or even ending it, though after it was over, all those mysterious symptoms dissapeared.  When they return every now and again, I know to look around and see whats going on to cause them.

I never thought about cheating, or even leaving.  I never would have done it because of our kids.  Its still something I have a hard time with but I have to deal with it because it is what it is.  He cheated and was the one suggesting the separation/divorce.  I'm happier for it, and in a lot of ways it was the best thing he ever did for me.

To the OP, I would really suggest talking to your husband, with a counselor, if necessary.  You may both decide to end your relationship, you may decide on an open arrangement, or you may decide on a whole bunch of other things.  You may even decide that the best thing is to cheat, but I think the important thing is to talk to him first. 




Devilslilsister -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 6:42:17 PM)

i've been in situations like this........ sort of.......... except i was never married and i didnt have unmentionables.  My answer was always just to leave the one i was with.  Its a short life.

i think it is a dilemna as your husband started things off as being dishonest.  I agree that two wrongs dont make a right, but i think its insane to meet dishonesty with honesty.  You'll only end up with the short end of the stick.  Yet, its never wise to compromise your own morals or beliefs, the end result only ending with you feeling poorly about yourself. 

i would say - discuss the issue, throw down the hammer and force the issue.  Be honest, explain, talk, discuss and then simply tell him "it will be this way".  "i am going to do this"  He can either like it or leave it.  Its a short life.  I think that before you discuss it, you'll need a game plan.  You'll need to carefully work out all the consequences and decide what you can deal with and what you cant.  If he decides to walk - can you deal with it?  If you end up with no one - can you deal with it? 




ArgoGeorgia -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 6:53:37 PM)

I can really relate to you - married, a young unmentionable, etc.  Few differences, my wife and I don't have sex anymore - ever.  She has no desire to at all, doesn't even miss it.  (Yeah, I know doesn't sound like a ringing endorsement of my skills!).  Was never into BDSM so that was never part of the picture.  For the most part, she is completely asexual.  Unfortunately, I'm not, and I feel like I've been lied to.  And I can imagine that you feel the same way. 

How will things work out?  I don't know.  I've been trying and doing everything I can for years now.  While the rest of our relationship is pretty good, the fact that such a major need of mine is not being met has taken its toll. 

Infidelity is an option.  But, it's an option from which there is very rarely a positive return.  Even if Z were 'the one', you have started a relationship on what amounts to a huge lie and the breaking of faith.   

My suggestion, for all it's worth.  Talk to him.  Tell him you are unhappy, you feel deceived (if you do) and that you can't live life like this.  Maybe he will realize what a good thing he has and change his ways.  If not, then it might be time for you to leave the relationship.




BeatMeDaily -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 7:12:55 PM)

I've never one to advocate splitting up and/or divorcing.  But I have been in your exact
situation before and I can tell you, it probably won't get any better.  The compromising scenes
that may arise will again end and be filled with empty feelings.
Not only do you lack what you want and made perfectly clear in the beginning, but even
vanilla sex is lacking.  If they can't make love to you, what's left ?




hereyesruponyou -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 7:19:54 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BeatMeDaily

If they can't make love to you, what's left ?



It's not all about sex in any relationship. When my first husband became will i never had thoughts of infidelity. We had so much more of a relationship that had nothing to do with sex. I kinda figured once he was healthy again the sex would pick back up i guess, but it certainly wasn't a concern of mine. He was my soulmate and a part of me died with him.

It took a long time to even want to try again. I could have lived with the second husband if we had the same level of relationship once the sex life dropped off, but there was so much more missing than that (when your wife gets sent to the cardiologist for a stress test at least ask the results, geeesh).  In that case I was filled daily with feeling more and more alone. It SUCKS to feel alone when someone is lying next to you.




ArgoGeorgia -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 7:36:15 PM)

I agree, it usually isn't just about sex.  I think sex is almost like a thermometer and is indicative of other aspects of the relationship.  But, even though it isn't typically all about sex, it is still very important.  I mean, by law, sex is the one thing you can only get from your spouse.  Everything else you can find other outside sources without infidelity.

And yeah, hereyes, it does suck to be alone when laying next to someone. 




LuckyAlbatross -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 9:13:16 PM)

You've already gotten great advice.  I would only feel very sad if you chose to have offspring in a relationship you knew was not satisfying you (unless you got pregnant in that first mont).

No, you don't have to have a joyless life- and neither does your husband.

But thinking that infidelity will do ANYTHING in the long term towards giving you a fulfilling life is just delusional.  Try to work with your husband on the marriage, or make the decision on your own to end it and start a different life for all three of you, but do the honorable thing and you will ALL be better for it in the end.

To address Focus- he may very well be correct in that the husband is straying as well, but I know that lots of men will accept sexless marriage to avoid dealing with other issues.  There are plenty of outlets other than sex that people find to fill voids in marriages.  It's just as useless but generally less directly destructive to the marriage.




akisha -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 9:28:53 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BlissfulBunny

I need advice.  I can't promise I will follow it, or do the right thing or even the smart thing, but I will listen and value it.  Here is my query...

I am married with one young unmentionable.  I have been in the lifestyle for some time, but my husband had not been in it before me.  When my husband and I met I made my needs as a submissive very clear to him and he seemed happy to oblige.  He swore up and down that he was interested and had just never acted on it.  Within a month after we married all activities relating to BDSM had ground to a halt.  Now, several years later, there is still nothing.  Nada.  Zilch.  The only sexual activity that occurs is a five minute bout of the most vanilla, missionary sex you could imagine, and that only happens once every two weeks.  It may sound full of myself, but I'm a very, very attractive woman and can't figure out what's going on.  I've told him how much this bothers me and he doesn't care.  He led me to believe that BDSM would be an ongoing part of our life when he had no real genuine interest in it.  He snagged me, and as soon as he had me he quit the thing that won me.

<snip>


You just stated my exact marriage experience.

The relationship lasted 5 years almost to the day. Before the wedding he was totally into it and everything then put the ring on and not just the BDSM but the normal sex life came to a halt as well. Marriage lasted 2 years, 8 months. No the sad sex life was not the only reason the marriage failed, but it was a factor.

I don't believe in cheating. If he's agreeable to an open relationship that's different but cheating only gets everyone hurt.

Only you can decide what is the right thing for you to do. No one can tell you what is right or wrong for you.

For me, I




BlissfulBunny -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/24/2007 10:10:53 PM)

A sincere thank you goes to all of you.  Some of you were able to read between the lines to things I didn't even know were going on until I really thought about them.  I'm positive he's not cheating on me.  It's a sincere and bone deep laziness in him that is indicative of most other areas of his life.  I've made him appointments with counselors to no avail.  He just won't go.

I do believe that the best advice is to pitch him an open lifestyle.  I've been in such a confused place (I'm not used to this kind of conflict) that I never thought about losing my little one, mainly because I don't think any sane person would award my husband custody.  But you never know, and his parents are rich and can afford great lawyers.  Could I live without my husband?  Quite possibly.  He's my best friend and I truly love him, but other than that he's basically just a roommate.  I feel warmth toward him, but nothing beyond that.  Could I live without my little one?  Never.  I'd die first.  So it comes down to talking with him about an open relationship or to eventual divorce.  I would love to salvage my marriage if I can.  So I'm going to give it time and try the first.  If it doesn't work I'll resort to the latter.  You all were right, though.  Thoughts of cheating are indicative of problems in other areas.  I was debating leaving him anyway for some serious lack in other places.  I believe he's depressed, but at some point a few years ago after he refused help so many times, it fell out of my hands to deal with.

Another thing that throws a wrench in the works is that I've known Z nearly as long as my husband, so it's a strange situation.

Lucky, just so you know, it was the third month (when I was still holding on to tattered shreds of hope) that I got pregnant.




SusanofO -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/25/2007 12:37:27 AM)

I have been in a very similar situation, and my heart sincerely goes out to you.

I was going to suggest counselling, but since you just mentioned he won't go (my husband went for 2 months and quit), I would go ahead and pitch an open life-style to your husband.

You will of course know best how to phrase and introduce this possibility to him as a solution, since you know him best (how conservative, or open-minded he might be toward it).

I'd emphasize to him that if you engage in this option (an open relationship) you'd be careful about not spreading STD's, and be very discreet for the sake of your child, or whatever parameters you'd think are necessary -in any case, I'd address his concerns one by one, whatever they are. 

Before you bring it up at all, I'd try to envision how you will be working it (an open relationship) also be clear in your mind about how you'll feel if he has another female in his life - because that may happen in the future. If you won't care then, fine. If you might, you can handle your feelings when they come along, I suppose, but be prepared to at least have that happen, possibly. 

I am not "pro" or "con" re: An open relationship  (and in fact, I see an "open relationship" as a way to work within, and possibly save, an otherwise viable marriage. I am just encouraging you to think it over thoroughly before you talk to him, because he will probably have questions, etc.)   

Having been in your shoes (or close to it, and for over 11 years) here is my advice:

**If, when you discuss this w/your husband, he says he "just doesn't understand why you need an open relationship"(insinuating the situation isn't "that bad" or some such nonsense), I am all for the no BS, direct response:

1) *Tell him you're willing to talk about an open relationship OR else "the ball is in his court" to take very noticeable and immediate steps to improve your sex life, as you are done knocking yourself out, and being taken for granted in this arena for nothing. Explain in no uncertain terms, just how devastating this is to you emotionally, and how tempting it is for you to cheat on him, due to his own neglect. If this doesn't bother him, it should.

2) Inquire politely if he may have some medical issue that makes sex difficult for him (and if he thinks he might have one, then IMO, it is upon him to see a doctor - not for you to have to beg him to see one, or drag him there. I'd make that clear as well).

Don't get too caught up in being overly nice when you have this discussion with him, simply because you feel  he's "such an otherwise nice guy". I'd be polite, but frankly - he is a married, an adult, and a father. This is up to him to fix, and you've certainly done your part. I'd make that clear, and I'd not veer from it.

Yes, maybe he needs to see a doctor for some anti-depressant meds. I'd be basically kind, but I'd still be very firm re: Your expectations here. If he is, he needs to see a doctor, and it's up to him to make the papointment and to keep it, and to keep any follow-up appointments. Your situation sounds a lot like mine, and I was way too "understanding" for years, and things did not improve. In fact, they got worse.        

3) *Let him know if neither of these two options above appeal to him, you will have your attorney contact him re: Further developments concerning your "relationship" (or lack thereof).

4) *Then I would pack my bags and leave for a week or two (see if you can stay w/ a friend, or a distant relative who can keep their mouth shut re: All this (all you need is relatives hounding you about your personal business), or at a hotel or motel) to consider your next move - and also to let him know you are deadly serious that you have zero intention of putting up with this situation for years on end.

IMO - If he appears to not take your concerns seriously, and has no  "plan of action" to address them - he needs an effective wake up call, and leaving for a week or two might do the trick. He can watch your child (and also will find out what things would really be like if you left, for good, then, regardless of that not probably happening re: You leaving your child).

He needs a good scare, frankly, and if he has working brain cells, and any sense of reponsibility, he is an adult, and is capable of arranging for a sitter while he is at work - what would he do if you died, for example?  I'd not let that concerns about a grwon adult's ability to mcare for his own child stop me from leaving for a week or two, if I found it necessary to make it clear just how painful this situation has become to you - the future of your marriage depends on it, very possibly, IMO. 

I am not at all suggesting you'd  actually leave your child for good - I am saying he may need a serious wake up call if he just "poo-poohs" your concerns (which is what he's done so far, apparently). He is capable of child care (or at least figuring out how to get that done, for a week or two, I'd think. He'll have to do it too, if you are not there - won't he?)

*Do not take your child with you and just disappear, or he could have you arrrested for kidnapping.    

I put up with a similar situation way, way too long (minus the child) -for years, in fact - it tore me apart, and deadened me inside, as far as thinking of myself as appealing, or appreciated (even though that wasn't true). Sex isn't the be-all, end-all of a relationship, but he is just plain ignoring your needs. Make it clear that is very hurtful to you, and furthermore, it is not something you intend to put up with, especially with no viable solution in sight.   

The fact is, he is choosing out of simple laziness to ignore a very basic need of yours. Sexual abandonment of a partner is still grounds for divorce in many states (meaning no sexual contact w/ a marital partner, for 2 years or longer (usually, although the length of time depends on the state).   

**IMO, these responses on your part will either get him thinking there are serious aspects re: Your relationship that need definite improvement, and he will start paying attention to in proving what he can.

Or he will ignore what you are doing, basically, and you will just do what you want (a somewhat open relationship), while still remaining married, or - (worst case) you'll do what you want inside your marriage anyway, regardless of whether he "approves" or not -  and he will seek a divorce (which, IMO, might not be a bad thing, but you decide).

I know it must be a big challenge sweetie, but you are very sensibly asking for advice, and my heart goes out to you. Good luck, and I'll say a prayer for you.

- Susan




KatyLied -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/25/2007 3:25:45 AM)

You need to be aware that if you leave the marital home and your um for a few weeks you should only do after seeking legal advice as it could affect physical custody of the um in the future.  A move like that can be seen as abandonment of both your husband and your um.  I would tread carefully on that suggestion.




Focus50 -> RE: The Issue With Fidelity (3/25/2007 3:50:26 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LuckyAlbatross

To address Focus- he may very well be correct in that the husband is straying as well, but I know that lots of men will accept sexless marriage to avoid dealing with other issues.  There are plenty of outlets other than sex that people find to fill voids in marriages.  It's just as useless but generally less directly destructive to the marriage.

"Sexless marriage", ay?  Several have stated something similar and I've found it rather enlightening.  But you get zilch for now guessing which 52yo Aussie Dom has NEVER been married.... lol
 
Focus. 




Page: [1] 2 3   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875