Aswad -> RE: National Sex Offender Registry! (3/7/2008 7:49:34 AM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: kittinSol I feel ambivalent about such registries. I'm not the least bit ambivalent. They're an abomination. quote:
On the one hand, it's reassuring to know who the offenders are and where they live; but on the other hand... what do I do with the information? Well, to put it quite simply: there's only one purpose to it- to circumvent the presumption of innocence. I think it would be interesting to see some statistics on sex offenses committed before and after the list was published, not to mention recidivism rates. I mean, it's a standing invitation to be lynched, and takes away a lot of the incentive for staying on the mat. Might as well go all the way by branding them criminals (Mark of Cain?) and be done with it. That would at least avoid those cases where people end up on the list by accident (getting back off, even when you can document that you're not supposed to be on it, is a long uphill battle) and the cases where lynch mobs get the address off by one digit, etc. quote:
I'm not going to lynchmob these people and make myself a criminal. Is that the only reason you're not going to lynch them? quote:
When I looked at the local registry I freaked out a little bit: here are the names, mugshots and biodata of these people (a few are women - one slept with a sixteen year old boy, and she was twenty-one; I thought it was a bit much she figured with rapists and other violent criminals, but anyway).... I can't decide whether it's reassuring to know all this. Great. So now the list has put a little bit of fear into your heart as well, compounding the original offense. Consider for a moment that this is just breaking your illusions, not actually changing anything (I'd recommend checking out the book "Beyond Fear" by Bruce Schneier, by the way; it deals, in layman's terms, with how to think about such things). After all, 3% of Danish men have been convicted of rape by my age. Presumably, that adds up to about 8-9% being convicted in their lifetime. Which doesn't take into account those that are not convicted (it's still hard to get a conviction, since few women secure any evidence). Nor does it take into account the higher baseline crime rates in the US, or the order-of-magnitude higher recidivism rates. Or the women, for that matter. You are not safe. You never were. You never will be. You can deal with it by learning how to be safer, or by sticking your head in the sand; this list helps with neither. Health, al-Aswad.
|
|
|
|