Who would have thought -- war is 'hard'

Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid

Message

Loki45 -> Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 12:20:27 AM)
http://www.cnn.com/2009/LIVING/worklife/10/16/challenge.women.military/index.html Apparently war is "hard" on women. Well no shit. [sm=applause.gif]

DarkSteven -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 3:46:44 AM)
It ain't easy on men either. Or children, for that matter.

housesub4you -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 3:55:49 AM)
Thankfully, we had people in power who understand this and only go to war as a last result.

sirsholly -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:15:21 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: DarkSteven It ain't easy on men either. Or children, for that matter. not a picnic for the spouses either....

Loki45 -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:25:36 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: DarkSteven It ain't easy on men either. Or children, for that matter. Exactly my point. If you take away the sexual assault (because really, that can and does happen no matter where you live, work, or whatever) then the 'horrors' they are experiencing are not only no harder than what the men face, but now they are bitching about it after jumping up and down and screaming that they should be allowed to go into combat because "they can do everything a man can." Sheesh. I saw another story on CNN about a former female soldier who said she had PTSD and had all sorts of problems now that she's out. But her 'big' defining PTSD-inducing moment was that a van pulled up next to her convoy and men opened the doors and (brace yourself) yelled at her. I mean seriously? Some guys in a van yell at her and that gives her PTSD? In a place where men are gunned down by snipers, choppers shot down by RPGs, roadside bombs that go off and level an entire convoy.......and men "yelling" at her gives her PTSD? [8\|]

sirsholly -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:31:41 AM)
quote: I mean seriously? Some guys in a van yell at her and that gives her PTSD? In a place where men are gunned down by snipers, choppers shot down by RPGs, roadside bombs that go off and level an entire convoy.......and men "yelling" at her gives her PTSD? Loki...damn right the yelling can be a trigger. PTSD can be triggered by the things you least expect. Do you think a VietNam vet needs to hear gunfire to have a flashback?

Loki45 -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:33:25 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly Loki...damn right the yelling can be a trigger. PTSD can be triggered by the things you least expect. Do you think a VietNam vet needs to hear gunfire to have a flashback? You misunderstand. The yelling didn't cause the girl in the article to have a flashback. That was the event "over there" that supposedly GAVE her PTSD to begin with. She wasn't in combat. She wasn't attacked. Her best friend didn't die in her arms, she didn't have half her convoy wiped out by a roadside bomb. Guys yelled at her and now that's she's back home, she can't function. Hell, I got "yelled at" in basic training. Didn't phase me a bit.

sirsholly -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:35:40 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Loki45 quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly Loki...damn right the yelling can be a trigger. PTSD can be triggered by the things you least expect. Do you think a VietNam vet needs to hear gunfire to have a flashback? You misunderstand. The yelling didn't cause the girl in the article to have a flashback. That was the event "over there" that supposedly GAVE her PTSD to begin with. She wasn't in combat. She wasn't attacked. Her best friend didn't die in her arms, she didn't have half her convoy wiped out by a roadside bomb. Guys yelled at her and now that's she's back home, she can't function. Hell, I got "yelled at" in basic training. Didn't phase me a bit. PTSD does not have to involve gunfire and bloodshed. It involved trauma. It is not the place of anyone to say what qualifies as traumatic for anyone other than ourselves.

Loki45 -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:37:17 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly PTSD does not have to involve gunfire and bloodshed. It involved trauma. It is not the place of anyone to say what qualifies as traumatic for anyone other than ourselves. Seriously? You think yelling is a PTSD qualifier? If that's the case, we need to bring home all the girls from the military. Because if yelling at them is enough to ruin them, basic training is ruining them by the dozens every 6 weeks or so.

DarkSteven -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:38:14 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly quote: I mean seriously? Some guys in a van yell at her and that gives her PTSD? In a place where men are gunned down by snipers, choppers shot down by RPGs, roadside bombs that go off and level an entire convoy.......and men "yelling" at her gives her PTSD? Loki...damn right the yelling can be a trigger. PTSD can be triggered by the things you least expect. Do you think a VietNam vet needs to hear gunfire to have a flashback? I know someone who was repeatedly and seriously abused as a child. Her PTSD can be triggered by damn near anything, such as garages, the word "electrician", back yards, and of course yelling as well.

thishereboi -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:39:12 AM)
I wonder how much money it cost to come to this amazing conclusion.

Loki45 -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:41:00 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: thishereboi I wonder how much money it cost to come to this amazing conclusion. Probably far less than it did to train them and send them all over there only to be 'traumatized' by 'yelling.'

thishereboi -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:41:34 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Loki45 quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly Loki...damn right the yelling can be a trigger. PTSD can be triggered by the things you least expect. Do you think a VietNam vet needs to hear gunfire to have a flashback? You misunderstand. The yelling didn't cause the girl in the article to have a flashback. That was the event "over there" that supposedly GAVE her PTSD to begin with. She wasn't in combat. She wasn't attacked. Her best friend didn't die in her arms, she didn't have half her convoy wiped out by a roadside bomb. Guys yelled at her and now that's she's back home, she can't function. Hell, I got "yelled at" in basic training. Didn't phase me a bit. I've gotten yelled at walking past constructions sites, can I claim PTSD now?

DarkSteven -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:42:43 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Loki45 quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly PTSD does not have to involve gunfire and bloodshed. It involved trauma. It is not the place of anyone to say what qualifies as traumatic for anyone other than ourselves. Seriously? You think yelling is a PTSD qualifier? If that's the case, we need to bring home all the girls from the military. Because if yelling at them is enough to ruin them, basic training is ruining them by the dozens every 6 weeks or so. WTF? We should do this for all females because of the responses of one of them? You sound like one of the male subs who whine about all Dommes being rude, or moneygrubbers, or about some other perceived slight.

Loki45 -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:43:45 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: thishereboi I've gotten yelled at walking past constructions sites, can I claim PTSD now? Yeah, if I claimed PTSD everytime I got yelled at, I'd have to be in a rubber room, rocking back and forth now.

sirsholly -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:44:16 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Loki45 quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly PTSD does not have to involve gunfire and bloodshed. It involved trauma. It is not the place of anyone to say what qualifies as traumatic for anyone other than ourselves. Seriously? You think yelling is a PTSD qualifier? If that's the case, we need to bring home all the girls from the military. Because if yelling at them is enough to ruin them, basic training is ruining them by the dozens every 6 weeks or so. i am not comfortable arguing this point on a story i know nothing about. Can you post a link? But...the "bring the girls home" shit is really rather insulting. A van of men pulled up and opened the door and began to scream at her. For heavens sake, i would have peed my pants!! I am defenseless against a van full of men. It was a trigger. What happened to her...what was the flashback?

Loki45 -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:45:00 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: DarkSteven WTF? We should do this for all females because of the responses of one of them? You sound like one of the male subs who whine about all Dommes being rude, or moneygrubbers, or about some other perceived slight. Actually, I sound like a misogynistic asshole who doesn't think that women belong anywhere near combat and am using this as an example of why. If you're going to extrapolate about me and my motives, at least get it right.

sirsholly -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:45:35 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Loki45 quote: ORIGINAL: thishereboi I've gotten yelled at walking past constructions sites, can I claim PTSD now? Yeah, if I claimed PTSD everytime I got yelled at, I'd have to be in a rubber room, rocking back and forth now. Post the fucking link or stop talking about something we have no knowledge of!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Loki45 -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:49:29 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly i am not comfortable arguing this point on a story i know nothing about. Can you post a link? http://www.cnn.com/2009/LIVING/09/25/homeless.veterans/index.html quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly But...the "bring the girls home" shit is really rather insulting. So is the notion of PTSD for being yelled at. Our boys over there experience 100 times worse than being "yelled at" and when they get back, they are treated like shit. Or made to feel badly because of the REAL trauma they experienced. I see the girl in this story as the equivelent of a woman who falsely cries rape. Much as a false accuser makes it tougher on every woman who really is raped, women like the one in that story, to me, belittle the people who really go through fucked up shit over there and come back worse for it. quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly A van of men pulled up and opened the door and began to scream at her. For heavens sake, i would have peed my pants!! I am defenseless against a van full of men. Maybe, but she was in an armed convoy, which greatly out-numbered the shouting men. quote: ORIGINAL: sirsholly It was a trigger. What happened to her...what was the flashback? You're still mis-reading. The van thing wasn't the trigger. It was the the "traumatic event" that supposedly gave her PTSD.

DarkSteven -> RE: Who would have thought -- war is 'hard' (10/17/2009 4:49:49 AM)
quote: ORIGINAL: Loki45 quote: ORIGINAL: DarkSteven WTF? We should do this for all females because of the responses of one of them? You sound like one of the male subs who whine about all Dommes being rude, or moneygrubbers, or about some other perceived slight. Actually, I sound like a misogynistic asshole who doesn't think that women belong anywhere near combat and am using this as an example of why. If you're going to extrapolate about me and my motives, at least get it right. I didn't. I said you sounded like. I did not speculate on what your motives were. I'm not the one who didn't get it right, Loki.

Page: [1] 2 3 4 5 next > >>

Collarchat.com © 2025

Terms of Service

0.03125