gungadin09 -> RE: guys suck, but i'm not a man-hating dyke (6/16/2011 6:37:04 PM)
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: HeatherMcLeather ...she says she starts every man she meets off with a blank slate, and lets him prove what sort of man he is...she is willing to give every man she meets a fair chance. Sorry, Hannahlyn and Heather, but i think this "blank slate" idea is bogus, and i'll proceed to explain why. quote:
ORIGINAL: Hannahlyn there's a really good reason so many ex-prostitutes identify as lesbians, and that reason is men. But only the men from their past, right? Only the men that they already know? Only the ones that they have personal experience with? All those johns that come back and try to have meaningful relationships with their hookers? Or are these ex-hookers that foreswear men judging all men by the bad experiences of their past? quote:
ORIGINAL: Hannahlyn ...when they are freed of societal constraints, they are, on the whole, very fucking unpleasant creatures. What is this if not a generalization? quote:
ORIGINAL: Hannahlyn ...trust me ladies, you sure as fuck do not want to know what your loving husbands, sons, and fathers really think of you. Because you've spoken to every husband, son, and father of every woman on this board, and can attest to this from personal experience? OR, are you making a judgement about men you've never met based on your experiences with the ones you have? quote:
ORIGINAL: Hannahlyn i give every man the chance to prove himself, they all start with a clean slate. but when it comes to men i've done my fucking research, and i'm a realist about them, so i really don't expect to fucking much from them." That is NOT the same thing as being "forgiving and optimistic". On the contrary, it's starting out with the full expectation that men will prove to be the overwhelming shits you already suspect that they are. quote:
ORIGINAL: HeatherMcLeather Surely you can't really blame her for being wary, for expecting the worst, given her background. i surely DON'T blame her. But being "wary" and "expecting the worst" from men in general is prejudice, by definition. quote:
ORIGINAL: HeatherMcLeather But equally you can't really call her a man-hater when she so very much wants every man she meets to be one of the good ones. She really would love to be wrong, she just doesn't think she is. The fact that she would love to be wrong but "doesn't think that she is", is another example of prejudice. quote:
ORIGINAL: HeatherMcLeather Because she wants to, she really wants to be able to trust you guys again. Which guys? The guys that she knows from personal experience are shits? Or the male sex in general? If she wants to "learn to trust" men again, it means she doesn't trust them now. i doubt anyone would blame her, but that's called "prejudice". quote:
ORIGINAL: HeatherMcLeather She hates being scared and automatically getting ready to fight or run whenever a man approaches her, she hates that she wears boots, not because she likes them, but because she can hide a knife in them. She usually wears sort of long baggy tops or sweaters so she can hide her pistol, and she hates feeling that she has to do that. She hates the way she nearly panics when I go out without her to protect me. She worries about me when I'm her alone, because she knows from personal experience that a lot of men would be only too willing to take advantage of that. Yeah, you're right. That's a "blank slate", that's being completely open minded and hopeful. quote:
ORIGINAL: HeatherMcLeather So, you see, she really doesn't hate men, she just doesn't trust them. And no wonder, men as a whole have given her no reason to trust them, and every reason not to. But she keeps hoping and she keeps trying. How can you say things like this, and then claim NOT to be generalising? Hannahlyn doesn't trust men, but only the ones she personally knows to be bad, those are the only ones she's judging, right? No. "Men as a whole" have given her a reason not to trust them. And unless she claims to have interacted with every single man on the planet, she is making a judgement about a whole group based on a sample of that group. Which is exactly what so many posters on this thread have had a problem with, not that she judges the ones she already knows. quote:
ORIGINAL: HeatherMcLeather It's really important to me that you see her for what she really is, that you understand why she has such a low opinion of men, and just how hard she is trying to overcome her past and to believe that men can be good and decent people. i think many people will see Hannahlyn in a new light because of this thread. However, one of the things that you've made clear is the fact that she does have a low opinion of men, and not just the ones that she happens to know. The fact that she she does, the fact that she has such difficulty believing that men CAN be decent people, based on her experiences, is exactly the prejudice that people are accusing her of. pam
|
|
|
|