RE: Kinky Jews (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


TribeTziyon -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 3:22:32 PM)

If you are serious about exploring Judaism than do so. There are many sites that can give you information. I would suggest http://www.jewfaq.org/index.htm or www.myjewishlearning.com/.
 
I would also offer the thought that conversion in one branch will not always translate into acceptance in another. One who converts other than under orthodox auspices has a tough road in many arenas if heading to Israel to make a life.




AquaticSub -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 3:29:22 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: TribeTziyon

I would also offer the thought that conversion in one branch will not always translate into acceptance in another. One who converts other than under orthodox auspices has a tough road in many arenas if heading to Israel to make a life.


That is another thing that needs to be seriously considered, OP. I'm debating converting again through the Orthodox branch once I've gotten through it with Conservative. So far not seriously but it's a thought. I have read of people in my assigned reading who had to go through the process of conversation because their mothers never formally did.




TribeTziyon -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 3:37:04 PM)

Even among the 'orthodox' conversions there is still a hot debate on the validity of a rabbbi's conversions. They are yanking conversions made years ago and impacting lives of the convert and their families.




AquaticSub -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 3:41:33 PM)

Ugh... I don't want to think about that. I haven't even thought about what it's going to be like going to Israel and if I'll be able to visit as a Jew or if I will go as an American.

I just won't think about it until after the conversion and the wedding.




flower2007 -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 3:43:11 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: candystripper

I am asking if I am devote, an adherent of my faith, will I feel or be taught that D/s is wrong?



Would it matter if it was?  People pick and choose which rules to follow anyway, and since you're not planning on covering your head or keeping kosher, why worry about sex? Not meaning to offend, just honestly confused as to why D/s would be an issue when all the other rules won't be.




TribeTziyon -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 3:44:47 PM)

Unless you're making aliyah I don't know how much of a concern ulitmately that would be for you. Of course, any children that come of the union may have issues on some fronts if they marry into some branches.

What a headache, no?




AquaticSub -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 3:46:11 PM)

Very much so. But worth it, for me anyway. [:)]




TribeTziyon -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 3:53:30 PM)

Well may it all be good things for you.




DomMeinCT -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 5:27:22 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: TribeTziyon

If you are serious about exploring Judaism than do so. There are many sites that can give you information. I would suggest http://www.jewfaq.org/index.htm or www.myjewishlearning.com/.
 
I would also offer the thought that conversion in one branch will not always translate into acceptance in another. One who converts other than under orthodox auspices has a tough road in many arenas if heading to Israel to make a life.


Good recs.

It's interested that you talk about acceptance into various branches.  Even the Orthodox branch has branches
now, and I've been to two synagogues in the past year that described themselves as "modern Orthodox".  Though the ritual and service were firmly Orthodox, women sat with the men, though at one, women were not welcome on the bimah.

On another topic you mentioned, do you really think it's difficult to make Aliyah if you're not Orthodox?  I'd think that difficulty would only apply if you were planning on living in an ultra-Orthodox enclave or neighborhood, but I've not lived there (only have friends that live there).




candystripper -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 8:34:22 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: AquaticSub

Yes, there are TONS of rules regarding your personal life. There are 613 "rules" or mitzahs, or steps to heaven. These range from when you can have sex (while on the rag is a big no-no), how to cleanse your body, what type of fabrics you can wear and what you can stock in your kitchen. Pre-martial sex against the rules. I have heard that in certain circumstance it is allowed but I have yet to find out exactly what those circumstances are.


Thank you..where do I find the 613 mitzahs? Are they in the Old Testmanent?  The Torah?  Can I just go to the library and get an English verion of The Torah?
 
I know not all religious Jews 'keep kosher', etc.  Are the 613 mitzahs applicable to all Jews?
 
Is there no sect of Judaism which permits 'pre-marital sex'?
  
Have a lovely evening.
 
candystripper  [sm=pole.gif]




candystripper -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 8:41:02 PM)

quote:

I've don't recall ever hearing discussion in my religion about going to Hell for activities.  The focus is much more on taking personal responsibility to add good deeds to the world, rather than focus on sin and punishment.  My experience only.  Others may have differing experiences.

DomMeinCT


This I did know.  I must have seemed very stupid asking 'where's the Cathecism'?
 
My apologies; it's a bit of a journey for me.
 
Peace.
 
candystripper  [sm=pole.gif]




TribeTziyon -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 9:38:25 PM)

I always tend to recommend the more orthodox sites for information in general to those looking. Just my habit, I am far from the orthodox frame of reference in my beliefs and life. I see it as starting point of study to get the basics and branch out from, but that's just me.

As for emigrating to Israel, I believe it is still in effect that if you have a Jewish grandparent, be it maternal or paternal, you can gain citizenship. That's the secular part of it all, the religious part would be a whole other ball of wax depending on what side of the blanket your Jewish roots come from.

I would hazard the guess that a reform or conservative conversion would probaby be an impediment for the  person making aliyah. I'd have to dig deeper into that. You might be able to emigrate as a regular person but I would suspect you would not be recognized as "Jewish".

Myself, I don't see conversions of the reform or conservative branches as any less valid but that's my opinion.




AquaticSub -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/15/2008 10:08:42 PM)

~Fast Reply~

Random thought since it won't be bumping the thread: Does anyone think the rule about no tattoos and piercings would apply to deliberate scarring or needleplay?

That would be something to ask the Rabbi, if someone had the chutzpah. I don't, yet anyway. [:)] 




aravain -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/16/2008 10:39:21 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: candystripper
Maybe it would help if i asked a specific question.  What does the Jewish faith say on the matter of 'pre-marital sex'? 


In general?

"Don't."

I mean, there's different intricacies... but for women it's technically not allowed ever unless they're a prostitute... but there's other things involved with that. Men is a whole different situation. If I remember from studying, correctly, if they pay for it, it doesn't count (that's a gross over-simplification, of course)

But reform judaism doesn't adhere to that as much, in general most reform communities choose to (in their eyes) accept that the old laws to not necessarily apply to modern life, and what's important is the faith and relationship with god.

Or at least that's my experience.

Keep in mind that even orthodox jews don't believe in a 'hell' or a place that you go for 'punishment' once you're dead.

On the issue of scarring... body modification is the issue, not necessarily just earrings and tattoos ;) Since your body isn't your own (it's god's) you can't/shouldn't modify it. *shrug*




AquaticSub -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/16/2008 11:38:15 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: candystripper

quote:

ORIGINAL: AquaticSub

Yes, there are TONS of rules regarding your personal life. There are 613 "rules" or mitzahs, or steps to heaven. These range from when you can have sex (while on the rag is a big no-no), how to cleanse your body, what type of fabrics you can wear and what you can stock in your kitchen. Pre-martial sex against the rules. I have heard that in certain circumstance it is allowed but I have yet to find out exactly what those circumstances are.


Thank you..where do I find the 613 mitzahs? Are they in the Old Testmanent?  The Torah?  Can I just go to the library and get an English verion of The Torah?
 
I know not all religious Jews 'keep kosher', etc.  Are the 613 mitzahs applicable to all Jews?
 
Is there no sect of Judaism which permits 'pre-marital sex'?
  
Have a lovely evening.
 
candystripper  [sm=pole.gif]


The Torah is what Christians call the Old Testment. The Torah not going to explain all the rules to you as they apply to modern life because the mitzahs have been debated and drawn out further. The ban on tattoos and body piercings comes from a comandment not to cut or mark ourselves in mourning.

In all seriousness, if you actually want to do this I think you need to forget about this thread and start reading. The books I suggested will be a good start.




DesFIP -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/16/2008 3:50:25 PM)

Most temples will keep a small lending library on Jewish studies for the Hebrew School set. That's an excellent beginning. The Torah is the first five books of the Bible, what you would call the Old Testament.

Being a Reconstructionist, BDSM is not, I wager to guess, strictly prohibited. There's a line somewhere in the Torah about not doing unnatural things. Now Orthodox consider homosexuality to be unnatural, but Reconstructionists consider going against your nature to be unnatural. So to us, staying in the closet, marrying someone you cannot enjoy sex with, etc is unnatural. As such, the kid who was bar mitzvahed the week before my son was the son of two female partners and nobody gave a damn, especially the rabbi. Nor do we care if both parents are Jewish. If they aren't, the nonJewish partner can come up on the bimah but not recite any prayers.

Pity that, because The Man's got a better voice than I do and I always get tapped for High Holiday Readings.




LadyTeazer -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/16/2008 6:02:35 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: RealSub58

I want a liturgy and a dogma.  I want to study and learn my religion, and worship with others who believe as I do.  I do not want to feel estranged from Gawd because I am not adhering to the cathecism. 
It seems you want a dogma and liturgy that is to your liking....   you want control, structure, but are unwilling to submit to the control and sturucture of a religious institution. 

BossyShoeBitch   But your reason has to be a valid one. Why do you feel you want to be a Jew?  THAT is the question you need to ponder and be ready to answer sincerely.
Very well stated. Wonders if she knows the answer?  Catholic to Jew all for a set of rule and regs you don't want to follow anyway.AquaticSub  Judaism does have rules and guidelines for sex, from everything to the circumstances to what forms of birth control are acceptable due to the religious laws of not altering the body. I want a congregation to worship with, but I see no point in joining a religion which is going to give me a rash about how I live.  
You want Identification with, a religious social community that you finds meets your standards on how you live.Won't happen.  Might I suggest you start your own religion? 
Catholics have a Cathecism.  A book of rules about what we're supposed to believe and what will happen to us if we don't. Have you even browsed the Torah?  Look at Leviticus and you will pass out with all the laws on how to live!  Includes cooking, sex during menstruation.........
  My impression is Jews study all their lives.  Not only the Old Testament, but the language of Hebrew and the Torah.  I'm not sure whether they have Canonical lawyers, as Catholics do.  (Man, those Jesuits are some smart folks.) Well I am sure the higher archy of the Cathlic persausion "study" all the time.  They came up with pergatory, they come up with new rules to live by yearly or with change of Pope.
I want a liturgy and a dogma.  I want to study and learn my religion, and worship with others who believe as I do.  I do not want to feel estranged from Gawd because I am not adhering to the cathecism. 
It's God, not Gawd.  You might find yourself estranged from Jehovah/Yayah = God if you refuse to follow the laws of the Torah.  Religious institutions have rules, laws and regulations to keep you confined in a box, obedient, submissive. You break down a wall in this institution and you are free to break rules, walk away (as you seem to be doing with Catholisim) and you wonder into yet another institution with rules, regs and laws.   came4U  Can't you even tone it down a bit long enough to learn, discuss and pray without being in an all fire hurry to worry about what they will think about your personal traits.
Maybe until you have the maturity level to forget about kink and what people think for a day and you can be be fully and genuinely immersed in Judiasm, you will not be recognized as 'becoming faithful' to any God    Very well stated.greeneyedreamerBUT on the other hand if you do whatever you want and disregard the laws of your church or synagogue, then just shut up. Very well stated as she will be looking for yet another form of control whose rules, regs and laws she cannot submit to.





AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA -- MEN!!!!!!!! 
Well said everyone.     [:D]

My first thought in reading OP's comments is that she seems to have a lot of anger inside her about something.  I tried several times to pull up her profile, to find out more about her, and what might be the cause of that inner anger.  Kept coming up "Profile Not Found".   Hmmmmmmm..........   Kinda peculiar, no?

She seems overly worried about being accepted (anywhere) because she thinks she is kinky.  My instinct tells me that she has not/cannot accept herself as being kinky, and hence, is worried what other people will think of her once they find out her 'secret'.   If you're so concerned that people will not accept you because of your kink, there is an easy solution to that -- don't tell them!  Unless.... you *want* to be rejected by others, and the best way you can see to make that happen is to tell them that you are kinky, purely for the shock/horror/disdain value.  Sounds like the only one 'giving her a rash about the way she lives' is herself.

You want to convert to Judaism, but even before you have fully explored what that involves, you are already saying that you WON'T do this (keep Kosher), and you WON'T do that (cover your hair in public).  Is disobedience a kink of yours?   ALL religions have rules/laws/guidelines on how you are to live your life, and what consequences follow if you don't.  Religion is not a buffet where you can pick and choose what you want to folllow -- you take the religion as a complete package, or you don't take it at all.   

I am a lapsed Catholic myself.   I was raised in a very strict household, and in no way, shape or form do I feel "entitled" to be cheesed off at the church.  I disagreed with many of their teachings and beliefs, so I just stopped going to services.   

What truly offends me about the OP's comment's is the opening line -- that she lives in f**king Cleveland, Ohio.   So what??  I am PROUD to say that I am a native Clevelander!!  I love it here.  Have lived here all of my life.  Wouldn't want to live anywhere else.  This is **home**.    If you find f**king Cleveland to be such a terrible place to live, then don't let the Terminal Tower hit you in the ass on your way out.

You think that there is a lot of bigotry here?  What makes you think that this is any different from any other city, state, or country that you might find yourself in?  Perhaps you are choosing to hang with people who are like that.  Heck, you've never hung with me, so you don't know how liberal I am. 

And lastly, the correct word is "shikseh", not 'shiksa'.  If you want to be Jewish, learn the language.  (Yiddish, as well as Hebrew)    I should know from a shikseh, because I am one.  [:)]    My college sweetheart was Jewish, and that was his pet name for me.   We went to Kent State University, and all these years later, we are still  *great*  friends.







LadyTeazer -- proud and happy Owner of [saberwolf34]
and still a WOW -- Wonderful Older Woman







ShaktiSama -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/16/2008 9:38:20 PM)

Fast Reply to the OP:

I'm only half-Jewish myself, but I know that there are sects of Judaism that are much more tolerant than others.  My female cousin is a practicing rabbi in the Reform or "Progressive" tradition; if you're serious about converting, I would strongly suggest you avoid converting to a more Orthodox form.  The entrenched misogyny and xenophobia of Ye Olde Tyme Judaism is NOT a pretty thing.

P.S.  I don't know why people are saying all the hottest kinksters are Jewish; personally, I would vouch for the Catholics.  All of the kinkiest human beings I've ever met in my life were raised Catholic!  If I ever meet the Pope, I will have to thank him personally.  [:)]




aravain -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/16/2008 10:18:55 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LadyTeazer
Kept coming up "Profile Not Found".


That's because the profile's been deleted...

that's what it says when I read my last CMail from her :(




thishereboi -> RE: Kinky Jews (11/17/2008 3:51:43 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: candystripper

quote:

ORIGINAL: persephonee

stef wanted to know if you had ever considered converting on 11/12....at 129 pm. Is that why you posted this now?


Really, what business is it of yours?  Why do I need to defend something which could not possibly be more personal?
 
Would you inquire about the spiritual life of a stranger face to face?  I think some people lack boundaries...a bit sad if you're an adult. 
 
candystripper  [sm=pole.gif]


While I definately agree that this is a personal subject...your the one who brought it up. Your the one who asked for peoples opinions on it. If I came face to face with a stranger and they were holding a sign that read " I could use some help, folks.  I’m considering converting to Judaism.  (I don’t yet know what’s involved – I’m meeting with the Rabbi Sunday morning.) " Then yes, I might inquire about it.

As far as your converting goes, the answer seems kinda easy to me. If you have discovered that you believe the same things that the Jewish faith states as true, then I think you should do everything you can to convert. If your only looking for a group of people to belong to, that won't hate like those terrible Catholics do, then maybe you should rethink things.




Page: <<   < prev  5 6 7 [8] 9   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875