RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


knees2you -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/19/2006 10:37:29 PM)

We're all Desendents of Apes anyway right?

quote:

"If a Snake bites[sm=banghead.gif] before it is Charmed, there is no profit for the Charmer." 

 
Antt, & LilBecque[sm=news.gif]




Lordandmaster -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/19/2006 10:38:06 PM)

Why do Christians PERSIST in misunderstanding evolution?




knees2you -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/19/2006 10:58:30 PM)

quote:

Why do Christians PERSIST in misunderstanding evolution?


Hey I know about Evolution.
 
Why do Scientists keep looking for the Monkey, Ape,
Human Connection?
 
quote:

Maybe it has to do with Your picture of Elephants?
[sm=biggrin.gif]

 
Ant, & LilBecque[sm=news.gif]




caitlyn -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 7:30:26 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Lordandmaster
Did your boyfriend dump you or something today?


It's a topic I feel strongly about, and expressed a strong opinion.
 
Nice to know how concerned you are though.[8|] It's true, I've been through a rediculous number of boyfriends in the past few years. I would estimate around fifty.
 
Clearly, either them or me has some issues to work out. [;)]




Arpig -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 9:38:47 AM)

Caitlyn's opinion is based on a review of the historical evidence, the track record of immigrants as opposed to uninformed finger-pointing. Illegal immigrants are breaking the law, and until that law is changed it should be enforced. Any attempt to blame any economic ills on legal immigrants is farcical and completely inane.




popeye1250 -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 10:16:48 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Sinergy

quote:

ORIGINAL: popeye1250

quote:

ORIGINAL: Sinergy


Hello A/all,

I was having a discussion on the phone with strumpet a while ago talking about the job market in that part of the state of California she lives in.  Apparently, there are some jobs like picking spinach and scooping cow manure that dont pay particularly well and no American citizen wants to do them.

I pointed out to her that Cesar Chavez and the grape growers in California faced similar issues 60-80 years ago and they got around it by unionizing and demanding better working conditions for migrant workers.

United we bargain, divided we beg.

Just me, could be wrong, but there you go.

Sinergy



Sinergy, I agree. Years ago I was in a Union.
The problem is that everyone wants help but they don't want to pay the working man or woman anymore.
They want to drive Mercedes Benz's instead of Cadilacs.
In Capitalism if you can't find help you raise the pay rates until you can, not hire people who are in our country illegally at lower rates!
We're supposed to be a Capitalistic country but only the rich are doing well and they're doing well because they're breaking our laws!


It is not only that, popeye.

There is no actual law that says Pacific Bell cannot move their customer support center to Mumbai.

There is no actual law that says that Ford cannot have their cars made in China.

With NAFTA and CAFTA in place, there is no law that says that Dell cannot move their factories to Mexico.

To me, the issue is not about what is legal, the issue is about what is right.

Auto manufacturers in this country started to show a severe lag in auto sales around the time the Clinton era of prosperity was gutted by Monkeyboy and all those Americans now found their jobs disappearing.  Happily, McDonalds was there to keep them out of the unemployed statistics so the people in Dumbfuckistan could believe that Monkeyboy was doing a bang-up job.  But McDonalds does not pay enough to buy either a Cadillac made in China or a Mercedes Benz made in Alabama.

The reality of the situation is that when the investor money fled from the IT industry, and the jobs were offshored to Mumbai, all those people who were previously making nice wages doing computer jobs could no longer afford to buy cars, or computers, or go on vacations, or whatever.  When auto manufacturers broke their unions, and cut the wages of the workers, these workers could no longer afford to buy things.  When steel mills closed and left it up to China and Korea to make steel products for pennies on the dollar, all those people who had high paying jobs to support their families were now SOL.

Our prosperity was built on the backs of the people of America who worked for a living and built a strong economy.  This has since been coopted by a bunch of greedy multinationalists who really dont care whether you or I starve as long as they get rich off it.

I was chatting with somebody a while ago who said that the older he got, the more the logic of "Compost the Rich" came unbidden to his mind.

Just me, could be wrong, but there you go.

Sinergy



Sinergy, very well said and I couldn't agree with you more!
As Julia said a while back only big business people were involved in that "NAFTA" We really do need to get out of that!
Twelve years now and it has turned out to be a MAJOR misstake!
I have no problem with a company moving overseas but if they do they should forfeit any right to sell or do any business in the U.S. (Ha, Ha) Funny, they want to move overseas and take all their jobs and equipment with them but they STILL think they should be able to have access to our market!




caitlyn -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 11:44:24 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: popeye1250
I have no problem with a company moving overseas but if they do they should forfeit any right to sell or do any business in the U.S. (Ha, Ha) Funny, they want to move overseas and take all their jobs and equipment with them but they STILL think they should be able to have access to our market!


So, you want to deny American business a low income labor pool by strangling immigrant workers, AND deny them the ability to go overseas to get a low income labor pool while still having access to American markets?
 
Seriously question ... totally not meant to be snarky. I'm willing to be open minded, but I just can't see how this would be anything but a disaster for American business, and even worse for American consumers. What good would job protectionism do, if everything costs twice as much?
 
Perhaps someone can respond and explain it ... I'm very interested in this topic.




popeye1250 -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 12:11:18 PM)

Catlyn, if there is no more middle class in the U.S. who are these businesses going to sell their products to?
People who make $30-$40 per hour buy houses, cars, furniture, appliances and many other things.
People who make $9 per hour don't buy much of anything!
Big business wants to have their cake and eat it too.
And they don't think they should have any loyalty to America but only to their bottom line. But, individuals are expected to be loyal to America even to the point of giving their lives for their country and the "interests" of Big Business in foreign countries? (Exon/Mobil)
If a company moves from the U.S. to a cheap labor foreign country like in the case of Hanes underware co (and many others) I'm just not going to buy their products anymore.
Lou Dobbs has a list of such companies and I don't do business with any of them.
It's an Irish term called "Boycott".
You're a math major, right?
Ever study Economics?




Lordandmaster -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 12:27:38 PM)

Caitlyn, if you want to understand why people think of you as an uppity college student who thinks she knows everything and really doesn't know anything, just take this statement to one of your economics professors and ask him to explain to you why it's wrong.

I'll give you a hint.  Paying for healthcare is not cheaper than shipping parts to and from Mexico.  Not even close.  But your college teacher will have to fill in the rest for you.

quote:

ORIGINAL: caitlyn

If we had low income workers, there would be huge numbers of factory type jobs, and these companies would pay for healthcare for these workers, because paying for healthcare for workers is far cheaper than shipping parts to assemble a Ford, in from Mexico.




defiantbadgirl -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 1:20:44 PM)

Well said popeye1250. I've been trying to tell everyone on here the same thing about the devistating job losses of outsourcing and immigration. Outsourcing might have caused more job loss than immigration, but immigration is still causing some of it. I even had one person ask me if I could prove what I thought was common knowledge. I know a guy who's job is to get rid of American IT workers and replace them with immigrants with B1 Visas. I asked him why he would do such a thing and he said it was the only stable IT job he could find. I've also read forums with entry after entry from outraged IT workers. Doesn't that prove something? Anyway, I'm glad to know someone on here can see what's plain as day.




caitlyn -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 1:20:56 PM)

I never really expected you to join the ranks of the personal attackers.
 
It is good to know what people think of me though.




popeye1250 -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 1:27:17 PM)

Caitlyn, I'm glad you're a math major and not an economics major.

Defiant, illegal aliens have the affect of lowering wages for working people.
Now, if we had 20 million lawyers or doctors sneaking into this country and lowering wages in those professions how long do you think that would last?




defiantbadgirl -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 1:29:35 PM)

Caitlyn, I can answer your question about everything not being made overseas costing too much. We had a discussion about this very issue in my American Government class. People who are either unemployed or forced to work for minimum wage won't even have the money to buy the cheaper products, much less pay their heating bills. If you want a cheaper economy, you should start pressuring the utility companies to lower their prices instead of relying on immigration.




MistressCamille -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 1:49:19 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: defiantbadgirl

Well said popeye1250. I've been trying to tell everyone on here the same thing about the devistating job losses of outsourcing and immigration. Outsourcing might have caused more job loss than immigration, but immigration is still causing some of it. I even had one person ask me if I could prove what I thought was common knowledge.


And you avoided giving that proof too!




defiantbadgirl -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 2:07:17 PM)

There you are. If immigration doesn't cause job loss, then why are there people making a living firing American workers and replacing them with immigrants? When I asked this person why he would do this, I was told it was the only IT job he could get that he doesn't have to worry about losing. In order for anyone to make a living that way, it would have to happen quite frequently don't ya think? What about all those threads I read of outraged IT workers either being unemployed or having to work for a fraction of what they used to make? Meanwhile, I don't see utility companies lowering their rates due to immigration. I don't see the cost of rent going down. Immigration is just causing companies to lower employee's wages while the rest of the economy isn't lowering prices to match these salary reductions. What do you think the end result will be?




defiantbadgirl -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 2:12:50 PM)

I think the fact that people make a living putting americans out of jobs and replacing them with immigrants is plenty of proof. I seriously doubt every one of those IT workers in the forum I read were lying. More proof?




Lordandmaster -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 2:21:17 PM)

Yeah, whatever, but don't forget to ask your teacher whether paying for healthcare is cheaper than shipping parts to and from Mexico.

quote:

ORIGINAL: caitlyn

I never really expected you to join the ranks of the personal attackers.
 
It is good to know what people think of me though.




defiantbadgirl -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 2:33:00 PM)

It doesn't matter what's cheaper. It's about people keeping their jobs and not having to choose between paying rent, the heating bill, or food for their families. Oh, I guess if a person worked at McDonalds they could sneak home leftovers.......until they got caught.........then they wouldn't even be making minimum wage. Never mind that they used to make 50K a year and have a college degree. Cheap is important, but there's something else that's even more important........the American people.




Lordandmaster -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 2:43:11 PM)

I don't disagree with you, but you're confusing a lot of different things.  Corporations aren't in charge of doing what's best for the American people.  They never have been and never will be.  Corporations do what earns a profit, because if they don't, the shareholders oust the decision-makers and install new ones.  If a corporation finds that, when all is said and done, one way to do things is cheaper than another way, they're going to do it the cheaper way.  If corporate business practices harm the American people, then it's up to the American people, through their elected representatives, to put an end to what's happening.

Also, I'm talking specifically about caitlyn's statement that paying for healthcare is cheaper for an employer than shipping parts to and from Mexico.  It's about as wrong as can be.  And it's not one of those wrong statements that's just trivially wrong; it's like arch-wrong, because it's wrong about the most important thing you can be wrong about.  It's like you're talking about seventy-seven step problem, and ... BAM, you're wrong at Step One.  I took the liberty of pointing this out because it's typical of caitlyn; she has this habit of concocting grand and utterly unrealistic programs for the reformation of all mankind, and then criticizes other people for failing to offer "solutions."  I regret that many people will agree with me when I say that she needs to learn a lot more about how the world works before she takes up the pretense that she can solve the world's problems and everyone else is a dumass.




defiantbadgirl -> RE: WELCOME NEW AMERICANS! (10/20/2006 2:58:51 PM)

Thanks for clarifying that. I knew her statement had to be wrong. As for me confusing things, I know big businesses aren't out to protect the American people, but I also know the government isn't either or they would have done something about the problem instead of letting a few protesting immigrants scare them. On second thought, maybe they're afraid to do anything because there are too many immigrants that might implement a terrorist attack. In that case, while taking care of Iraq, the US government has lost control of our own country.




Page: <<   < prev  7 8 [9] 10 11   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
2.929688E-02