ThatDamnedPanda
Posts: 6060
Joined: 1/26/2009 Status: offline
|
Good posts, Marie. You're making a good argument here. I'm a little shocked at the incredible emotional over-reaction by some posters to such a benign OP. All the guy does is post a Youtube link, and the next thing you know he's called out as a hypocrite and a menace to society. Granted, I disagree with him quite a bit myself on issues of crime and punishment, but the way the poor bastard has been demonized in this thread is way over the top. I don't care what his posting history is, this kind of response is disproportionate and out of context. People need to take a step back and a deep breath. quote:
ORIGINAL: marie2 quote:
Barelynangel Sorry but running for office when you are 21 and its now 12 years later and you are so passionate and negative about a system willing to generalize a group of people whose motive for being is really to help and not harm, won't make the change you complain about. I don't see this as a viable argument, but I sure do see it a lot of the boards. The trend seems to be "if you're not doing something to change it, then you have no right to discuss it or complain about it". I have to disagree with this. This is a discussion forum, we might talk about things from whether or not cigarettes should be taxed, whether or not fat people should pay more for airline tickets, whether or not slavery should be legal, whether or not some cops suck, or the legal system sucks, and on and on and on. And most of us are not lobbying to change these things. Not everyone is in a position in their lives to fight every cause that they have a strong opinion on. This whole "if you're not doing something about it, then you have no right to complain" has become a bottom line generic "argument" that strategically puts a person on the defense, and derails the actual topic. Seems to me this is a topic about cops who have transgressed, not whether or not slaveboy has run for office. You're right, that's seldom a very relevant argument. And it's particularly weak in this discussion. The guy was called out and checked for credentials, and he provided them. Sounds to me like he's done a lot more to effect change in his community than most people on this forum, and yet that's still not enough - he's maligned even more vehemently because he's not lobbying in Washington, for christ's sake. This is absurd. Every single one of has a mental list of things we don't like about the world in which we live, but that doesn't mean we're all hypocrites if we don't spend every waking hour campaigning on behalf of those causes. The guy's catching way more grief here than he's got coming to him, and he's making some pretty well-reasone arguments in the midts of it all despite the flak he's catching - arguments that unfortunately seem to be sailing right over the heads of the people who are jumping on him.
_____________________________
Panda, panda, burning bright In the forest of the night What immortal hand or eye Made you all black and white and roly-poly like that?
|