Kaliko
Posts: 3381
Joined: 9/25/2010 Status: offline
|
quote:
ORIGINAL: shiftyw Sure- I'm putting "spin" on it I guess. I guess I don't know why you're focusing on you're own experience so much and ignoring what others may experience... Well, that's the thing. That's what's kind of fascinating about this to me is that my experiences aren't that much different than, say, yours (for example) and what you described. I'm not ignoring the experience of you or others. I'm pondering how we can walk away from our similar experiences feeling completely differently about the role that slut-shaming has on our lives. I've said that it might be that I am already somewhat aligned with that type of thinking. I think a woman should consider the ramifications of promiscuity. I believe in differences between the genders and that we cannot possibly be judged equally across the board on all points. And I am 100% certain that I'm not alone in feeling this way. (Though, I might be here on these boards, I know.) And I'm aware that these being my beliefs might explain why I don't feel oppressed. But seeing as I'm not alone in my beliefs, then those who are fighting slut-shaming are not fighting for oppression against women. They're fighting oppression against women who perceive oppression. Without going back to reread my posts to be sure, I'm pretty sure I left myself open to the possibility that the oppression does exist and I just don't see it. You volunteered some examples, but I can't agree that they're necessarily examples of oppression. As a counter, similar to what Catize briefly touched on, I saw recently across my Facebook feed a teacher's contract from 1923. A teacher (female, then, of course) was not allowed to marry, leave town, smoke cigarettes, drink alcohol, dress in bright colors, etc. If legally we were forced to endure these types of restrictions, forced to endure sexual harassment in the workplace, or if we were forced to endure rape as a man's right, .... That is oppression, and oppression that any woman would be at risk of being the victim of. But knowing that some people don't approve of my sexual activity? And they might voice that? I'm still having trouble seeing how other peoples' opinions oppress me. I almost want to apologize. I feel like you (general you, not just shifty) might be banging your head against the desk at my inability to see this. But no. I just don't. And (respectfully and with some slight humor), the fact that you posted that list from Facebook as perhaps a means to convince me is just another example of how far apart we are on the spectrum. Not that you're wrong. And not that I am. But wow, we are reading that list completely differently.
|