Rover
Posts: 2634
Joined: 6/28/2004 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: barelynangel Okay let me see if i can put these in simple words for you: 1. If you aren't willing to do your homework, you CAN'T BE GOREAN. Ummmmm... okayyyyyyyy.... first, please explain to me how this isn't telling me that I can't be Gorean (at least not until I satisfy your standard of study). Second, what *is* the homework? Reading some books? Or is it something else. C'mon, angel. Spit it out. And third, please reconcile this statement with your refusal to accept my claim that I *am* Gorean. It seems plain as day to me, but then, I may be missing something. quote:
2. If you are willing to put the homework in, maybe you CAN BE GOREAN. What that maybe depends on is what you decipher from your homework. Gee, that is very benevolent of you.... allowing me a path to *be* Gorean. Ok, you've set forth new standards here. All that talk about morality, loyalty, home, honor, etc. as that which *makes* one Gorean was... well.... let's say that it was not full disclosure. Now, what is it that one must decipher in order to achieve a standard by which they *are* Gorean? quote:
I have never put a value on the amount of homework or anything, i have not put any concept of what the homework is other than what it MEANS to you. And to me it means nothing. I am already satisfied with my understanding and incorporation of principles such as honor, integrity, home, ethics, morality, etc. But evidently that is not enough, because you refuse to accept what it means to me and demand that I achieve a standard that suits you. All the while not sharing what that standard *is*. quote:
If your integrity allows you to say you know everything about Gor... Sorry to dice up your sentences, but you must be out of periods and commas. Does anyone's integrity allow them to say that they know everything about Gor? And is that the standard by which one is judged to *be* Gorean? quote:
... because you have read and studied the books beyond the plot and actions of the warriors and slaves, to make an INFORMED decision as to your definitions of all those topics you have named and when held together as a whole by you they reflect what you seriously believe being Gorean is I am quite satisfied that I am informed about integrity, home, loyalty, ethics, morals and quite a bit more. quote:
-- then its up to you to choose if you want to identify as Gorean. And I've chosen. Why does that bother you so? quote:
If you do, then yes, your beliefs if you intend to be around other Goreans will probably be discussed and people will determine whether you are flying out your ass on cliffnotes, or whether your understanding is similar to theirs or whether your understanding is something they may have missed or need to consider because it makes sense to the whole of being Gorean. First of all, what happened to the individuality you said was inherent to Gor? This sounds awfully rigid doctrine that's quite exclusionary. quote:
Some will agree you are Gorean, some will not, in the end if you really give a damn, then you still don't get it. Well, then I must "get" it, because I already don't give a damn. I'm my own man. quote:
If you go back and read what i said, that is what i have stated all along. The concept of homework is vague in all of my statements. YOU have put a value on it that i never have nor will i. I strongly disagree. It's you that has determined that my homework is insufficient. And in order to do so, you have to put a value on it, and to compare it to some unspoken standard. quote:
I have as an individual a personal opinion of what i see as Gorean, with me you either will fit it or not. If you care enough to change your mind about what is Gorean to you and the identity of being Gorean, you won't gain my respect. If you stand by what you believe, i may not agree with you, but part of being Gorean is maintaining the integrity of your personal decision based on your informed decision. Well, at least on that standard I *am* Gorean. quote:
So quit whining about how i am telling you that you can't BE Gorean, if you go back and read what i said THE WHOLE OF IT, instead of focusing on the last part of the sentence, you will see i never have stated anything of the sort. Seriously, I don't recall that I've been whining at all. Simply engaging you in discussion and asking you questions. And if you'd like, I can copy and paste each time you said I can't *be* Gorean. Perhaps they slipped your mind. John
< Message edited by Rover -- 11/7/2008 11:04:49 AM >
_____________________________
"Man's mind stretched to a new idea never goes back to its original dimensions." Sri da Avabhas
|