RE: What is it? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


TracyTaken -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 6:37:05 AM)

quote:

most ppl that fall into that victim status were abused as kids plain and simple.


Yes, and often that is the status they seek to maintain.  A victim may say "This time, it's going to be different, and all of my wounds will be healed because he'll see how mean is to me and he'll be so sorry and love me forever and I will have my happy ending..." right before she jumps headlong into *another* abusive relationship.  There is not much that can be done for a perpetual victim unless she sees how she makes her own victimization possible.

Edited to add:  I am not being unkind.  We can't rid the planet of abusers, so there's only one other way to go.





TysGalilah -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 6:49:23 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DisenchantedLife

I've been thinking a lot lately about relationships, specifically how others end up in bad relationships, specifically abusive relationships.  What is it about some girls (or guys) that allow those fuckers in their lives?  Why do they take the shit?  Why don't they stand up and demand better?  Is it some pathological need (which it surely can't be, cos it needs to be a "fixable" answer)? Is it low self esteem?  Lack of confidence?  Because I know not every woman in the world is in an abusive relationship.  I also know there are tons of those fuckers out there - so its not that there is a lack of fuckers for women to fall prey too.  So if not every woman in the world is in one, and some have never been in one.. than they have something in them that prevents falling into an abusive relationship.  Is it confidence?  Confidence to expect better?  Expect more?  Confidence to know the difference?  To expect to be treated a certian way and when that way isn't there, they just ditch the fucker? 

I also know that those fuckers look, even if subconsciously for that type of girl.  The ones they know they can snag and ensare, that will take their shit, take their abuse, and not kick them to the curb.  What do they look for?  Stupidity?  Low self esteem? Some need that, needs to be fullfilled, and as long as that need is there and is being fullfilled, they'll take the shit?  Is it lack of confidence and need?

Basically..... what is it?  What allows this stuff to happen?


it is my belief that the level of health and happiness in the relationships we find and make , will be alligned with the amt and level of emotional health and balance one has found/developed for themselves.

healthy attracts and finds healthy
unhealthy attracts and finds unhealthy.

its just easier to point the finger of blame outward, than it is to look inward to find our answers to unhappiness and abuse.

it has been said>
we teach people how to treat us.

::putting on flame-retardant suit now ::








eyesopened -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 6:52:24 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: TracyTaken

quote:

victim=never at fault...victim=the one being abused...victims that cant stop or do not want to stop the abuse...have reasons (and many other reasons) like i mentioned above to not able to stop.
it is still never their fault.


The problem with that is if a victim cannot (or will not) see the part she played in getting into and maintaining an abusive relationship, nothing ever changes for her.



Abuse, like rape, is a robbery.  It robs one of the very attributes that would get a person out of the abuse.  When there is no physical violence, its almost impossible to see the abuse until the robbery is complete.

i suppose a mugging victim should have stayed home, not carried a wallet, wore less expensive clothing, and should see the role they played in being robbed in the first place.




Sundowner -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 7:07:54 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BlackPhx

...

Here is the education list from National Domestic Violence Hotline 
...



The line is so fine it's hard to see sometimes - I so love most of the things on the lists! And so do my sub partners.

For me, the difference is ..... "caring"? I'm not happy playing unless I'm pretty convinced the sub really enjoys whatever goes on. No enjoyment from her, turn-off for me.

Makes me a bit of an iffy dom, but sure makes me not an abuser.




StormsSlave -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 7:13:47 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: BlackPhx

Then here is the rest of the story. WIITWD is a hairsbreath in many cases from the warning signs of Abuse. That we enter into it consentualy and happily does not change that fact. That BDSM relationships can turn abusive is also a possibilty. One I have lived. As I have said before, what he did to me, I asked for, my kids didn't, when he began to abuse the kids I got out. It wasn't easy, it was extremely dangerous for me and the kids and twice he tried to break into the apartment I got after leaving, Once with a threat to kidnap the kids while I was at work and a babysitter was with them, the second time, dislocated my jaw and broke several bones.

Here is the education list from National Domestic Violence Hotline Pay particular attention to the section on A Sexual Abusive Relationship and please tell me it does not contain all the things many of us do on a regular basis.
What is Domestic Violence?
Domestic violence can be defined as a pattern of behavior in any relationship that is used to gain or maintain power and control over an intimate partner.
Abuse is physical, sexual, emotional, economic or psychological actions or threats of actions that influence another person. This includes any behaviors that frighten, intimidate, terrorize, manipulate, hurt, humiliate, blame, injure or wound someone.
Domestic violence can happen to anyone of any race, age, sexual orientation, religion or gender. It can happen to couples who are married, living together or who are dating. Domestic violence affects people of all socioeconomic backgrounds and education levels.

You may be in an emotionally abusive relationship if your partner:
  • Calls you names, insults you or continually criticizes you.
  • Does not trust you and acts jealous or possessive.
  • Tries to isolate you from family or friends.
  • Monitors where you go, who you call and who you spend time with.
  • Does not want you to work.
  • Controls finances or refuses to share money.
  • Punishes you by withholding affection.
  • Expects you to ask permission.
  • Threatens to hurt you, the children, your family or your pets.
  • Humiliates you in any way.

You may be in a physically abusive relationship if your partner has ever:
  • Damaged property when angry (thrown objects, punched walls, kicked doors, etc.).
  • Pushed, slapped, bitten, kicked or choked you.
  • Abandoned you in a dangerous or unfamiliar place.
  • Scared you by driving recklessly.
  • Used a weapon to threaten or hurt you.
  • Forced you to leave your home.
  • Trapped you in your home or kept you from leaving.
  • Prevented you from calling police or seeking medical attention.
  • Hurt your children.
  • Used physical force in sexual situations.

You may be in a sexually abusive relationship if your partner:
  • Views women as objects and believes in rigid gender roles.
  • Accuses you of cheating or is often jealous of your outside relationships.
  • Wants you to dress in a sexual way.
  • Insults you in sexual ways or calls you sexual names.
  • Has ever forced or manipulated you into to having sex or performing sexual acts.
  • Held you down during sex.
  • Demanded sex when you were sick, tired or after beating you.
  • Hurt you with weapons or objects during sex.
  • Involved other people in sexual activities with you.
  • Ignored your feelings regarding sex.


poenkitten (been there, done that, wrote the t-shirt that went to Washington)


Here is the dividing factor between BDSM and sexual abuse, imho.




Leatherist -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 7:15:32 AM)

It doesn't always start out to badly. Sociopaths are very charming and manipulative. The masks don't come off until much later on. That does not neccesarily mean the victim is stupid, only that they were duped.




GreedyTop -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 7:28:18 AM)

poenkitten.... awesome poem....




TracyTaken -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 7:42:46 AM)

quote:

Abuse, like rape, is a robbery. It robs one of the very attributes that would get a person out of the abuse. When there is no physical violence, its almost impossible to see the abuse until the robbery is complete.


What exactly does that looking like in domestic violence?  When is it "complete"?  When somebody leaves?

quote:

i suppose a mugging victim should have stayed home, not carried a wallet, wore less expensive clothing, and should see the role they played in being robbed in the first place.


Don't reduce to utter bullshit please, and do not try to make me out to be a bad guy.  I'm sure I've filed more motions for restraining orders for people than you are years old.  I suppose I see a big difference between being the victim of a one time act of random criminality and intentionally staying in an abusive relationship, which does take intention, and work, and keeping lots of secrets, and acting as if, etc.  It also requires something in the one abused that if not addressed, will not change.




angelic -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 7:48:30 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Leatherist

It doesn't always start out to badly. Sociopaths are very charming and manipulative. The masks don't come off until much later on. That does not neccesarily mean the victim is stupid, only that they were duped.


Yes, and in my case, by the time i realized what was happening it was too late. 

My personal situation is similar to Owned's, except he was not my husband.  However, I made him my God.  At one point that was how I was to address him... as my God.  I did not know (and still am not 100% convinced myself) that I was in an abusive relationship, but it was an ugly, ugly relationship that lasted almost 5 years.

Many folks here relate to being abused as a child.  I wasn't except for a couple of incidents with a dentist when I was very young.  However, I now carry the scar of a cigarette burn, it is not a big ugly scar, but one put there by the x.  If it had been a loving relationship, I would carry that scar like a Red Badge of Courage, but it was not.  I stayed in this relationship for 5 years, I consented.  I could have left and did not.  Lord knows, he was constantly and forever telling me to move on.  Releasing me and then telling me he would never let me go.

I could put the blame 100% on him, but the bottom line is, I was 40 years old at the time and f****g knew better.  Yet, it happened nonetheless. 




eyesopened -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 7:56:36 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: TracyTaken

quote:

Abuse, like rape, is a robbery. It robs one of the very attributes that would get a person out of the abuse. When there is no physical violence, its almost impossible to see the abuse until the robbery is complete.


What exactly does that looking like in domestic violence?  When is it "complete"?  When somebody leaves?

quote:

i suppose a mugging victim should have stayed home, not carried a wallet, wore less expensive clothing, and should see the role they played in being robbed in the first place.


Don't reduce to utter bullshit please, and do not try to make me out to be a bad guy.  I'm sure I've filed more motions for restraining orders for people than you are years old.  I suppose I see a big difference between being the victim of a one time act of random criminality and intentionally staying in an abusive relationship, which does take intention, and work, and keeping lots of secrets, and acting as if, etc.  It also requires something in the one abused that if not addressed, will not change.


To me it is "complete" when there is nothing left for the robber to steal.  Not all abusive relationships are physical and often they don't turn physical until the mental abuse has already robbed the victim of the means to fully understand how to escape.  So you've filed over 55 motions for restraining orders.  Good for you.  Keep calling these people stupid and for being responsible for their own abuse.   But understand that not all abuse is obvious and that not all victims are intentionally working toward continuing the abuse.  The one thing it takes is a good, strong friend to understand, to not be quick to judge, to try to walk a mile in their shoes.  And the ability to teach forgiveness.




TysGalilah -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 8:02:11 AM)

I wanted to add something to my previous post:
I was referring to relationships we choose to be in.

And was not referring to being victims of crime and psycopaths that attack and harm.  I don't feel "those" people we attract or find due to our level of emotional health..

Just wanted to clarify that, since the thread seemed to take a turn talking about random sexual abuse, rape and predators.






StormsSlave -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 8:27:19 AM)

I'm sure the only thing that drew my person lunatic to me was the fact that:
A) I had good credit, which I now don't.
B) I was willing to give him the time of day.

These days, I find I'm a lot less willing to give people the time of day.  Lesson learned.




DesFIP -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 8:35:34 AM)

Family of origin stuff, almost always.

See if you come from a family where the male role model is emotionally absent, or physically absent, then you go looking for someone who will love you in the same way, by not being there for you. And you feel that if your own male parent couldn't love you, then you don't deserve love. And you prove it by finding someone who also doesn't love you. At the same time, you're so desperate for love that you take any connection believing that is love. Better bad breath than no breath at all.

Plus in people who have cravings for pain, it's easy to accept poor treatment because it appears to be satisfying the pain drive. Unfortunately it does so in a way without consent and in a bad way.

It takes a lot of self knowledge and usually some professional help to get it all straightened out. And in this world or the vanilla, there are a lot of people, male and female, who never do get it straightened out. BTW, if you suffer from sexual abuse at a tender age, especially repeated and from those who ought to be protecting you, long term treatment with others who also suffered is necessary if you want to ever get your life together.




StormsSlave -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 8:40:36 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DesFIP

Family of origin stuff, almost always.

See if you come from a family where the male role model is emotionally absent, or physically absent, then you go looking for someone who will love you in the same way, by not being there for you. And you feel that if your own male parent couldn't love you, then you don't deserve love. And you prove it by finding someone who also doesn't love you. At the same time, you're so desperate for love that you take any connection believing that is love. Better bad breath than no breath at all.

Plus in people who have cravings for pain, it's easy to accept poor treatment because it appears to be satisfying the pain drive. Unfortunately it does so in a way without consent and in a bad way.

It takes a lot of self knowledge and usually some professional help to get it all straightened out. And in this world or the vanilla, there are a lot of people, male and female, who never do get it straightened out. BTW, if you suffer from sexual abuse at a tender age, especially repeated and from those who ought to be protecting you, long term treatment with others who also suffered is necessary if you want to ever get your life together.


Nope.  My father, brothers, and uncles were incredibly involved in my life, and I can't remember a single time ever in my childhood when I didn't feel loved and needed, wanted and cared for.  It wasn't perfect, we struggled, but we did love. 

The man didn't make me feel anymore loved.  The closest anyone has hit on the truth here is in the sociopath description.  Everyone loved him, everyone thought he was wonderful.  People told me how lucky I was to have such a wonderful husband.  He presented himself to me the same way, had recently lost about 60 lbs, said he had money in the bank to contribute to financial goals, etc. etc. etc. 

There's no stereotype you can shove an abused person into.  We don't fit into pigeonholes.  We come from every walk of life, every race, both genders, every religion. 




ownedgirlie -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 9:04:02 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: TysGalilah
it is my belief that the level of health and happiness in the relationships we find and make , will be alligned with the amt and level of emotional health and balance one has found/developed for themselves.

healthy attracts and finds healthy
unhealthy attracts and finds unhealthy.

its just easier to point the finger of blame outward, than it is to look inward to find our answers to unhappiness and abuse.

it has been said>
we teach people how to treat us.

::putting on flame-retardant suit now ::


No need for the suit - I agree with everything you have said, but it took awhile for me to reach that point in my life.  My therapist used to tell me I needed to take my share of responsibility for what happened.  This always made me so angry.  One day I read an excerpt from Don Miguel Ruiz's "The Mastery of Love" and I went into therapy and cried, asking, "Why did I let him treat me this way?"  and then, "How am I ever going to be able to forgive myself for that?" 

The excerpt I read was that we allow ourselves to be treated the way we think we deserve to be treated (totally paraphrased) and once I realized that, I realized that was the responsibility I needed to take for the abuse that occurred.  Only then could I begin to heal from it.


quote:

ORIGINAL: angelic

I stayed in this relationship for 5 years, I consented.  I could have left and did not. 



This is precisely why I don't agree with the premise of defining abuse by saying "When it's not consentual."  Abuse sufferers almost always consent to their abuse.  That's why it continues.  By remaining in such relationships, they are saying it is OK for the abuser to treat them that way, even if they hate it.  This is why I believe, in many cases, lack of self worth and/or self esteem is involved.  Until one comes to feel strongly that no, it is NOT OK to be treated that way, therefore rescinding consent, and takes action on it, the abuse will continue.

I like to share this link when I can as it helped me heal and helped me to realize I was not mentally ill like he had convinced me I was:  www.youarenotcrazy.com.  

As for the sociopath, they are like sharks who feed off of their "victim's" reactions.  My ex used to upset me to the point of hysteria, and then he'd offer a loving hand and bring me back to calmness, thus being the rescuer and hero.  It was an awful, unhealthy pattern, but it worked for him every time.  Once the abused is hysterical there are no more rational or logical thoughts and feelings - he/she is out of control and will accept any means to come back to calmness again.    Or, he would make me happy and make me laugh, thus illustrating what a good and fun guy he actually was, and I must have been misunderstanding him all this time.  Getting a reaction is a way of maintaining control.  It was interesting, the first legal meeting I sat through with the ex - it was just last month, and it was the first time I had seen him in a year.  He pulled no punches in attempting to push my buttons and I gave no reaction at all, just shrugged him off.  I watched him fall apart before my eyes as a result.  He saw he had lost his control over me and our situation, and hadn't a clue what to do.  Once he crumbled, I raised my head and demanded those things from him which I deserved.  I got some of them...I'm working on the rest.  [;)]




GreedyTop -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 9:13:23 AM)

Wow...owned... thanks for the link...




faerytattoodgirl -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 9:15:51 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: eyesopened

quote:

ORIGINAL: TracyTaken

quote:

victim=never at fault...victim=the one being abused...victims that cant stop or do not want to stop the abuse...have reasons (and many other reasons) like i mentioned above to not able to stop.
it is still never their fault.


The problem with that is if a victim cannot (or will not) see the part she played in getting into and maintaining an abusive relationship, nothing ever changes for her.



Abuse, like rape, is a robbery.  It robs one of the very attributes that would get a person out of the abuse.  When there is no physical violence, its almost impossible to see the abuse until the robbery is complete.

i suppose a mugging victim should have stayed home, not carried a wallet, wore less expensive clothing, and should see the role they played in being robbed in the first place.


yes and its the persons fault who was raped because she's too pretty and went out alone at night not knowing someone was waiting for her to jump her and poof it all begins.  the victim is innocent. 

should the victim go to jail then if they are at fault? and the abuser goes free?while the victim is traumatized for life...and the abuser is just laughing and goes off to do another one.


nobody just let's things happen.  they just dont have control over what is happening and cant stop it from happening.




ownedgirlie -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 9:17:28 AM)

My pleasure.  It took a LOT of hard work to recover and more forward.  I am happy to share knowledge and information to help others. 




ownedgirlie -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 9:20:12 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: faerytattoodgirl
yes and its the persons fault who was raped because she's too pretty and went out alone at night not knowing someone was waiting for her to jump her and poof it all begins.  the victim is innocent. 

should the victim go to jail then if they are at fault? and the abuser goes free?while the victim is traumatized for life...and the abuser is just laughing and goes off to do another one.


nobody just let's things happen.  they just dont have control over what is happening and cant stop it from happening.



All due respect but rape by a stranger is not the same as remaining in an abusive relationship over the course of years.  The OP is not about voilent crime against strangers; it is about abusive long term relationships.  And in such cases, as long as the abusee remains in the relationship, he/she is consenting to the abuse.




faerytattoodgirl -> RE: What is it? (2/24/2008 9:21:55 AM)

my point of that post is that the victim is never at fault and i was pointing out a scnario.





Page: <<   < prev  1 2 [3] 4 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.0625