Collarspace Discussion Forums


Home  Login  Search 

RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Citizenship responsibilities?


View related threads: (in this forum | in all forums)

Logged in as: Guest
 
All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid >> RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Citizenship responsibilities? Page: <<   < prev  2 3 4 5 [6]
Login
Message << Older Topic   Newer Topic >>
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/21/2007 10:05:43 PM   
CuriousLord


Posts: 3911
Joined: 4/3/2007
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: KnockerBockers

It has been a while since the draft. We have always lived in a violent society but it has become far more so since the draft ended. Should all able bodied men and women be made to serve 3 years in the service and 3 years in the reserve,as a part of the right of Citizenship? Defending one's nation should be a noblis oblige and a right of passage. Who agrees/disagrees?


I utterly hate the notion that, should such a law pass, one such as myself would be torn away from research to perform a relatively mundane task.  Nonetheless.. it is.. a noble idea?  It strikes me as horrific, the idea that bright minds would lose some of their most clear-minded years to vulgar service  Though, such would satisfy some notion of "fairness" to many.  And, in the end, service men and women are in demand.

It's a hard call, really.  Right now, so long as individuals can be attracted to the service through voluntary means, despite the understanding of likely being called on for extended tours- then this isn't necessary.  However, it may start becoming necessary.

I fear what may become of this nation if we should become so apathetic towards service that we trust our nation's defense to lawyers and diplomats who can only threaten UN santactions.

(in reply to KnockerBockers)
Profile   Post #: 101
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/21/2007 10:44:26 PM   
Honsoku


Posts: 422
Joined: 6/26/2007
Status: offline 		All gripes about the current war(s) and administration aside;

Truly mandatory military service I would say no to. I find that idea smacks of totalitarianism. Though I could see a Heinleinesque model where voting privileges and the like required military service (or an acceptable substitute). On top of work ethic, honor, etc there is another very important concept that military service can provide; namely the ability to put group needs before individual needs/wants. I think that this is a very valuable mindset to have amongst the voting population as it should keep at bay the tendency for people to vote themselves bread and circuses.

Another good reason for the idea is that this model would put a price on the ability to vote, thus giving it some level of value. As a general rule people do not respect what they are given for free. Making the ability to vote come with a price would hopefully lead people to treat voting more seriously (instead of just stumbling in drunk on election day and checking off the candidate that you think has the best name). This benefit would be missed if service was mandatory.

Do I personally want this to happen? I think would be interesting to try, though there would undoubtedly be unforeseen ramifications.

(in reply to CuriousLord)
Profile   Post #: 102
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/21/2007 10:58:51 PM   
domiguy


Posts: 12952
Joined: 5/2/2006
Status: offline 		Maybe more people would show their patriotism by voting if the gov't would offer something like free tuition in exchange?

_____________________________



(in reply to Honsoku)
Profile   Post #: 103
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/22/2007 12:00:54 AM   
Honsoku


Posts: 422
Joined: 6/26/2007
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: domiguy

Maybe more people would show their patriotism by voting if the gov't would offer something like free tuition in exchange?


More people would definitely vote (until they had all the education they cared for). Unfortunately, cost/benefit is in the wrong order. Voting is now the cost and not the benefit. Voting quality would probably decrease as people would go in to vote just for the tuition. On the other had, this might have a better long term effect of increasing the general level of education. If education was positively correlated with voting quality, then this might work (after all correlation does not equal causation). Though with all the free tuition floating around the price of education would almost certainly rise to compensate.

The problem with bribing people to vote is an issue of effort vs. reward. Voting can range from extremely easy to very effort intensive. If a person can get away with something easy (uninformed voting) in return for something valuable (tuition or whatever) than those who don't value voting in and of itself will take the easy route. Voting is now the means to an end for them. If the order is reversed and something valuable is required in exchange for voting, the people who choose to pay will generally have a psychological investment in making the most out of what they have acquired. Of course the purpose of voting being a reward is based on the idea that there is such a thing as voting quality; that informed, thoughtful voters will make better decisions.

(in reply to domiguy)
Profile   Post #: 104
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/22/2007 3:54:18 AM   
farglebargle


Posts: 10715
Joined: 6/15/2005
From: Albany, NY
Status: offline 		I didn't read all 6 pages, but....

They gotta do UNIVERSAL HEALTHCARE if they expect a socialist scheme like this to work.



_____________________________

It's not every generation that gets to watch a civilization fall. Looks like we're in for a hell of a show.

ברוך אתה, אדוני אלוקינו, ריבון העולמים, מי יוצר צמחים ריחניים

(in reply to Honsoku)
Profile   Post #: 105
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/22/2007 9:20:51 AM   
pollux


Posts: 657
Joined: 7/26/2005
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: TheHeretic

       I would probably support some variety of mandatory national service, but I would still prefer a volunteer military.

      And since we are doing a roll call now, yes, I served.


(Kinda sad to see all those who aren't around anymore when these old threads get pulled back up.  I miss Iron Bear's contributions.)


+1

I pulled up this oldy moldy thread and had the same thought...  John Warren too.  I didn't always agree with him but he always had something valuable to contribute.

(in reply to TheHeretic)
Profile   Post #: 106
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/22/2007 9:42:53 PM   
Owner59


Posts: 17033
Joined: 3/14/2006
From: Dirty Jersey
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: KnockerBockers

It has been a while since the draft. We have always lived in a violent society but it has become far more so since the draft ended. Should all able bodied men and women be made to serve 3 years in the service and 3 years in the reserve,as a part of the right of Citizenship? Defending one's nation should be a noblis oblige and a right of passage. Who agrees/disagrees?



I`m for this,and for both men and woman.

I heard Al Frankin talk about this years ago.

He talked about having a choice of 1)two years in the military,or you could 2)opt for a 3 year  civilian service program.This way,someone wouldn`t be forced to kill,or help kill.They could tend to sick veterines,or help fight forest fires,or any number of important things.



Peace

(in reply to KnockerBockers)
Profile   Post #: 107
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/22/2007 11:17:18 PM   
popeye1250


Posts: 18104
Joined: 1/27/2006
From: New Hampshire
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: CuriousLord

quote:

ORIGINAL: KnockerBockers

It has been a while since the draft. We have always lived in a violent society but it has become far more so since the draft ended. Should all able bodied men and women be made to serve 3 years in the service and 3 years in the reserve,as a part of the right of Citizenship? Defending one's nation should be a noblis oblige and a right of passage. Who agrees/disagrees?


I utterly hate the notion that, should such a law pass, one such as myself would be torn away from research to perform a relatively mundane task.  Nonetheless.. it is.. a noble idea?  It strikes me as horrific, the idea that bright minds would lose some of their most clear-minded years to vulgar service  Though, such would satisfy some notion of "fairness" to many.  And, in the end, service men and women are in demand.

It's a hard call, really.  Right now, so long as individuals can be attracted to the service through voluntary means, despite the understanding of likely being called on for extended tours- then this isn't necessary.  However, it may start becoming necessary.

I fear what may become of this nation if we should become so apathetic towards service that we trust our nation's defense to lawyers and diplomats who can only threaten UN santactions.


I think it was Marshall Petain who said; "Indespensable men?"
"The cemetarys are full of indespensable men!"

There were I'm sure fathers who thought that due to their station in life, their sons shouldn't have to join the Military but go to college instead on a deferment during Vietnam.

And then there was Ted Williams of the Boston Redsox.

< Message edited by popeye1250 -- 7/22/2007 11:18:58 PM >

_____________________________

"But Your Honor, this is not a Jury of my Peers, these people are all decent, honest, law-abiding citizens!"

(in reply to CuriousLord)
Profile   Post #: 108
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/25/2007 4:02:33 PM   
MasDom


Posts: 375
Joined: 11/10/2005
Status: offline 		Give me a government thats not completely retarded ,and i,ll think about it.

(in reply to thetammyjo)
Profile   Post #: 109
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/25/2007 5:49:12 PM   
Sinergy


Posts: 9383
Joined: 4/26/2004
Status: offline
quote:

ORIGINAL: Owner59

He talked about having a choice of 1)two years in the military,or you could 2)opt for a 3 year  civilian service program.This way,someone wouldn`t be forced to kill,or help kill.They could tend to sick veterines,or help fight forest fires,or any number of important things.



I dont agree with it being mandatory.  Somebody wants to live in a hovel in the mountains in Montana and howl at the moon, far be it from me to say he/she/it should not have that right.

On the other hand, I agree with this sort of a program (military or other non-military public service) as a prerequisite for voting privileges, or more importantly, the right or ability to run for political office.

Things that are free lack intrinsic value.  Giving everybody the ability to alter their countries future is a huge power, and if it is given to everybody without said person having to earn the privilege, it becomes a worthless privilege.

I am with Heinlein on this one.  Do something that proves one puts the body politic ahead of one's personal survival and I will be the first to agree that this person should be allowed the privilege to vote and hold a public office.  Somebody who has paid in blood and sweat and tears for that privilege will not stand idly by and not make use of it either.

Just me, could be wrong, but there you go.

Sinergy

edited played -> paid.

< Message edited by Sinergy -- 7/25/2007 5:50:18 PM >

_____________________________

"There is a fine line between clever and stupid"
David St. Hubbins "This Is Spinal Tap"

"Every so often you let a word or phrase out and you want to catch it and bring it back. You cant do that, it is gone, gone forever." J. Danforth Quayle


(in reply to Owner59)
Profile   Post #: 110
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/25/2007 6:03:10 PM   
MasDom


Posts: 375
Joined: 11/10/2005
Status: offline 		Could I be allowed to bring personal armoments,
and vehicals?
 Cause if I had to go, I want a tank and a mini gun.

(in reply to Sinergy)
Profile   Post #: 111
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/25/2007 6:48:58 PM   
Sinergy


Posts: 9383
Joined: 4/26/2004
Status: offline 		I dont care what you bring.

I will do my service in a non-military branch, such as postulated by Heinlein.

Which is weird, because I teach full-contact self-defense, but I am a non-violent pacifist.

The joy of being a Zen Taoist is I dont have to think about it, and I can live a weird
contradiction.

Sinergy

_____________________________

"There is a fine line between clever and stupid"
David St. Hubbins "This Is Spinal Tap"

"Every so often you let a word or phrase out and you want to catch it and bring it back. You cant do that, it is gone, gone forever." J. Danforth Quayle


(in reply to MasDom)
Profile   Post #: 112
RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Cit... - 7/25/2007 6:49:40 PM   
michaelOfGeorgia


Posts: 4253
Status: offline
quote:

Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Citizen...


no


_____________________________

Are we having fun, yet?

(in reply to KnockerBockers)
Profile   Post #: 113
Page:   <<   < prev  2 3 4 5 [6]
All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid >> RE: Should Compulsory Military Service be a part of Citizenship responsibilities? Page: <<   < prev  2 3 4 5 [6]
Jump to:





New Messages No New Messages
Hot Topic w/ New Messages Hot Topic w/o New Messages
Locked w/ New Messages Locked w/o New Messages
 Post New Thread
 Reply to Message
 Post New Poll
 Submit Vote
 Delete My Own Post
 Delete My Own Thread
 Rate Posts




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy

0.094