RE: Why they riot (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Community Discussions] >> Dungeon of Political and Religious Discussion



Message


slvemike4u -> RE: Why they riot (5/1/2015 6:13:01 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: MrRodgers

The best statement yet on why they riot. For any objective sociological assessment as to why people would go to such extremes. This becomes a very important question...why ?

“My greater source of personal concern, outrage and sympathy beyond this particular case is focused neither upon one night’s property damage nor upon the acts."

“It is focused rather upon the past four-decade period during which an American political elite have shipped middle class and working class jobs away from Baltimore and cities and towns around the U.S. to third-world dictatorships like China and others, plunged tens of millions of good, hard-working Americans into economic devastation, and then followed that action around the nation by diminishing every American’s civil rights protections in order to control an unfairly impoverished population living under an ever-declining standard of living and suffering at the butt end of an ever-more militarized and aggressive surveillance state.”

Peter Angelos Owner of the Baltimore Orioles, responding to a sports radio broadcaster upset about earlier protests causing gate closures at Camden Yards.

Thinking of the presidential hopefuls:

Almost none of the presidential hopefuls — themselves backed by corporate patrons — even mentions poverty. So it’s doubtful they’ve considered the sense of hopelessness that chronic unemployment might cause, or the disenfranchisement a black man might experience when his very presence is treated as a problem. It might mean getting pulled over for doing nothing wrong, or being handcuffed on a walk home. Or ending up dead for selling cigarettes, or for having the nerve to look a police lieutenant in the eye, as Freddie Gray did.....

Angelos and Basu are exactly right.



I posted that quote a few days ago in a thread that is no longer with us.
I thought it was eloquent and spoke to the problem forcefully.
As to Sanity's post,I'm from New York and I recall the big deal made when a major theater chain opened a sixplex or something in Newark NJ in the late eighty's .
Seems no major motion picture theater had been built opened there since the riots of the late sixties.
Over twenty damm years !!!!!!
Apparently there was not only a lack of will there was also an impossibility in acquiring insurance for any endeavor .




slvemike4u -> RE: Why they riot (5/1/2015 6:20:49 PM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: bounty44

that's a dandy question...apart from liberal race baiters and the pandering democrats, im not sure.

bill o'reilly mentioned recently he thinks its going to take Baltimore decades to recover from this.

one thing missing so far in response to the OP (though i trust it will show up eventually) is the notion of individual responsibility. I can be oppressed, disenfranchised, and unemployed, and still I have a choice to burn and loot, or to not.

Personal responsibility is of course necessary....but when you combine that statement with O'Reilly's about how long it will take Baltimore to recover you have to take into account the difficulty other urban area's have faced coming back from major public dis rest(re:riots)no one will want to invest !
Once you find someone willing to invest they themselves run into the issue of an inabilty to secure insurance ....which makes a fiscal bounce back nigh on impossible.
Which just might be where the need for governmental assistance comes into play.

By the way,yeah Democrats pander to their constituency but Republicans pander to theirs too.It's called politics and it takes a strong and gifted politician to rise above it and actually lead.

For myself I don't see one on the Republican horizon,I'm sure you feel the same way about Democratic hopefuls.




BamaD -> RE: Why they riot (5/1/2015 6:43:36 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: HunterCA

quote:

ORIGINAL: Marini

DmSM
quote:

ORIGINAL: MrRodgers

The best statement yet on why they riot. For any objective sociological assessment as to why people would go to such extremes. This becomes a very important question...why ?

“My greater source of personal concern, outrage and sympathy beyond this particular case is focused neither upon one night’s property damage nor upon the acts."

“It is focused rather upon the past four-decade period during which an American political elite have shipped middle class and working class jobs away from Baltimore and cities and towns around the U.S. to third-world dictatorships like China and others, plunged tens of millions of good, hard-working Americans into economic devastation, and then followed that action around the nation by diminishing every American’s civil rights protections in order to control an unfairly impoverished population living under an ever-declining standard of living and suffering at the butt end of an ever-more militarized and aggressive surveillance state.”

Peter Angelos Owner of the Baltimore Orioles, responding to a sports radio broadcaster upset about earlier protests causing gate closures at Camden Yards.

Thinking of the presidential hopefuls:

Almost none of the presidential hopefuls — themselves backed by corporate patrons — even mentions poverty. So it’s doubtful they’ve considered the sense of hopelessness that chronic unemployment might cause, or the disenfranchisement a black man might experience when his very presence is treated as a problem. It might mean getting pulled over for doing nothing wrong, or being handcuffed on a walk home. Or ending up dead for selling cigarettes, or for havingthe nerve to look a police lieutenant in the eye, as Freddie Gray did.....

Angelos and Basu are exactly right.


As a BLACK African American woman, I thank you for this.
I realized LONG ago, Many non-Black folks on here, feel they are experts on how many Black people think, so I don't bother to debate on most topics dealing with race on here.
[sm=goodpost.gif]
Thank you, and fucking A, Mr. Rogers
I told an elderly family member last night, that I agree with what one young man in Baltimore, stated in an interview.
....Many people have NO idea how many young Black people feel in the inner city.

As a Black woman, I agree.
When I was much younger, it was EASY to get a job, and times were much easier.

With Black unemployment at critically high levels, I don't know what it"feels like", NOT to be able to get a job, to feel like I have little to no opportunites, and to live with chronic/pervasive hopelessness.

Thank you Mr. Rogers

PEACE



I don't think I'm an expert on how black people think. I know I'm not an expert on how white people think. I think it's weird to assume all people of any group think a like. But I do have some experience. I had a black sub once years ago. She'd text me while she was sitting around her kitchen table with her family. She'd tell me they were talking about how much they hated white people. I don't recall one similar kitchen table talk in my home. Yet, if one group is seeing the world through that sort of mindset, I'm pretty sure they're going to project onto me that I hate just as they do.

I know for a fact liberal's of all colors project that onto me now.

Of course they project, they excuse their hatred with how much they assume you hate them.




BamaD -> RE: Why they riot (5/1/2015 7:01:24 PM)

fr

it isn't like all blacks burn and loot
it isn't like all the arsonists and looters are black
The question is why some people believe in anarchy.




Marini -> RE: Why they riot (5/1/2015 7:52:08 PM)

Fast reply, because this is for no one in particular.

We all have a right to discuss any topic that we want, online or offline.
I NEVER stated that people of other races, could or should not discuss Black people/or Black issues.

*It's insane, I need to even type this, which is why I normally avoid threads in which "Black people" are being discussed on here. These threads tend to normally go the same way, and I don't come here to find people to despise and hate on-line, so best not to read them.**

It would never enter my head to think I know how it really feels to be: gay, jewish, hispanic, white, blind, deaf, President, a siamese twin, etc.

I know many people feel they really KNOW how other people feel/and think, when in fact you have NO idea how you would REALLY feel IF you were in their shoes.
I don't give a flying fuck if everyone you know is Black, you don't know how YOU would feel if YOU were Black.
**Or gay, blind, disabled, living in a 3rd world country, a slave, held hostage by terrorists, {you insert situation here}.

There is a big difference betweeen discussing ANY situation/or race of people in the world, and presuming that you know {for a fact},how YOU would feel if you were of that race or in that situation.

I can discuss any subject in the world, but damn if I would attempt to think I know FOR A FACT, how I would feel if I were THEM/or in that situation.
**I can study, speculate, guess, hypothesize, and fucking analyze, but damn if I can get into the "head" of someone else.**

This is only a message board, and I have enough real life issues not to really give a damn.

So, as pretty much the only regular Black poster around here, I will say---goodbye to this thread/and any other similar thread, for the time being.

I will hardly waste my time, chatting or typing to someone/or people that think I don't know what it is like to be a Black woman.
[sm=abducted.gif]

**This shit is too crazy even for me.**

So enjoy and have fun!

Isn't free speech wonderful?
[sm=line.gif]

Peace




tweakabelle -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 2:53:02 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Marini

DmSM
quote:

ORIGINAL: MrRodgers

The best statement yet on why they riot. For any objective sociological assessment as to why people would go to such extremes. This becomes a very important question...why ?

“My greater source of personal concern, outrage and sympathy beyond this particular case is focused neither upon one night’s property damage nor upon the acts."

“It is focused rather upon the past four-decade period during which an American political elite have shipped middle class and working class jobs away from Baltimore and cities and towns around the U.S. to third-world dictatorships like China and others, plunged tens of millions of good, hard-working Americans into economic devastation, and then followed that action around the nation by diminishing every American’s civil rights protections in order to control an unfairly impoverished population living under an ever-declining standard of living and suffering at the butt end of an ever-more militarized and aggressive surveillance state.”

Peter Angelos Owner of the Baltimore Orioles, responding to a sports radio broadcaster upset about earlier protests causing gate closures at Camden Yards.

Thinking of the presidential hopefuls:

Almost none of the presidential hopefuls — themselves backed by corporate patrons — even mentions poverty. So it’s doubtful they’ve considered the sense of hopelessness that chronic unemployment might cause, or the disenfranchisement a black man might experience when his very presence is treated as a problem. It might mean getting pulled over for doing nothing wrong, or being handcuffed on a walk home. Or ending up dead for selling cigarettes, or for havingthe nerve to look a police lieutenant in the eye, as Freddie Gray did.....

Angelos and Basu are exactly right.


As a BLACK African American woman, I thank you for this.
I realized LONG ago, Many non-Black folks on here, feel they are experts on how many Black people think, so I don't bother to debate on most topics dealing with race on here.
[sm=goodpost.gif]
Thank you, and fucking A, Mr. Rogers
I told an elderly family member last night, that I agree with what one young man in Baltimore, stated in an interview.
....Many people have NO idea how many young Black people feel in the inner city.

As a Black woman, I agree.
When I was much younger, it was EASY to get a job, and times were much easier.

With Black unemployment at critically high levels, I don't know what it"feels like", NOT to be able to get a job, to feel like I have little to no opportunites, and to live with chronic/pervasive hopelessness.

Thank you Mr. Rogers

PEACE

QFT.

The statement by the Peter Angelos struck me as the most incisive and intelligent comment I have seen or heard on this issue, either here or in the media. It answers the question 'Why do they riot?' eloquently and comprehensively. Who amongst us wouldn't be tempted to react strongly faced with that set of circumstances?




bounty44 -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 5:20:46 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: slvemike4u


quote:

ORIGINAL: bounty44

that's a dandy question...apart from liberal race baiters and the pandering democrats, im not sure.

bill o'reilly mentioned recently he thinks its going to take Baltimore decades to recover from this.

one thing missing so far in response to the OP (though i trust it will show up eventually) is the notion of individual responsibility. I can be oppressed, disenfranchised, and unemployed, and still I have a choice to burn and loot, or to not.

Personal responsibility is of course necessary....but when you combine that statement with O'Reilly's about how long it will take Baltimore to recover you have to take into account the difficulty other urban area's have faced coming back from major public dis rest(re:riots)no one will want to invest !
Once you find someone willing to invest they themselves run into the issue of an inabilty to secure insurance ....which makes a fiscal bounce back nigh on impossible.
Which just might be where the need for governmental assistance comes into play.

By the way,yeah Democrats pander to their constituency but Republicans pander to theirs too.It's called politics and it takes a strong and gifted politician to rise above it and actually lead.

For myself I don't see one on the Republican horizon,I'm sure you feel the same way about Democratic hopefuls.


possibly, except it was the local government that more or less let the destruction occur to begin with. I still wouldn't invest there unless something significantly changed in the leadership. the final responsibility for the destruction lies with the individuals who looted and burned but the democratic leadership in the city was absolutely negligent if not complicit.

I don't see pandering as bipartisan in politics. pandering refers to gratifying a person's weakness or vulgar tastes. the democrat position vis-à-vis blacks is, vote for us because (non liberal) whites and republicans are racist, capitalism is evil, and the government is here to help you (create dependence ). essentially, if its not "vote for us and we'll give you stuff" I don't know what it is and those positions appeal to relatively base sentiments in a person.

I also suspect if democrats didn't pretty much have blacks in their back pocket, they wouldn't nearly get elected to the extent they do.

if there is a republican counterpart to that, I don't know it. but that said, im not about republicans per se, im about the type of freedom that finds its home in libertarian/conservative thinking. not all republicans embody that.






bounty44 -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 5:38:41 AM)

I watched a lot of the coverage of this last night and one of the things that came up was the idea of the city attorney's "rush to judgment" in her charges of the officers in question and the mayor's ill-used phrase of "justice for Freddie."

the former might be problematic because the charges, in the eyes of some legal experts ive been listening to, might be an overreach.

the latter is problematic because it implies knowledge that the police are already guilty.

in both cases, this is going to put a tremendous amount of pressure on the trial. my supposition would be, if the people don't get the convictions they want there is likely going to be more rioting.

that said, imagine the pressure the jurors are going to feel in making their judgments.





cloudboy -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 6:34:14 AM)

One thing about lawyers, they come in contact and represent a great deal of different types of people. We learn about their lives, troubles, goals, challenges, etc.

Lawyers often have some of the best insights and often work on the front lines of important social issues. Most of Angelos clients are class action plaintiffs, and the bulk of those he represents are blue collar employees.

Bethlehem Steel used to be the largest employer in Baltimore. Now, its GONE. IF you drive in BALTO roads, you'd think the USA was a third world country.

We can only wonder in dumbfounded terms what the opportunity cost of endless wars in Afghanistan and IRAQ have cost us back home.

MNOT believes we should abandon globalization and go back to protectionism. Bernie Sanders is against the Asian Trade Deal (new Presidential nominee.)




cloudboy -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 6:46:27 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: tweakabelle


QFT.

The statement by the Peter Angelos struck me as the most incisive and intelligent comment I have seen or heard on this issue, either here or in the media. It answers the question 'Why do they riot?' eloquently and comprehensively. Who amongst us wouldn't be tempted to react strongly faced with that set of circumstances?


He hasn't run our baseball team so well.....(unfortunately)




Lucylastic -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 6:52:57 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Marini

Fast reply, because this is for no one in particular.

We all have a right to discuss any topic that we want, online or offline.
I NEVER stated that people of other races, could or should not discuss Black people/or Black issues.

*It's insane, I need to even type this, which is why I normally avoid threads in which "Black people" are being discussed on here. These threads tend to normally go the same way, and I don't come here to find people to despise and hate on-line, so best not to read them.**

It would never enter my head to think I know how it really feels to be: gay, jewish, hispanic, white, blind, deaf, President, a siamese twin, etc.

I know many people feel they really KNOW how other people feel/and think, when in fact you have NO idea how you would REALLY feel IF you were in their shoes.
I don't give a flying fuck if everyone you know is Black, you don't know how YOU would feel if YOU were Black.
**Or gay, blind, disabled, living in a 3rd world country, a slave, held hostage by terrorists, {you insert situation here}.

There is a big difference betweeen discussing ANY situation/or race of people in the world, and presuming that you know {for a fact},how YOU would feel if you were of that race or in that situation.

I can discuss any subject in the world, but damn if I would attempt to think I know FOR A FACT, how I would feel if I were THEM/or in that situation.
**I can study, speculate, guess, hypothesize, and fucking analyze, but damn if I can get into the "head" of someone else.**

This is only a message board, and I have enough real life issues not to really give a damn.

So, as pretty much the only regular Black poster around here, I will say---goodbye to this thread/and any other similar thread, for the time being.

I will hardly waste my time, chatting or typing to someone/or people that think I don't know what it is like to be a Black woman.
[sm=abducted.gif]

**This shit is too crazy even for me.**

So enjoy and have fun!

Isn't free speech wonderful?
[sm=line.gif]

Peace


QFT plus 1
Hugs to you Marini
I wish we had more like you posting here to be honest.




DaddySatyr -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 6:53:59 AM)


I believe the attorney is actually a state attorney but I could be wrong.

That aside, your point about the rush to judgment and seeming slant to the authorities in this is disturbing.

Let me say this, at the outset: I believe that something wrong or illegal - possibly a felony - happened, here. The seemingly credible evidence we have, so far, tells me that Mr. Gray stepped up into the van under his own power (there's video of that). His neck wasn't broken, when he got into the van. To me, that semi-exonerates the first two cops. We'll call them sacrificial lambs as there's been no evidence that they did anything wrong.

As far as the attorney saying that Mr. Gray was arrested illegally, that is plain, undiluted, bullshit. When Gray took off, running, the cops were absolutely within the law to chase after him. He was a known drug dealer. That's called probable cause.

So, something happened in that van. Did the van driver give him a "rough ride"? That's possible; maybe even probably. However, there's no evidence of that, either. We can assume and common sense might tell some of us that something had to have happened but that isn't evidence.

There was a report that Gray was throwing himself around in the back of the van. That "evidence" comes from some other dirt bag that was locked up in the van with him; on his way to the police station ... to be charged with some crime ... looking to make a deal. Not exactly unimpeachable evidence.

Here's something that was brought up on one of the news shows, last night. They interviewed an anonymous cop who said that Gray was a known drug dealer (Gray's record confirms that). He also said that Gray had co-operated with the police on several occasions; that he had "made cases" for BPD. I have to ask myself: was one of the cases he made against the other dirt bag in the van? That guy may have had opportunity and if my surmise is correct, he certainly had motive.

All of this aside, there is pretty irrefutable evidence that Gray asked for medical attention. Any cop who heard this request and ignored it is guilty of negligence, in my mind. Negligence, however, does not equate to murder 2.



Michael




bounty44 -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 7:07:20 AM)

could be state attorney yes...

I wonder if we both watched the same thing? the anonymous police officer who was on the Kelly file?

as a small aside---the thing there is, and this was troubling, the person had such an amazing and identifiable speech habit that I cannot believe for an instant that anyone who actually knows that cop would have any problems at all identifying him. he said "you know" close to every 2nd or 3rd sentence. from a speech perspective, it was excruciating to listen to.

if I understood the description of the police van rightly, I think the other fellow and Freddie gray were separated by a metal panel down the middle of the van.

one of the other things that the interviewed cop said was that criminals who the cops use as snitches often make a great public display or "show" of resistance in order to keep up their "non-cooperating" image to the public and that Freddie was possibly engaging in that.




kdsub -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 8:10:26 AM)

quote:

know many people feel they really KNOW how other people feel/and think, when in fact you have NO idea how you would REALLY feel IF you were in their shoes.


You know... when discussing my posts it is ok to talk with me directly... I respect your point of view even though I don't always agree..

Oh by the way there were white people rioting in Seattle I would like to talk and compare this with the riots in Baltimore... but of course since these were mostly white you are not qualified because you have no idea what it is like to be in a white persons shoes. I guess i will have to find white people to talk about it with... boy that really solves problems in America with race relations doesn't it.

Butch




Lucylastic -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 8:23:14 AM)

and whooosh...missing the point entirely, many times you have blamed it on the black community, ferguson and this riot in Baltimore, you have lots of blame, but little else, and attitudes like that ARE the ugly part of the problem.






BamaD -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 8:27:19 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: kdsub

quote:

know many people feel they really KNOW how other people feel/and think, when in fact you have NO idea how you would REALLY feel IF you were in their shoes.


You know... when discussing my posts it is ok to talk with me directly... I respect your point of view even though I don't always agree..

Oh by the way there were white people rioting in Seattle I would like to talk and compare this with the riots in Baltimore... but of course since these were mostly white you are not qualified because you have no idea what it is like to be in a white persons shoes. I guess i will have to find white people to talk about it with... boy that really solves problems in America with race relations doesn't it.

Butch

Did I have an excuse to cheat in college? (I didn't)
Middle aged white conservative in a traditionally black university where several professors refused to allow me to participate in class discussion for up to a month into classes. One professor who resented me because I not only disagreed with her a lot, but had better sources than she did(that one was white) All the time listening to crap about my "white privilege".

The point is those things would have been excuses to cheat, and people who want to cheat would have used them.
People, both black and white want an excuse to steal, the don't burn and steel because of outrage, they burn and steel because that is what they want to do.




Sanity -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 8:27:34 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Lucylastic

and whooosh...missing the point entirely, many times you have blamed it on the black community, ferguson and this riot in Baltimore, you have lots of blame, but little else, and attitudes like that ARE the ugly part of the problem.


Its okay to post about the topic, rather than constantly trying so hard to make other posters the topic lucy

You can even get the same point across without making it personal

Well, maybe you cant. But you could try once in a while




kdsub -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 8:34:19 AM)

No Lucy I see reality...I demand answers not lame excuses.. I challenge you to show one of my posts that did not have truth in it...just one. The truth is just that.. the reality of what happened. Just because you don't agree does not change these basic truths.

If blacks are killing blacks 80 to 1 in my town how is making people realize this is happening blame? If blacks are playing knock out games... if blacks are assaulting people on the streets.. If blacks are having gun battles on our highways... if blacks are killing children during drive by shootings... how is this anything but the truth...not blame. Until people address what is really important I will keep pointing the TRUTH out. This is not being a racist to wonder WHY. The why is what I want to talk about and it sure as hell is not the police that are the cause or problem.

Butch




Lucylastic -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 8:35:36 AM)


quote:

ORIGINAL: Sanity


quote:

ORIGINAL: Lucylastic

and whooosh...missing the point entirely, many times you have blamed it on the black community, ferguson and this riot in Baltimore, you have lots of blame, but little else, and attitudes like that ARE the ugly part of the problem.


Its okay to post about the topic, rather than constantly trying so hard to make other posters the topic lucy

You can even get the same point across without making it personal

Well, maybe you cant. But you could try once in a while

I dont blame all people at once....I dont assign blame to everyone because of one posters post. I actually like Butch a great deal, so get off your high horse.
Tell me what is not true, and where I have insulted or made him the topic, no I disagreed with him and said why I see it that way.
Tarring all with the same brush is NOT my thing, report me, please....
Im disagreeing with his posts.
but carry on dear...
snorts, ohhh fuck, the irony




slvemike4u -> RE: Why they riot (5/2/2015 8:36:46 AM)

The irony of you,of all posters,taking another poster to task for posting style is almost too much to bear.

I mentioned something somewhere that I knew more about humor than you......the above post convinces me that I'm not in your league.....you are for damm sure the funniest guy I have ever seen here [:D]




Page: <<   < prev  1 [2] 3 4 5   next >   >>

Valid CSS!




Collarchat.com © 2025
Terms of Service Privacy Policy Spam Policy
0.0625