RE: Mental Illness (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Casual Banter] >> Off the Grid



Message


MalcolmNathaniel -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 1:50:46 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: LookieNoNookie


quote:

ORIGINAL: MalcolmNathaniel


quote:

ORIGINAL: LookieNoNookie

That was either remarkably uninformed or....you're just an asshole.

It's not that simple, and I suspect you're not an asshole (but, you could be).




Perhaps before assuming malice you should request clarification?

I never said it was an easy thing to deal with. In fact any time you see a bullet list you should assume that there is a lot more complication behind the scenes. It was a highly simplified version of the cycle not the entire process.

Perhaps I should not have use the phrase 'feel better.' I should probably have said, "respond in a more acceptable way to outside stimuli in the presence of localized chemical within the brain structure while suffering a wide range of negative byproducts due to the presence of said chemicals.

That would hardly be relevant to the cycle itself though. That cycle is present in most of the people I have had to deal with in these situations, 2 of whom are very sick. And the sicker they are, the harsher their drugs (and the harsher the side effects. It is no wonder that they want off of them.

As for 'ignorant' - I deal with these issues on a regular basis.

Again, next time request clarification. Since the original question was about people going off their medication, don't you think an overall view of the cycle is important, perhaps even before learning the details of each step?



Sorry, I presumed you meant what you wrote.

I don't tend to write stuff just to hear my own voice.

If that was your intent, perhaps you can put an advance notice on same: "This is simply blather...I don't really mean what I'm about to say",



I did write what I meant. You misinterpreted in and took offense. I'm pretty sure that has never happened on the internet before.

More to the point: Someone is wrong on the internet!




kalikshama -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 2:00:00 PM)

quote:

But earlier I had mentioned that my mom had eight kids, and evaluated some of her troubles from that, whereupon your comment was "eight kids?",


Hey, I was raised Catholic, plenty of big families in my genealogy.

I'd like to see the thread - IIRC, my judgement had nothing to do with how many children she'd had but that the decision to refinance at her age in order to renovate a house to accommodate 48 or so family members who visited a few times per year didn't seem particularly wise.

I am truly sorry that you interpreted my comment in the way that you did.




kalikshama -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 2:03:39 PM)

quote:

bdsm is known to basically accept anyone...any shape, size


Then why do we have so many fat threads? (Although, admittedly, not as much lately.)




GotSteel -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 2:19:01 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: littlewonder
Simple....bdsm is on the outside of society..not exactly accepted in the mainstream (but it's getting there quickly) and bdsm is known to basically accept anyone...any shape, size, color, gender, views, fetishes, etc....it's where people go to who feel they don't fit in anywhere else and well...why not get into bdsm? They'll feel as if they belong because everyone belongs....at least that's the thought of many people imo.


This seems strange to me, I can understand that appeal working for certain groups such as religions, even satanism. But somehow I just don't expect "come to BDSM, we have torture" to have the same appeal to those of us who aren't inherently kinky. I've always figured you're kinky or your not, that trying to get into BDSM made about as much sense as trying to get into homosexuality.



[image]local://upfiles/566126/D666AC9EB539431182C7F66B6356F8E7.jpg[/image]




Edwynn -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 3:39:14 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kalikshama

quote:

But earlier I had mentioned that my mom had eight kids, and evaluated some of her troubles from that, whereupon your comment was "eight kids?",


Hey, I was raised Catholic, plenty of big families in my genealogy.

I'd like to see the thread - IIRC, my judgement had nothing to do with how many children she'd had but that the decision to refinance at her age in order to renovate a house to accommodate 48 or so family members who visited a few times per year didn't seem particularly wise.

I am truly sorry that you interpreted my comment in the way that you did.


No "interpretation" about it, your conflating two distinct different occurrences notwithstanding. In any case, I don't know how to look up a three or four month old thread.

Selective memory and for-purpose bad math skills ("48 or so family members"? Good gosh ... that's all eight kids having spouses, three kids to every one of them. Not actually how it turned out, safe to say) seem to be serving the job well enough there. The renovation, never actually mentioned heretofore, was upon move-in and part of the original mortgage. The ten yrs. later re-fi to extract 50K (from a significantly larger equity base) from a lifetime of work came at another time. Thanks for keeping up, as you always do.






quote:

Posts: 9902
Joined: 8/8/2010
Status: online

quote:

quote:

Of course, there isn't a lot of citation to be had on this topic, but I did run across this survey someone did on FL with a relatively small amount of people. (Link) Keep in mind that there's always some error with surveys as well, so this isn't completely solid evidence.



quote:

Online surveys like these are for entertainment only and have no statistical validity.

_____________________________

Curious about the "Sluts Vote" avatars? See http://www.collarchat.com/m_4133036/mpage_1/key_/tm.htm#4133036


See? That's not you at all, is it? Not attacking or challenging in some way, others going through some struggle in life?

Not you at all.

It's true that statistics do not tell the whole story. Thank goodness we have your Bill Maher to set us right and tell the true story in that regard.





DesFIP -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 4:07:06 PM)

Somebody claimed that a hundred or more years ago, people didn't suffer from mental illness and they led happy and productive lives instead of taking medications prescribed by people who study the brain and its functioning.

I'd love to know in what universe that happened. Because in my family, what we did a hundred years ago and in every generation since then until the invention of SSRIs and more modern medications, was kill ourselves. A great uncle dead at 22. Another at 50. I had a couple of suicide attempts prior to modern "big pharma".

I'm grateful every day of my life, which I wouldn't have had otherwise for these meds.




kalikshama -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 4:08:43 PM)

Namaste




LadyHibiscus -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 4:09:57 PM)

And let's not forget mental asylums, and locked attic rooms. The mentally ill were disposed of, or tortured, or killed themselves.




dcnovice -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 4:10:34 PM)

FR

One possible connection that just occurred to me is that folks who've pressed through the risk of social disapproval and (perhaps) internalized shame to own their kinky natures may be more comfortable being honest about mental issues. Just a thought.




dcnovice -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 4:13:46 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: DesFIP

Somebody claimed that a hundred or more years ago, people didn't suffer from mental illness and they led happy and productive lives instead of taking medications prescribed by people who study the brain and its functioning.

I'd love to know in what universe that happened. Because in my family, what we did a hundred years ago and in every generation since then until the invention of SSRIs and more modern medications, was kill ourselves. A great uncle dead at 22. Another at 50. I had a couple of suicide attempts prior to modern "big pharma".

I'm grateful every day of my life, which I wouldn't have had otherwise for these meds.

When I started on my first antidepressant, I remember my sister worrying about what the long-terms effects might be. I quietly pointed out that without some help for the depression, there wasn't going to be a long term.




Edwynn -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 4:18:37 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: DesFIP

Somebody claimed that a hundred or more years ago, people didn't suffer from mental illness and they led happy and productive lives instead of taking medications prescribed by people who study the brain and its functioning.

I'd love to know in what universe that happened. Because in my family, what we did a hundred years ago and in every generation since then until the invention of SSRIs and more modern medications, was kill ourselves. A great uncle dead at 22. Another at 50. I had a couple of suicide attempts prior to modern "big pharma".

I'm grateful every day of my life, which I wouldn't have had otherwise for these meds.


That was not me that made any such claim that no one had mental/emotional issues prior to 'big pharma.'

Sorry you missed it, but the point made (and made well enough for those not defending the dispensing of drugs to kids) was/is the issue of society's acceptance (or lack thereby) of people who are somewhat "different," and that such 'definition' is evermore finding its way by such 'definition' of these same companies.

I am glad that things turned out well in your case, I truly am. But My niece was far from suicidal and was forced to take drugs nevertheless, and she was just a normal kid who happened to be just a bit too boisterous for the modern-day school system.

By the "Geist" or mindset extant among some here, uncle Ed might have served her better if he did not so openly invite and so easily accept her every expression of will and great personality, such acceptance as she had a hard time finding elsewhere.

She might not have needed to be put on drugs, were it not for my occasional influence, we might say.

So there we have it.








MalcolmNathaniel -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 4:33:21 PM)

Edwynn: stop reading conspiracy theory literature. It will *fnord* make things dificult to deal with.

When you look for a conspiracy *fnord* rather than base human *fnord* greed you end up *fnord* seeing them everywhere!

Conspiracies do exist. They happen. "The Fast and Furious" operation is an example.

But it is never a big, all inclusive but nebulous 'them.'

*fnord*

Big Pharma is not a person or a group. It is a made up entity in the minds of people who feel wronged in some way.

I have worked for one of the biggest drug companies in the Western hemisphere (outside of Columbia) and they are just as confused as you are. They just want to provide a product like anyone else.

There is no *fnord* conspiracy! All you need to do to slip from their grasp is DON'T BUY FROM THEM if if you don't believe them. That's it.

One last word: *fnord*




littlewonder -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 4:39:03 PM)

I so love reading the conspiracy theory people on here. lol. I swear I think I'm gonna make and market the tinfoil hat. But then they'd think it was a conspiracy theory to control their thoughts. do do do doooooo.......




Edwynn -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 4:46:09 PM)


Well then, *fnord* you and me both.

I'd hope you could see the *fnord* in my use of the term 'big pharma,' as I have no issue with companies making a go of it, on that account alone.

In any case, after having been through several microeconomics classes and one very stressful (both mathematically and conceptually) but quite informative Industrial Organization and Regulation class, it's a given that companies do anything and everything they need to do to increase the numbers from one year to the next. No "conspiracy" behind any of that, it's just everyday business.





kalikshama -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 4:56:20 PM)

quote:

My mom (whom you have attacked) and my dad (whom you have attacked previously, as did numerous others, for attempting to get back some minimal portion of what society has taken from from him all his life)


You said:

quote:

I am close to a situation where a retiree house owner simply cannot sell.

A $60,000 kitchen remodeling (complete ripping out and replacement of everything, floor, walls, ceiling, island range and counter top installed, all appliances, etc.) was done upon last purchase.

The house was assessed at $725,000 in 2007, which we now know as being the peak before the bust. It was assessed at $685,000 in 2002, prior to the CDO-induced price inflation. The current price is listed at $499,000, after numerous reductions. The latest offer is $470,000, and that being half-hearted and half-serious.


quote:

The wife in this matter insisted on a house large enough (and the kitchen) to accommodate family get-togethers at least twice a year, being as that her health had deteriorated to such that she could not do the beach or mountain vacation thing anymore, and the 22-29 people at such gatherings (8 kids, 6 grand kids, spouses, bfs, gfs, friends, etc.) necessitated the square footage.


In response to the bolded, I said:

quote:

/Attempts to muster sympathy/

/fails/


Once I suspected you were referring to a family member (you never used the words "mother," "father" or "family" in this thread), I said:

quote:

Edwynn - while it is indeed despicable to prey on the elderly, I seem to be missing some facts in your example to draw this conclusion. Perhaps you could set out the timelines again? I don't see how a house that was bought in 1999 could be in such trouble now. Did something shady happen during the boom?


I find it extremely unfortunate that today you remember it thusly:

quote:

But earlier I had mentioned that my mom had eight kids, and evaluated some of her troubles from that, whereupon your comment was "eight kids?", in somewhat judgmental tone, followed by something along the lines that you had no empathy for her if she was stupid enough to have eight kids.




lovenhate -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 5:00:28 PM)

quote:



Somebody claimed that a hundred or more years ago, people didn't suffer from mental illness and they led happy and productive lives instead of taking medications prescribed by people who study the brain and its functioning.

I'd love to know in what universe that happened. Because in my family, what we did a hundred years ago and in every generation since then until the invention of SSRIs and more modern medications, was kill ourselves. A great uncle dead at 22. Another at 50. I had a couple of suicide attempts prior to modern "big pharma".



Over a hundred years ago, people were still suffering, but it wasn't called "mental illness". I don't think the "mental illness" label was a good idea, because it makes a certain class of people's suffering seem totally different from that of the rest of the species, thus making it harder for those labeled "mentally ill" to find friendship and empathy. Also, it's used to justify locking people up and forcing treatments on them that sometimes make things worse.

As for the medications, they work great for some people, other people they don't do anything at all for, still others experience disastrous side effects. We are not all the same. That's part of why it's so important to have free choice.

MalcolmNathaniel: Are you being ignorant here or deliberately misleading? Pharmaceutical companies try to sell their products. They often do this by giving kickbacks to high-prescribing doctors, holding "continuing medical education" classes in resort settings that promote their products under the guise of education, and manipulating clinical trials to get the results they want. And although it's fine for you and me to just not buy from them, not everyone has a choice in the matter. In NY state, under "Kendra's Law" some people are forced to take psychiatric drugs as a condition of living free in the outside world.




Edwynn -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 5:09:52 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: kalikshama

quote:

My mom (whom you have attacked) and my dad (whom you have attacked previously, as did numerous others, for attempting to get back some minimal portion of what society has taken from from him all his life)


You said:

quote:

I am close to a situation where a retiree house owner simply cannot sell.

A $60,000 kitchen remodeling (complete ripping out and replacement of everything, floor, walls, ceiling, island range and counter top installed, all appliances, etc.) was done upon last purchase.

The house was assessed at $725,000 in 2007, which we now know as being the peak before the bust. It was assessed at $685,000 in 2002, prior to the CDO-induced price inflation. The current price is listed at $499,000, after numerous reductions. The latest offer is $470,000, and that being half-hearted and half-serious.


quote:

The wife in this matter insisted on a house large enough (and the kitchen) to accommodate family get-togethers at least twice a year, being as that her health had deteriorated to such that she could not do the beach or mountain vacation thing anymore, and the 22-29 people at such gatherings (8 kids, 6 grand kids, spouses, bfs, gfs, friends, etc.) necessitated the square footage.


In response to the bolded, I said:

quote:

/Attempts to muster sympathy/

/fails/


Once I suspected you were referring to a family member (you never used the words "mother," "father" or "family" in this thread), I said:

quote:

Edwynn - while it is indeed despicable to prey on the elderly, I seem to be missing some facts in your example to draw this conclusion. Perhaps you could set out the timelines again? I don't see how a house that was bought in 1999 could be in such trouble now. Did something shady happen during the boom?


I find it extremely unfortunate that today you remember it thusly:

quote:

But earlier I had mentioned that my mom had eight kids, and evaluated some of her troubles from that, whereupon your comment was "eight kids?", in somewhat judgmental tone, followed by something along the lines that you had no empathy for her if she was stupid enough to have eight kids.





Irresponsible parents and 48 house guests from all that.

Yeah, we get it.






kalikshama -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 5:11:30 PM)

quote:

*fnord*


In case anyone else was wondering:

http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=fnord




Edwynn -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 5:33:08 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: littlewonder

I so love reading the conspiracy theory people on here. lol. I swear I think I'm gonna make and market the tinfoil hat. But then they'd think it was a conspiracy theory to control their thoughts. do do do doooooo.......



"Who's your Daddy!"

Michael Taylor, he of top lawyer and executive from Monsanto, head honcho and "Food Safety Czar," in da (white) house!

The term "conspiracy" is used by the semi-literate, those who believe everything they are told, take anything the media says at face value, no questioning, as anything resembling thoughtful question is quite beyond them.

What a wonder!







kalikshama -> RE: Mental Illness (7/28/2012 5:52:33 PM)

quote:

Irresponsible parents

I never used the words "irresponsible" or a synonym on that thread and no one, including you, used the word "parents" or a synonym.

Your insisting here that I attacked your mother and father, despite evidence to the contrary, makes me concerned for you, as you are someone whose thought process I respect. In fact, when you took me to school for improperly using statistics, I accepted my lesson with grace, and respected your ability to appreciate the nuances. Your repeated insistence now on something that just plain didn't happen has me concerned.




Page: <<   < prev  4 5 [6] 7 8   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.046875