RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


StormsSlave -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 4:11:35 PM)

I think it's pretty ballsy for some "dom" to stand outside a relationship and judge the people in it.  Did you tell him to go fuck himself, Blushes?

In my heart, submission to My Lord is simple: give myself over to the relationship honestly, sincerely, and wholeheartedley.  Sometimes it's sexual, sometimes it's emotional, and sometimes it's physical.  Often, it's a struggle.  Sometimes shutting my mouth and doing as I'm told without further discussion is my submission.  Sometimes speaking up is my submission, since my prime directive is to protect our relationship, even against ourselves.

The ACT of submission changes almost daily, depending on our circumstances, the situation, and the need of the time time.  The HEART of my submission to him never changes.

I don't get off, in any way, on the ACT of submitting.  I submit to My Lord because he is the one man, of all the men I've ever been with, who is deserving of my trust in doing so.  What anyone else in the world thinks of that--shrug--not my problem.




slavegirljoy -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 4:27:08 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ExSteelAgain

Joy, MADE was in caps italics for a reason. [;)]

Sorry.....i should have caught-on to that. [;)]   Of course, a lot of people like being MADE to do things (that they wouldn't "normally" do.)  i understand that.  It's very exciting to feel like you are being forced to do things for your partner, even if you don't really have to be forced.  It's exciting to feel that power being used, even though it's not necessary.
 
joy
Owned servant of Master David




NuevaVida -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 4:35:34 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: slavegirljoy

quote:

ORIGINAL: ExSteelAgain

Joy, MADE was in caps italics for a reason. [;)]

Sorry.....i should have caught-on to that. [;)]   Of course, a lot of people like being MADE to do things (that they wouldn't "normally" do.)  i understand that.  It's very exciting to feel like you are being forced to do things for your partner, even if you don't really have to be forced.  It's exciting to feel that power being used, even though it's not necessary.
 
joy
Owned servant of Master David


I kind of just overlooked "MADE" for that reason. "Made" was never really an issue with me, either. But being required to do things that were...um...less than pleasant gave me a great deal of fulfillment. I never much understood the idea of being forced, only because it never applied to me.




MadRabbit -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 4:40:34 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Darcyandthedark

quote:

ORIGINAL: MadRabbit

I don't find unenjoyable or enjoyable acts to be more or less submissive than the other. Both are forms of expression only. But if my will being carried out is based solely on the contigency of it being something they "want" to do, then, in my opinion, what is being expressed isn't submission.


You really only want your property to do shit that she doesn't like, to prove submission, to make your dominance feel worthwhile?
Maybe I am fortunate.  I do not have to prove my submission by doing only things I loathe for Darcy.  I simply submit to his will.

 
Nope, not at all. Those are words you put in my mouth and bare no resemblance to anything I said in the above quote.
 
Simply put, we can define submission as "obeying one's will", but I find it highly unrealistic to think that I am never going to have to give a command that falls into the category of being unenjoyable or defined as something they don't want to do.
 
When faced with such a dilemma, what I should do? Alter my will and reform it as such that it is something "enjoyable" or something they "want" to do? I don't find any enjoyment in that kind of "dominance".
 
Pragmatically and realistically, at times, I will have to alter my will. The well being of my partner means a lot to me and there is going to be things that are hard for them, they are afraid of, uncomfortable with, or just flat out incapable of doing for a variety of different reasons. Some things are too important or too great that I can't change without severe consequences and that's something I will have to either mold to or break the deal over. That's just the reality of being a good leader and making good decisions.
 
But still, given that self gratification is part of my nature and that I have expectations that will be met, there will be plenty of times when they are going to have to do something for me they might not "enjoy" or "want" to do.
 
As such, I consider a willingness to do things that one does not want to do to fulfill the will of their partner to be essential to "submission". Maybe not in a perfectly logical sense, but certainly in a pragmatic one. Is it possible that I will find a partner who is perfectly compatible to me in every way? Sure, it's possible, but I am not holding out. And even if I were, given the fact that we are both constantly changing entities in flux, I doubt we could stay 100% compatible forever.
 
It has nothing to do with "making them do things they don't like to prove themselves to me." That "intention" and "motivation" has to be there to be willing to put my "will" over theirs. I've met quite a few girls who made it clear in the beginning that they were willing to follow my rule as long as it didn't inconvenience them, discomfort them, or pain them in anyway. I wish them luck in finding someone who enjoys that kind of submission, but it's not for me!

Maybe your one of those people who thinks that a submissive should never ever have to annoy, inconvenience, discomfort, or pain themselves for the will of their Owner. If that's the case, I welcome you to your definition, but it's not mine. I won't mock yours if you don't mock mine, cool?
 
With all that said, I do happen to enjoy making my girl endue suffering and hardship solely for my will. It has nothing to do with "proving", but rather I find the experience to be a very powerful expression and find it very poignant when someone is willing to endure something to please me. Of course, there is always that possibility I might meet a girl who finds nothing I do to her painful or hard and that would be quite a bummer. I would be robbed of an enjoyable sadistic kink, but as long as the intention is there, I could be happy.
 
Of course, just because I find value in that kind of expression doesn't mean I can't appreciate and enjoy them simply buying me an ice cream cone.[:D]





WarriorsGirl -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 7:08:13 PM)

Would I consider washing the dishes when I don't feel like it to be submissive?  Well, I would say it depends. 

If I get up off the couch all by myself and wash the dishes because they need to be done, then I get to pat myself on the back for being mature and responsible and getting over my laziness. 

If I get up off the couch and wash the dishes because he tells me to, then I get to feel myself go through this giant range of emotions (magnified here for the sake of example) - I might be ticked off, but obedient, then I might even be upset, feeling tired and a little bratty....but then I will start to feel the shift inside of me, the internal pleasure that I get from doing something because he told me to do it, and then the realization of the journey my emotions just took.

Basically, I guess, it's that shift that I long for and that to me is what defines my submissiveness.  Not that I do something for him, but that I give my will over to him and hopefully better myself in some way, by going through the phases of my struggle to obey.  (oh - that rhymed!) 

I don't know.  This probably doesn't make any sense.  Maybe I'll delete it.





IrishMist -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 7:23:08 PM)

Quite honestly; its just a word that people throw around for impact.

Nothing more, nothing less.

Applying the word to yourself, myself, or anyone else does nothing but say 'hey look at me'. Unless you feel the meaning in your soul...for any reason, whether it be play, personality, or relationship...unless you FEEL the meaning in your soul...its just a word that is thrown around for impact.

Argue the semantics till you are blue in the face; but it will not change the fact that submissive...is nothing more than a word.




masterofdrkness2 -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 7:30:34 PM)

Being submissive is  ( drum rolls please) To me it is really simple , what the people involved in the relationship define as being submissive is what it is , I know what I say is being submissive does not equal to what another will say . I accept that and in no way say mine is right or their's is wrong . 




CallaFirestormBW -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 7:41:47 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: xxblushesxx

So what IS submissive?


Submissive is an attitude, behavior, or a way of "being". It comes out of a willingness to yield to direction that comes from somewhere other than within oneself. One can be submissive and not have anything to do with the BDSM lifestyle -- it is possible to submit to service on a spiritual path, or submit to the direction of a boss or supervisor. There is no particular skill-set that determines what submission is -- all that it requires is that attitude of yielding to the direction of an outside force.

Now, that being said, as the directing party someone may say "this is what it will mean for you to be submissive to me". In order to show hir submission in that dynamic, the submissive individual would have to behave in the manner required by the directing party. That -doesn't- mean, however, that in a different dynamic, the expressions of submission would necessarily have to be the same. This is why it is important, I think, to guide a servant to understand what submission would mean in a given dynamic, and why, sometimes, no matter how much previous experience a person has, that experience will be irrelevant to a subsequent relationship, except in the fact that the individual is familiar with and embraces the position as one who yields to direction provided from outside oneself.

Calla Firestorm






Maxwell67 -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 7:42:22 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: IrishMist
Quite honestly; its just a word that people throw around for impact.

By 'impact', I suppose you mean they use it to make an impression on someone?  All words are 'just words.'  If you do not give them a meaning they are just letters on a page in a pattern that can be spoken aloud to make a relatively unique sound.  What good does reducing any word to that level do?  It has to have some kind of generally accepted meaning to have any use at all.  There is some level of ambiguity in all words, but taken in the context of a phrase most people get a general impression of a meaning, even if is it just onomatpoeia.  All of our conversations about what this label or that means to each of us is very useful, I think.  We are learning about each other.  Trying to reach some consensus on a general level and insert an individual perspective to give each other some impresson of 'who I am' as well.  Are we actually going to EVER crystallize one of these labels down to a single meaning everyone can agree on?  Gods, I hope not.

Edited because somehow I missed half of a sentence when cutting and pasting this from the general 'stream of conciousness' scratch page I often use to organize my thoughts...




Leatherist -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 7:44:18 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: IrishMist

Quite honestly; its just a word that people throw around for impact.

Nothing more, nothing less.

Applying the word to yourself, myself, or anyone else does nothing but say 'hey look at me'. Unless you feel the meaning in your soul...for any reason, whether it be play, personality, or relationship...unless you FEEL the meaning in your soul...its just a word that is thrown around for impact.

Argue the semantics till you are blue in the face; but it will not change the fact that submissive...is nothing more than a word.


When the rubber hits the road-it's about what you do, not what you say.
 
 Talk is cheap-I want to see action.




Maxwell67 -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 8:13:42 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: CallaFirestormBW
quote:

ORIGINAL: xxblushesxx
So what IS submissive?

This is why it is important, I think, to guide a servant to understand what submission would mean in a given dynamic, and why, sometimes, no matter how much previous experience a person has, that experience will be irrelevant to a subsequent relationship, except in the fact that the individual is familiar with and embraces the position as one who yields to direction provided from outside oneself.

Calla Firestorm


You know, Calla, I really think that it is for reasons like this that we have these conversations at all.  I like the way you think, even if I sometimes have to read some of your phrases twice to get the full meaning.[:)]   Then again I know I often have the same problem...

Alright this is going to sort of sidetrack part of this conversation, but I think it is relevent to the discussion so I am going to just say it here...

It is funny, isn't it, that so often the more proficiency one has with a language the harder it is to construct a way to say 'exactly' what you mean?  If we had not so innoculated (inculcated?  indoctrinated??  All those words help express this thought, but they have different meanings.. ain't language grand?) ourselves against miscommunication in the things we said, do you think it would be any easier to communicate?  I suppose we could try expressing things poetically (impressionistically?)  I wonder if that would make things clearer or just muddy things up more. Hmmm.. Well it might be fun to try.  It is not as if this conversation will ever end.

Edited to insert whimsy...  um... what were we talking about again?




xxblushesxx -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 8:25:20 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: StormsSlave

I think it's pretty ballsy for some "dom" to stand outside a relationship and judge the people in it.  Did you tell him to go fuck himself, Blushes?


No, she is a switch who we were considering allowing to dom me. It didn't work out.




xxblushesxx -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 8:32:43 PM)

Great responses everyone, I do feel like I am growing by reading them.
Dark, especially, thank you.

We have problems sometimes because my submission is limitless (besides the obvious crap like death or handi-cap) except when it comes to my little ones. We have different ideas regarding raising children, so, it's difficult to be submissive, and a mother tiger for my babes.

I really was curious though, because of that other thread. And because of how that woman (who made a thread about our meeting) took my answers to her questions regarding submission.

Thanks all!

~Christina




BRNaughtyAngel -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 8:34:43 PM)

For me, it's about trying (and not always succeeding) to put His wants, needs and desires ahead of my own. 

It's about doing things to make His life easier, even if they make mine more difficult. 

It's about doing things that He wants me to do, even when I don't want to do them.

It's about obedience and pleasing Him.

It's about humility.

It's about service.

It's about kink.

It's about answering to Him.

It's about loving Him and accepting His love in return.

It's about doing all of this and more with joy in my heart, even when I'm sometimes inclined to knock a knot on His head. [;)]

Is this submission?  [sm=dunno.gif]  I dunno, but it feels like it to me...... and it works for us, so......






elleelisa -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 10:47:31 PM)

Sort of like religion, there are strict interpretations and those who interpret loosely.  There are always limits, odd circumstances, etc. and no way is the "right" way. 

The more I look into BDSM [since I'm super new] the more I realize that my way is right for me.

Reading through the forum I don't think I am as kinky or intense as some of the people, though that doesn't mean I am not submissive... it just means that I practice it a different way.  There are a lot of religions and denominations (haha, I almost wrote, "dominations"[sm=lol.gif])




OTKkindaGirl -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 10:58:15 PM)

beautiful




leadership527 -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 11:03:51 PM)

GREAT THREAD




zhouwuatsien -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 11:48:39 PM)

It's obvious.

Being Submissive is being a "dirty little daddy's slut" while being "peed on, whilst forced to eat poop" and to "take it from animals".  "To be treated in a completely derogatory manner" and to be beaten and raped.  A lot.  Sometimes both at the same time, or all ten at the same time.  Which takes skill.  It also means you have to cut off all your hair like Britney Spears.  And you also have to do the housework, and cook dinner.  Naked.  With hot irons on your nipples.  Which are pierced.  Every day.

I got all my knowledge from "REAL DOMINANTS" from the website.  As a young dominant, all spongy for information.  That's what I've learned.

Man, I can't wait till I'm 50 to treat my human slave as a derogatory shit eating sex toy with no will of her own.  That's better than Oreo Cheesecake.

---

Submission is to follow the Will.  Not the Order.




GreedyTop -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/5/2008 11:52:30 PM)

*hugs Zhou*

How are ya, darlin?

and Oreo cheesecake? eww...

and about that being peed on thing.. *melt*




DMFParadox -> RE: ok, then what IS submissive? (8/6/2008 12:02:10 AM)

Referring back to my answer on 'what is a true Dom?', a Dom is someone who gets a sexual charge from the obedience of their partner.  So 'submissiveness' under the same terms is someone whose sexuality is tied to obedience to another.  From there, the details vary greatly; is the obedience given freely, must it be wrested from the sub for them to feel sexually fulfilled, etc... different for every person, but there's a consistency in how the submissiveness must be either a)explicitly asked for or b)strongly hinted at by another.  A Dom.  The feeling of power taken, somewhat irresistably, from the sub is part of why the dynamic is important to them; of, by request, handing the decision of 'What next?' over to the Dom, and discovering the outcome.

Spelling note: Dom and Domme sound the same out loud, so to hell with the extra 'me'.  I'm putting that in my tagline.




Page: <<   < prev  1 2 [3] 4 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875