ObedientYYC
Posts: 80
Joined: 8/25/2006 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: SweetDommes quote:
ORIGINAL: ObedientYYC quote:
ORIGINAL: SweetDommes So, by your theory, there should be no societies where the woman was the hunter and the man was the gatherer ... oh, wait, there are a lot of those out there, in history, and today. Guess that blows your theory. I think that most people's temperments are molded by what they are exposed to - so the stereotypes persist because people expect them to. My, um, "theory" made no reference to nature or nurture. I also never said that ALL women like to do ALL traditional feminine things. It seems people just read what they want to read because they apparently WANT to be offended. Sheesh. So ... when in Rome... I will now clarify my position. All women are biologically programmed to bake cookies, dust furniture, and be Stepford wives. Thank you. Technically, you are correct - you did not flat out say anything about nature vs. nurture. However, you DID state that you think stereotypes are stereotypes because men and women naturally orient one way or the other ... if that were true, then there would be no societies that go against what the "modern" world considers the norm - there are exceptions in every society, but a society as a whole would not be able to go completely at odds with natural delineations ... thus there cannot be "natural" delineations in either direction. I think you're stretching a little :) I was only making comments in regards to the only society that is relevant to my personal life - our western society. Ie. that men and woman do tend to generally orient certain ways within our society, that we see as masculine or feminine. I don't normally make conversation within the context of a broader abstract anthropological point of view, since people would probably think I was even geekier than I already am!
|