RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> General BDSM Discussion



Message


sunshinemiss -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/24/2013 4:24:57 AM)

Quote of the Day
goes to
OsideGirl
for
You've been a good girl.
You deserve a spanking!
[sm=spanking.gif] [sm=spanking.gif] [sm=spanking.gif] [sm=crop.gif] [sm=crop.gif][sm=crop.gif] [sm=whap.gif] [sm=whap.gif] [sm=whap.gif]


http://www.collarchat.com/m_4501245/tm.htm




NuevaVida -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/24/2013 6:23:14 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Focus50


quote:

ORIGINAL: NuevaVida


quote:

ORIGINAL: kalikshama

quote:

ORIGINAL: Focus50

I "punish" her by banishing her from my presence until I've at least cooled down. Not so much an active punishment dynamic as the withdrawal of all attention toward her. I've found that to be most effective on the submissive mindset.


This would certainly be effective with me!


This has the opposite affect on me.

But but but, one size fits all, surely? [8|]

Focus.


Nope - I was talking about "me" not "all." [;)]

In my world, when someone pulls their attention away, I go elsewhere. I used to not be this way, but I am now. It's basically that I won't be where I'm not wanted. And if he doesn't want to be with me, that's cool, but I'll find something else to do.

I do get upset if I think I've upset him, and he *has* taken some time away from me to regroup before (by that I don't mean extended time, although "extended" is subjective), and I get that he needs to do that. But I'll really just go off and find something else to do in the meantime. I am not the pining kind. Used to be, but no longer am.

The one time he withdrew himself for an undetermined period of time, I considered us "done" until further notice. Not because he said we were, but because I'd rather just walk away than play the emotional yo-yo game. We have since had some really good discussions and agreements about cooling off periods, and found some ground that won't kill our relationship.

Where do you get the one size fits all idea from my post? I didn't think I indicated anything about anyone other than myself.




Kana -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/24/2013 6:32:23 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: sunshinemiss

Quote of the Day
goes to
OsideGirl
for
You've been a good girl.
You deserve a spanking!
[sm=spanking.gif] [sm=spanking.gif] [sm=spanking.gif] [sm=crop.gif] [sm=crop.gif][sm=crop.gif] [sm=whap.gif] [sm=whap.gif] [sm=whap.gif]


http://www.collarchat.com/m_4501245/tm.htm

We're baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaack!
Hiya Sunny, good to see TQOTD has returned




Focus50 -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/24/2013 10:32:06 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: NuevaVida

Nope - I was talking about "me" not "all." [;)]

In my world, when someone pulls their attention away, I go elsewhere. I used to not be this way, but I am now. It's basically that I won't be where I'm not wanted. And if he doesn't want to be with me, that's cool, but I'll find something else to do.

You'd end a relationship because your dom isn't entitled to his emotions (like anger at something you did)? Your way of showing who's boss? [:-]



quote:

I do get upset if I think I've upset him, and he *has* taken some time away from me to regroup before (by that I don't mean extended time, although "extended" is subjective), and I get that he needs to do that. But I'll really just go off and find something else to do in the meantime. I am not the pining kind. Used to be, but no longer am.

See, contrition changes a lot of things. If my girl screwed up big time and was genuinely upset at herself for doing so, I seriously doubt I'd be angry myself. And since I define punishment as deriving from that which has made me angry, the whole issue is reduced to a discussion.

The trouble I'd have here, though, is the rest of your paragraph doesn't sound much like contrition. Getting "managed" is the kinda thing that'd make me walk away permanently.




quote:

Where do you get the one size fits all idea from my post? I didn't think I indicated anything about anyone other than myself.

Uh-oooooooh...! lol

The number of topics we've crossed paths in and you're not familiar with my brand of humour? No clue in the "but but but", fer instance?

Errrm, you'd be American?

Focus.




NuevaVida -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/25/2013 9:25:43 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Focus50
You'd end a relationship because your dom isn't entitled to his emotions (like anger at something you did)? Your way of showing who's boss?[/font][/size][/color] [:-]

Aw, Focus, don't read too much into it. I like you, after all!

No, I don't show who's boss - I don't do games like that. He is certainly entitled to his emotions, as I am mine. If he cuts me out, I refocus my attention. Why would I want to be where I'm not wanted?

The one time I did consider us "done" was due to the context in which his attention was withdrawn. It was much more complex than I care to write about here, suffice to say we had things worked out in about 2-3 days. It wasn't a manipulation thing, it was figuring out what was healthiest for our relationship, assuming we wanted to keep it (which we did).

I just don't do the game thing, nor do I do the pining thing. I've suffered huge loss in my life, and have learned that I can be happy just fine on my own. People come and go. I've grieved relationships before, and I know I can recover from them. I'm with him because there's nowhere in the world I would rather be, but not because I NEED him. If he wants to go away, then that's his choice - who am I to beg him to stay somewhere he doesn't want to be (wouldn't THAT be manipulative and disrespecting his feelings?). So if he does the "withholding attention" thing, yes it absolutely hurts, and my reaction isn't to consider the relationship over, but I do just find something else to do with my time until he feels like coming back. Hell, there is so much life to explore, so much out there to experience - why would I stay at home and pine for someone who doesn't want to be with me?

Mind you, if he's just pissed off and wants to go in the other room for awhile, well hey I get that. But if it's a prolonged period of time, I'll start calling friends, making plans, reading books, watching movies, going to the gym, etc. Let me know when you want to talk again and you'll have my absolute attention. Until then? I'll be over here ------>


quote:

See, contrition changes a lot of things. If my girl screwed up big time and was genuinely upset at herself for doing so, I seriously doubt I'd be angry myself. And since I define punishment as deriving from that which has made me angry, the whole issue is reduced to a discussion.


About 99.9% of the time, that's the case with us.

quote:


The trouble I'd have here, though, is the rest of your paragraph doesn't sound much like contrition. Getting "managed" is the kinda thing that'd make me walk away permanently.[/font][/size][/color]

That's because you view it as being managed, rather my own emotional response, due to my personal history, etc. You see it as manipulation, which it isn't. He doesn't see it as manipulation. He knows where my heart is, and where I've come from, and what my emotional triggers are. He is fully prepared to deal with the ramifications of a trigger being hit. I do find it interesting that your first conclusion is "getting managed." He doesn't see it that way at all, but that's because he knows me, and we give each other the benefit of the doubt.


quote:


The number of topics we've crossed paths in and you're not familiar with my brand of humour? No clue in the "but but but", fer instance?

Yeah, I figured it out after we posted.

quote:


Errrm, you'd be American?


American, raised in a Spanish/Italian culture. Why?




DesFIP -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 6:16:53 AM)

Just withdrawing attention without any explanation? That wouldn't work for me.

Saying "I'm too upset to talk about this now, we'll discuss it in the morning when I'm calmer" is totally fine. Both of us have done this, explained that we need to calm down and that further conversation at the moment will just make things deteriorate.

Table the serious talk till later and until then we are more physically affectionate in an attempt to help the calming process and increase the strength of the relationship.

But just disappear till you feel better without a word? Not knowing if you'll ever reappear is too much anxiety provoking to be something I can tolerate. I would be emotionally withdrawn and fear based after the first time, and after the second time you would not be accepted back.




NuevaVida -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 7:06:46 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: DesFIP

Saying "I'm too upset to talk about this now, we'll discuss it in the morning when I'm calmer" is totally fine. Both of us have done this, explained that we need to calm down and that further conversation at the moment will just make things deteriorate.


Yep, this happens with us from time to time. I wouldn't say we're more physically affectionate, although it's happened.

With us, there's still the miles between us - we're about 90 minutes away. So our weekends are our sacred time together. There has been a small handful of times where he's canceled a weekend together because he was either angry or just needed time to think things through. I use that time to catch up with old friends, go out, and enjoy my "me" time. Not to say there aren't some pangs within and a lot of internal thought processing about the whole situation, but I really do go out and fill my time and enjoy myself.

There was one and only one time in which we were both really really angry, and his decision to stay apart until further notice resulted in me considering us over. I don't do the "on hold" thing - you either want me or you don't. It was an extremely difficult time for both of us emotionally - we both had emotional triggers tapped all over the place. It resulted in some amazing conversations, a re-commitment of what we are to each other, and some measures put in place to do a better job of protecting our relationship. Shit happens. Relationships get ugly. You can use that to build (or in our case, rebuild) and make things better than ever. Or you can decide to leave it and move on. I'm more than willing to get down in the dirt and work things out, if the other person is wanting and willing to that, too. But if someone can't decide if he wants me or not, I focus my attention elsewhere. It's just how my emotional make-up works.




UllrsIshtar -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 7:55:40 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Focus50

Yeah, but the discipline for the dom there is to follow through - that it really has to be dropped and the sub forgiven. Fine in theory but there are those who hold onto resentment.

Me, I don't have such a simple switch to throw. If it's made me angry, it needs its own time to go away. I've been known to ignore my girl (as punishment) for 3-4 hours but even after, I can't pretend I'm as cheery as I was before she infringed. Yeah, officially or formally, she's forgiven and I say as much, but the original mood needs more time. The ol' "forgive and forget" is a good example - who really forgets that which polarises a personal relationship?

So I tell her she's forgiven; the clean slate etc - but I also tell her that the mood/demeanour etc takes a bit longer. Anyone that's ever had a fight within a vanilla relationship can appreciate that.
Focus.



That would be a giant dealbreaker for me, and something that I've not experienced at all, or would tolerate within a vanilla relationship.

When you fight you fight, and when you're making up and saying that forgiveness is granted you forgive them. Extending the resentment beyond that point I not only consider enormously unfair, and passive aggressive, but also a sign that the issue never really got resolved and you're just pretending to move on.

For me, if the 'mood' is still there, the 'talking about what happened' isn't done yet, and nothing is resolved yet. The idea of moving on from a fight with anything but both parties feeling genuine remorse, and a sort of vulnerable openness towards each other from having grown together is ludicrous to me. It seems to indicated that nothing got 'forgiven and forgotten' indeed, and the resolution never got passed the initial conflict solving state of 'lets clear out their air and tell each other what's on our minds'.

If you're not coming out of a fight stronger, more and love, and more open towards each other, all you're doing is slowly killing the relationship.




slaveluci -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 9:14:57 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: NuevaVida

No, I don't show who's boss - I don't do games like that. He is certainly entitled to his emotions, as I am mine. If he cuts me out, I refocus my attention. Why would I want to be where I'm not wanted?

The one time I did consider us "done" was due to the context in which his attention was withdrawn. It was much more complex than I care to write about here, suffice to say we had things worked out in about 2-3 days. It wasn't a manipulation thing, it was figuring out what was healthiest for our relationship, assuming we wanted to keep it (which we did).

I just don't do the game thing, nor do I do the pining thing. I've suffered huge loss in my life, and have learned that I can be happy just fine on my own. People come and go. I've grieved relationships before, and I know I can recover from them. I'm with him because there's nowhere in the world I would rather be, but not because I NEED him. If he wants to go away, then that's his choice - who am I to beg him to stay somewhere he doesn't want to be (wouldn't THAT be manipulative and disrespecting his feelings?). So if he does the "withholding attention" thing, yes it absolutely hurts, and my reaction isn't to consider the relationship over, but I do just find something else to do with my time until he feels like coming back. Hell, there is so much life to explore, so much out there to experience - why would I stay at home and pine for someone who doesn't want to be with me?

Mind you, if he's just pissed off and wants to go in the other room for awhile, well hey I get that. But if it's a prolonged period of time, I'll start calling friends, making plans, reading books, watching movies, going to the gym, etc. Let me know when you want to talk again and you'll have my absolute attention. Until then? I'll be over here ------>


My sentiments exactly. You sum it up so well. It is so wonderful to see how things are going for you these days. You're more beautiful than ever - inside and out - and continually posting smart, inspiring things. You've always been my "hero" here on these boards and I just wanted to say it again. [sm=cheering.gif]

luci




NuevaVida -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 10:45:05 AM)

Luci thank you. That really touched me.




SimplyMichael -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 12:03:18 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: UllrsIshtar


quote:

ORIGINAL: Focus50

Yeah, but the discipline for the dom there is to follow through - that it really has to be dropped and the sub forgiven. Fine in theory but there are those who hold onto resentment.

Me, I don't have such a simple switch to throw. If it's made me angry, it needs its own time to go away. I've been known to ignore my girl (as punishment) for 3-4 hours but even after, I can't pretend I'm as cheery as I was before she infringed. Yeah, officially or formally, she's forgiven and I say as much, but the original mood needs more time. The ol' "forgive and forget" is a good example - who really forgets that which polarises a personal relationship?

So I tell her she's forgiven; the clean slate etc - but I also tell her that the mood/demeanour etc takes a bit longer. Anyone that's ever had a fight within a vanilla relationship can appreciate that.
Focus.



That would be a giant dealbreaker for me, and something that I've not experienced at all, or would tolerate within a vanilla relationship.

When you fight you fight, and when you're making up and saying that forgiveness is granted you forgive them. Extending the resentment beyond that point I not only consider enormously unfair, and passive aggressive, but also a sign that the issue never really got resolved and you're just pretending to move on.

For me, if the 'mood' is still there, the 'talking about what happened' isn't done yet, and nothing is resolved yet. The idea of moving on from a fight with anything but both parties feeling genuine remorse, and a sort of vulnerable openness towards each other from having grown together is ludicrous to me. It seems to indicated that nothing got 'forgiven and forgotten' indeed, and the resolution never got passed the initial conflict solving state of 'lets clear out their air and tell each other what's on our minds'.

If you're not coming out of a fight stronger, more and love, and more open towards each other, all you're doing is slowly killing the relationship.


THIS




Focus50 -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 3:28:36 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: NuevaVida

I just don't do the game thing, nor do I do the pining thing.

What is this "game" thing you keep banging on about? I'm talking about *this topic*, not pretend or roleplay or the like, which I don't indulge in anyway. Real people in real relationships that don't always run silky smooth.

The way you've presented (or I've received) your meaning is that if sub screws up to a point of making dom angry, while diddoms dom is off sulking, sub will wile away the time finding other things to do. Never mind walking away, I'd never have been in THAT "relationship".




quote:

Mind you, if he's just pissed off and wants to go in the other room for awhile, well hey I get that.

And yet again, I'm not talking about a mood or just being "pissed off", I'm talking about if sub's actions are the actual reason for that mood change and of consequences. You know, THIS topic.



quote:

That's because you view it as being managed, rather my own emotional response, due to my personal history, etc. You see it as manipulation, which it isn't. He doesn't see it as manipulation. He knows where my heart is, and where I've come from, and what my emotional triggers are. He is fully prepared to deal with the ramifications of a trigger being hit. I do find it interesting that your first conclusion is "getting managed." He doesn't see it that way at all, but that's because he knows me, and we give each other the benefit of the doubt.

Hey, I'm doing my best to interpret your words and the context in which you're presenting them. Overall, I'm getting the gist that fuck-all is ever your fault or responsibility. But lol, I don't actually believe that to be the case. So what you find "interesting" equates to me scratching my head and often muttering "wtf?".



quote:

American, raised in a Spanish/Italian culture. Why?

Lol, I hadta ask cos I'm on something of a roll with Americans on this site (not you - yet) and what constitutes humour. Apparently, unless I actually add a smiley face every single time (the magic code?), well, how are they ever gonna know what's implied...?

Errrm.... [:)]

Focus.




Focus50 -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 3:48:50 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: UllrsIshtar


quote:

ORIGINAL: Focus50

Yeah, but the discipline for the dom there is to follow through - that it really has to be dropped and the sub forgiven. Fine in theory but there are those who hold onto resentment.

Me, I don't have such a simple switch to throw. If it's made me angry, it needs its own time to go away. I've been known to ignore my girl (as punishment) for 3-4 hours but even after, I can't pretend I'm as cheery as I was before she infringed. Yeah, officially or formally, she's forgiven and I say as much, but the original mood needs more time. The ol' "forgive and forget" is a good example - who really forgets that which polarises a personal relationship?

So I tell her she's forgiven; the clean slate etc - but I also tell her that the mood/demeanour etc takes a bit longer. Anyone that's ever had a fight within a vanilla relationship can appreciate that.
Focus.



That would be a giant dealbreaker for me, and something that I've not experienced at all, or would tolerate within a vanilla relationship.

When you fight you fight, and when you're making up and saying that forgiveness is granted you forgive them. Extending the resentment beyond that point I not only consider enormously unfair, and passive aggressive, but also a sign that the issue never really got resolved and you're just pretending to move on.

For me, if the 'mood' is still there, the 'talking about what happened' isn't done yet, and nothing is resolved yet. The idea of moving on from a fight with anything but both parties feeling genuine remorse, and a sort of vulnerable openness towards each other from having grown together is ludicrous to me. It seems to indicated that nothing got 'forgiven and forgotten' indeed, and the resolution never got passed the initial conflict solving state of 'lets clear out their air and tell each other what's on our minds'.

If you're not coming out of a fight stronger, more and love, and more open towards each other, all you're doing is slowly killing the relationship.


This is the on/off switch I was talking about - the one I don't have.

So what you're saying is that if you have one of those "knock-down, drag-out" (not physically) relationship fights where *everything* is fair game (or ammunition), and then it's over and you make up, a day later it's like it never happened? Any memory is wiped?

What about an hour later - you're back to exactly the same happy demeanour you were in immediately before the first trigger was pulled?

I'm sure as hell not talking about lingering resentment or grudges, merely that I can't pretend nothing happened at all. But way to grasp for the opposite extreme! Anyway, show me a couple that never had a fight and I'll show you a couple who never made up etc. That's finding out all there is about each other.

But forget? How do you wipe your memory clean like that? And consequently, how do you retain any lessons learnt? No shit, I'm genuinely intrigued...! Right now, I'm at the stage of thinking this is feel-good theoretical hokey - lotsa gaps waiting to be filled in....

Focus.




Focus50 -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 3:56:34 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: DesFIP

Just withdrawing attention without any explanation? That wouldn't work for me.

Saying "I'm too upset to talk about this now, we'll discuss it in the morning when I'm calmer" is totally fine. Both of us have done this, explained that we need to calm down and that further conversation at the moment will just make things deteriorate.

Table the serious talk till later and until then we are more physically affectionate in an attempt to help the calming process and increase the strength of the relationship.

But just disappear till you feel better without a word? Not knowing if you'll ever reappear is too much anxiety provoking to be something I can tolerate. I would be emotionally withdrawn and fear based after the first time, and after the second time you would not be accepted back.


Again with this "for no reason or explanation etc" derailment....

Or are you getting that just from NuevaVida, too?

Focus.




Focus50 -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 4:08:26 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: SimplyMichael

quote:

ORIGINAL: UllrsIshtar

That would be a giant dealbreaker for me, and something that I've not experienced at all, or would tolerate within a vanilla relationship.

When you fight you fight, and when you're making up and saying that forgiveness is granted you forgive them. Extending the resentment beyond that point I not only consider enormously unfair, and passive aggressive, but also a sign that the issue never really got resolved and you're just pretending to move on.

For me, if the 'mood' is still there, the 'talking about what happened' isn't done yet, and nothing is resolved yet. The idea of moving on from a fight with anything but both parties feeling genuine remorse, and a sort of vulnerable openness towards each other from having grown together is ludicrous to me. It seems to indicated that nothing got 'forgiven and forgotten' indeed, and the resolution never got passed the initial conflict solving state of 'lets clear out their air and tell each other what's on our minds'.

If you're not coming out of a fight stronger, more and love, and more open towards each other, all you're doing is slowly killing the relationship.


THIS


I dunno Simply, your idea of discussion is all over the place and I can't keep up. But ok, it's possible it's just me....

Anyway, you're done with this topic or you're not. And if you're not, well, I did respond to your last post that consisted of more than lazily barracking from the bleachers like this.

You're quick to grab for words like courtesy and class etc - in or out - too hard?

Focus.




theshytype -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 5:04:29 PM)

Focus,

If I understand you correctly, I'm the same when it comes to fights.
I don't have an on/off switch, instead it's more like a dimmer.

If we have a large fight, he apologizes and I forgive him. But, my mood cannot be restored as quickly as it was destroyed.
Some need foreplay to warm up for sex. Me, I need a warming up period for my mood.

It's not holding onto a grudge, he doesn't need to kiss my ass, I just don't jump from upset to happy-go-lucky at the snap of a finger.
There are ways he speeds up the process, though, such as making me laugh.




UllrsIshtar -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 8:30:00 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Focus50

This is the on/off switch I was talking about - the one I don't have.

So what you're saying is that if you have one of those "knock-down, drag-out" (not physically) relationship fights where *everything* is fair game (or ammunition), and then it's over and you make up, a day later it's like it never happened? Any memory is wiped?

What about an hour later - you're back to exactly the same happy demeanour you were in immediately before the first trigger was pulled?

Focus.



Nope, I'm saying I don't have any "knock-down, drag-out, relationship fights where *everything* is fair game or ammunition" I don't see a point in being with somebody who resorts to making *everything* fair game when we get into a fight.

If you're making *everything* fair game, it means that -in that moment- your ONLY goal is to hurt the other person.
I'm not in relationships with people who are out to hurt me, whether they're angry or not when they try to is absolutely irrelevant to me.

When I fight with my husband, it's usually caused by a misunderstanding. One of us, or both of us, are for whatever reason, more touchy in that moment where the fight starts, and say, or take something that's been said, the wrong way. From there, miscommunications pile up, until we're both convinced that we're right, and the other one is wrong and should apologize.
From there, we often both needs some time to cool off, but as soon as we both have cooled off enough, we talk things through, and look to untangle the mess that caused the fight in the first place. Apologies are made when necessary, usually by both sides, and with every piece that's resolved we move on more.

What we do NOT do is aim 'ammunition' at each other, either from passed, or current events. We're not out to get cheap shots in, or to hurt each other, or into making *everything* fair game. Usually when we're fighting, we're both hurt because we're misunderstanding the other's intentions, but I've never known either of us out TO hurt the other one.

In fact, I can't really imagine wanting to do that, or wanting to be with somebody who wants to do that when they're angry.

For me, fights are about miscommunications, which is why it's easy to forget afterwards. It's not that I literally can't remember what he did to upset me, it's that, once it's become clear to me why he did that (he was upset and accidentally a little snarky, or I completely misunderstood his intent, or he completely misunderstood mine, or whatever) the fact that he did it isn't important anymore, because, through talking, and understanding what happened, the entire context is now changed.

If we get into a fight because I think he's using a passive aggressive snarky tone with me, and midway through the fight we come to the conclusion that he was doing so because he was actually really upset about me forgetting to do something I promised to do, and he comes to the conclusion that I didn't forget but delayed because something unforeseen was thrown my way and it was actually quite reasonable of me to delay it, then what the fuck does it still matter if I remember or not that the fight started because he was being snarky? I mean, at that point the chain of events has been resolved to the point that his actual tone that caused the fight has become so irrelevant that, even though I technically still remember it happened, I may as well have forgotten because it's just not important anymore.

Now, if he in fights was deliberately trying to hurt me by making *everything* fair game, and deliberately said a bunch of nasty stuff to me in order to get the trump to wear me down and 'win' the fight, now THAT I'd definitely not forget... but the thing that I'd remember about that is that if it happened on an even semi-consistent basis is that this is a person whose ultimate goal -when push comes to shove- is to hurt me, not to love me and work with me. Reaching that conclusion, which I'd come to after only a very very few of such fights, I'd pack my bags and leave.

I don't understand why I'd want to be with somebody who desires to hurt me whenever things get a little harder on him for a bit because of his anger.




littlewonder -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 8:53:58 PM)

In all the time that Master and I have been together I think we have only had one nasty fight and even that fight didn't last longer than a day or two. I would not be in a relationship with someone who felt that they still had to hold onto anger or negative emotions afterwards or it was a no holds barred type of fights and they happen over and over again. That type of relationship would literally kill me. I just couldn't do it.

As Master explained, if he does get upset with me, he punishes me, we talk about it and then all is over. We move on. We don't hold it against each other. We don't feel angry or upset any longer. It's just over. If he felt a need to hold onto the negative emotions afterwards I would wonder why he bothered to punish me and why am I still there. It would just seem like a big, huge waste of time to me.





NuevaVida -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 11:38:12 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Focus50

]What is this "game" thing you keep banging on about? I'm talking about *this topic*, not pretend or roleplay or the like, which I don't indulge in anyway. Real people in real relationships that don't always run silky smooth.

Maybe you guys across the pond use the term differently than we do. I'm talking about this topic, too, and my posts have nothing to do with role play.

Over here in my world, being manipulative, or "showing who's boss" or being anything other than my authentic, honest and loving self would be playing a game - an emotional or mental game. Passive aggressiveness, for example, is game playing to me, where you're not just putting your honest cards on the table, but instead you're behaving or speaking in a way with a manipulative agenda in mind. You made a comment to me about showing him who is boss -that falls into this category. We're just not that way with each other. I know he's the boss, and I have no desire otherwise. "Showing him who's boss" would be some sort of one-upmanship with him, which to me, serves no purpose in our goal of moving a healthy relationship forward and with honesty.

Yeah, I'm well aware that real people in real relationships don't always run silky smooth. I actually said in a subsequent posts that relationships can get ugly sometimes, and that I'm more than willing to get down in the dirt to work things out. At least in my real relationship, with real and honest participants in it, that's how it works.

quote:


The way you've presented (or I've received) your meaning is that if sub screws up to a point of making dom angry, while diddoms dom is off sulking, sub will wile away the time finding other things to do. Never mind walking away, I'd never have been in THAT "relationship".

Either you received it wrong or I didn't communicate clearly or a little bit of both.

First, you're assuming in my situation that he was mad at me because I "screwed up." That wasn't the case. I didn't say why he was mad. But with us, it's usually some sort of misunderstanding, or in the case where I felt we were over, some very serious PTSD emotional triggers were hit very hard, and my anxiety attack over it was something he wasn't understanding, and was something that actually triggered his own emotional land mine. It was a series of horrible reactions to each other, which took great effort to work through. His initial reaction was to remove himself from me for a matter of days, with no resolve in sight.

In the situations I was talking about, in no way did I ever imply he was "sulking" (where the hell did you get that??), and I'm not really sure what wiling away means. When he has needed time to think, my heart aches, but I find things to do. Would you prefer your girl curl up in a ball and pine? Life is too short for that. I don't take it lightly. I ache for him, but that doesn't mean I stop living.

As for this: Never mind walking away, I'd never have been in THAT "relationship". What a strange and judgmental statement. Are you in a current relationship that's fulfilling your life like you've never imagined? If so, that's awesome. I am. As I commented in another post, that one situation was a very emotionally difficult one for both of us, and we worked a lot out as a result of it. Like you said, real relationships with real people don't always run silky smooth. Life isn't so black and white.


quote:

And yet again, I'm not talking about a mood or just being "pissed off", I'm talking about if sub's actions are the actual reason for that mood change and of consequences. You know, THIS topic.

Pardon me. I should have said "Pissed off at ME." I figured you would have inferred that, since we were talking about...you know...THIS topic. [;)]

But again, you assume he might be pissed because of a misbehavior, rather than a reaction to his own actions, or an emotional trigger, or a misunderstanding, or....anything else. This whole exchange is about how him removing his attention from me would do nothing to "punish me" or teach me anything or straighten me out, in response to your post that that's what you find works. I'm saying it doesn't work here. He knows this, and is far more creative about getting what he wants from me. And he does get what he wants from me.

In over 4 years, I think he's gotten pissed off at me 2, maybe 3 times. It hardly comes up. And when it does, he works toward getting us on the same page, rather than emotionally separating us.



quote:

Hey, I'm doing my best to interpret your words and the context in which you're presenting them. Overall, I'm getting the gist that fuck-all is ever your fault or responsibility. But lol, I don't actually believe that to be the case. So what you find "interesting" equates to me scratching my head and often muttering "wtf?".

Well, to be honest, we don't really look at things as "fault" between us. If I fuck up it's because there's a foundational upset of some sort, or because of some underlying reason that needs to be addressed. I aim to please him, always. If I don't please him, or think I don't please him, I ask him if he's upset at me, or if I offended him, or if I can do something to fix it, etc. Seriously, we talk all the time. About everything. What I'm saying is, whatever the reason for a screw up (and trust me when I say the screw ups are never intentional), the very few times he's withdrawn his attention have been counter-effective for us. That's a tool in the toolbox that doesn't work for us. If he withdraws his attention, I shut down from him, emotionally. It's a protective measure that I'm wired with. It's an emotional response. It's not a "fuck all, I don't give a shit" - it's a break down of our bond, particularly if it's for more than a day.

This is why, as I also said earlier, we have incorporated tools in our relationship to not let this happen.



quote:

]Lol, I hadta ask cos I'm on something of a roll with Americans on this site (not you - yet) and what constitutes humour. Apparently, unless I actually add a smiley face every single time (the magic code?), well, how are they ever gonna know what's implied...?

Errrm.... [:)]

Focus.

Well, smiley faces are cool. I think you should add 'em. [:D]

Seriously though, I'm not sure if you actually feel this way or not, but your posts seem to show a "you versus me" attitude with regard to your relationships. He and I don't operate that way. Knock down, drag out fight, where everything is fair game? That doesn't happen over here. We get pissed off, we spar over it, we figure out the root of it, we fix what the problem is, we remind each other that we love each other, and we move forward. Everything fair game implies to me that we're each other's enemy, and we're not. The problem is the enemy. We're on the same team. And there are boundaries to respect. We don't treat the people we love most with "everything is fair game because we're in a fight." Our minds and hearts just don't go there. Maybe that's why you & I aren't understanding each other in this discussion - because we seem to be coming from two totally different places.




NuevaVida -> RE: Do you use spanking/whipping as punishment? (7/26/2013 11:43:52 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: UllrsIshtar


If you're making *everything* fair game, it means that -in that moment- your ONLY goal is to hurt the other person.
I'm not in relationships with people who are out to hurt me, whether they're angry or not when they try to is absolutely irrelevant to me.



I could have quoted your entire post with a big applause, but I just wrote up a big ol' post myself, and I'm trying not to take up so much screen space lol.

But seriously, everything you said resonated with me. He & I are on the same team. We love each other and that means we don't try to hurt each other. Arguments are the result of misunderstandings, and are resolved and then put away.

We don't have ammunition to use on each other in this relationship. To me, that's not a relationship worth having. The goal of our relationship is to be happy together. That means if there's a problem, it's he & I on one side of the table and the problem on the other. Sometimes we might spar about how to resolve that problem, or we might get frustrated with each other. But we are always on the same side.

Thanks for posting what you did. Awesomely said.




Page: <<   < prev  3 4 [5] 6 7   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
6.445313E-02