RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion

[Poll]

Do you support a Palestinian State?


Yes
  52% (18)
No
  38% (13)
Unsure
  8% (3)


Total Votes : 34
(last vote on : 9/20/2011 5:36:01 PM)
(Poll will run till: -- )


Message


thompsonx -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 2:06:37 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub

quote:

it would be interesting to see the "big boys" loose their grip on the big stick of the veto.


I would call this agreement...or sort of...you know the answers to questions you give kinda sorta.

quote:

I am not convinced by his arguements as I am not convinced by yours but it would be interesting to see the "big boys" loose their grip on the big stick of the veto.


To trim a quote to change it's meaning is decietful...you are being decietful because you have come to class without doing your homework. If you wish to enter into a discussion, don't you feel it is incumbant upon you to acquaint yourself with the facts of the discussion before you start offering your ignorant,ubsubstantiated and puerile opinon?If you cannot discuss honestly then do not expect me to respond to someone who has both feet in his mouth.



quote:

Please try to disagree with what I say and not what you think you can snark at


Because there is an actual date...use it....

To what purpose? Because you demand it[8|] get over yourself.

Butch





thompsonx -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 2:09:40 PM)

quote:

Im not saying it, an executive commitee member of the Muslim Brotherhood said it.


Richard nixon said "i am not a crook"[8|].Do you believe that?




willbeurdaddy -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 2:43:04 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ashjor911


The Palestinian people come from Palestine,


So they are imaginary? Because Palestine as an autonomous nation is a fiction too.

Muhsein is also dead, but somehow I have to talk with him, but you dont have to talk to Mohammed. It's odd that there isnt a single reference to him being anything but a well respected leader of the MB, the PLO and the Ba'ath party. Why dont you tell us exactly where you got your "crazy" information?

You cant. So sell it to anyone with less half a brain, because fully functioning 6 year olds wouldn't buy the shit youre trying to peddle.

Oh and Im still waiting for that list of non-Zionist media, so we know exactly who is telling the truth (as interpreted by Ashjor).

Oh, and out of curiosity, what does Ashjor mean? And what is the 911 reference in your name?




ashjor911 -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 3:20:43 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: willbeurdaddy


So they are imaginary? Because Palestine as an autonomous nation is a fiction too.

Yeah right..... is this on sale.... dont bother... not buying it.

quote:

ORIGINAL: willbeurdaddy
Muhsein is also dead, but somehow I have to talk with him,

OMG, are you hearing him as well,
FAST DIAL (911) in case you are stroking,
that where 911 came from (I did answere that one as a fromer Firefighter).

quote:

ORIGINAL: willbeurdaddy
but you dont have to talk to Mohammed. It's odd

Its Odd that i am not you, you I mean who can talk to dead people... are you saying that you are jesus?

quote:

ORIGINAL: willbeurdaddy
Why dont you tell us exactly where you got your "crazy" information?

If its crazy, why do you give a shit about it? do you wanna buy it?

quote:

ORIGINAL: willbeurdaddy
You cant. So sell it to anyone with less half a brain, because fully functioning 6 year olds wouldn't buy the shit youre trying to peddle.

I geuss you are not buying after all, its on sale by the way..

quote:

ORIGINAL: willbeurdaddy
Oh and Im still waiting for that list of non-Zionist media, so we know exactly who is telling the truth (as interpreted by Ashjor).


lets name few shall we:
1- al -jazeera.
2- http://www.alquds.co.uk/
3-http://www.spiegel.de/international/

quote:

ORIGINAL: willbeurdaddy
Oh, and out of curiosity, what does Ashjor mean? And what is the 911 reference in your name?


Iam ( Ana) al SHareef ( titile like SIR in uk) Who hails from a dynasty of the JORdanian royale Blood line.
911 for a former firefither, as a call of help.

in case you curios about my penis size as well , 9 inches.
balls weight: 300 grams for each.

Do you want to ask me any other questions not related to the subject? or you want to skip the personal (get to know me ) crap,




Anaxagoras -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 4:59:56 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ashjor911
quote:

ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras
You were talking about a broader place but the thread is about Palestine so thats what I referred to when mentioning the Islamic capital of the region. The Romans first used the name after the Bar Kokhba revolt in 135 AD which Arabs adapted to Filistin so it was also a distinctive place. Ramla is still lived in today but is smaller that Jerusalem at this stage.

yes, Ramla is still lived in today but is smaller that Jerusalem at this stage, but it was not the Islamic capital of the region.
the name (Ramla) without THE means (the small round grain of sand). which is arabic but also its in the Modern arabic accent,
the name almost 200 years old (as theModern arabic accent) , which means it has some other roman name, & it was not the Islamic capital.

actually there was not any other Islamic capital other than (Madeina, Damascus, bagdad) the rest were just cities or towns,
& they uesd to put some one incharge for some cities like (al-Basra, al-kofa (iraq) ) & I really dont remember that there was a (wally) on Ramla,

It was formerly known as al-Ramleh with variations of the spelling. It was founded at the start of the 8th Century and became important as a trading route with Cairo. Just do a google search of "Ramla capitol". Here are a few examples:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramla
http://www.travelujah.com/blogs.php?action=show_member_post&ownerID=598&post_id=596
http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Archaeology/Ramla.html

quote:


PS: you know that there are some people who can change whats on (wikipedia.org) as you can see the ([edit]) before every thing. the (some people) I am referring to are powerfull, & got the media in the US, (Zionists) you dont think they would actually build (wikipedia.org) based on their only side of the story?
for that I will ask you nicely for a more (reliable) proof for your claim, which is:
quote:

That is the correct term in old use which I referred to but it refers to the Jewish Temple Mount


Wiki is of course not 100% reliable but it is usually OK for basic facts. WIth contentious political issues it is dubious. Contrary to what you claim wiki has been shown to be more sympathetic to Palestinianism because it is a popular movement so the number of users inputing data from that stance are greater. Here is an example documenting a quite well known case on wiki: http://frontpagemag.com/2010/07/13/wikipedias-jewish-problem/

Here is one source - a book that refers to the meaning: and another that refers to the temple rather than a mosque. Thats why the translation "The City of the Temple" is relevant




ashjor911 -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 5:35:32 PM)

First,
Its just was not (Islamic capital) not now, not in the past, not ever, no matter who build it ( first they were the romans " in earlier post of you" now its was umyaaden chalifat) ....

second,
بيت المقدس= the home of holyness= Jerusalem,
بيت= home, house, the land of.
المقدس =anything holy, holyness,
not the Temple
I know my first languge better than you do..... get over it.

about the Wiki, maybe your right, (maybe), not in the mood for googleing anything now
but here is something for you,
& this can not be 100% reliable, but that city Real name is (UrShalim)....

quote:

What is UrShalim
Contrary to the Arrogant Zionist claim that the Apartheid State of "Israel" invented the name "UrShalim", the fact is that this name is so ancient, it even predates Judaism. And it certainly is many thousand years older than any Racist Zionist.

"Ur" is an Aramaic word for city. "Shalim" means peace. Salam in Arabic. "Ur-Shalim" is then the "City of Peace" (Madinat al Salam). It is the ancient name of Jerusalem or Al-Quds.


http://urshalim.blogspot.com/




thompsonx -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 5:50:45 PM)

quote:

Dear clueless troll, if you don't know what relative humidity means and where Giza is and where the Aswan Dam is you should shut the fuck up.

You said

quote:

The evidence strongly suggests that the area has had very low humidity since thing slike the Luxor temple was built and that since the Aswan Dam was completed the humidity level has risen and those hieroglyhs have dramatically faded. You will of course contest those facts so I'll simply direct you to contact the Oriental Institute at the University of Chicago and bother them with your clueless nonsense.


My cite shows that you were mistaken about the "very low humidty". So it would appear that you are the "clueless troll who should shut the fuck up"



BTW your own link says increased humidity at Giza has caused damage to the Giza monuments.
quote:

In our case the increased relative humidity over Giza during recent years due to urbanization processes, as mentioned above,

My cite, which you quote, states unequivocally that the increased humidity is caused by urbanization not the aswan dam as you claim...once again someone other than myself is the "clueless troll who sould shut the fuck up"

causes various harmful effects on its historical places and important monuments whereas the mineral composition of stone monuments has been changed due to hydration processes.




pahunkboy -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 5:55:43 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras

quote:

ORIGINAL: ashjor911
quote:

ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras
You were talking about a broader place but the thread is about Palestine so thats what I referred to when mentioning the Islamic capital of the region. The Romans first used the name after the Bar Kokhba revolt in 135 AD which Arabs adapted to Filistin so it was also a distinctive place. Ramla is still lived in today but is smaller that Jerusalem at this stage.

yes, Ramla is still lived in today but is smaller that Jerusalem at this stage, but it was not the Islamic capital of the region.
the name (Ramla) without THE means (the small round grain of sand). which is arabic but also its in the Modern arabic accent,
the name almost 200 years old (as theModern arabic accent) , which means it has some other roman name, & it was not the Islamic capital.

actually there was not any other Islamic capital other than (Madeina, Damascus, bagdad) the rest were just cities or towns,
& they uesd to put some one incharge for some cities like (al-Basra, al-kofa (iraq) ) & I really dont remember that there was a (wally) on Ramla,

It was formerly known as al-Ramleh with variations of the spelling. It was founded at the start of the 8th Century and became important as a trading route with Cairo. Just do a google search of "Ramla capitol". Here are a few examples:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramla
http://www.travelujah.com/blogs.php?action=show_member_post&ownerID=598&post_id=596
http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Archaeology/Ramla.html

quote:


PS: you know that there are some people who can change whats on (wikipedia.org) as you can see the ([edit]) before every thing. the (some people) I am referring to are powerfull, & got the media in the US, (Zionists) you dont think they would actually build (wikipedia.org) based on their only side of the story?
for that I will ask you nicely for a more (reliable) proof for your claim, which is:
quote:

That is the correct term in old use which I referred to but it refers to the Jewish Temple Mount


Wiki is of course not 100% reliable but it is usually OK for basic facts. WIth contentious political issues it is dubious. Contrary to what you claim wiki has been shown to be more sympathetic to Palestinianism because it is a popular movement so the number of users inputing data from that stance are greater. Here is an example documenting a quite well known case on wiki: http://frontpagemag.com/2010/07/13/wikipedias-jewish-problem/

Here is one source - a book that refers to the meaning: and another that refers to the temple rather than a mosque. Thats why the translation "The City of the Temple" is relevant



Well- use a good source!   Like the King James Bible.




Anaxagoras -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 6:07:01 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ashjor911
First,
Its just was not (Islamic capital) not now, not in the past, not ever, no matter who build it ( first they were the romans " in earlier post of you" now its was umyaaden chalifat) ....

I never said the Romans built it. I said the Romans were the ones who used the word "Palestine" which the Arabs adapted to "Filistin" - this point was made on the previous page (Post 47). I said the Muslim Arabs built the city although if I remember correctly there was a small settlement there previously but that is how it is with most cities.

quote:


second,
بيت المقدس= the home of holyness= Jerusalem,
بيت= home, house, the land of.
المقدس =anything holy, holyness,
not the Temple
I know my first languge better than you do..... get over it.

about the Wiki, maybe your right, (maybe), not in the mood for googleing anything now
but here is something for you,
& this can not be 100% reliable, but that city Real name is (UrShalim)....

Ash, I know only a few Arabic words. I don't claim to speak it at all so I would defer to what you say except that the sources I listed back up what I read about the old Arabic word meaning "City of the Temple". Otherwise I would take your word for it.

quote:

quote:

What is UrShalim
Contrary to the Arrogant Zionist claim that the Apartheid State of "Israel" invented the name "UrShalim", the fact is that this name is so ancient, it even predates Judaism. And it certainly is many thousand years older than any Racist Zionist.

"Ur" is an Aramaic word for city. "Shalim" means peace. Salam in Arabic. "Ur-Shalim" is then the "City of Peace" (Madinat al Salam). It is the ancient name of Jerusalem or Al-Quds.


http://urshalim.blogspot.com/

The seems to be similarity between Ur-sha-lim and Jer-us-alem. Some Arabic and Aramaic words are similar as far as I know. There is a view about how urshalim as a word came about in Arabic use to actually express Israeli control of Jerusalem which contradicts what you say but might like anyway: http://friendsofopenhouse.co.il/default.php?pagenum=24




ashjor911 -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 6:40:52 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras

Ash, I know only a few Arabic words. I don't claim to speak it at all so I would defer to what you say except that the sources I listed back up what I read about the old Arabic word meaning "City of the Temple". Otherwise I would take your word for it.


you can read whatever you want, no matter if its true or not,
I read a book about yoga good ....etc
you read a book about yoga sucks .... etc,
we can argue abut that,
one may convence the other, or we both have a mind of a rock, & that would never happen.

but I can not read a book about walking on the fire bare-foot, & talk you into it.....

"City of the Temple" translation ( not from google)
City=مدينة
Temple= معبد
the = ال
مدينة المعبد = may be a any sort of temple, (fire temple fot old persians)
however, "City of the Temple" means not Jerusalem, actually, I think you came up with it.

quote:

ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras
The seems to be similarity between Ur-sha-lim and Jer-us-alem. Some Arabic and Aramaic words are similar as far as I know. There is a view about how urshalim as a word came about in Arabic use to actually express Israeli control of Jerusalem which contradicts what you say but might like anyway: http://friendsofopenhouse.co.il/default.php?pagenum=24


some words are the same, maybe, but not this one.
arabic name for "UrShalim" is (Al-Quds)
the only thing is that Q dose not Pronounce as Q in arabic, not even close.

PS: you know where I live, which means I can not view pages had (.il) in it.




pahunkboy -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 7:02:54 PM)

OPEN HOUSE Ramle was founded in 1991 to further peace and coexistence among Israeli Arabs and Jews. This Project was created as a result of a unique encounter, in July 1967, between the Arab family that lived in the house before 1948 and the Jewish family that came to inhabit it afterwards. As a result of an ongoing relationship, the two families decided to dedicate the house they both called home to the children of Ramle.




ashjor911 -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 7:09:04 PM)

you may wanna watch this one first,
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1366409/




pahunkboy -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 7:16:54 PM)

Dont mind Anax.   He has a hard time getting along with people.   Mostly his ego. 




tweakabelle -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 7:20:35 PM)

The West-Eastern Divan Orchestra, founded by the wonderful Israeli pianist/conductor Daniel Barenboim and the late Palestinian intellectual/political activist Edward Said is inspirational. Check it out here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West-Eastern_Divan_(orchestra)

There's an interesting interview with Bareboim about the orchestra here:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/music/proms/6055045/West-Eastern-Divan-Orchestra-interview-with-Daniel-Barenboim-for-the-BBC-Proms.html




Anaxagoras -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 7:34:11 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: ashjor911
quote:

ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras
Ash, I know only a few Arabic words. I don't claim to speak it at all so I would defer to what you say except that the sources I listed back up what I read about the old Arabic word meaning "City of the Temple". Otherwise I would take your word for it.

you can read whatever you want, no matter if its true or not,
I read a book about yoga good ....etc
you read a book about yoga sucks .... etc,
we can argue abut that,
one may convence the other, or we both have a mind of a rock, & that would never happen.

but I can not read a book about walking on the fire bare-foot, & talk you into it.....

Ash you are the one who has swallowed the old PLO propaganda about the Jews not having any connection with Jerusalem. That ignores the immense history these people have. When talking to you I never presumed I could convince you of anything. I appreciate you live in a certain culture which has tought you very negative things about Jewish people.

quote:


"City of the Temple" translation ( not from google)
City=مدينة
Temple= معبد
the = ال
مدينة المعبد = may be a any sort of temple, (fire temple fot old persians)
however, "City of the Temple" means not Jerusalem, actually, I think you came up with it.

Ash you are just being silly about this. I quoted the wiki source, which clearly makes that point and you refused to accept it. I then linked you to two books which feature on Google and still you are not happy. Then you imagine I invented the theory!!! The name Beyt al Makdess refers to Jerusalem, and it refers to it being a City of the Temple as numerous sources point out. The first book I linked to was about the site itself. The second book about Islamic sites. It has to be an explicit reference to the Temple Mount because loads of cities had temples but the Temple in Jerusalem was even at that time a historically famous building which the Romans had destroyed to humiliate the Jews. Then there is the similarity of Islam to Judaism making it important in that respect. It was central to Jewish faith in the way Mecca is to the Muslims. Jews actually face it when praying in Jerusalem.

quote:

quote:

ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras
The seems to be similarity between Ur-sha-lim and Jer-us-alem. Some Arabic and Aramaic words are similar as far as I know. There is a view about how urshalim as a word came about in Arabic use to actually express Israeli control of Jerusalem which contradicts what you say but might like anyway: http://friendsofopenhouse.co.il/default.php?pagenum=24

some words are the same, maybe, but not this one.
arabic name for "UrShalim" is (Al-Quds)
the only thing is that Q dose not Pronounce as Q in arabic, not even close.

I was talking about the connection between Urshalim and Jerusalem rather than al-Quds. Urshalim was what you were referring to and I thought they had a phonetic similarity.

In the link it is said the Israeli authorities wanted Ur-Shalim Al-Quds to be used by the State itself when using the Arabic.

quote:


PS: you know where I live, which means I can not view pages had (.il) in it.

Thats unfortunate for reasons I probably shouldn't mention just in case it gets you into trouble but you can probably guess.




Anaxagoras -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 7:37:44 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: pahunkboy
Dont mind Anax.   He has a hard time getting along with people.   Mostly his ego. 

PA your sniping is getting tiresome. I was just talking with Ash, and there were no insults but you keep butting in with remarks that don't add anything to the points being made.




pahunkboy -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 7:50:12 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras

quote:

ORIGINAL: pahunkboy
Dont mind Anax.   He has a hard time getting along with people.   Mostly his ego. 

PA your sniping is getting tiresome. I was just talking with Ash, and there were no insults but you keep butting in with remarks that don't add anything to the points being made.



WRONG




Anaxagoras -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 7:53:34 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: pahunkboy
quote:

ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras
quote:

ORIGINAL: pahunkboy
Dont mind Anax.   He has a hard time getting along with people.   Mostly his ego. 

PA your sniping is getting tiresome. I was just talking with Ash, and there were no insults but you keep butting in with remarks that don't add anything to the points being made.

WRONG

I told you before you need to justify yourself if you disagree with others. If I am wrong point out where you have made a worthwhile comment about the particular topic myself and Ash were discussing.




ashjor911 -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 8:20:25 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras

Ash you are the one who has swallowed the old PLO propaganda about the Jews not having any connection with Jerusalem. That ignores the immense history these people have. When talking to you I never presumed I could convince you of anything. I appreciate you live in a certain culture which has tought you very negative things about Jewish people.


I think I did make this clear once before, here we go again,
I dont have anything with the Jewish faith or the Jewish people,
I dont hate them, but I dont love them either, I respect them & their faith,
I respect that I swear to god.

but for the love whatever is holy for you stop beeing so personal, trying to fix me, I am not broken,
we agree on something, its perfectly helthy for us to be disagreeing on something else.

about the PLO, the PLO toke something away from me, & I hate them for that, I dont like them,
I hate them, & I whish that there was someone else than "abbas" in that chair now,
but I always loved arafat, for many years,


quote:

ORIGINAL: Anaxagoras
Ash you are just being silly about this. I quoted the wiki source, which clearly makes that point and you refused to accept it. I then linked you to two books which feature on Google and still you are not happy. Then you imagine I invented the theory!!! The name Beyt al Makdess refers to Jerusalem, and it refers to it being a City of the Temple as numerous sources point out. The first book I linked to was about the site itself. The second book about Islamic sites. It has to be an explicit reference to the Temple Mount because loads of cities had temples but the Temple in Jerusalem was even at that time a historically famous building which the Romans had destroyed to humiliate the Jews. Then there is the similarity of Islam to Judaism making it important in that respect. It was central to Jewish faith in the way Mecca is to the Muslims. Jews actually face it when praying in Jerusalem.


you gave me 2 books,
I guess you read them, yes?
that is my whole point, just because someone wrote something dose not make it right,
psst: the arabs came after the 1st & the 2nd temple, so they did not see any temples at all "when the came"
which means, the name is not translated correctly in other words ( the books are wrong) unless they wore wrote by some Zionist which make the completely wrong.
PS: Zionist dose not mean to be Jewish,
FYI: there some "arabs" who happend to be Zionist..

Jerusalem & Urshalim have no phonetic similarity what so ever, for Gods sake................... sing them.

Last smoke for the day 6:20 am local, & off to bed




TheHeretic -> RE: Do you support a Palestinian State? (9/20/2011 8:42:31 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Iamsemisweet

Do you believe Israel has the obligation to treat their neighbors in a neighborly fashion? And why do you believe the have the right to exist on that piece of ground? Do you think there are limits an israels right to expand?



quote:

ORIGINAL: 
Would it not follow that israel should act in a neighborly fashion?



To the question that matches, I would certainly hope so.  They seemed to be getting along with Egypt, until the recent diplomatic unpleasantness.

Iam, your last question sounds like a good topic for the table.

Why there?  Because the the Jews were scattered from that land a couple thousand years ago.  Somehow, they remained a people, retained a culture, withstood centuries, and cycles of persecution, ultimately 'luxuriated in the swimming pools of Aushwitz,' said "fuck this," and were able to re-occupy and conquer what the empires had kicked them off of, way back when.  I don't know that being one of God's Chosen People is all that wonderful all the time, but it seems to be worth something.

I'm all for a peaceful solution that the people can not only live with, but prosper by.  I don't much care what form it takes, but until that day comes, I'm pretty much going to back Israel, even when they make rough decisions.



Edited for big whoops




Page: <<   < prev  1 2 3 [4] 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875