dcnovice
Posts: 37282
Joined: 8/2/2006 Status: offline
|
quote:
Black realignment occured mostly under the new deal. From what I've read, it sounds like African Americans began voting (when they could) Democratic in FDR's day but didn't identify themselves as Democrats till later. quote:
The trends are not endemic to blacks - but they are far more severe in the black population. Any theories why? quote:
While it is true that Democrats and Republicans have alternated control, republicans have passed virtually no social legislation that "advanced' civil rights. So this entire social direction we've been taking is following a democrat pied-piper. When you say "civil rights," do you mean things like desegregation and voting rights? Or are you talking about economic programs, which are different and apply to the whole population? quote:
It was a republican president and a republican congress that passed the 13-15th amendments. It was the republican party that was specifically formed as an abolitionist party. And lynchings etc occurred under DEMOCRAT governors, not republicans, in the 1870's - 1900s. Very true. It took Democrats far too long to see the light. And it wasn't easy. As LBJ said after signing one of the civil rights bills, "We've just lost the South for a generation." The GOP, interestingly, launched its "Southern Strategy" at the same time. I wonder what Charles Sumner or Thaddeus Stevens would have made of that. quote:
regarding economic segregation: The democrats didn't bring about economic segregation. They promulgated policies that designed to end it. De facto (as opposed to de jure) segregation continues to exist despite flushing trillions of dollars down this pipedream. I'm not sure it was all a "pipe dream." quote:
Let me give you a small example. I understand the unintended consequences of the minimum wage (though I'm not sure I've ever heard them articulated by someone living on it), but it seems an odd example of economic segregation. Doesn't segregation mean living and working apart? quote:
How is it that the illegal immigrant community - works without the benefit of a minimum wage do you suppose. And millions of them have gone on to own homes. Put kids through college. Should blacks use illegal immigrants as role models then? More seriously, their buying homes and sending kids to college seems more like integration than segregation. * * * I'm intrigued by the one question of mine that you didn't answer: Were blacks, as you seemed to be arguing, better off in 1900?
_____________________________
No matter how cynical you become, it's never enough to keep up. JANE WAGNER, THE SEARCH FOR SIGNS OF INTELLIGENT LIFE IN THE UNIVERSE
|