A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


TheHeretic -> A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 7:49:00 PM)

        ATLANTA, Georgia (CNN) -- A Pakistani man accused of killing his daughter because she wanted out of an arranged marriage told a judge Tuesday that he had done nothing wrong.
 
 
http://www.cnn.com/2008/CRIME/07/08/honor.killing/index.html?eref=rss_latest


        Yep.  Right here in the good old US of A. 




AquaticSub -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 7:51:51 PM)

http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9D0CE7D81231F93BA15753C1A967958260&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=1

This is one I always found creepy. If the FBI hadn't been convinced to release the tapes, the parents may have gotten away with it.




PanthersMom -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 8:25:53 PM)

we had a similar incident here a few years back involving an honor killing of a young lady from lakewood ohio. her cousins i believe were the ones who were convicted.  they picked her up right after work and murdered her, tried to make it look like she'd been robbed.  it makes me sick to think of all the women and girls who have suffered this fate for the "honor" of their families.  it's honorable to murder your child rather than let her marry for love?  that's just plain screwed up thinking!
PM




TheHeretic -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 8:38:12 PM)

        These women have been collateral damage of our desire not to "offend" members of certain nameless cultures for far too long.

       Perhaps with a change in our political power structure, the willfull (criminal?) blindness of people who ought to care about this will end.




slvemike4u -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 8:43:57 PM)

This is an abberation and a mutilation of something called faith,to ascribe a monopoly to one religion is to kid ourselves.All the worlds major religion's have a fringe element that insists on a fundemental and extreme view of their respective faith...it is ugly and perverted no matter the genisis




jlf1961 -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 8:51:21 PM)

If I may interject, the victims of rape up until the early part of this century in many countries were often convicted of 'contributing,' including the United States.

It was legal in many states for the father of a girl to kill both the daughter and the boy she ran off with if he had disapproved of young man in question.  However, if the son ran off with a girl the family did not approve of, the family could legally deal with the woman in the most expediant fashion possible.

The dodging of arranged marriages in the middle ages and early years of the European Expansion was also grounds for the execution of both parties.  This was the custom up until the late 16th and early 17th centuries.  In some countries, the laws stayed on the books until the 18th century.

Please note, these all were western countries.

However, in order to avoid dishonoring the family name, and in many cases with the help of an understanding older sibling or mother, the young bride was given a concoction that would prevent the groom (arranged marraiges usually involved girls in their early teens and very mature individuals) from being able to perform his husbandly rights, thus rendering the marraige null and void, the girl received a substantial sum of money from the old guy, and she and the guy she really wanted went their merry way.

There was always the chance that too much would be given and the poor groom would suffer a heart attack.  If forensic science had been around back then, a lot of young brides would have gone to the gallows.  However, since poisoning could not be proved, the girl gained an  inheritance and still got the guy she wanted, (one way to have your cake and eat it too.)

After it was deemed illegal to kill your daughter for disobeying the family in such matters, it was allowed for the father to sell the child into slavery.  If she was a fair wench, the highest bidder was usually the owner of the local brothel.  He in turn would offer the girls beloved the chance to buy her contract, and thus save her from a life of shame.

So Islamic tradition still has the sell the girl into slavery period to go through before they hit the modern era, figure another 300 years.

I guess the plains indians were a bit more to the point, they just put a mark on the girls nose, showing she was a woman of no virtue.

I am not trying to belittle the atrocities committed in the name of honor, but I am pointing out the muslims were not the only ones to do this.  Our own western culture was guilty of it too.

Honor does not have to be defended. Robert J. Sawyer




TheHeretic -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 9:06:00 PM)

        All of which makes it perfectly acceptable to ignore it in the present?

      Maybe the tide is starting to turn a fraction.  Maybe what a lot of people have been willing to drop down the values heirarchy is beginning to rise.  This one is Huffington.  Maybe it's ok to be a little outraged?

http://news.yahoo.com/s/huffpost/20080709/cm_huffpost/111549;_ylt=Aq.YaeU6wn.Ldz3o.iVe4hsd6sgF


    




jlf1961 -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 9:15:32 PM)

I never said not to be outraged or ignore it.  At least in this country, we will deal with the ones who commit these crimes in an orderly fashion, unless some screwball gets the supreme court to make it legal.




DomAviator -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 9:21:14 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slvemike4u

This is an abberation and a mutilation of something called faith,to ascribe a monopoly to one religion is to kid ourselves.All the worlds major religion's have a fringe element that insists on a fundemental and extreme view of their respective faith...it is ugly and perverted no matter the genisis


Yeah thats right Mike the Baptists are well known for their honor killings LMFAO And theres nothing like those Burkah wearing pentecostal women being beaten with a cane for having their ankle showing...

I swear to god does PC prohibit speaking truth?? Name ONE other religion that requires honor killing Mike?

Jesus Christ they are gonna need a lot of busses to the DNC, since they will be using the short ones....




DomAviator -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 9:50:37 PM)

jlf - remember in your other thread you wanted to be called out on things which might diminish your ability to get laid? Post #6 will not only keep panties firmly in place, the woman will probably pull them up to just under her armpits and then have them stapled to her lest you get them off... Seriously dude, you just knocked off about 40 points on the fuckability scale with that.... Just calling it out as you asked....




N4SDChastity -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 10:03:11 PM)

Inconvenient truths are still, by definition, truths.  Stating historical facts in no way takes away from the realities or the need to bring other cultures into mondernist thinking.  It just make your high-horse a little less so.  Your soap-box one slat shorter.  Continue with your righteous indignation, and I will proudly stand beside you and exhort just as loudly as you, but I will do it with my feet firmly planted on the ground.




slaveboyforyou -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 10:08:24 PM)

quote:

It was legal in many states for the father of a girl to kill both the daughter and the boy she ran off with if he had disapproved of young man in question.  However, if the son ran off with a girl the family did not approve of, the family could legally deal with the woman in the most expediant fashion possible.


Jlf, this is absolutely not true.  It's never been legal in any state of the United States to kill anyone because you disapproved of their affair.  The United States has never sanctioned vigilantism or allowed honor killings by law.  Yes, murders happened because of these circumstance, and I'm sure many fathers got away with it.  But the law has never allowed them in our entire history as a nation. 

quote:

After it was deemed illegal to kill your daughter for disobeying the family in such matters, it was allowed for the father to sell the child into slavery.  If she was a fair wench, the highest bidder was usually the owner of the local brothel.  He in turn would offer the girls beloved the chance to buy her contract, and thus save her from a life of shame. 


When was this?  It certainly wasn't in modern Western history. 




Racquelle -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 10:10:03 PM)

quote:

All of which makes it perfectly acceptable to ignore it in the present?
  Um...no.  The point is that it is an unacceptable practice regardless of when and where it happens - we need not use it as yet more fuel to the flames of ethnic intolerance.  There is yet to exist a perfect culture or an unblemished history.  I prefer to identify behaviors I find inappropriate without turning it into yet another venomous attack on another culture.  The seeds of oppression are in each of us.

In our own country, in our own time, marriages are arranged and young women kept from full control of their own destinies - nice wholesome white Christian folk.  It is not unique to Islam.  To deny the place that similar activities have had in Western history is to deny a clearly observable reality.




slvemike4u -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 10:11:45 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DomAviator

quote:

ORIGINAL: slvemike4u

This is an abberation and a mutilation of something called faith,to ascribe a monopoly to one religion is to kid ourselves.All the worlds major religion's have a fringe element that insists on a fundemental and extreme view of their respective faith...it is ugly and perverted no matter the genisis


Yeah thats right Mike the Baptists are well known for their honor killings LMFAO And theres nothing like those Burkah wearing pentecostal women being beaten with a cane for having their ankle showing...

I swear to god does PC prohibit speaking truth?? Name ONE other religion that requires honor killing Mike?

Jesus Christ they are gonna need a lot of busses to the DNC, since they will be using the short ones....
Hey DA where did I say that another religion requires honor killing...nowhere in my post did I suggest that.It might be helpfull if You read the damm post before injecting your usual venom....now for the benifit of those on the short busses what I diid suggest is Islam is not the only religion that the word RADICAL can be placed in front of...now I am not going to sit here and give you chapter and verse of obscure passages in both the old and the new testament that when taken in a litteral fashion would find Your ass in jail...You can do your own homework...oh btw did you miss the part where I called it an abberation,mutilation,perverted and ugly.....breath before You post




DomAviator -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 10:12:10 PM)

quote:

Inconvenient truths are still, by definition, truths.  Stating historical facts in no way takes away from the realities or the need to bring other cultures into mondernist thinking.  It just make your high-horse a little less so.  Your soap-box one slat shorter.  Continue with your righteous indignation, and I will proudly stand beside you and exhort just as loudly as you, but I will do it with my feet firmly planted on the ground.


Dude, seriously - take the stick out its got to hurt... I dont even know which of my posts you were replying to as you didnt cite it.

However if it was the first one - other religions do not practice honor killing. If they do they need to do it somewhere other than here because we wont tolerate it and have a needle waiting for those who wont adapt to US rather than Islamic law.

If it was the second one - the man specifically requested in another thread to have it pointed out whenever he said something likely to reduce his appeal to the ladies. It wasnt an attack, he asked to have it pointed out when he would  say something to reduce his marketability.

Incidentally, my high horse NEVER shrinks - I have ego and arrogance to spare and more growing by the minute. LOL




slvemike4u -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 10:17:40 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DomAviator

Dude, take the stick out its got to hurt... I dont even know which of my posts you were replying to as you didnt cite it.

However if it was the first one - other religions do not practice honor killing. If they do they need to do it somewhere other than here because we wont tolerate it and have a needle waiting for those who wont adapt to US rather than Islamic law.

If it was the second one - the man specifically requested in another thread to have it pointed out whenever he said something likely to reduce his appeal to the ladies. It wasnt an attack, he asked to have it pointed out when he would  say something to reduce his marketability.

Incidentally, my high horse NEVER shrinks - I have ego and arrogance to spare and more growing by the minute. LOL
Now there is a mystery of faith...the source of DA's arrogance




DomAviator -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 10:18:35 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slvemike4u

quote:

ORIGINAL: DomAviator

quote:

ORIGINAL: slvemike4u

This is an abberation and a mutilation of something called faith,to ascribe a monopoly to one religion is to kid ourselves.All the worlds major religion's have a fringe element that insists on a fundemental and extreme view of their respective faith...it is ugly and perverted no matter the genisis
 

Hey DA where did I say that another religion requires honor killing...nowhere in my post did I suggest that.It might be helpfull if You read the damm post before injecting your usual venom....now for the benifit of those on the short busses what I diid suggest is Islam is not the only religion that the word RADICAL can be placed in front of...now I am not going to sit here and give you chapter and verse of obscure passages in both the old and the new testament that when taken in a litteral fashion would find Your ass in jail...You can do your own homework...oh btw did you miss the part where I called it an abberation,mutilation,perverted and ugly.....breath before You post


See the portion in red. Honor killing is in fact the province of one religion., and is NOT practiced by "all the worlds major religions"... Even the most extreme Christian sects - Baptist and Pentecostal emphasize FORGIVENESS not punishment.  Ditto for the Jews, Catholics, etc... The Mormons and Jehovahs witnesses are even less condoning of violence...




slvemike4u -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 10:28:24 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DomAviator

quote:

ORIGINAL: slvemike4u

quote:

ORIGINAL: DomAviator

quote:

ORIGINAL: slvemike4u

This is an abberation and a mutilation of something called faith,to ascribe a monopoly to one religion is to kid ourselves.All the worlds major religion's have a fringe element that insists on a fundemental and extreme view of their respective faith...it is ugly and perverted no matter the genisis
 

Hey DA where did I say that another religion requires honor killing...nowhere in my post did I suggest that.It might be helpfull if You read the damm post before injecting your usual venom....now for the benifit of those on the short busses what I diid suggest is Islam is not the only religion that the word RADICAL can be placed in front of...now I am not going to sit here and give you chapter and verse of obscure passages in both the old and the new testament that when taken in a litteral fashion would find Your ass in jail...You can do your own homework...oh btw did you miss the part where I called it an abberation,mutilation,perverted and ugly.....breath before You post


See the portion in red. Honor killing is in fact the province of one religion., and is NOT practiced by "all the worlds major religions"... Even the most extreme Christian sects - Baptist and Pentecostal emphasize FORGIVENESS not punishment.  Ditto for the Jews, Catholics, etc... The Mormons and Jehovahs witnesses are even less condoning of violence...
Okay perhaps it reads a little fuzzy when you crimp that one line,but combine it with the line not highlighted(which is how most of us read)and the point is made that I was referring to the fact that all the worlds religions have fringe elements that tend to look at the basic text of their religion in a literal way(feel like I'm repeating myself here)Now if You want to dispute that statement feel free....but please don't butcher my intention and than expect me to engage in the game




philosophy -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 10:37:06 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DomAviator

Even the most extreme Christian sects - Baptist and Pentecostal emphasize FORGIVENESS not punishment.  Ditto for the Jews, Catholics, etc... The Mormons and Jehovahs witnesses are even less condoning of violence...


.....hmmm, you may find that a few families of those killed by radical anti-abortion Christians will disagree. As for the Jews, i think you'll find quite a few Lebanese who haven't seen that peace loving side to their neighbours to the south.

You seem to be seriously suggesting that Christianity doesn't have a lunatic fringe, populated by people as full of hate as any jihadist. Now, you may counter argue that such people aren't 'twue' Christans.....and you may be correct. But the same logic applies to Islam. Their terrorists are just as rare.
Ah, but then you'll bring up something like, say, Palestinians celebrating 9/11. Perhaps some did (and you can be sure that there were many cameras pointed at them).......now how is that different to you and your buddies glorying in and justifying the deaths of innocent Muslims?
You have far more in common with terrorists than you think. You are, in a very real sense, their ally. Without people like yourself, those who seem to revel in division and violence, the threat of terrorism would be enormously reduced.
Moderates, like myself, who want to see an end to violence on both sides are the enemy of both Islamic radicals and Christian radicals alike.




slvemike4u -> RE: A Little Too Much Multiculturalism (7/9/2008 10:42:00 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: philosophy

quote:

ORIGINAL: DomAviator

Even the most extreme Christian sects - Baptist and Pentecostal emphasize FORGIVENESS not punishment.  Ditto for the Jews, Catholics, etc... The Mormons and Jehovahs witnesses are even less condoning of violence...


.....hmmm, you may find that a few families of those killed by radical anti-abortion Christians will disagree. As for the Jews, i think you'll find quite a few Lebanese who haven't seen that peace loving side to their neighbours to the south.

You seem to be seriously suggesting that Christianity doesn't have a lunatic fringe, populated by people as full of hate as any jihadist. Now, you may counter argue that such people aren't 'twue' Christans.....and you may be correct. But the same logic applies to Islam. Their terrorists are just as rare.
Ah, but then you'll bring up something like, say, Palestinians celebrating 9/11. Perhaps some did (and you can be sure that there were many cameras pointed at them).......now how is that different to you and your buddies glorying in and justifying the deaths of innocent Muslims?
You have far more in common with terrorists than you think. You are, in a very real sense, their ally. Without people like yourself, those who seem to revel in division and violence, the threat of terrorism would be enormously reduced.
Moderates, like myself, who want to see an end to violence on both sides are the enemy of both Islamic radicals and Christian radicals alike.
How I wish I had the intelligence to respond to his post in this fashion....well said ,unforunately falling on dead ears(closed mind?)...Thank You for the post




Page: [1] 2 3 4 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
4.785156E-02