What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


chase4647 -> What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 10:24:43 AM)

Hello to All,
(To the person mentioned in this post: please note that I omit all identifiable details - I will never try to harm you, my goal here is to understand).

First time poster, and total newbie here (which explains a lot of what I'm about to write). Signed up to CM maybe a couple of weeks ago, identified myself as a gay male switch, but soon was more drawn to the sub side.

Early on I striked up a conversation with a Dom from another country (I live in the US), and after a few emails we hit it off, and started IM'ing to each other several times a day, some of those for a few hours. There were also a few phone calls and emails. I really liked him because he seemed intelligent, gentle and caring. Since I'm new to the whole thing he took a long time explaining how it all works, said that he would train me as his slave starting slow, and was vey tolerant to my desire to avoid almost all physical pain.

The first red flag happened perhaps 2-3 days after our first contact, when he said that once I accepted to be his slave I should send him a gift to show appreciation for my Master, and then my (long-distance) training could begin. Pretending not to know what he meant (but I don't think it was a Valentine's day card!) I said ok, and asked what kind of gift. After some back and forth, he suggested $200 to pay for his internet bills would be an appropriate gift, since he needed the internet to talk with me. Now folks, here's the clincher: by this time I was already so wrapped up in him that money was the least of my concerns. I actually felt _honored_ that my (future) Master and Lord would deign to take my humble money. This was a person who was paying me a lot of the attention that I craved for: he told me that when I went to his country to visit we would play with his Dom friends and their slaves, the slaves all pretending to be dogs and thrown peanuts directly into their mouths (yummy!); I would worship him as my God at his feet (doule yummy!); etc etc. So as I said I felt a vague sensation of pleasure by agreeing to send him th emoney and formally begin our M/s relationship.

This lasted maybe 30 minutes... In that same IM I told him that I was having second thoughts about the money. He was very understanding and said to forget about the money, and that our relationship was not going to be about money. I felt releived.

We continued in this vein for several days, me asking questions about was going to happen (and - mea culpa here - being a rather difficult slave I'm afraid, with lots of limits and demands).

In the last two days or so, he told me that his internet connection was about to be taken down and that our contact would have to be over the phone. As this is not very practical (I'm married and at least for now don't want my wife to know any of this), I suggested to send him the money after all. He said no no no, our relationship is not about the money. I insisted. He refused. I did not insist enough.

Then he said that it would take him months to get the connection back and that therefore we needed to wait some months before beginning the relationship. I asked: how can we handle that? He said: I think I will take you up on your offer.

Long story short (is anyone still reading?): shortly thereafter we said "goodbye forever." I still asked whether he would forgive me for not fully trusting him (which I acknowledged was the case), and he said that he could forgive me. I never sent the money, although the Lord knows (the actual Lord, not this one) that I was tempted to.

What do you think: was this a scam attempt? What probability would you attach to that: 100%, 50%. My own private probability is only 20% but that is probably because I was truly falling in love for the guy and probably still have a soft spot for him.

I have made a list of the reasons to believe it was a scam:

1) Aasking for money early on, later the insistence on using Western Union.
2) He is still using the internet.
3) He would not give me the email of his ex-slave so that I could check that he was real. (Feel free to tell me I'm not a good slave, what with all the demands, and I'll freely agree -- but that's not the point of this post).


I have also made a list of the factors that make me think perhaps it was not:

1) There was a gentleness and humanity in him that I think is hard to happen as just a performance if you don't feel anything. He seemed to be truly searching for love.
2) He seemed genuinely upset by the fact that meanwhile I had already agreed to be someone else's slave, even though I told him I didn't want to be that person's slave anymore (insert more comments about my bad here - my only excuse is that I thought that first relationship was on a trial basis and could end at any point).
3) He seemed genuinely upset when I said that I would visit his country only in two years. He said: I want a slave to be with me and serve me full time, not just from time to time. No mention of money issues here, full mention of companioship and relationship.
4) He seemed very upset by all of my demands. He said: you are overpowering me.

Regarding points 2-4 my question would be: if all he wanted was money, why would he be so upset?

Anyway, I would love to hear from all of you, especially if you are more experienced than me. Anyone who has been scammed want to share their experinces and / or views, perhaps?

Finally, apologies for the long post, but you could not answer the question in the title if I didn't give you the details.

Thank you in advance for all responses.




AquaticSub -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 10:28:10 AM)

You know... I know it doesn't have to do with your question... but all I can think is how pissed I would be if Valyraen starting sending random people in other countries hundreds of dollars without talking to me first.




mnottertail -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 10:30:40 AM)

Hey, you give me money I will tell you all sorta shit too.

None of it necessarily has to be true, and you are going to have a hella time telling your wife why you went and spent 12000 on your singular bachelor vacation to nigeria, so I am sure that you would actually cave out of the deal before meeting me, and even then........

But as long as there is talk, there is hope of getting money out of you.

(I think that's it in a nutshell).

Ron




domiguy -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 10:33:36 AM)

Do you need any monkeys?




AquaticSub -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 10:37:09 AM)

Hey... if we rented Greedy out and split the profits, she could join me at Dragon*Con! Plus she's a flying monkey so we can charge more.

GREEDY!!! Get your sexy butt over here!




littlewonder -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 10:37:21 AM)

I'm going to guess you're both scamming each other and others...does the wife know? Does the "Master" know about the wife?

If no one knows anything then imo...you get what you give out to the world.





MissBeautiful2U -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 10:39:34 AM)

Whether he was real or a scam, consider this... if he is not capable of providing his own internet connection, do you really see him as capable of entertaining you etc?  My take would be different on this had you already had an established relationship where you have spent time in person together and you knew of his financial situation.  When someone hits someone up for money, particularly as a sign of affection, it just feels funny to me.

This would be my question for you: 1) How would you have sent the money?  Be aware that a lot of scams can get your personal information when you send money.  2) Would you be willing to pay $200 for this interaction?  How long might it continue for?

I would not provide money to anyone who you will not see in real time if I were you.  Unless of course it is a porn site lol and you know that going in.

There are others out here who might be willing to play with you should you be honest about your situation, that said being married may exclude you from a lot of people's interests as well.

I wish you luck.




agirl -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 10:45:56 AM)

People would sell a lot less if they couldn't convince us by one means or the other that we'll get JUST what we want. We rarely need convincing about the things we need.

agirl




windchymes -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 11:08:04 AM)

1. If you have to ask if it's a scam, it is.

2. Scammers don't "deign" to take your money. They take it gleefully.




Rochsub2009 -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 11:13:01 AM)

None of us has the information needed to determine whether it was a scam or not.  But the thing that stood out to me was the fact that you said that he needed money because his internet was being disconnected, but then he is still on-line.  How long has he been on-line since he told you that?  If it was a few days, then it might be cut off soon.  But if it was months ago, then he may not have been honest.

My rule of thumb is to never send money to anyone that you haven't met.  Of course if you are dealing with a pro Dom/Domme or a financial Domme, then that might change.




xxblushesxx -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 11:23:29 AM)

Yes. It was a scam. He knew you couldn't talk by phone which is why he did the internet bit.
I talk to men on the phone for a living. I charge quite a bit per minute.
You wanna know something?
I can sound sincere because (most of the time)I am sincere in caring for my customers. But I still do it for the money.
The best scammers are the ones who seem the most sincere; if he can add a little of his own personality to the mix, it will be all the more real to you.
There will probably be men who try this on you again after reading about it here.
Don't send tributes (unless that is a fetish of yours)
Don't pick up on the hints that a future "master" has a need for something tangible and you should supply it. (unless it's a special picture of you, or a certain kind of delicacy that is produced where you live.)
And don't "lend" them money either. You won't get it back.




AquaticSub -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 11:31:57 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: xxblushesxx

Yes. It was a scam. He knew you couldn't talk by phone which is why he did the internet bit.
I talk to men on the phone for a living. I charge quite a bit per minute.
You wanna know something?
I can sound sincere because (most of the time)I am sincere in caring for my customers. But I still do it for the money.


To fair, you aren't scamming them. They know upfront what they are getting into. Athough it is strange how you can get attached to the regulars. I always knew when one guy would call. [:)]

BTW - you have mail babe.




lizi -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 11:42:53 AM)

It's a scam.
I don't have to write more to convince you....you already know in your heart it is a scam. You were accepting it as reality because you are more or less sneaking around on your wife so you thought you found something that would work for you and you simply wanted it to be true. He's a scammer. His sincerity just means he's good at what he does.




LafayetteLady -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 12:07:56 PM)

So in a matter of a couple of weeks, you have made a commitment to not one but TWO different masters, identifying yourself as a gay switch, all while being married and keeping this secret from your wife and your only worry here is whether or not this guy in another country is scamming you?

As Aqua pointed out, taking money away from your primary relationship to send to some stranger without the knowledge of your partner is never good.

Further you seem to be confused as to what you want to begin with. You list as a switch, but then apologize for being a "bad slave," because you asked questions and having limits and demands.

You say you have completely new to this. What you need to do is learn a bit more before jumping into anything, especially making commitments to someone in another country while still in a commitment yourself.

Ok, so none of that was about your question. To answer that, YES he was scamming you. You are completely new and have little idea of what you are doing and jumping into multiple relationships at a time. You're an easy mark.




kushiels -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 12:08:43 PM)

My vote goes for scam as well. And as for numbers, I'd be on the opposite end of you--I feel 80% sure it's a scam, and allow for the 20% possibility that I'm wrong, and that he's just unfamiliar with how many of these scams work and didn't realize what a red flag asking for money is.

Him being sincere, and upset about your "demands" isn't something that vetoes that for me--it's enough to make me wonder if I'm wrong, but, again, asking for a couple hundred bucks for his internet connection (how funny that what he really needed the money for is something YOU are invested in as well!), nah, I don't buy it.




chase4647 -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 12:54:23 PM)

Let's see if this works, I'm quoting people for the first time.

quote:

ORIGINAL: domiguy

Do you need any monkeys?


Explain please.

quote:

ORIGINAL: MissBeautiful2U

Whether he was real or a scam, consider this... if he is not capable of providing his own internet connection, do you really see him as capable of entertaining you etc?  My take would be different on this had you already had an established relationship where you have spent time in person together and you knew of his financial situation.  When someone hits someone up for money, particularly as a sign of affection, it just feels funny to me.

This would be my question for you: 1) How would you have sent the money?  Be aware that a lot of scams can get your personal information when you send money.  2) Would you be willing to pay $200 for this interaction?  How long might it continue for?

I would not provide money to anyone who you will not see in real time if I were you.  Unless of course it is a porn site lol and you know that going in.

There are others out here who might be willing to play with you should you be honest about your situation, that said being married may exclude you from a lot of people's interests as well.

I wish you luck.



Thanks MissBeautiful2U. The point is not that he can't provide his internet connection. The point is that he can (I can see that he is online) and therefore he lied to me. But I agree with the general thrust of your post.

mnottertail and agirl: you both are saying the same: while there is talk there is hope of getting money from me -- alas, I'm afraid you may be right. One thing I'll tell you: if I ever want to be a scammer (not likley btw!), I'll pose as a Dom, rather than a sub. I think scamming can happen both ways, but being in a sub position makes you more vulnerable.

quote:

ORIGINAL: windchymes

1. If you have to ask if it's a scam, it is.

2. Scammers don't "deign" to take your money. They take it gleefully.


1. GOOD POINT.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Rochsub2009

None of us has the information needed to determine whether it was a scam or not.  But the thing that stood out to me was the fact that you said that he needed money because his internet was being disconnected, but then he is still on-line.  How long has he been on-line since he told you that?  If it was a few days, then it might be cut off soon.  But if it was months ago, then he may not have been honest.

My rule of thumb is to never send money to anyone that you haven't met.  Of course if you are dealing with a pro Dom/Domme or a financial Domme, then that might change.



Well he said that the internet WAS already disconnected and that to get to me through the internet he need to go to a cafe which took a long time and was expensive. But now I see that he is online all the time, including at hours when internet cafes are likely to be closed.

Cute photo btw [:)]


quote:

ORIGINAL: xxblushesxx

Yes. It was a scam. He knew you couldn't talk by phone which is why he did the internet bit.
I talk to men on the phone for a living. I charge quite a bit per minute.
You wanna know something?
I can sound sincere because (most of the time)I am sincere in caring for my customers. But I still do it for the money.
The best scammers are the ones who seem the most sincere; if he can add a little of his own personality to the mix, it will be all the more real to you.
There will probably be men who try this on you again after reading about it here.
Don't send tributes (unless that is a fetish of yours)
Don't pick up on the hints that a future "master" has a need for something tangible and you should supply it. (unless it's a special picture of you, or a certain kind of delicacy that is produced where you live.)
And don't "lend" them money either. You won't get it back.



Good advice, I'll follow it. One possibility is that he was BOTH interested in my money and in me. Oh, well, I'll never find out.





AquaticSub -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 12:57:54 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: chase4647


Good advice, I'll follow it. One possibility is that he was BOTH interested in my money and in me. Oh, well, I'll never find out.




Unlikely. But if he was interested in you... how were you going to explain the trip to your wife or were you scamming the guy?




stella41b -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 12:59:49 PM)

Not sure whether it's a scam or not but I feel I can offer some advice in this situation.

Having something online is okay if you're into that sort of thing. But however if you're actually looking for something real time then online is a good enough start, even internationally, but I wouldn't suggest in getting involved in 'real time' issues until you are actually face to face in real time.

What would I define as a real time issue? Well to me money going from one person to another, training between dom and sub, and actually requiring or offering submission.

This obviously doesn't involve gifts, in the commonly accepted understanding of gifts, offered by the donor and accepted by the receiver. Any exchange of anything material based on a request from the receiver is at best a plea for help or charity, but most often a scam.

Yes you can offer your submission online in words only, but it's a promise and a promise is a comfort only to a fool. The same in my opinion can be said about training and any significant emotional commitment.

To me the Internet doesn't change anything, a relationship based on an authority transfer dynamic is one established face to face. Of course you can discuss submission, domination, how your relationship is going to look in reality and even if you like the finer aspects of jiggy jiggy, but until you meet face to face and your words become actions it's still only words and good intentions.

When it's long distance and international I can understand - given the costs involved - some financial arrangement needing to be worked out, but surely we would be talking here only in terms of a flight, visa costs and expenses incurred in obtaining a visa, i.e. the costs involved in two people coming together. But in this situation, if I were the one agreeing to meet certain expenses, I would be looking not to send a money but a ticket for a flight, or to cover the costs of the visa via some sort of online payment. This wouldn't extend to someone's Internet bills, gas bills or household expenses.

Let's face it, the Internet is only a tool for communication, or the gathering or distribution of information between people, or getting to know people. It's not meant to be a life replacement system or even an electronic relationship substitute.




chase4647 -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 1:04:52 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: LafayetteLady

So in a matter of a couple of weeks, you have made a commitment to not one but TWO different masters, identifying yourself as a gay switch, all while being married and keeping this secret from your wife and your only worry here is whether or not this guy in another country is scamming you?

As Aqua pointed out, taking money away from your primary relationship to send to some stranger without the knowledge of your partner is never good.

Further you seem to be confused as to what you want to begin with. You list as a switch, but then apologize for being a "bad slave," because you asked questions and having limits and demands.

You say you have completely new to this. What you need to do is learn a bit more before jumping into anything, especially making commitments to someone in another country while still in a commitment yourself.

Ok, so none of that was about your question. To answer that, YES he was scamming you. You are completely new and have little idea of what you are doing and jumping into multiple relationships at a time. You're an easy mark.


Yeah you're right, as were all of the other ones. In reponse to several people: I was very upfront in all of my contacts through CM that I was married. As for how I deal with my wife, she "knows" about me in general, and told me that I can explore, as long as I don't tell her about it. That's what I am doing. I'd like to share all of this with her -- she is my companion and best friend -- but in order to protect her feelings I can't.


quote:

ORIGINAL: kushiels

My vote goes for scam as well. And as for numbers, I'd be on the opposite end of you--I feel 80% sure it's a scam, and allow for the 20% possibility that I'm wrong, and that he's just unfamiliar with how many of these scams work and didn't realize what a red flag asking for money is.

Him being sincere, and upset about your "demands" isn't something that vetoes that for me--it's enough to make me wonder if I'm wrong, but, again, asking for a couple hundred bucks for his internet connection (how funny that what he really needed the money for is something YOU are invested in as well!), nah, I don't buy it.



I think that makes it unanimous so far. Thanks for still allowing for the 20% probability -- I don't feel so bad then. [:)]




WinsomeDefiance -> RE: What do you think: was this a scam attempt? (2/10/2010 1:09:02 PM)

You know chase (which if you name yourself after a bank....ummm....anyway)  there's nothing wrong wth seeking a professional help.  Seriously.  I'm not being snarky.  I don't mean therapy, but a Pro Domme.  If you are entertaining the option of sending anyone money, at least with a Pro Domme, you get what you negotiated for (usually) and they don't typically care if you are married.  I'd say if it walks like a duck, loooks like a duck and quacks like a duck - its probably a duck, but this is CM - it could be a goose.




Page: [1] 2 3 4 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
8.007813E-02