RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


Nosathro -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 7:54:45 AM)

Yes ThatDamnedPanda...I was trying to point that out




tazzygirl -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 1:39:44 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: juliaoceania


quote:

ORIGINAL: tazzygirl

quote:

The above portions that bolded....Schizophrenics often have delusions that some force outside of them controls their behavior.


Take a look around these boards, julia. If that is your belief, then you are arguing with people who are mentally ill, which in itself is a cruelty. You can believe you are being controlled/persecuted and still not be schizophrenic.



Tazzy, that is ONE of the symptoms. I did not say it was the ONLY symptom. Not all people who believe in conspiracies are schizophrenic. If you believe that some external force outside of yourself is controlling your behavior, then you might well be schizophrenic, but it is only one indicator. If you notice, I do not spend much time debating conspiracy theories with people on this board, even though most of them do not seem schizophrenic to me.

You say you worked with schizophrenics. I am somewhat surprised you didn't know that schizophrenics had delusional beliefs such as what I have described,... it is a little like Schizophrenic 101.

quote:



Delusions
A delusion is a firmly-held idea that a person has despite clear and obvious evidence that it isn’t true. Delusions are extremely common in schizophrenia, occurring in more than 90% of those who have the disorder. Often, these delusions involve illogical or bizarre ideas or fantasies. Common schizophrenic delusions include:

Delusions of persecution – Belief that others, often a vague “they,” are out to get him or her. These persecutory delusions often involve bizarre ideas and plots (e.g. “Martians are trying to poison me with radioactive particles delivered through my tap water”).

Delusions of reference – A neutral environmental event is believed to have a special and personal meaning. For example, a person with schizophrenia might believe a billboard or a person on TV is sending a message meant specifically for them.

Delusions of grandeur – Belief that one is a famous or important figure, such as Jesus Christ or Napolean. Alternately, delusions of grandeur may involve the belief that one has unusual powers that no one else has (e.g. the ability to fly).

Delusions of control – Belief that one’s thoughts or actions are being controlled by outside, alien forces. Common delusions of control include thought broadcasting (“My private thoughts are being transmitted to others”), thought insertion (“Someone is planting thoughts in my head”), and thought withdrawal (“The CIA is robbing me of my thoughts”).




I said I had a clinical rotation... I never worked with them directly on a psych unit... only as part of their medical treatment.

Now, I never said they didnt have delusions. What I said was delusions can be caused by many things. Attributing them to mean someone is schizophrenic would be diagnosing without the information that is needed.

His case isnt a 101 Case.

Examples of Physical Symptoms----

--A blank, vacant facial expression. An inability to smile or express emotion through the face is so characteristic of the disease that it was given the name of affective flattening or a blunt affect. (check his mug shot for this one)
--Overly acute senses- lights are too bright, sounds are too loud.
--Staring, while in deep thought, with infrequent blinking.
--Clumsy, inexact motor skills
--Sleep disturbances- insomnia or excessive sleeping
--Involuntary movements of the tongue or mouth (facial dyskinesias). Grimacing at the corners of the mouth with the facial muscles, or odd movements with the tongue.
--Parkinsonian type symptoms- rigidity, tremor, jerking arm movements, or involuntary movements of the limbs
--An awkward gait (how you walk)
--Eye movements- difficulty focusing on slow moving objects
--Unusual gestures or postures
--Movement is speeded up- i.e. constant pacing
--Movement is slowed down- staying in bed (in extreme cases, catatonia)

Examples of Feelings/Emotions----

--The inability to experience joy or pleasure from activities (called anhedonia)
--Sometimes feeling nothing at all
--Appearing desireless- seeking nothing, wanting nothing
--Feeling indifferent to important events
--Feeling detached from your own body (depersonalization)
--Hypersensitivity to criticism, insults, or hurt feelings

Examples of Mood----

--Sudden irritability, anger, hostility, suspiciousness, resentment
--Depression- feeling discouraged and hopeless about the future
--Low motivation, energy, and little or no enthusiasm
--Suicidal thoughts or suicidal ideation
--Rapidly changing mood- from happy to sad to angry for no apparent reason (called labile mood)
--Severe Anxiety

Changes in Behavior associated with schizophrenia ----

--Dropping out of activities and life in general
--Inability to form or keep relationships
--Social isolation- few close friends if any. Little interaction outside of immediate family.
--Increased withdrawal, spending most of the days alone.
--Becoming lost in thoughts and not wanting to be disturbed with human contact
--Neglect in self-care- i.e. hygiene, clothing, or appearance
--Replaying or rehearsing conversations out loud- i.e. talking to yourself (very common sign)
--Finding it difficult to deal with stressful situations
--Inability to cope with minor problems
--Lack of goal-directed behavior. Not being able to engage in purposeful activity
--Functional impairment in interpersonal relationships, work, education, or self-care
--Deterioration of academic or job-related performance
--Inappropriate responses- laughing or smiling when talking of a sad event, making irrational statements.
--Catatonia- staying in the same rigid position for hours, as if in a daze.
--Intense and excessive preoccupation with religion or spirituality
--Drug or alcohol abuse
--Smoke or have the desire to want to smoke (70-90% do smoke) - note: this is a very normal behavior for people who do not have schizophrenia also!
--Frequent moves, trips, or walks that lead nowhere
Examples of Cognitive Problems Associated with Schizophrenia ----

--Ruminating thoughts- these are the same thoughts that go around and round your head but get you nowhere. Often about past disappointments, missed opportunities, failed relationships.
--Making up new words (neologisms)
--Becoming incoherent or stringing unrelated words together (word salad)
--Frequent loose association of thoughts or speech- when one thought does not logically relate to the next. For example, "I need to go to the store to buy some band-aids. I read an article about how expensive AIDS drugs are. People take too many street drugs. The streets should be clean from the rain today, etc" The need to go to the store to buy band-aids is forgotten.
--Directionless- lack goals, or the ability to set and achieve goals

--Lack of insight (called anosognosia). Those who are developing schizophrenia are unaware that they are becoming sick. The part of their brain that should recognize that something is wrong is damaged by the disease.
--Racing thoughts
--In conversation you tend to say very little (called poverty of speech or alogia)
--Suddenly halting speech in the middle of a sentence (thought blocking)

--Trouble with social cues- i.e. not being able to interpret body language, eye contact, voice tone, and gestures appropriately. --Often not responding appropriately and thus coming off as cold, distant, or detached.
--Difficulty expressing thoughts verbally. Or not having much to say about anything.
--Speaking in an abstract or tangential way. Odd use of words or language structure
--Difficulty focusing attention and engaging in goal directed behavior
--Poor concentration/ memory. Forgetfulness
--Nonsensical logic
--Difficulty understanding simple things
--Thoughts, behavior, and actions are not integrated
--Obsessive compulsive tendencies- with thoughts or actions
--Thought insertion/ withdrawal- thoughts are put it or taken away without a conscious effort
--Conversations that seem deep, but are not logical or coherent

Examples of Delusions----

The most common type of delusion or false beliefs are paranoid delusions. These are persecutory in nature and take many forms:

--Overpowering, intense feeling that people are talking about you, looking at you
--Overpowering, intense feeling you are being watched, followed, and spied on (tracking devices, implants, hidden cameras)
--Thinking that someone is trying to poison your food
--Thinking people are working together to harass you
--Thinking that something is controlling you- i.e. an electronic implant
--Thinking that people can read your mind/ or control your thoughts
--Thinking that your thoughts are being broadcast over the radio or tv
--Delusions of reference- thinking that random events convey a special meaning to you. An example is that a newspaper headline or a license plate has a hidden meaning for you to figure out. That they are signs trying to tell you something.
--Religious delusions- that you are Jesus, God, a prophet, or the antichrist.
--Delusions of grandeur- the belief that you have an important mission, special purpose, or are an unrecognized genius, or famous person.
--Delusions that someone, often a famous person, is in love with you when in reality they aren't. Also called erotomania or de Clerembault syndrome.

Examples of Hallucinations----

--Hallucinations are as real as any other experience to the person with schizophrenia. As many as 70% hear voices, while a lesser number have visual hallucinations.
--Auditory hallucinations can be either inside the person's head or externally. When external, they sound as real as an actual voice. Sometimes they come from no apparent source, other times they come from real people who don't actually say anything, other times a person will hallucinate sounds.
--When people hear voices inside their heads, it is as if their inner thoughts are no longer alone. The new voices can talk to each other, talk to themselves, or comment on the person's actions. The majority of the time the voices are negative.
--Visual hallucinations operate on a spectrum. They start with the overacuteness of the senses, then in the middle are illusions, and on the far end are actual hallucinations.



Disclaimer: The following symptoms overlap with many other diseases such as bipolar disorder, major depression, the various kinds of personality disorders (specifically paranoid and schizotypal personality disorders), and other problems such as brain tumors and temporal lobe epilepsy. There is no "typical" case of schizophrenia. Everyone has different symptoms. Seek the opinion of your doctor always.

Moreover, it is always important to keep the big picture in mind. Having just a few of these symptoms does not necessarily mean that a person has schizophrenia, or any other sort of psychiatric disorder. Almost all of the signs below can be present to a "normal" degree in people; it is when someone displays them to a significant degree that they can become psychiatric symptoms. Think if all of these behaviors as being on a continuum, in which the middle 99% of people displaying varying degrees of the behavior, but are still within the "normal" range. The 1% of people on the outer edges have the behaviors in extreme proportion, and/or a significant proportion of the time, and that is when they can become debilitating.

A diagnosis of schizophrenia requires that continuous disturbance (i.e. debilitating symptoms) be present for at least six months, including at least one month of certain key symptoms (active symptoms: delusions, hallucinations, disorganized speech, disorganized/catatonic behavior, negative symptoms such as severe emotional flatness or apathy)


http://schizophrenia.com/earlysigns.htm




juliaoceania -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 2:04:41 PM)

You posted this in regard to whether or not Loughner was schizophrenic enough not to realize he committed a crime:



quote:

ORIGINAL: tazzygirl

I dont believe that is the case here, do you, julia?



Now, he has presented several symptoms of schizophrenia... including a sudden shift in his behaviors, self medicating, delusional thoughts, thoughts that others control him.

The medical diagnosis of schizophrenia doesn't seem a shocker to me. And I did learn about schizophrenia in my psych 101 class.









tazzygirl -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 2:11:04 PM)

Psych 101 is only the beginning, julia.

Add in a few abnormal psych classes, some medical training, maybe a degree, and you may start to understand. I am not belittling your knowedge. But its just not that easy to diagnose simply by saying... he had delusions.

And, no, I dont believe that is the case. Frankly, I believe he has concocted this whole insanity plea to save his own ass.

Examples of Physical Symptoms----

--A blank, vacant facial expression. An inability to smile or express emotion through the face is so characteristic of the disease that it was given the name of affective flattening or a blunt affect. (check his mug shot for this one)
xamples of Mood----

--Sudden irritability, anger, hostility, suspiciousness, resentment
--Depression- feeling discouraged and hopeless about the future
--Low motivation, energy, and little or no enthusiasm
--Suicidal thoughts or suicidal ideation
--Rapidly changing mood- from happy to sad to angry for no apparent reason (called labile mood)
--Severe Anxiety

Take a look at his mug shot.... that picture doesnt fit the mold.



[image]local://upfiles/502828/0E71AE6F92DF4D788D81D6459A78221C.jpg[/image]




juliaoceania -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 2:17:17 PM)

quote:

Add in a few abnormal psych classes, some medical training, maybe a degree, and you may start to understand. I am not belittling your knowedge. But its just not that easy to diagnose simply by saying... he had delusions.


Funny, I never diagnosed him, I only stated that is what doctors have found... The doctors have found him incompetent, diagnosed him with schizophrenia, they may very well support a "not guilty by reason of insanity" defense...

My position remains the same, what little I have read about his state of mind (not much is really widely known) seems to support the doctor's diagnosis. I then showed the news article and the ways in which his behaviors were symptomatic of that condition, as was already diagnosed by doctors. I am not the one second guessing the doctor diagnosis here.




tazzygirl -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 2:19:16 PM)

Mine is a personal opinion, not a medical one. Based upon what I see, I dont think he is as sick as he is letting on. Time will tell.




tazzygirl -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 2:35:53 PM)

~FR

For those who are curious...

http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Guilty+but+mentally+ill

I do believe Arizona has this option.




juliaoceania -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 2:44:56 PM)

From your link


Those who wish to retain it note that forty-eight of the fifty states have some type of insanity defense. This, they claim, is evidence of the need for such a defense. The public is given a distorted view of who uses the defense and how it is employed. In fact about one percent of criminal defendants invoke the defense. More important, criminals rarely "beat the rap" by Pleading insanity. When an insanity defense is employed, it means the defendant admits committing the criminal behavior and is now seeking a not guilty verdict on the basis of his state of mind. If the jury does not agree, the defendant will be convicted, and generally will serve a longer sentence than will someone convicted of the same crime who has not pleaded insanity.




tazzygirl -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 3:24:06 PM)

Though the insanity defense is rarely invoked in criminal trials, it remains a controversial issue. Legislators and the public generally question the need for the defense after a defendant in a highly publicized murder case is found not guilty by reason of insanity. For example, when John Hinckley successfully used the defense after shooting President ronald reagan to impress the actress Jodie Foster, there was a public outcry. Legal and medical commentators have divided opinions about the need for the insanity defense.

Those who wish to retain it note that forty-eight of the fifty states have some type of insanity defense. This, they claim, is evidence of the need for such a defense. The public is given a distorted view of who uses the defense and how it is employed. In fact about one percent of criminal defendants invoke the defense. More important, criminals rarely "beat the rap" by Pleading insanity. When an insanity defense is employed, it means the defendant admits committing the criminal behavior and is now seeking a not guilty verdict on the basis of his state of mind. If the jury does not agree, the defendant will be convicted, and generally will serve a longer sentence than will someone convicted of the same crime who has not pleaded insanity.

Juries find for only about 20 percent of the defendants who plead insanity. Even this figure does not reflect the reality that many insanity pleas are the result of plea bargains, which indicates that prosecutors agree that such pleas are sometimes appropriate.

Finally, the fact that most highly publicized cases involve murder disguises the true demographics: 60 to 70 percent of insanity pleas are for crimes other than murder. They range from assault to shoplifting.

All these myths have led to the belief that criminals can avoid punishment by claiming insanity. The truth is that the insanity defense is a risky one at best.

Apart from combating these myths, advocates of the insanity defense contend that a fundamental principle of Criminal Law is at stake. The insanity defense is rooted in the belief that conviction and punishment are justified only if the defendant deserves them. The basic pre-condition for punishment is that the person who committed the criminal behavior must have responsibility as a moral agent. When a person is so mentally disturbed that her irrationality or compulsion is impossible to control, that person lacks responsibility as a moral agent. It would be unfair to punish a person in such an extreme condition.

Based on this argument, proponents of the insanity defense do not support its application to a person who willingly consumes a powerful hallucinogen and then commits a criminal act. Nor would they allow its application to a person who is able to control a mental disorder through medication but fails to do so. But they do support the defense for a person who unwittingly consumes hallucinogens and then commits a crime.


Julia, its all part of the myths. Keep it in context, please.




TheHeretic -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 5:56:34 PM)

Don't muddy the issue with facts, Tazzy. She has "feelings" about it...




juliaoceania -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 6:02:08 PM)

quote:

Julia, its all part of the myths. Keep it in context, please.


You realize that what you bolded supports the things I have said, right?





tazzygirl -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 6:05:20 PM)

That myths are right?

Perhaps you should explain it. Maybe Im reading you wrong.




juliaoceania -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 6:11:38 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: tazzygirl

That myths are right?

Perhaps you should explain it. Maybe Im reading you wrong.



I agree that these pleas rarely happen, and when they do they are rarely successful.

I think that insanity as a defense is bolstered by the fact that so many prosecutors do not prosecute people they think are crazy.

I would agree that there are many ill-informed people (some of them posting on this thread I might add) who think that there are all these people escaping justice because of their mental illness when the opposite is true, some people shouldn't be advocating for themselves because of their mental condition.... and do so every day, and that is why the system is burdened with them when they should be in hospitals




tazzygirl -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 6:25:17 PM)

The insanity defense should not be confused with Incompetency. Persons who are incompetent to stand trial are held in a mental institution until they are considered capable of participating in the proceedings.

No one at this point is just released to go home. Which, I believe, is where Laughner is at... incompetent. He is headed for a state hospital where he will stay until such time as the Drs believe he is competent once again.

If that day ever comes, he will go before a Judge and be held for trial. He can be found guilty, guilty but mentally ill, not guilty by reason of insanity, or not guilty.

But, if he is ever declared competent, he will stand trial.




juliaoceania -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 6:33:56 PM)

Arizona has limited its use, they haven't done away with it




tazzygirl -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/27/2011 6:34:48 PM)

We also have to remember this is a Federal case, not a state one.




SternSkipper -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/28/2011 12:03:14 AM)

quote:

But why? unless you want the initials GOD. Hmmmmmmmm......... uhhhhhhhhh, brb.


FUCK ... why DIDN'T I think of that... shit now that god's taken... what office in what state can I grab to get BUDDHA?





tazzygirl -> RE: Judge: Ariz. shooting suspect mentally incompetent (5/28/2011 12:08:32 AM)

Butt Ugly Deranged Ditto Heads of America?




Page: <<   < prev  3 4 5 6 [7]

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875